Stopped in not really knowing anything about the place. Not a bad idea, and my visit would have been better if I'd actually just made "My" Pie. Instead, I opted for their featured "Gyro" pizza. Bad, bad idea. I just tasted like a leftover gyro that had been heated up. Tzatziki sauce just shouldn't be hot....ever. Prices seem a bit high for a personal pizza, even if it is custom, but I'm kinda cheap. That said, we'll probably go back at some point....I'm sure it's better than that pizza....it has to be. read more

Finally ate here in person! Service was smooth - getting the sauce and toppings correct on my pizza was an easy process along with ordering drinks. The food was very delicious - the toppings were fresh and tasty and the crust was some of the best I've ever had in this area. I'm not sure if things are normally different since this was my first and only visit, but I wish there was normal bar service in the bar area. As in, someone stops by to check and see if you want another beer or dessert and you get a normal restaurant bill rather than paying at the register. As it was, we just decided to leave rather than stick around when my boyfriend finished his beer. If we hadn't been stuck with getting up to get another beer and a dessert to share, I'm sure we would have, but the system we were presented with last night as dine-in customers just made it easier to leave rather than stick around for another beer or two and dessert as we usually end up doing when dining out. I will probably give dining in another try, but if it's the same there is really no benefit to dining in over take out. (Food alone warrants a 5, but knocking it down to a 4 because I'd expect SOME benefits to sticking around and dining at the establishment.) read more

Your Pie - Current seasonal pizza - Sriracha Nacho - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia

We went here on a Friday because we were driving around looking for something easy/fast. For the uninitiated, this is kind of like a subway/chipotle model but for pizza. The staff working the bar were friendly and we both ordered something off the menu rather than a "create your own". The pizzas are small but not tiny. They come in record time and they serve alcohol. Nice fast-casual place that fits the bill when you want decent pizza and want it in a hurry. read more

Ohh your pie..I was so excited to try out this place considering it has brick oven pizza and Gelato. I absolutely adored the concept. .but The atmosphere was cute, great, the people were friendly The Gelato was damn delish; I got salted caramel. The pizza...was fresh tasting and pretty good but not like *ehem* some chains I know. But if youre looking for freshness and authenticity and a more refreshing flavor, go to your Pie for sure. Maybe Im just a sucker for chain pizza thick crust but your pie was still pretty good. read more

Super cool little place. Kinda has the chain feel but the awesome pizza and local beers on tap make it what it is, a welcome edition to the area. read more

Your Pie - Awesomeness - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia

See all

Loved this place, the one time we ate here a couple weeks ago. Our pizzas came out just as tasty as we expected. We used a "check in" deal that gave us a free scoop of gelato and it was delicious! The staff was wonderful as well. When ordering a childs pizza, they use a large bowl to trim off excess dough to make a smaller pizza and they gave the dough to my son to play with while we waited for our food to come. I thought that was very thoughtful and smart. We have dubbed this place our "go to" pizza place!! Great job, guys! read more

Your Pie - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia

See all

This is a great spot for brick oven pizza. Only wish is they had larger sized pizza. But overall great spot for a good pie!

Make your own personal pizza for one price?? I love the idea and it's very hard to not enjoy the pizza you create. I like the different options of toppings and sauces and it came out very quickly! Tasted delicious and was the perfect size. I was so hungry that I forgot to take pictures for this review. AND I was able to get the free scope of gelato with my Yelp checkin. I wish they had some more gelato flavors but they had classics like chocolate, vanilla, and cookies and cream along with a few others I can't remember. It was a great touch to the meal. I'll be coming back to maybe try a panini or a different combination of toppings on my pizza. read more

My husband and I came for the soft opening at lunch. They were very busy but the line went fast. I compared this to the Subway of Pizza. You pick what you want to go on your pizza and they throw it in the oven. I had a white pizza with a lot of toppings. It was very good and I felt it was a lot of pizza for one person. My husband also got a white pizza with ham, bacon and garlic. His was very good as well. We also got a Caprese salad. My husband liked it but I felt it left something to be desired. We were very happy with the taste and quality of the food. The only reason I am giving this place 4 stars is because they lost my husbands pizza and he had to wait until after I was finished for his to come out. (I eagerly await coming again to update my review) read more

