We found this place going to Sedona. Very good food, price and atmosphere. Very clean and so many options! My kids loved the food too.

Great food and atmosphere. Staff is horrible they act like they don't want to be there. This happened all 3 times I went

I've been visiting this location over the past few years and their quality can really fluctuate. Worst case has included orders being 25 minutes late, burnt, extremely oily, poor customer service, or missing ingredients. On good days, the staff can be friendly, the order is perfect, and they've even offered a free brownie due to a small mistake! I love that there is vegan and vegetarian options, but again, the quality is variable. For the price, the food is fairly good. I wish the paninis were a bit bigger. I like being able to select my own toppings and customizing my order. The salads are delicious and I appreciate so many different dressings! I would return, but I'd like for the chance of a "bad day" to be less often. read more

I ordered a Nat's Signature pasta and it was missing all the things I was looking forward to: chicken, sun dried tomatoes, and spinach. They basically just gave me noodles and sauce when that is not what I ordered. They missed ingredients from the pizza and kids pasta we ordered also. Not as detrimental as my non-Nat's pasta though :( read more

We like this location because it is away from everything and the people there are always nice. However, this isn't the cheapest pizza in town. Last time we went they were out of some cups, lids for others, I never got my wings, but they were all nice. It is what it is. read more

Solid joint. The workers are super friendly and the prices are cheap. Post-Covid, the place also seemed to return to normal. Pizza came out hot and I enjoyed the entire pie by myself. I like how many options they have and how receptive the workers are to requests. All in all great place! read more

Your Pie Pizza - inside - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

very good pizza especially if u are allergic to a lot of things, it is very worth your money and super good, the service is fast and the workers are nice. the place looks very nice and sets a warm mood. read more

I am always a sucker for building my own pizza especially when you can load it on with as many veggies, cheeses and toppings as you want for $10. This place has a great selection of fresh ingredients. The cutest part is that someone will hand toss your dough right in front of you! Only disappointing thing is the pasta. You still pay $10 and it is the absolute smallest portion of pasta you can imagine. It is almost like a side pasta and could not be worth more than $5. It wasn't my pasta so I don't know about the taste but the portion was disappointing for my brother. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Build your own loaded with veggies - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Reminded me a lot of Pieology and Blaze!! If you're a fan of making your own pizza, this is the place for you. Super cute place, realllly efficient staff and little wait time in a popular area, and the pizza was really good. Lots of great toppings to choose from, and everything was ready in under 10 minutes! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Went here today, we're local and try to come here once a week, but half the employees will scrap the burned black stuff out of their ovens and the other half of employees won't. 1/10/24 I came in for lunch and saw the black buildup in their oven and asked if she could help me out and clean an area I won't get that on my pizza... she laughed. Eating burned anything is u healthy. If you don't care about my health how can I trust you with the other foods toy handle. read more

My pizza was burnt on the bottom but I think that if it hadn't been for this, it would've been a great pizza. Staff is friendly. Prices are reasonable. If I wasn't passing by I would give it another shot. read more

Quick service and excellent food. There are base menu items but you're able to customize those in so many ways. Lots of delicious options, but honestly the gelato was my favorite. Clean and spacious restaurant with a down to earth feel. read more

I was beaucoup impressed with this place. I mean, Flag is beautiful already, but this place was impressive to look at. And when you go inside, your get to have a hand in making your pizza. The wait was a bit long, but with all that is going on with Covid, that is to be expected. But then they apologized and cleared out the wait. I was in no hurry, I was watching the pizza's getting baked in that super cool brick oven!! The pizza was VERY good. There was a lot more flavor than I remember ever having with a pizza. And the fire roasted tomatoes I added had a lot more pop than I expected. And it all tasted great with a frosty glass of Blue Moon! We made sure we marked this place as a favorite to frequent when we get up there. Maybe next time we will just hang at the bar! :) read more

See all

I have been to several make your own pizza type restaurants in LA including Pieology and MOD. This is the best I've been to of this type. The ingredients were loaded on(no skimping) including salami, sausage, mushroom, artichoke hearts and the pizza was very fresh and healthy tasting and more delicious than the chains I've tried. This is the largest property I've been to with fine restaurant seating, large patio and a wine/beer selection. Service was outstanding by Manager Daniel and my pizza was ready in under 15 minutes. I asked for Tabasco and he brought that right out. This may be the best make your own pizza place in the state. The side greek salad was also excellent and I really liked the thick, creamy dressing. My combo of pizza, salad and drink for less than $15 is a great value. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Oh boy.....custom made pizza, tap house w 20 taps, and Gelato-- all in one. Plus large indoor and huge outdoor seating. You had me at pizza to start. Then, how can you pass up the Gelato for dessert??? Big TV and space for the game too. Sure glad I don't live in Flag, or I'd be here every night. Can you open one in Twin Cities, Minnesota please? read more

See all

Pizza toppings were great. Good selection. Negatives are time to eat (takes so long in line to order), and bottom of pizza gets charred black and inedible. See photo - we ate it but probably won't come back. read more

