Order before you sit, wood fired pizza type place with a great selection of beers. It's a college town so the bar feels appropriate. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

The pizza is delicious. Tanner was very nice and friendly. All around good experience!

Concept of a custom build pizza where you progress thru the line and choose toppings. Positive interaction w the manager regarding paying for me and the kiddo while we made separate trips thru the line. Good pie. Good beer. Friendly staff. Nice large patio area surrounded w beautiful trees. read more

Your Pie opened in Flagstaff recently and I just got the chance to come by on September 2nd. I've been to a few of the "build you own" pizza style places in the past. I was really surprised when I walked into Your Pie to see how bit and open the restaurant is. I was excited once inside to see what they had to offer. I also wanted to add how amazing I find it that they also serve gelato/sorbet, and also local beer selections on tap! FOOD: I got the BBQ Chicken Pie with banana peppers, bacon, and ricotta cheese added. My first job was at a family owned pizza shop in Scottsdale, Az so I'm a little bit of a pizza snob. After ordering and paying for my food (pizza and drink $12) I was happy that the pizza was delivered right to my table in under 10 minutes. The food was really great! My pie was cooked crispy and was full of flavor. I was also happy to see that this place offers free ranch dressing if you want! I would alone just return for the food. STAFF: I didn't interact with the staff much as this isn't a traditional serving restaurant. The staff making the pizza were willing to help with any suggestions and also friendly which was great for a business still so new to town. OVERALL: I really enjoyed my visit here to Your Pie. Flagstaff has been in need of some fresh and creative businesses. I'm glad to have a quality custom pizza place in town and will definitely be returning. I recommend Your Pie to anyone looking for a custom pizza bite for lunch or dinner! read more

See all

Pretty similar to other chain of pizzerias, but it was good , had a hood beer selection, the ingredients were fresh, clean and they had a propane fire pit at the patio which made it a nice cozy experience read more

The pizza is not amazing but not terrible. I really like the setup and idea of this pizza place, you basically order like a chipotle or subway restaurant. They also serve beer so that's a plus. The summer is a great time to visit as they have a really cool outdoor patio. read more

This a Blaze type pizza place. You walk up tell them which dough you would like and then pick your toppings. Many to choose from.. Like the different option of cheeses. Love feta and goat on my pizza. Takes about 2 minutes to baked and then they deliver it to your table. No screaming your name. Liked then fact they also had a great selection of beer and wine. And desserts. Had a nice outside area with a fire pit. Live band playing when we were there so it was a little load. Not enough tables inside but that shouldn't stop you from going. read more

See all

Wow, great pizza! Gluten free crust was best I've ever had! My friend had cauliflower and I tried that one too and it was super good! The only reason I gave it a four-star was they gave a 6 ounce pour and I swear it was not 6 ounces! My girlfriend had less wine than me so 6oz isn't always same pour. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Well Hello!!!! We found this place one night just after the restaurants reopened after Covid for dine in. The place we originally had chosen had an hour wait time (from your car). We were bummed but now so happy or we would have never found this place! The menu is huge on the wall. It's literally on the wall for your viewing! You order an individual (pretty large) size pizza and get to put whatever in the world your little heart desires and although we've all been taught to be considerate of others when ordering pizza (cause you all share) here, you get to be a little selfish!! They have a bar with beer and wine! They have a wonderful out door dining area with fire pits and spacious indoor dining. It's clean, cool and so yummy! Super good pizza and salads!! Plenty of drinks to choose from and even have some desserts. The staff are kind and personable and makes to a T!! Will be back!! read more

See all

This place is ok. Nothing mind blowing but it was fast and you can pick your toppings . Nice that you can pick pizza, panini or salad and combo options are a good add on. The gelato was the best thing!! read more

Walked in at around 11 there was one poor kid working who seemed over whelmed with the orders that had come in. Employee apologized said he just had a big order come in. No problem, we wait to place our order. A few mins later a mob of people come in at rush lunch hour. Employee looks up and is stressing on the people and probably how many orders he has to fill. Felt bad for him, was working his butt off to try and get out orders. There was another employee here who popped out of the kitchen once in a while to throw some pizzas in the oven but wondered off like nothing was going on. The pizzas were very good and worth the wait. The employee even went to our table again to apologize for it taking so long and asked if the food was good. Pizza was really good employee was over worked and needed some help! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

I was really excited to try this new pizza place! It did not disappoint. I love that you are able to choose as many toppings as you would like and it not going up in price. As I was going through choosing my toppings the staff was really friendly and welcoming. The pizza was ready in minutes -- I got my drink, sat down, and my pizza was brought out to me. I was impressed. This was the same for everyone else that I was with. I also tried their gelato and it was delicious! I had the mint chocolate chip. Will be returning! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Subpar pizza kid couldn't even get any toppings on a few of my slices of the margarita. Not very friendly either.

