Outstanding food. Great service. You would think your eating in a NYC Restutant Upstate ny truly has the gem of a family restaurant!!!! The pizza is great as well. I love the cheese steak pie !!! Oh the homemade bruschetta with homemade mozzarella is to die for. Did I forget the cannolis ? A++++++. All in an old world setting. read more

We ate at Aiello's on Jan 19, celebrating my husbands birthday. Everything was outstanding. The calamari appetizer was the best we have ever had. We ordered Delmonico Steaks. They were so tender and flavorful. Excellent choices of wine and large portions add to the great dinner. Our server, Tyler, was also excellent. He was quite busy and handled it perfectly. He was attentive and friendly. We couldn't have asked for more. We will definitely go back. read more

I understand that during a pandemic, restaurants may not be able to serve at their full potential, however, this place was horriblee. There were flies in the restaurant buzzing around us. And we were given a couples size table for 4 people. That's barely any room. The workers were nice but the food was horrible. None of us even got through half of the meal. How can they mess up Buffalo wings?? The chicken was under cooked and it was drenched in hot sauce. Don't get their chicken piccata and definitely not the calzone. You're better off going to Dunkin' Donuts. Waste of money, the best item was their complimentary salad and bread. read more

First time there. Mushroom soup room temperature. Meatballs served with stuffed rigatoni room temp. Seems a little more time in the microwave was needed. Wife had a side of spaghetti, seemed like it was tossed with a can of hunts tomato sauce. I will try again as everyone can have a bad day, but definitely not impressed. read more

We stopped here on our long drive back from Ithaca to Long Island over the weekend. I googled places to eat and this place was one of the few non fast food options. The place was like walking into your great grandmother's Italian old home. It had an odd smell but I got pasted it. We waited a long time for our waitress who was scary happy to serve us. I had a spinach salad with chicken which wasn't anything to write home about but it was OK. The coffee I ordered was just boiled water, had no flavor and I had to do to Dunkin nearby to get my fix. All and all, one of the non fast food options so it is what it is. read more

Aiello's Restaurant - Chicken spinach salad... Nothing special - Italian Near Me - Whitney Point, New York

Great food. Best Alfredo sauce I've ever had. I got Cajun chicken in Alfredo sauce with Linguini. Chicken and spice was perfect. My wife's Arugula salad was very good. read more

Aiello's is a great spot!! Me and my friends stopped there for a what we thought would be a quick bite but after talking to Jeremy about the history of the place we ended up staying over an hour and a half. Was truly a great experience and the service was top notch. A great group of staff and the food was amazing! Highly recommend! Thanks for the desert Jeremy! read more

This place is awesome. Great food. Great pizza. Loved the marguerite pie. We came here on Mother's Day after a graduation so we were concerned the service would be bad. It was actually impeccable. Try the stuffed mushrooms. Ours was seafood l-stuffed. It was also really good. I plan on coming back here anytime I am in Binghamton or Cortland. Worth the trip! read more

I definitely recommend this restaurant! Everything was simply delightful! Every plate or bowl was beautiful and it tasted as good as it looked, it was amazingly tasty. I ordered the ravioli, it had the perfect amount of cheese and delicious tomato sauce. The ravioli in general had a scrumptious cream cheese and bright veggies, it was as smooth as butter and the way the skin looked was so pretty! While we where waiting for our food our waiter named Crystal was so nice and funny, and gave us some bread. The bread with butter was awesome! The crust of the bread was nice and crunchy but the middle of it was really soft and fluffy! Almost the best bread I ever had!!! It was all delightful. read more

We went for a nice dinner tonight. I had chicken franchise, my wife had fish and chips. All was homemade including the bread - REALLY delicious. Highly recommended this place read more

Stopped here on the way on us81, location is convenient. Owner is nice to give is menu as waitress was busy. We ordered mushroom soup which was delicious, meatballs, shrimp which were OK and veal marsala. Veal was over salted and sauce was too sour. I ate only peace and left it. Waitress asked how we are doing but didn't really care about the answer. Didn't ask why the veal is almost not touched. Not returning read more

Aiello's Restaurant - Veal marsala - Italian Near Me - Whitney Point, New York

THE BEST GARLIC KNOTS EVER! Pizza is good too... A nice restaurant to sit down for a meal or take some food to go. Always a consistent good quality meal. read more

Very good food great service. They always have a smile and courteous. I had the ranchero chicken panini and loved it.

Great food, great drinks, great atmosphere. Upscale restaurant/lounge in a lovely little town located between Binghamton Ny and Syracuse.

