We've been meaning to come here for months and it just so happened that there was a really long…read morewait at another nearby restaurant we went to grab dinner at so we said OOOH, let's try Marbleheads and boy are we glad we did! Walking in it was lively in the bar area because they were having a trivia night where you can win gift cards. They also have other daily events and happy hours which was great to know. We were immediately seated and our server arrived a few minutes later which was nice bc it gave us time to peek at the menu which is extensive but it was really fun because it's an actual little newspaper which was cute. We ordered the crab dip and a mango martini for me and a blood orange margarita for him of which all three were really good! So much crab dip that we took 1/2 home. And the bread and veggies they serve it with both hit! Entree wise we both ordered items we felt would tell us all we needed to know regarding whether or not they were a legit seafood restaurant - a fried shrimp basket and a broiled combo platter .... BOTH AMAZING! The fried shrimp were MASSIVE and the broiled platter was well seasoned and cooked wonderfully. We had no room for dessert but the menu sounded great. Oh our server was also wonderful! I wish I remembered her name, but she was a tall, blonde young lady with a great sense of humor. So glad our original dinner plans fell through and we finally wound up here - we will be back!

we had a great dinner tonight! it was pretty busy when we…read moregot there, but I had made a reservation, so we were seated promptly. the menu has a lot of options, and most come with a choice of two sides, so lots of decisions. I asked the server to help me choose, and she recommended the baked cod with ritz cracker crust. I remember having this type of preparation at Charlie Brown's back in the day, which was formerly in this space. we chose salads & baked potatoes as our sides, and the salads were substantial and fresh.warm rolls with butter came alongside. after a nice interval, entrees arrived piping hot and the baked potatoes were perfect. my husband got seafood au gratin which was delectable. my cod was delicious- buttery crispy topping and succulent fish. we were too full for dessert but they looked good. service was efficient and helpful, even with a busy room.

I love the New England Clam chowder!! Always delicious. Crab dip is great!! I ordered the medium…read moresize blue crabs and very good size. Very good!

I'll start off by saying that I truly want to give them a 3 1/2 star review, but since we know that…read morecan't happen I have to go with 3 stars because it wasn't close enough to a 4 star review. People love this place ... I say that because we were there late afternoon during the week and it was busy ... and it kept getting busier. I do understand why folks love it tho, because there's no other real seafood "shack" in the area specifically where folks can get their blue claw crabs. It truly does look and feel like a seafood shack because the wooden walls, brown paper on the table, paper towels on the table and overall decor scream "We are at the beach in a small southern town in the middle of nowhere where" lol Our server was great! She was very attentive and made recommendations... she was also very patient with us given that this was our first time here and we're a bit undecided on what we wanted to order. Now on to the food - this is honestly where I was underwhelmed. The broiled seafood had a whisper of flavor, the crab cake left a lot to be desired and the garlic buffalo shrimp were overwhelmingly buffalo sauce on top of fried shrimp. Now the clam chowder I had was amazing and I even ordered some to go. My friend enjoyed her crab legs meal overall and perhaps if we visit again that's the route I'll go. Oh and it's also a BYOB , so, be sure to grab your favorite bottle and bring it on in.

Server Rihanna was very nice. Tuna nachos and hush puppies on point. The whole reason I came there…read morethough, the hot lobster roll, was a disappointment. Pathetic small portion. Complained to server about it and she confirmed she's heard the same from other customers about the drop off in portion size over last few years. Probably going across the street to Atlantic for rolls going forward. And that missing bite in pic was mostly bread which actually tasted good.

Cute little fish shanty by the water in Point Pleasant. The food was great and the service was…read morefriendly. This has a great low-key vibe with a real fishing type of decor. The area is great. We had a lobster roll, New England clam chowder, Manhattan clam chowder, swordfish bites, and brussels sprouts, with bacon and Parmesan, and two unsweetened iced teas. Everything was wonderful. We highly recommend the swordfish bites, they were literally fantastic. You can sit inside or outside, we opted for outside because they had shady little nooks where you could sit that had fans and it was so cool and comfortable. I could've sat there for hours. This is a BYOB. We had also visited the other point lobster house that is in the walkable town a few blocks away and that is a bar so it's not a BYOB. Just something to keep in mind the spot that's by the water you need to bring your own wine.

Always return here and am never disappointed. On point service and a kitchen that created a…read morewonderful Salmon Risotto. As I said in a previous review this place is boring in the best way possible. Parking can be an issue on some side streets because regrettably, Princeton hates cars but after 5p you can slide in across the street at the Post Office. Five enduring stars.

We're regulars who came to celebrate our anniversary and left disappointed…read more The seafood is still the highlight; the black cod is excellent and the kitchen clearly knows what it's doing. But the service was frankly poor. We waited endlessly for a takeout box and had to track down a different server to get one. The ice bucket arrived barely filled. The dessert looked like an afterthought, nothing close to what you'd expect at this price point. The only thing that came fast was the check. At $152 (before tip) for two entrees, a salad, an app, and one forgettable dessert, the value just isn't there when the service is this slack. The food still has potential, but we left feeling like our loyalty and our anniversary celebration deserved better.