Ordered the spicy pepperoni sticks and the pizza on the menu listed as spicy. Everything was bland tasting.

Went here with family while traveling over the weekend. Most of the rest of the family are all gluten intolerant but i am not. My order of a very good create your own pasta bowl came out within minutes as did another member's pizza came out pretty quickly too. The four gluten free pizzas took almost an hour to get to the table. We were informed twice that they were contaminated that needed to be remade/cooked. While we commended them for their honesty how did it take an hour to get this right? Whats more one of the pizzas was burned when it arrived. Even burned everyone liked their food. Not having to worry about gluten I would totally eat here again. As I said the pasta was the bomb. I do not think my gluten free family members would be as willing to try it again. read more

Awesome spot to grab a pizza have a beer and eat some ice cream! Lots of seating inside and outside. Tons of toppings to choose from, 10 inch pizzas loaded with your favorite toppings for not a bad price. I will be back! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Walked in Friday at 1:00 pm, the team serving/cooking/assembling were ON POINT and super helpful. We got pizzas and pasta with vegan cheese which was better than I expected. The pizza was also more filling than I expected. Will definitely be back due to tasty variety of vegan options. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Vegan cheese with veggies - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

I heard good things about Your Pie from my kids so we ordered delivery last week and it was "meh" at best. One pizza was a large pepperoni. The other mushroom and black olives. The toppings were fine and fresh but the crust was tasteless and flat. Not flat and crispy. Just flat and completely tasteless. My preference is for the crust to be an ingredient to the overall taste experience not just a delivery mechanism for the toppings. The crust had all of the flavor of a vegan, soy free, salt free, gluten free limp cracker. We will probably order again and see if it was an issue with what we ordered or if that this is not the place for us. read more

The pizza is amazing here. and of course that's why we come here to have pizza. but I also need to say the employees are absolutely amazing. Iliana especially is super amazing and lovable. she makes coming in an even better treat. thank you Your Pie ! read more

The only way I can describe Your Pie to out of town guests is "like Subway but for pizza." It truly is- you choose your crust (white/wheat/gluten free/cauliflower), your sauces, your cheeses, veggies, and meat, and then they pop your specialized, personal sized pizza in their oven and cook it right when you build it. It's a neat process, your food is always 100% fresh, and everybody gets exactly what they want- no compromising. I usually get the BBQ chicken pizza, and it comes out perfectly every time. They have a menu board with some pre-made options, but you can choose to do a totally personalized pizza version of your own. I got the combo special today that includes a drink with free refills and a side of chips, though you can choose a side salad or gelato as your side. If you're in the mood for dessert, definitely go to the gelato, it's delicious. Your Pie even has a small bar area with beer, wine, and root beer on tap. They have a small area of board games, as well as an outdoor patio for good weather days. It's a little pricey for a lunch- $15+ for a combo before tip- but it's more the experience than anything else. read more

See all

Pizza is okay. Service is lacking. I was the only person in line and waited 15 mins. About 7 employees but no movement. Other good pizza places to go. Don't waste your time. read more

Nice place, good pizza. 4 stars because the amount of toppings they put on isn't as much as other like pizza places I've been to. I had to ask a couple times to add more of the same topping. Since I don't eat meat, I get more veggies. I love the fact they have vegan cheese, I would love to see a vegan meat option in the future. There are two dairy free options for dessert (that I saw) which was a plus, and very good! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Got a burnt and soggy pizza for a kids order. My 5 yo says just ate one slice which was less burnt and complained. I called the manager explaining the situation . He said that he is ok to make one more for me after he made a comment that he personally took the pizza from oven and it was not burnt. This is after I told him I can send pictures if he doesn't trust. I declined his offer and told him that he lost a customer because of his bad attitude and customer service, especially from a store manager. I am never going to flagstaff "your pie" again. read more

See all

Very disappointed! I am usually a big fan of Your pie and I ordered online for pick-up. When I got home, I opened the box to see my cheese-sticks to look like this. It feels like I was given someone else's leftovers. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Usually a big fan of Your Pie but just got home from a pick up order and my order of cheese sticks looked like this. - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