See all

I never got to eat the food. They use uber eats to deliver. Waited at the curb but it never arrived. I called the delivery and he (Tyree O) blocked my number. No help from Your Pie or Uber. I'm still hungry. I will not support either company in the future read more

We love coming here. For around $14-$15, you get to personalize your pizza, get a drink AND a salad/chips/gelato. One of our favorite places to grab a quick but yummy dinner with fresh and high quality ingredients. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Good food. Nice employees. *Insanely* high prices. A large Coke is $5.55. FIVE FIFTY FIVE. Never making the mistake of paying for soda here again. What on earth. read more

I came here for the first time yesterday and was pretty disappointed. Your Pie is like a lower quality and poor serviced Mod Pizza. We got there and there was no line, so we walked right up to the counter. We weren't acknowledged by any staff for a really long time. All the employees seem like they hate their jobs. We got a pizza and a panini for dine in. After we went down the line and customized our toppings, we waited several minutes at the register and nobody rang us up. Then, the girl at the register asked if we were given some kind of order card, which we did not receive, and she had to leave to figure out what order was ours. We waited about 20 minutes for our food, which came out in to go boxes. I opened my pizza up and they gave me someone else's order. They had to go back and figure out which one was mine since they had mismatched them. It was super a super disorganized experience and the service was just really poor. The food was okay. The pizza was better than the panini. The panini bread is super thin and tastes like a weird whole wheat flatbread. The restaurant was super messy, lots of tables weren't cleaned and the bar of pizza toppings was a disaster. Everything was messy and lots of cross contamination between ingredients that had spilled into other bins. Overall, I don't think I'd come back here due to low quality food and subpar service. Also, it's late January and they were playing Christmas music still...a little weird. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Custom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

It's like a mod pizza but you feel less bad about getting 10 types of toppings bc the crust is super thin. Service is quick and turnaround is quicker. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Red sauce pizza with spinach pep and three cheeses - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

I was really disappointed in this place. I ordered a summer peach salad and got something else with only greens, mozzarella cheese, red onions and tomatoes. There were no peaches. No one provided any service, they just left our salad in queue and no one bothered to ask if those were our salads, or if there was anything else we would like. The service and the food was not what I would expect. I honestly felt there was no use tipping but I did tip. read more

We order in and the pizza was good and we enjoyed the salad as well.we called on and it on time.

We ordered a 14' pepperoni pizza. The pizza was good although it lacked pepperoni. The wait time was a bit longer, I placed an online order for pick up at 6 pm. When we arrived we were told the pizza was going into the oven so that took another 15-20 minutes. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

I get that you are doing online orders and that you might be backed up while a line of in person customers are waiting, I get that it has been tough on restaurants, and to be clear I don't mind waiting and I try really hard to eat local. But it is super hard to want to spend money with you when you are just being ignored. Simple fix, have your staff say Hi! I'll be right with you or just give me a minute. When you are standing at the front of the line and their are 6 people working and they are doing a lot of things but don't acknowledge the in person customer for 5 minutes, you start to think, could I be spending my money better? Are there places that would be happy to see me as a customer? The food here is honestly hot or miss, it depends on who is working. Sometimes you can get a really good pizza with awesome ranch, and sometimes your order takes 45 minutes because they forgot to do it and it's soggy and undercooked. It's close to the house and has a great patio, I keep trying it saying maybe this time will be awesome but the awesome experiences are nor the exception nor the rule. COVID is not an excuse to be rude. read more

This is a make it your own way pizza, salad or panini. I can only eat 2 pieces max so all we needed was one pie. We got the regular crust and they also offer a gluten free crust. We had shredded and fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, sun dried tomatoes, lots of garlic, pepperoncini, and artichoke hearts. Service is quick and friendly. Once you order, your pie is brought to the table. Choose indoor or outdoor seating. The pie was delicious. Give your pie a minute or two to settle otherwise your ingredients will slice off the crust. Plenty of parking. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Front of restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Lisa and Pete have created the best Pizza experience in Flagstaff! I have been filling their journey since they broke ground here at Your Pie. They have become like family to me because we come here all the time! I get the Gluten after Cauliflower crust pizza all the time, it's made in the back to help prevent any cross contamination. They really take it serious here and I thank them for that! It's the Best gluten free pizza in town. We come at least once a week. The staff are so amazing here, so friendly! Most of them know me so they already know that I get the cauliflower crust and it gets made in the back. I love that feeling that they treat me like family. Love the rustic vibe inside, love the seating outside. They have great gelato options and alcoholic beverages. Just a great place to come with the family. Can't wait to celebrate the one year anniversary coming up June 15th! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Gluten Free, Cauliflower crust custom pizza that we love! - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Placed an order later in the evening after spending most of the day outdoors. Ordered a gluten free personal chicken and pesto pizza which was very good. We also ordered their supreme and a kids cheese pizza for my picky son. It was a great deal to get pizza a drink and scoop of gelato for $9. Quick service and friendly staff, we will return again next time we are in the area. read more

