Ameti&#x27;s Pizza

Katz like quality and size at about half the price and without the toll and tunnel, what's not to…read morelike?!

I just had to Reuben with the corned beef. It was really really great one of the best sandwiches…read moreI've ever had.. i can tell you this as a chef for over 30 years if you love corn beef, pastrami, or brisket this is a place for you. No reason to go to nyc this is the jersey spot for corn, beef, pastrami, brisket, all hands down it's a great place a lot of people would compare it to Kats in New york. My advice is order on the phone to take out 30 min ahead. This place is busy. Once the word gets around on how great the food is it will be just a long to wait like Kats in nyc So go there now Service is as great as it can be because its busy now. I dont know whats going to happen when word of mouth hits because this place is really that great If you like my reviews add me as your friend

The kitchen

Rueben sandwich - wow!

See all

Tony Boys Sandwich House

4.4(30 reviews)

3.7 mi

My daughter surprised me with this Tony's Boys tuna fish wrap, fantastic! From the moment I…read moregrabbed the cold bag, I knew this tuna was freshly prepared and taste great Needless to say, it was heavenly well prepared with fresh lettuce, tomato, and wheat wrap. I will be back Jack! Awesome staff with order on time. Show me sandwich deli.

Came here during the week for lunch with my girlfriends. My one friend and I got two different…read moretypes of their cutlet sandwiches. They were a pretty big size for a good price. The cutlet themselves were pretty tasty. My friend got the buffalo chicken salad and she liked it, but she wished she got a cutlet sandwich after seeing them. I do wish the cheese on my sandwich was melted, but that was my mistake. I could've asked for that.

The Nutty Pig - Chicken Cutlet w/ warm peanut butter sauce, jelly & bacon.

See all

Salads, Cold Subs & More

Agamie Gourmet Delicatessen & Caterers

4.7(90 reviews)

1.1 mi

Fantastic dishes, delicacy, cold, cuts, sandwiches, hot, or cold like they used to be in back in…read morethe day‍. What a delightful atmosphere and friendly staff. My cheesesteak sandwich was custom with shredded lettuce and flavorful chopped steak . Also, the Italian Classic sandwich is above the best deli.

Delis like this are all but extinct. Live that this place still exists…read more Think 1980's and you will be transported back in time. Not much special here just your run of the mill deli which I love. Their bread isn't great but it goes well with their meats and cheeses.

Front of Agamie Deli.

See all

Classic Italian .

Nonno's Pizzeria Deli & Catering

4.3(42 reviews)

2.6 mi

Great place ! Nice ppl pizza and wings were excellent ! Thank you ! We will definitely order again…read more!

Pizza is one of the worst things I have ever put in my mouth. Nonna is spinning in her grave, if…read morethat's the sauce they went with. Pretty close to kepsup.

Drunken Grandma Slice

See all

The Happy Belly Cafe

4.5(128 reviews)

1.5 mi

7/16/26: (Update) The Happy Belly is still a winner!…read more Ordered the Crab Cake Sandwich and Grilled Chicken Wrap through DoorDash. It was my first time ordering the crabcake sandwich. The three fresh crabcakes are very small, but extremely tasty with their special Aioli Dressing. I would definitely order again! The grilled chicken wrap is very good too! Have been ordering here for over three years! The food continues to be wonderful. Congratulations to The Happy Belly Cafe! Your recognition for Restaurant Guru 2026 is well deserved!!!

I noticed that they were giving out plastic bags for 2go orders even though they are banned. I also…read morenoticed that there are recyclables in the garbage. I asked the person who helped me if you recycle and they said no. You lost my business. It's estimated that 80% of materials in landfills could have been recycled. This is why. I recycle at home. Why don't you recycle?

Limited Hearty Breakfast Wrap, the Chicken Caprese Panini, 16 oz. Hot Chocolate, and the 16 oz. Matcha Latte

See all

Doordash- Roasted Turkey Avocado Sandwich.

Staci's Sandwich Joint

4.8(75 reviews)

3.8 mi

Women-owned & operated

Catering service

One of my friends was raving about The Caesar Sandwich Chicken Cutlet Semolina I just had to go and…read moretry it myself. After practically inhaling it, I concluded "she was NOT exaggerating"!

I've only had, "The Zach" sandwich and love it so much I'll probably never have anything else!…read more Very fresh Italian bread and a freshly fried breaded chicken cutlet. Overloaded with Romain lettuce and delicious buffalo/blue cheese dressing! I always begin eating it with a knife and fork until I can close it! A bit pricey but in all fairness a sandwich is large enough for two adults. Or the next day! Service is very friendly as well!