I had been craving pizza after being at Lake Powell for eight days and was super excited to come here, but was quickly disappointed when I got my cold pizza. I don't know if the employees are not taking into consideration how one pizza takes so long to cook compared to the other pizza in the same party, but my husband's pizza was lukewarm. I'm guessing my pizza was sitting waiting for his to cook. . I ordered the cauliflower crust at a $4+ added cost - not good, I've had frozen which was much better. I question is the oven was at the ideal temp because it took a while to get our food; I've been to similar style cooking establishments which served the pizza hot and much quicker. On a positive note - the place was clean. read more

I'll give it 2 stars instead of 1, because the order was correct. We ordered through an app. The pizza looked nothing like the photos, it was very thin & flat. The pasta was severely over baked, extremely dry. The cheesy bread was also over baked & half the size of pics. I'm such an easy customer, not high standards, but this meal was very disappointing. read more

Very disappointed in the amount of toppings and sauce. Very meager. I didn't want to argue with the girl. Gave me a water cup with sediment in it. The water dispenser had a broken handle. I was told oh ya we gotta fix that. So they knew about it for a while. read more

The ownership of this place should fire all the employees and replace them with semi intelligent monkeys. Every time we order delivery with a kids meal which comes with a gelato, they forget the gelato. Every time. We even write in "don't forget the gelato" but they still forget the gelato. We've complained. They don't fix it. When we order a salad, they also forget the salad. I understand that Rome wasn't built in a day, but how long would it take to fix the system so the staff doesn't forget to hand the refrigerated items to the delivery person? 5 minutes. Do they need me to make a Power Point for them? The only reason we still order from here is for the keto pizza. As soon as another place in town develops a keto pizza, we're out! read more

Expect to wait a very long time in line just to place your order. Very inattentive staff. Only one employee is wearing a mask this evening & the establishment does not require patrons to mask up. Flagstaff has some great pizza places, but this is not one of them. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Photo of the bar from one section of seating. No dedicated employee working the bar. Overall, a poor customer service experience. - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

I don't offer reviews with inflation. In other words, I will only give reviews in which are factual and how I felt the service was received. To start out this was my first visit going to Your Pie. I have a gluten intolerance and have not been able to enjoy pizza in awhile. The last time I had pizza was at Pizza Press. To go on with my experience, I walked in the door to what felt like a welcoming vibe and modern feel. Having experienced ordering down-the-line pizza places before I had a feeling of where I needed to start my order. A person who has never experienced this type of ordering style may be confused due to the lack of signage directing where a person is to order. When I approached the counter to order I was not greeted, yet asked what I wanted. I asked for a gluten free crust and explained it was an allergy. Having never been there before the lady grabbed a piece of receipt paper and asked what toppings I wanted. Well what do you have? There are no sign labels of toppings nor was she any help. As she stood there staring at me I walked down the line to see what they offered. My order: GF crust, pesto sauce, mozzarella cheese, feta cheese, onion, mushroom, artichoke hearts, sundried tomatoes, and fresh basil on top. After yelling at an employee in front of everyone in the restaurant to stop burning pizzas, she handed the receipt paper with my order to another employee telling him to make the pizza. He then preceded to walk in the back of the restaurant with the piece of paper. The lady then handed me a laminated card. What is this for? What does this mean? It would have been nice for her to say something along the lines of, your order number is ___, and please give this card to the cashier to pay. Here's my issue with the what I just went through. When you order a pizza in a down-the-line style the experience of it is that you get to see what's going on your pizza as you walk down the line. Since I ordered gluten free as an allergy, I was neglected to receiving this experience. The next thing that troubles me is that if an employee has an issue with another employee you ask to speak to that employee in private, not shout at him in front of customers. Finally, the lack of explanation throughout the whole service was lackluster and a bit disappointing. At this point I was thinking about just leaving without my pizza or paying. After finally getting to the cashier to pay, I had to wait another 5-10 minutes. The cashier (not even dressed in work attire) decided to have a conversation with a customer. I assume he was the owner. This man gave the impression of not having a clue on how to work a cash register. It looked like a caveman who just discovered fire. While he was nice and polite, he didn't give off a feeling of welcoming, more of a trying to make me feel uncomfortable. The "owner" up-sold me into a combo of a drink and salad. I picked out the caprese salad which was pre-made and had a side of dressing in it. When I opened the salad container the tomatoes on the opposite side were moldy white and had an off smell to them. The spinach leaves were a wilted and the "fresh mozzarella" was wet and smelly. I let the "owner" know and he offered me another one. I politely said no, and took a seat to wait for my pizza to finish. Once getting my pizzas after 20min it was served to me I found some of the toppings to be burnt, missing completely, and lacking in the amount of toppings. I stood up and went to the register to ask the "owner" if he could add more artichoke hearts. He smiled and says no problem; preceding to walk away from an open cash register, with money sticking out of the drawer. The rude lady employee walks up and yells across the restaurant to the "owner" to close the register, and slams it shut. He comes back handing me my pizza and says to the lady that he had mistakenly forgot. To which he receives a questionably rude glance from her. My overall impression: For a first impression of the restaurant and its experience it was very underwhelming. If it wasn't for the rude service, the irate attitude of this lady employee, lackluster experience, and a quality product I would have given them a more-star review. My advice to the owner/manager: To offer Gluten Free customers the experience of down-the-line ordering I would suggest understanding when gloves are and are not necessary. FDA only requires gloves for ready-to-eat foods (food that is not to be cooked). With this being said if you're trying to play towards a sanitary way of topping pizzas, I would advise you to have your employees not use gloves when touching the dough. To only put on gloves when you are putting on the toppings. Also keeping a neat workstation free of excess flour will ensure that the gluten free customers can have the same experience as everyone else. If you're worried about some toppings containing gluten, a simple pair of tongs and solve the problem. Thanks read more