Your Pie - There would have been a picture of a full pizza but it was too good to let wait. - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia

See all

Great little pizza restaurant with fresh ingredients, made to order, the setting is nice the atmosphere is basic but refreshing, 10 stars better then the chain restaurants, [hint, hint, dominoes or papa johns, hint]. So if your in Norfolk give them a taste! read more

Your Pie - Made to perfection! - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia

This restaurant went way beyond my expectations, taste wise. I had a kids size pepperoni pizza on wheat and WOW! It was beyond delicious. My boyfriend got a chicken bacon ranch panini with tomato and spinach, and it was outstanding too! It was super crowded because we stopped by at lunch hour on a work day, but the customer service was still great! I'm so lucky I live within walking distance, I'll definitely be returning frequently. read more

Your Pie - My kid size pepperoni pizza on wheat, and boyfriend's chicken bacon ranch panini - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia

I have eaten here countless times and it's always a treat. You can customize your pizza and there are a lot more options that other craft pizza places including wheat dough and vegan cheese. I think that their quality is amazing. I'm a huge pizza eater so being able to grab a customizable and affordable pizza is great for a quick lunch or dinner option. They recently did a $3.14 special for the opening of the Chesapeake store and even despite how busy it was, my food was ready in a timely manner. Can't beat quick service! read more

Now this is mmyyyy kind of pizza! Totally diggin' this place. Instead of candy land, this is pizza land! Build your own for about $8. Start with a thin crust, choose a sauce - mine, basil pesto...can even do a half & half to try out the different kinds which I I did on my second visit...chose pesto for one side and ricotta for the other half - both delish! Next, the cheese - fresh mozzarella - so worth the extra $1. Then onto toppings galore - don't be shy...choose away! Your lovely masterpiece gets a number before going into the brick oven. Cooking time is quick with it being an individual size (10-in). In no time, we all were enjoying our yum in the tum pizza creations. All they need now is to open a Your Pie in Greenbrier!! Don't forget your free gelato for checking in. read more

See all

The food was subpar, nothing spectacular, could've made better at home. The order was all sorts of jacked up, we were missing a pizza and some cheese sticks. Won't ever order from here again and wouldn't suggest it to anyone read more

I am a self proclaimed pizza connoisseur. I have tasted pizzas from New York to California and all in between in my search for the perfect pizza. I've been to the international pizza expo several times in Las Vegas in my quest to learn from the worlds best pizza makers. Though I've given a relative 5 stars for the pizza in this area. I would give Your Pie a six. I found this place by chance but now I realize it was fate. I've been twice in the past 2 days since I've discovered the place. I have the BBQ chicken and Southern Heat. Both were perfectly made. Not overly topped ( yes there is such a thing) and not skimpy on the toppings. It was a well balanced topped pizza. The pizza is made in a brick oven thus the crust is light and crispy. Both pizzas were very flavorful. Best of all the price point is reasonable. This place is a must try. Definitely give it s shot if you happen to be in the area. I live on the other side of the tunnel which is the only downer and major obstacle to me being a regular. Your PIe pleaseeeeee come to Newport News! read more

This is most definitely my favorite pizza place. You can choose from the menu with pizza, panini, and salad favorites or just go down the line and build your own. Kids eat free Sundays, they have military Monday's and PINT NIGHT THURSDAYS. You buy a pint and get to bring the glass home or you can get any 10oz. beer for 3.14 (pi) get it ? Also you can select from red and white wines. Many different beers to try and they won't get old considering they get about 2 new beers every week. Each pint night features 3 or 3 company's beers. It's pretty cool. Really clean restaurant and bubbly, kind crew members. Every time I go everyone is nice and the pizzas only take about 5 minutes. Literally. I go around 1 or 2:00 I know I can study and enjoy the peace. It's usually a mini break in between that time and dinner. read more