The food and service at Aiello's were both decent, but not in proportion to the pricing. The location is convenient, but not exactly scenic. I found the Greek salad to be quite good, but the margherita pizza rather bland. That said, what really detracted from the experience was the state of the men's restroom, with an unflushed toilet and water (best case scenario) all over the floor. At a restaurant where dinner ran $30+ per customer, I expected the facilities to be in better shape. While I'm sure that another patron was to blame for the mess, it was a quiet evening and an employee could have found time to check on the state of the restrooms once in awhile. read more

WOOOOOOW...... This place is AMAZBALLS. Mikayla is the S#%^. I'm telling you. I've been to Italy a few times and it's just like the old Country. Thank you Charlie! read more

Excellent food and service. The haddock with seafood stuffing was superb. Definitely will eat here again.

Waiters were very kind and food was good , what I didn't appreciate was waiting for our food for almost an hour and a half but everyone who came way after us all enjoyed their meal and left, my husband and I are Latin and it's very odd and too much of a coincidence that we were the only ones waiting that long, our waitress was very apologetic but the owner seemed like he can care less that we waited that long, there was a table who came after us who got the same meal but was served first ... very disappointed because I was excited for the experience and food but instead we had to go through that ... read more

amazing food, amazing expeirence! waitress was so nice and food was authentic italian. read more

Aiello's Restaurant - Margarita Pizza - Italian Near Me - Whitney Point, New York

We waited over 20 minutes without 1 employee acknowledging us, they all walk passed and looked but no service.

Stopped in during our trip back from Syracuse. What a gem nested in an old building ! Top notch service ! Ask for Sarah Jane !! Everything was homemade and delicious; from the Sangria to the Tiramisu. We had a Sicilian "Charlie's Special" pizza. Unbelievably generous with the toppings. Best pizza I've had in a while. Took most of it home as it was sooo filling. Definitely stop by. You won't regret it. read more

Aiello's Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Whitney Point, New York

First time here and the food was excellent! Service was great and staff was super friendly! Clean, well spaced, and social distancing well practiced. We will definitely be back!! read more

This place is the best! Best in the area and the closest thing to NYC food! The owner- a real Sicilian knows how to cook and work a room!!

Cool little Italian spot to stop at off the main highways from PA into NY. Can be hard to "highway find" something other than a McDonalds or Sunoco, so a nice change when cruising along. Had a Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken and a new white wine on recommendation, and both were tasty. read more

Aiello's Restaurant - Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken - Italian Near Me - Whitney Point, New York

We wound up at Aiello's as it is one of the only sit-down restaurants in Whitney Point. We showed up on a Saturday night around 5:30pm with a party of 7 and were seated within 15 minutes. The ambiance is a touch strange but not enough to keep you from dining in (think: dining in your grandma's living room, complete with family photos and the like). The service was fast and friendly. We ordered 3 large pizzas including plain cheese, pepperoni and a house specialty with broccoli and tomatoes. All tasted great and I would definitely go again if we were in the area. read more

Just throwing this out there (not a huge review) but I've been going to Aiellos forever and it's always been simply fantastic. Love it there every time. The impetus for this review, though, is that my mom just brought home half a leftover BLT panini from Aiello's and I ended up eating it (cold, two days old). Now, I don't really like paninis and I don't really even like foccacia bread, or tomatoes, or lettuce, or mayo. I was eating the thing to get it out of the fridge. I do like bacon, though. A lot. And the bacon that Aiello's is using on these BLT's is absolutely fantastic. It's a heavily smoked bacon and it's magnificent. If you like smokey bacon, you will devour a BLT from Aiello's. Go get you one. read more

Great place for amazing Italian cuisine! We went on a Saturday night and the place was packed. We sat in the bar area in the very back corner. Despite all of the people at the bar, our waitress Crystal which ALSO ran the bar was the BEST waitress I have ever had! She is very personable, efficient and really cares about her customers. She made our experience amazing. I can't wait to go back and hope to get her as a waitress! read more

Aiello's is our favorite place to go. The atmosphere is phenomenal. Charlie and Vinny are always willing to talk with their guests and ensure they are getting the best service and to make sure they are enjoying their meals. The Prime Rib on Friday nights is our favorite. The pizza is terrific as well. There is no competition around when it comes to their pizza. The restaurant is very classy but also has a nice bar area if you are into more casual dining. ENJOY! If you want to try something amazing from your own home? Try their breakfast pizza!!! I was amazed how good it was read more

