Food New Haven style pepperoni and cheese was everything I…read moreexpected Crisp, great bite and absolutely tasty. The service is quick. You can order ahead online and tracking is pretty accurate. The ambiance is a step above a typical pizza place. 3/4 site down tables, 2/3 bar height tables. Great music playing all the time.

TLDR: if you like amazing pizza and chicken parm, this place is a must try…read more Had been a few times to the prior place in this spot and it was decent, but this new incarnation is next level. There is a lot of good pizza in a 20 min radius but Third Proof really stands out. I did not know until I went to write this review that they recently got a monster score from Portnoy, it was fully earned. Friendly pizza joint vibe with great pizza (and chicken parm) made with care and great service. We tried the New Haven style and a Vodka Parm. Being from the New Haven area I had a high bar they need to hit and they did. Perfect thin crispy crust with a touch of char and the right ratio of mozzarella to a delicious sauce with some salty parm to cut the sweet brightness of the tomato sauce. Bonus, it was even cut New Haven style with imperfect small to medium slice size. I don't know if they adjusted after Portnoy made his comment about the slicing style, but well done! Now for the chicky chicky parm parm.... Exceptional - What a huge surprise, delicious crispy thin chicken cutlets topped with delicious creamy vodka sauce and melted mozzarella. And they offer them in 4 different styles. Will go back very soon to try the others. If I had notes - slightly less mozz to checked ration and get a little more brown in the cheese. For a chicken parm it had such a light and flavorful feel. Often times too much sauce and gooey cheese overwhelm the chicken and at Three Proof the perfect chicken stands front and center and is well complimented by sauce and cheese.

I loved the pizza, they sell slices that come out of the oven tasting pretty good. They also have a…read moregreat crunch factor. Staff were friendly and my food came out quick. They also gave me a decent sized cup of pizza sauce for free which was greatly appreciated! Awesome place.

While shopping for a few items, we were getting hungry and wanted something light. We saw…read moreParsippany's Best Pizza and thought we'd see if it lived up to the name. I ordered a Margherita slice and honestly, it was pretty damn good! Very fresh sauce, good amount of fresh cheese and herbs. I also ordered a meat lovers because I wanted the contrast. It wasn't too overwhelming but fair amount of cheese and meats. Hubby ordered a grilled chicken Caesar wrap. The chicken was cut up just right so it didn't fall out as he bit into it and it came with a side of chips. It was a busy place and they had a lot of pick ups, deliveries and to-go orders. A group of middle school boys ordered 4 pizzas and chowed down which was entertaining to watch because they loved their plain, pepperoni and Hawaiian pies. Great service and options. It was a little chilly nice the door kept opening and closing, but definitely worth a stop if you are in the area.

Missed pizza from NY and NJ. When back visiting saw Johnny's Pizzeria and decided to stop in on a…read morewhim. Was greeted by those working behind the counter, very friendly. Interior had seating for dining with cute wall decor (pics of Italy landscape cities). Ordered a Johnny's special to go. As I waited I saw locals picking up orders and talking with the workers. Seemed like the staff built good relationships with their clientele, which seems rare now. Most businesses now appear strictly transactional with the patrons. The pizza had generous toppings of peppers, mushrooms, onions, pepperoni and sausage. All were fresh. The best part was the crisp thin crust and the sauce made of ripe tomatoes. What a gem!

Pizza - ordered 5 pies, went over - and walking in 20min later, they were just making the pies and…read morenot put in the oven yet. That delayed the work lunch. The fresh grandma's was a bit too soggy (fresh moz, tomatoes - all lead to a runny topping set), the regular grandma's was ok, and the favorite was the broccoli rabe w/ sausage in the group. Crust was tougher than Nonna's and overall - had better. Shop is simple, they have some seating and specials, and lots of people from nearby Double Tap which has no food order from here.

Palermo's has great.pizza! We also love their penne vodka with chicken. The staff is friendly and…read morethey have a great rewards program. Best Pizza place in Parsippany.

Always excellent! Probably have lunch here at least twice a week. Everything is good, and they also…read morehave very good soups! Only place around that sells garlic knots by the piece, which is great if you just want one or two along with your meal.

Annabella's is a local favorite. The entire staff could not be nicer and when dining in, Francisco…read more(hope I spelled that right), is an exceptional server. Everything I order exceed expectations and the portions always leave enough for great leftovers the next day. Have used them for catering as well and everyone raves about the food and not just because I paid for it :) highly recommended! You won't be disappointed.

This was the best I had in my life and I eat a lot of Pastas across the world. I was staying at the…read morehotel next door for a couple of months. This review was long overdue. I waited so long because I wanted to gate keep this restaurant. Service was prompt and efficient. Everyone's super friendly with an inviting smile. Dress code: casual or come as you are. Foods: i recommend those garlic knots and the spicy shrimp spaghetti. Those were the best knots I had in my life not even in Italy iI had something similar. As far the spicy shrimp spaghetti, I never had any pasta that tasted this good unless I was the one who made it. I honestly would fly from the west coast just to have it. I licked the container cleaned every time. The food is very affordable as well. For pizza I would go for the grandma style or plain cheese. I hope they never change the recipe nor their staff. The food is sinfully good.