See all

This is a very nice "build your own pizza/panini/salad" restaurant kind of in the same vein as Chipotle or Subway. You walk in and either choose to do a build your own or one of their suggestions of pizza/panini/salad and they put it together in front of you, then bring it out to you once it has cooked. Really good food and good price points. Fun to do, too! read more

Love this place, love this place!! It's unique, fun, and delicious. Basically you get to choose ever component of your pizza, crust, sauce, toppings, cheese, etc. They bake your pizza in the stone oven and it comes out fresh and delicious. You get to see all of the ingredients as it's being made right in front of you which is great for the picky eaters like myself. They also have Military Monday's giving Military members and other ID holders a discount, which is always a plus. I've never had a bad experience with employees, they're always professional and kind. read more

First time here and loved this place. The pizza is so good. As we walked in a young lady in braids was so nice and greeted us. She explained how it worked and proceeded to wait on us. It's like a subway but for pizza. The husband's pizza was sauage and pepperoni. My pizza was onion, bell peppers, pepperoni, and bacon. Both tasted amazing. The only problem (and it was slight) was checking out with a young lady named Cheyenne. She wasn't very friendly. We also purchased a salad and had walk around looking for a fork. She should have been proactive and let us know where they were located at the time of purchase since the salads are in front of the cash register. They also sell craft beers. We did not try those this time. Definitely will be putting this restaurant in the rotation. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia

See all

The pizza is fantastic and the feel is comfortable and fresh. Pizza cook from a open fire hearth, a good assortment of craft beers, and Gelato make this one happening place. The Bose sounds system is top notch. The service is quick, professional, and exceptional. read more

Your Pie - Pizza from the fire hearth oven, beer, and Gelato all in one awesome restaurant. Brilliant!!! - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia

This was my first visit, and I have to say I found my new go to pizza place. Its great for when you want more than one slice but don't need a whole pie. You choose the crust ( they have gluten free) sauce and toppings. You can make your own crazy combo or choose from a list of options. They also have a bar and gelato. Pizza beer and gelato all in one place. Get the fat pants ready! read more

Your Pie - This was my first visit, and I have to say I found my new go to pizza place. - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia

Love this place. Great pizza, love the toppings bar and flexibility! Fun place to eat and get exactly what you want. Fun date spot.

This pizza place is superb. Their customer service is top-notch. Their customization options are vast and the flexibility of them handling my complex order was executed flawlessly. Try this place and you will be pleasantly surprised. read more

Look the food is ussusly great and you can't beat the price... bit we waited 30 minutes for our pizza that they must of gave to someone else... and all we got was a "sorry for you experience" could of of offered a free pizza or something... disappointed read more

First time coming here and they burned my pizza along with several others, didn't offer a refund and remake. Just one of the other. Waited almost 30 minutes for my pizza to be burned and thrown out! I came along with 3 other people and their food was fine but not mine. If course I'm not going to wait for mine to be remade with no refund and eat alone! Terrible customer service! read more

Terrible experience with the staff! The staff seems put-out when you ask them questions and they are very rude. When speaking to the on-duty Manager he was also uncaring and rude. I have been to many places in Tidewater but this one does not have a trained staff and they run the restaurant with no customer care and they are not paying attention to what's going on and if you ask them a question, they get offended. There's no supervision at all and they are on their phones a lot. I feel bad that the owner is not there more because it want take long before he starts losing business due to the lack of care from his staff. Don't bother trying to ask for the owners name they will not help you if you have an issue. Sad, will not go there again. read more

They forgot to do my order and started in it after i arrived. But to be honest the food is nice and i love the place

This is an awesome place to build your own pizza. Its also family friendly!!!! Pizza tasted awesome too. They also have reasonable prices and deals. My only complaint was they need more selection of meats :). Otherwise great place. read more

Some of the best pizza in Hampton Roads, IMHO! Thank you, for the vegan options. I've had a few of the personal vegan pies that were catered to my work. Tofu is available as a topping along with vegan cheese and fresh veggies. The crust is perfect and all of the veg toppings have been high quality and scrumptious. I haven't actually been in the store yet so that's on my to-do list but I'd highly recommend this pizza based off the few pies I've devoured. read more