The place to go whether you are swinging through from out of town or just up the road. The "world famous" Aiello's doesn't disappoint! read more

Aiello's Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Whitney Point, New York

See all

I love the homemade everything.... no frozen mozzarella sticks here...all fresh and made here. My spaghetti cones with a fresh sauce and a sausage made in the kitchen. I live the 1920s decor, too. Very reed but they pull off the elegance. Hard to do. read more

Aiello's Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Whitney Point, New York

We went to NYC for the summer and our way back home to Canada, we took a pit stop as we were hungry. We had no idea we would find this hidden gem. WOW! Home made italian food and we even met the nonna who makes it. Talk about authentic. Everyone there was friendly and personable. The place was spotless and smelled amazing. I had the chicken parm and my husband had the penne a la vodka. Crazy amazing! All I can say is this a place we will definetly go back to when travelling to and from NYC!!! read more

Three things: great atmosphere and decorations, but slow service and expensive small meals. I came with a party of five and it seemed a little busy, but it took around an hour for us to finally get our meals. I ordered Fettucini Alfredo and was dissapointed on how small the plate was for 14 dollars. I order that almost everytime I go to an italian restaurant at home and it is always much cheaper with much more pasta. On the positive side, the sauce was very good quality and they had lots in the dish. If anything, they could have thrown in more pasta since there was so much extra sauce. read more

Amazing food...chef makes amazing seafood that is his speciality. Service was incredible, food was incredible. Absolutely going to return

I would give this place 3.5 stars if I could. A cute little place that we stopped at because we didn't want fast food. We sat for a while before our waitress came over to us, who was weird...I just can't explain it. Anyways. This place was a bar/pizzeria/restaurant so they had an extensive menu. We wanted to get on the road so we just ordered simple things. I started off with the French onion soup which was delicious! After that I got the chicken parmesan panini. It was eh. It didn't really have much flavor but the burger looked good. So did the pizza. I would recommend sticking to those. read more

I'm an NYC transplant to the area and a new acquaintance told me of this place. Said the owners born in Italy and came to upstate NY via Brooklyn. Ive eatin at some great restaurants in the city and these folks, I'll put them up against any of them. Sat at the bar, the owners son was behind the stick and very accommodating. Good selection of wines, was able to order off the menu with no problem. Looks like I've found a good spot for really great Italian food. If your in the area and don't stop your doing yourself a disservice. read more

Excellent food, great staff. Our waitress Margarit was delightful! Personable and attentive, happy and efficient!It was a great visit. Will definitely take my fiancée back there on Date Night again! read more

We order out from here probably once every two weeks. Their food has been consistently good over the years. Their garlic nots are very unique and not something you can get anywhere else. They are huge and are tossed in garlic butter, if I had to guess. Their subs good, fairly standard. Pizza is great New York style pie. Wings are very enjoyable. I can only really review the take out side of things. We never really stop into the restaurant to sit down for an actual meal. It's usually more on the expensive side. We just love getting food from here when we are all tired from work, and wasn't to drive up the road to get done great good to take home. Will absolutely keep coming back for years to come. read more

Quaint little gem. Great food, excellent service. Love the decor. A romantic dinner or a business lunch or dinner. You won't be disappointed. read more

My grandsons and I were headed home on I-81 when I suddenly had a desire for rigatonis and meatballs! Grandson both agreed Italian for dinner was the target! Coincidentally 5 miles down the road we saw a road sign for Aiello's Ristorante!!! WOW! Old school charm and fabulous food complimented by a welcoming and attentive staff!!! From now on Aiellos will be a destination spot for special times!!!! read more

Lunch but we definitely took it up a notch with everything we ordered. I chose the Greek Salad, added shrimp, $12 but well worth it! Loved the stuffed grape leaves! Joe ordered the mozzarella platter and a toss salad. Never have had mozzi's served like this, 4 triangles with sauce in the center. Really unique presentation. They don't serve bread and butter like we are use to getting while waiting for meal in an Italian restaurant, but we took the advice of our server and ordered mozzi bread - it was great! I opted to take cannoli home to enjoy, Joe ordered the carrot cake - the picture says it all - wow!! We really enjoyed lunch, the restaurant is a historical landmark in Whitney Point, very nice, we pretty much had the place to ourselves, it was Thursday 2pm. But be ready with the wallet - sure we pretty much ordered dinners, didnt take advantage of lunch menu, my glass of wine, 9 oz was $16 ouch....we took home leftovers that turned into our dinner so really a good deal for us! read more

See all