Fresh food and good service. We love that place. Price a little bit high but worth itread more

Archar's Seafood store in Somerset NJ is honestly the most wonderful and freshest seafood you can…read morebuy. Mike will help you with choosing fish and guide you on how to cook it! I had an education about the different salmons and how they are farmed and taste. I have gotten crabs cooked for me. This week ai ordered 2 pound lobster and I cooked them exactly as instructed by Mike. Perfect!!!! My 2 plus hour drive each way is always worth it. Next time oysters ( opened and packed up) and salmon. I do not understand why there is not a ten star option for my review?

We went here to buy the fish for our Christmas Eve celebration and ordered ahead for a seamless…read morepickup. We ordered a few days ahead of time and paid when we got to the store. We arrived around 10:30am and were helped immediately. The employees were very friendly and double checked the portions with us before providing us the order. The fish was also very fresh, great quality, and at very reasonable prices! We will be back again for any fresh fish needs.

This place is. Offf the hook literally we had tuna steaks. And scallops. They were right off the…read moreboat The prices were also awesome The nice gentleman behind the counter named Mike was so knowledgeable. He also directed us to the American shrimp. He told me about actually looking to see where the fish and other items come from We will most certainly be back

Oceancrat special with medium spice was perfect. Food was so tasty and fresh…read more 2lb snow crabs, 1lb muscles, 1lb shrimp, 1/2 lb of sausage, 2 lobster tails was plenty of food for 4 people. We had some leftovers to take home. The garlic noodles don't look like much, but were delicious. Adding the seafood boil sauce on top of the noodles was chef's kiss.

I've been here a few times. Overall, the food is good, great music playlist but the drinks are weak…read morein my opinion. It can get crowded in there real quick, so be mindful if you think you're gonna have an intimate dinner - you're not. I usually get the snow crab with sausage and white rice, no complaints with the food. The last time I went there, karaoke was supposed to happen, but it didn't.

I was craving some blue crabs soon my way home I popped in to check out what was available. They…read morehad so many different sized crabs for different amounts, I believe the smallest crab is $3 a piece. I only ordered a few just to snack on. They were meaty, sweet, and flavorful. The young man behind the counter was very kind and helpful. Nice business. They have a lot of other items to offer, so I will surely be back soon. There is plenty of parking but is located in a difficult spot if you are traveling south on route 1.

The crab and lobster are delicious here! I also love the soups. You can order cold, hot, or pick up…read morefrozen and they are quick to prepare your order. The staff are friendly and the quality of their food is top notch. We love this place!! Honestly, I'd much rather order seafood here than at a restaurant any day.

The owner JT is so funny, he's very nice. He's very very welcoming. The food is great. I mean the…read moreCrabs, shrimp, fried fish seafood salad. Everything is always so nice and fresh. The service is wonderful. If you come a couple times,He remembers you by name or the conversation y'all had last.

First of all the guy at the counter was very rude. We asked him if the platter could be split…read morebetween two people and he said no I will post the picture below of how large the platter was. It could definitely have been split so he lied.second of all it was a little gritty and not as clean as I would like, the bathrooms were disgusting. The corn on my platter was old and inedible. The clams were rubbery and tough. You do go to the counter to get your food yourself, but I figured they would clear the table for us, especially since I tipped them $10 but as I was walking out the door, the counter guy yelled at me." hey you need to throw away your trash!" it was very embarrassing, and I had neatly piled my plates and trash so that it was an easy cleanup and I figured they would have to wipe the table anyway, but now knowing how nasty it is in there, they probably don't wipe the tables. I do not recommend nor will I ever go here again. To top it all off I spent more time in the bathroom afterwards than I would like.

Went there Sunday morning with my daughter's family. They…read morewere crazy busy. Waited about 20 minutes and it was worth it. Excellent portions, good service, a little slow but worth the wait. A little loud, but understandable because it was so busy. We would definitely return

Well, the food is still outstanding, 12 days later, toilets have not been replaced and are still…read morenot flushing. Walked into a wad of TP and pee in the toilet. I didn't bring it to their attention this time. I just changed my instructions to make my food to go, instead. Anyway, not sure if they read yelp reviews, but they should. I don't want to say more, in person, because then I would be uncomfortable to even order take out. They could even decide not to serve me. They have that right. I'd be sad because the food is soooo good! lol The ambience is fair, the music is way tooooo loud. That might be nice for the chefs and staff. It is awful for the diners. Nobody ever wants to say anything. I cannot be the only one who feels this way. I should not have to talk very loudly to the person sitting next to me, let alone across from me. I must sit next to the person or I can't hear a thing. PS - my hearing is fine. No medical issues.