Poor quality food but high quality prices. People waiting on the customers do a great job but…read morepeople making the food don't care. I ordered a large calzone with extra pepperoni. When I got there 25 minutes later nobody could find my order. The cook never made it. So I had to wait for it to be made. When I got it there was no extra pepperoni, lite pepperoni at best, and a ton of sauce and dough. Worst calzone I ever had. And I paid $16 for it. I would never recommend this pizza place.

This was our first visit to LaCasa De Pizza. I was thrilled to find a local pizza place that has…read moregluten free pizza crust! And it was delicious! The ladies behind the counter were friendly and helpful! We definitely recommend this restaurant!!

If you find yourself In the small lil teeny tiny town of Findley Lake, New York you are more likely…read moreto see a bear than you are a traffic light. I am serious. So, the fact that a pizza, sub, salad and more place even exists in this area is amazing. "I wouldn't call this a restaurant, but you can take the family inside and put food in their bellies or drive there and take out" They can take your order on a late cold winter night when NO ONE ELSE IS OPEN! For me the food has always been good and was made quickly. I am a local and typically order pizza. I drive 10 mins to get there. There are some bars closer for me but Vinnies's pizza is way better. I have never had a bad pizza from them and I consider Vinnie's to be one of my favorites for pizza. Fresh dough, fresh ingredients, not greasy. Simple food and they are probably open right now. Are you from outa town and you are hungry? They are a very small and very BUSY Pizza place. You are FAR AWAY from civilization and they may be your only choice, seriously. Tired? Family on your case? Kids are hungry? Get YOUR BUTT into a car and PICK UP THE FOOD YOURSELF! This place exists in the snow belt and it could be snowing for all their deliveries but not at your hotel. Don't drive to fast in the dark and watch out for deer and bear.

The service and the food was great. We ordered a couple pizza and the battered fries. We also tried…read morethe fresh turnovers which were a bit hit. Great stop near Lake Findley for fresh pizza.

4.5 star overall experience! Wow! Yummy! $36 getting the…read more$29.99 14 inch pizza 12 wing special adding on taxes, extra cheese, and an extra ranch. 5 star wings! You get 12 perfectly cooked crispy extra saucy delicious wings with a large Delicious ranch or blue cheese. Top notch. Literally finger licking good. 4.5 star pizza! Really great sauce, cheese, pepperoni, and dough. Only slight complaint was it wasn't cut very well and we were eating it as a picnic at the lake with no silverware or napkins so we were just tearing it with our hands. Messy haha. 5 star service from guy. Super friendly knowledgeable guy helped me order on the phone without a menu and it being our first time there. 4.5 star service from girl. She first accidentally rang us up for the wrong special ($50 something) which is an easy mistake, we corrected her and she fixed it. We didn't get any napkins, wet wipes, or plastic silverware in our to go bag which made a picnic eating wings and pizza not cut all the way through in some spots very tricky to eat haha. We were literally sucking the amazing sauces off of our fingers. 5 star cleanliness 5 star location in a plaza downtown(4 1/2 min easy drive from Barcelona lighthouse) 4.5 star prices (pretty fair, especially for 12 wings and large ranches)

We love ordering pizza from here. Excellent pizza and the customer service is amazing.read more

My friend and I stumbled in here while in Jamestown and not knowing where to go. Lucky for us!…read moreThe service was friendly and attentive. The food was way BETTER than expected and I would recommend this establishment! The only minor criticism I can make is what ever they use to clean the place sorta lingers in the air - so you get a great smell of tomato sauce and the scent of Fabulosa cleaner. All being said- I'd go back!

The service and food were excellent here! Try the eggplant - it was amazing. Our server was so…read moreattentive and the restaurant itself was very clean and comfortable.

Pizza was mediocre. The cashier tried charging us $42 for 2 - 2 slices, blue cheese and 2 20oz…read moredrinks so we ended up just ordering a whole pizza because it was cheaper but of course we had to wait 25 mins. Another customer came in ordered a 2 slice with a 20 oz drink with a different cashier and the total came to around $10. Not impressed, won't return.

Delicious. Great meatball sub. Friendly place, friendly people. Pizzas looked good tooread more

Fresh dough pizza is the best here in North East. Very friendly staff. Very organized mini shop…read more Not a fan of the pepperoni balls. Seemed as if they were microwaved. I've had the brand they carry and much better cooked in oven.

Buy a sub, but don't expect to get much. Service was friendly, sub tasted good, but definitely not…read moreworth the price for what they give you. This was a 6" sub. Happened to me last time I was there and I always give the benefit of the doubt and try a place a couple times.

Came in with a big group of friends after skiing all day and it was the perfect meal after being…read moreout in the cold all day. Our server matched the fun energy of our group very well, joking around with some of my friends which we all appreciated. We started out with a bucket of Cajun wings and they were perfectly cooked and extra crispy just like we requested. For my dinner I had the hot roast beef which came with mashed potatoes all smothered in gravy. After being out in the cold all day it was the perfect meal to both fill and warm up. They also have shuffleboard, pool tables and some other games if you're looking more for a hangout bar kinda vibe.

Fun little hole in the wall. Stopped in with my daughter Food was good. Server was friendly…read more Portions were nice. Other families there as well. Will return

My only complaint is that they changed their blue cheese. Everything else is great but for some…read morereason they have decided it was best to add chives to their blue cheese which makes it only taste like chives. It's a milky range with some crumbles in it. Aside from that I'm a loyal customer!

We were passing through from out of town and found this cute little place. The wings and pizza were…read moreamazing. Great value and good quality.

Ownership recently changed. Re-opened on May 1, 2026. Will re-eview as soon as we have enough…read moreinfo on current offerings. We ordered take out tonight, and there were some differences. First, the look of the pizzeria has improved greatly. From a fresh paint job inside and out, to new windows in the front, to a re-do of the layout, the place looks refreshed and inviting. There are two tables for eating in. There are some difference with the new owners. We wanted a small pizza, but they were sold out (because the demand from the first two days of being open again was so great). We were thinking small and large pizzas would be the same size as before, but the large pizza we got was a 16" diam., as opposed to the old 12". We also ordered an order of wings (10, the same as before), and asked for medium sauce on the side. The pizza sauce was sweeter than the former owners', so those who like the sweeter sauce that most Western New York pizzerias offer will enjoy that. We prefer a less sweet sauce, but this sauce was fine. We asked for light sauce, and there was still plenty of sauce. The pepperoni is now smaller, more "cup" pepperoni, but not as small as most that is offered in the region. The sweet peppers were pre-cooked before being cooked on the pizza, which is okay, but we prefer ours to be uncooked before being put on pizza. The dough was slightly thicker than before, and seemed tough when cutting slices, but it didn't chew tough. The pepperoni and peppers were generous. The cost was higher than before, but considering it is a larger pizza and probably chicken prices have increased dramatically in the period they've been closed, $46.10 probably wasn't out of line. We will certainly be back for more, and intend on trying much of their menu. It is good to have a local pizzeria once again.

It was better when it was a mom and pop pizzeria. It caters to people that will eat anything that…read moreresembles pizza and wings. Food quality is lacking. Doughy crust and low quality sauce. You can tell nothing there is unique or home made. Wings was gummy like the oil it was fried in wasn't hot enough. Was there at the open of business and placed my order 1st but still had to wait over a half hour. DO NOT RECOMMEND