Its a great concept food is amazing, the people were great, very nice establishment. The pizza and the sandwich was a great size, I love it and I will definitely be back to have the amazing pizza. read more

Your Pie - Nice beer selection - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia

See all

First timer! Ordered two pizzas online through GRUBHUB and had a pick up time of 8pm and got there at 8 and they only made one pizza. So, I had to wait another 5-10 minutes. I didn't get an apology for their mistake until I got my pizzas, or even a hey you can have one pizza for free next time you come by??...‍ read more

I tried this place because everyone was talking about how wonderful it was & it is! I love this place. this is like the most brilliant idea ever made lol I give major kudo's to the owner! anyways, the pizza shown is pesto, chicken, spinach, broccoli, and pepperoni. I got a side salad and a cherry Sprite. my sister got the gelato. She got vanilla and mint. honestly, it was really good. The only thing I would say is, it wasn't worth $15. Don't get me wrong, the pizza and atmosphere and everything was great! but I wasn't full like I hoped. but I would definitely come back! read more

Your Pie - Pesto, chicken, pepperoni, spinach, broccoli, with a side Cesar salad w/ cherry Sprite - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia

See all

Great gluten-free pizza crust! The staff is very helpful and polite, the toppings were all fresh, the gelato was delicious, even the sweet tea was good. Just like chipotle or subway, you go through and pick your own sauce, cheese, and toppings. It's a very cool idea and it worked deliciously. read more

Your Pie - Spinach, tomato, onion, and chicken over feta and mozzarella with a gluten-free crust. And salted caramel gelato! - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia

I come to my local your pie quite frequently, but just realizing I've never given them a review! At your pie, you make personalized pizza, subs, or salads, etc! I always start with a nice classic great white base and add pineapple, bacon, pepperoni, onion, and bell peppers. I am low carb and gluten free, so their serving sizes and options are perfect for me. I've never had an issue with the staff. Your food comes out pretty quickly. They also have an app so you can earn rewards. read more

Your Pie used to be my go to when I was in Athens because that is where it originated from. The concept of making your own pizza pie is not only unique but also makes sure you get a fresh, customized pie to your taste every time. The quality stays excellent because you make it your own. Their chipotle pesto is one of my favorite sauces and it goes really well with fresh mozzarella for those who like that extra kick. The crust is perfectly done- not too crunchy or doughy. I would highly recommended this place for a fast, fresh and satisfying pizza experience! read more

I never give reviews but my food was so horrible I had to leave one. Chicken Alfredo? More like pasta with cheese - worst Alfredo pasta I have ever had. Go down the street to Razzos. read more

Good food, great staff, this locally owned franchise fits right in. They have a fantastic selection of local brews however, they are in the $$$ bracket compared to other local bars so you'll not want to stay for more than one. Then there is the gelato. Yum! It is great to a have a local place with outdoor seating, we have such moderate weather here most of the year and there are so few places to enjoy it with a meal in Norfolk. I hope they succeed and in turn lower bar prices so that it can also become a neighborhood place to meet friends for a drink and socialize. read more

Awesome staff. Awesome music playing. Great selection of beer. And some of the best brick oven pizza I've ever had. I'll be back...probably once a week with how delicious it was. read more

Your Pie - Build your own pie! - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia

My experience was very good. I haven't been to Your Pie since they first opened this location and it was just as good today as it was a few years ago. read more

Just passing through town for business and decided to make a pit stop to miss rush hour traffic. I'm so glad I did ! Staff was attentive and precise. Who doesn't like a custom pizza ? If you're undecided, they post employee favorites and have a few suggestions. We need a Your Pie in my hometown. Keep the smiles rolling ! read more

Your Pie - Best Ash Wednesday pizza ever ! Great family friendly atmosphere and vibe, yet caters to adults that enjoy wine and beer. Love My Pie ! - Pizza Near Me - Norfolk, Virginia