I was told this was by far the best pizza in Flagstaff, so of course I wanted to give it a try on my recent trip to the Flagstaff area. I watched the girl nearly drop my entire pie on the ground and watches as a significant amount of cheese slid off my pizza. She didn't put it back on my pizza, she just put it on a random empty shelf above it. When they brought it over to me I explained what I saw, and all the girl at the counter said was, "Well, I hope it still tastes okay.' The proper thing to do would've been to offer to remake it for me but that didn't happen at all. She didn't even apologize. I got some gelato to take home afterwards. The cinnamon vanilla was very tasty, the cookies and cream was kind of bland flavor-wise. And I had to ask her twice for some gelato spoons which were right in front of her. Then she made a joke saying she didn't know where her head was tonight. I would agree and concur- she was not thinking clearly that night during our interactions. As for the taste, the pizza wasn't bad. I got 'The Lineage' which is one of their specialties, but with meatball instead of sausage. I'd get it again, but I would definitely insist they remake it if they mess up the first one losing all that cheese, like they did during this visit. I also wish they made pizzas larger than personal size. A personal size really didn't fit what I was looking for that night. And they did give me some complimentary croutons (that I offered to pay for twice) for the Caesar salad I had brought with me on my trip, which was very nice of them, but not enough to overlook the major error they made with my pizza. I'd give them a second chance, but unless they start making larger pizzas it wouldn't be my go-to place. read more

I really enjoyed being able to choose all my own fresh ingredients for my pizza.... Which was delicious. It looks like its going to be a quick dinner but there was about 40 min wait between waiting to pay and getting our fresh baked pizzas. Also... they have some good local beers on tap AND WINE on tap! read more

The pizza is great, but the staff is horrible. the staff always gives me dirty looks like they're judging my food choice. if you want great pizza, come here! read more

Good place for allergies. Lost a star bc the woman making our allergy friendly pizza reached into the gf pizza crust box with contaminated gloves! Big no no. Same person also made me feel bad when I asked for a sorbet that wasn't all cross contaminated (she was like "what's the problem? The sorbetto is here in front" I pushed back that it was cross contaminated and she begrudgingly went in back to give us a scoop from the unopened sorbet containers. She wasn't nice about it. I think mgmt could do better training on these things and if you're going to be allergy friendly, then be friendly!!! Vegan gf pizza though was good my son loved it and he loved his sorbet so we'll be back. But I hope they can be more accommodating / friendly next time. read more

I ordered a side salad and a personal pizza through doordash and have done this before and dinned in the restaurant as well usually great. I mixed up my salad with the dressing in the togo container it came in and started eating then found a dead BUG WITH WINGS INSIDE IT. I am traumatized and will not be eating here again. read more

Your Pie Pizza - salad - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

I like this concept--good value for fresh made to order pizza. The portion sizes are reasonable, so one pizza is just about perfect for me for lunch. The wine and beer selections are a nice touch, providing a little local color. The times that I have been here, the service has been prompt, even when it was pretty packed. I also appreciate the app and being able to pay quickly from my phone! This is one of my new standby's for a quick meal. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Regular crust, marinara, mushroom, onion, garlic, jalapeño shredded moz, pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Burgers were cooked to perfection. Exceptionally tasty. We ordered takeout and food was ready promptly. Best burgers we've had in years.

Good pizza. Take out is very convenient. Service was very prompt. I would go there again.

This was a great place for lunch. The people were very friendly and helpful because There's so much to choose from. We created our own pizza and pasta. And don't forget to get the peach pizza dessert! Next time we are in town we will go here again. read more

The pizza is delicious. Tanner was very nice and friendly. All around good experience!

Wonderful pizza and plenty of vegetarian/vegan options. Had a regular crust pizza with their spicy marinara, vegan cheese, roasted tomatoes, and oregano. I kept it simple with toppings but they have a ton of options. I liked that that ordering was easy. As a reference, ordering went down a line of crust(or panini, salad), toppings, then register. Similar to ordering at subway. I was nervous about how their vegan cheese option may taste, but it was so good! The size of the pizza was just right. I had a coupon for a free 2 scoop gelato/sorbet cup. While the cup looked small, the scoops are generous. I had one scoop of their berry sorbet and one scoop of their lemon sorbet. Love that I was able to try both. The sorbet was a great way to end the meal. The space itself is clean and staff was prompt and kind. For some, the only downside about this place may be the noise level. I went on a Friday night and the place was packed. I didn't mind, but someone who isn't a fan of students or loud children may want to stay away. Love this place though and will definitely be back to try out more pizza toppings. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Vegan cheese pizza, sorbet, craft root beer. All delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

The pizza is not amazing but not terrible. I really like the setup and idea of this pizza place, you basically order like a chipotle or subway restaurant. They also serve beer so that's a plus. The summer is a great time to visit as they have a really cool outdoor patio. read more