Love this place! It's a nice open area with sweet staff who always find a way to make a seat open…read more The food is absolutely scrumptious, get the bacon egg and cheese croissant, it's so fulling but you'll always be satisfied coming here. And it has such a cute little atmosphere when they close the outdoor space. I came here with my grandparents multiple times and they also love it, it's one of my grandmas favourite places.

Fantastic staff- also don't be afraid of parking, there is a garage around the corner…read more We called in an order so we would have less of a wait with the kids and Edward took our order and held a table for us. We walked in 15 minutes later and he literally pointed to a booth where our two Detroit reds were just set up and waiting on us- we felt like royalty! On to the pizza- have tried many Detroit style pizzas over the years, I would say this was more Detroit "inspired", Aside from the edges, It had a soft bready crust - a little too fluffy compared to the crisp, almost focaccia-like crust we are accustomed to. Not to fret, it's still delicious! Quality pull on the cheese and the sauce holds its own. Some of the slices had the caramelized cheese halo and those were attacked first. Since we prepaid on the phone we didn't have the option to leave a tip. No worries, quick view of the sweet delights and we ordered some bombolones so that we could add a tip there!

This pizzeria is wonderful! We went in to order a thin pie & garlic knots to go but grabbed 2…read moregrandma slices to eat, while we waited. The grandma slices are the best I've ever eaten. Perfectly sauced & fresh mozzarella & basil. The cheese is real quality cheese (you know how "chewy" cheap cheese can be, like chewing gum. Its a pet peeve of mine, I can spot cheap cheese a mile away, this is QUALITY cheese) and the sauce is definitely a show stopper, very fresh! The garlic knots are perfectly seasoned, garlicky & nicely "bready" (soft & pillowy) We got the thin pizzas to go but my husband grabbed a slice out to try & it was so good he ate 3 slices on the way homeso thin with crispy cheese on the edges & it was perfectly sauced & topped with their delicious cheese all in the right proportions. We're going back on Wednesday to get a Sicilian pie (gonna grab another slice or 2 of the grandma pie to eat while we wait) It's worth the drive from Nutley to Parsippany, the food is that good & we live in an Italian town full of pizzarias. Didn't get a picture of the grandma slices, we were too hungry & they were too good! The owner, Johnny, is so friendly & just a great guy. You can see the pride he has for his restaurant & how much he cares for his customers.

Saw pizza review. One bite pizza 7.9 with Dave Portnoy. Met…read moreowner told him i saw his review. Said it changed his life. Business is very good since review . Pizza was very good.Thin slice, bar pie style Great friendly staff. Highly recommend.

Was fully packed on Wednesday eve, make reservations! We waited for 30mins to be seated…read more Relaxed rustic ambiance loved the atmosphere , we had Big Red Pizza, Pesto Chicken Pizza, roasted wings, focaccia bread. Everything was great, I like the chili oil in Big red. Nice place to hang out with friends and family. Will definitely come again!

Great family friendly spot. We were in and out on a Sunday…read morenight. Great beer list with some top notch local breweries. There was a typo on price and our server changed it right away on our check. Pizza good use a few more minutes in the oven but overall good flavor. Pastas served al dente. Our little one loved her pie from the kids menu. Will return especially after a costco run or after a movie in the area.

Rainy night ordered some take out. Got a pepperoni pizza and some garlic knots. Was greeted by…read morefriendly staff. Dinning room was open and guest were enjoying all kinds of delights. I enjoyed my yummy thin crusted pizza, just with the right amount of crunch, pepperoni was perfectly cooked. I had been craving some buttery garlic knots and this did not disappoint. I was so excited to eat this i forgot to take a picture. I will go back again! Hopefully you will too.

Ready exactly as conveyed. The Portnoy pizza was delicious. The meatballs were succulent. The salad…read morewas ok but loaded up with too much iceberg. Will definitely be heading back.

This place has been on my list for a while, and I won't be waiting long to come back…read more The parking lot is huge for such a quaint little tavern and restaurant, which is always a nice surprise. The staff was super friendly and hustling the whole time we were there. It seems like they shut off online ordering when things get too busy, which tells me they're doing plenty of business. First off, the sausage was absolutely delicious. Everything you'd want from a good Italian sausage. Salty, savory, and loaded with fennel flavor. I bet they make an awesome sausage and peppers sandwich. Don't let the picture fool you. This was one of the cheesiest pizzas I've had in a long time, and the sauce stood up to all of it. The crust had a great char and plenty of flavor. Overall, a really good pizza and a place I'll definitely be back to. Probably sooner rather than later.

KUDOS TO JENNY! Our group of 8 had a fabulous lunch @ Reservoir Tavern. The food and ambiance were…read moregreat but the level of service we received from our waitress, Jenny made all the difference. She was friendly, energetic and made us feel like family. She nailed every detail, was super attentive and got our order out to the table in no time flat. We'll definitely be back!