Your Pie Pizza - Old Tomatoes from salad - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Cute little spot for dinner or lunch. Was busy when I went but the line moves fast and the employees were nice and super fun! Pizza was great with lots of flavor. read more

Your Pie Pizza - My fantastic build your own! - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

I love the prosciutto and peach pie. I didn't see it this year, but I do go back. I like to sit on the patio

This place has great potential but their system of ordering is awful. You stand in line for forever, and there are not even many people there. It's a bottle neck of people at the register because they are not only checking out people who are paying for their order but they are checking out people who are picking up to go orders and also the people who are trying to get more gelato or more drinks. Either open up another register or figure out a way to remove the bottleneck. It is inefficient and a waste of time. Honestly the food is really good and it's nice they have beer as well but by the time I get to my table I'm ready to leave. read more

Had a fennel sausage pizza. EXCELLENT!! Margaritas were excellent!! Bruschetta great! Tomato basil soup couldn't be better! I highly recommend this place. Wish we had one of those in California!! read more

Got to the area before a hair styling appointment, which We thought was for 11am, but actually was 1pm. Two hours to kill. Your Pie was just opening and we went in and ordered some fantastic paninis and the 928 craft beer ( best beer in Arizona just FYI). Chatted with Brian. He's evidently the Asst Mgr of this location. A great representative for this company. Excellent customer service! Very personable, efficient, and proud to be their employee. Stop in some time and meet him, eat great food, and have a good craft beer. Definitely Recommend! read more

The pizza was great.....once we finally got it. This place was slooowww, even though there weren't very many customers there. Honestly, I think that there were about as employees as there were customers. It took a long time for us to make it through the short line to order our pizza and pay for it, then another long wait before our pizza was ready. read more

I so wanted to give this place the benefit of the doubt. I can't. I ordered from here a few of times in the summer/fall. Had no problems and pizza was goodish. Then comes a time that my husband is out of town and my 10 year old want pizza. I talk him into Your Pie. Bad move on my part. The pizza my 10yo wanted doesn't come. Delivery driver acts dumb about it. Then when I call the store I'm told there is nothing they can do. She said she'd refund the price of the pizza. It never happened. I thought whatever. Things happen. Until tonight. I ordered at 711. It's now 905 and still no pizza. This place has gone way downhill. I wouldn't suggest this kind of service to anyone. read more

Great home made food. Great atmosphere with a wide selection of empanadas Highly recommend for breakfast or lunch or just take home read more

This is the first time in Arizona. My friends and I landed in Flagstaff. The interior of this restaurant is very unique, colleague like and extremely spacious. They have a bar and also a variety of wine and beer. You can create your own pizza just like a chipotle style. The staff were very kind and friendly. They bring the pizza up to your table after seating yourself. The pizza were delicious!! Not to oily or doughy. Each customer pie is good for an individual. It's definitely filling. They also have combos for cheaper which is definitely worth the price. It was very convenient, only a 10 minute drive from the flagstaff airport. I highly recommend this to new incomers! read more

See all

This newer pizza location has great food and a nice variety of beverages. All pizzas come in personal 7'' sizes. Serves about 1-2 people. The canned sangria was surprisingly good. We got to try their gelato. I would definitely come back. read more