See all

Annamaria's Deli

4.7(102 reviews)

4.5 mi

Good people Good food…read moreGood prices Yes I'm recommend this places The best food & sandwiches

Annamaria's Deli is on Point!! It reminds me of the must go to sandwich shop in Rome Italy called…read more"All'Antico Vinaio" restaurant... it's a neighborhood hood sandwich shop that also sells limited Italian groceries too. There's many sandwich styles to choose from and I had the Anna Maria and it was excellent. The fresh meat cut for your sandwich is piled on and the other ingredients speak for themselves as the flavors keep you wanting more. I asked if I could change the hot pepper spread for the sweet "No Problem ". The service is top notch! I don't think you can get any closer to the taste of a sandwich in Italy so this is the next best thing. Make sure to stop by and find out what's your new favorite sandwich!

LOUIE - it's not roasted chicken which can be confusing, more like deli Turkey but enjoyed!

See all

Exterior

Vilardo's Deli & Catering

4.7(73 reviews)

2.0 mi

Consistently great. I have been coming to Vilardo's since they opened their doors, and from day one…read morethey have hit the mark. You'd be hard pressed to find a higher quality deli and that's saying a lot given the concentration of reliable Italian delis in the area. With that being said, the best kept secret is their catering. Without fail, guests rave about the food and always ask where it came from. And these are guests that know their food! Their shrimp scampi in particular was a massive hit. It's our go-to for catering any gathering and for good reason. Keep up the tremendous work!

Stopped into Vilardo's Deli for lunch and ordered the Chicken Cutlet #4. What a sandwich. Crispy…read morechicken cutlet topped with fresh mozzarella, arugula, roasted red peppers, and a balsamic glaze which brought everything together just perfectly. The bread was fresh and had just the right crunch. Service was quick and efficient, parking was easy, and the location is super convenient. Sometimes the simplest lunches end up being the best. This was one of them. I'll definitely be back for another.

Inside where you order food

See all

Taylor ham, egg & cheese

Troops Subs

3.9(99 reviews)

1.0 mi

I like the sub sandwiches here, you have to know what you want, quick! I can't remember what I…read moreordered, maybe the classic Italian, but it was awesome. Everything was fresh. The owner moves fast. But I honestly loved the sandwich!!!!!!

The sandwiches are pretty decent although the service was pretty terrible. The old man with the…read moremask taking the order was rude and showed no interest in the customer. He hardly made eye contact at all and had a horrible attitude when taking my order. Show some better customer service.

See all

Dutch's Sandwich Shop

4.5(85 reviews)

3.7 mi

Wow what a superb breakfast Sammy! The layers of my Becky were absolutely scrumptious, and I made…read morean excellent choice of adding a hash brown. Everything was so flavorful. Don't sleep on the donuts either! The Nutella Cronut was a delightful treat. Parking near here can be tough on the weekend.

My friend picked up this sandwich for me while I got my hair done and WOW did it hit the spot! From…read morethe sauce to the crispy hash brown and bacon to the soft bun - it really was delicious. Messy but worth it.

See more unrecommended reviews

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

21 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Gary B.

4 years ago

We have been ordering from Ameti's for over 20 years and they are one of the few Italian/Pizza restaurants to maintain consistency and quality of food in a service based industry. They have a great menu selection for not only Pizza, but salads, full dinners, etc. I think they recently updated their menus and specials. I have an old paper menu from 2021, which has daily specials printed on it. Altho their new menu is slightly different and prices have increased, they've always given us the better price when ordering off the old menu, as once we give our address for delivery, they know who we are. If you want fantastic chicken parmasean this is the place to get it. As with any dining establishment an off day does happen. None of us are perfect. Ameti's will continue to be our go to place for Italian food. I don't know where the negative reviews about call in service, delivery come from. We've not ever been treated poorly, phone, in person or by the delivery drivers. I guess the old adage of treat others as you want to be treated apply. A kind word and decent tips don't hurt either LOL.... read more

Brianna B.

261

6 years ago

Update **** I am now being harrassed over a refund Grubhub issued me when I spoke to them and how I was treated!! DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE!!! THEY ARE CRAZY! I want to like this place I really do and I have been ordering from here for years but their customer service is awful! If their not berating you over the phone their nasty when they come pick it up. The delivery driver wouldn't leave without a tip! Refused to drop off the food at the front desk until we came down and gave them a tip!! I thought I had pretipped on the grub hub app already! Being in the restaurant business myself I would never not tip a service worker! Unbelievable and embarrassing! Never again that was the last straw! So many better pizzas to order from without the attitude! I will gladly spend my money on other restaurants during this time! read more

John R.

7 years ago

Professionalism - 1 Customer Service - 1 Timing of food preparation- 1 Delivery driver- clipped my car side mirror and drove away to a delivery. Opened at 10am but no food to be served- Waited 30 minutes for a slice of pizza even though I was told 5-7 minutes. Cleanliness-1. It's 90 degrees outside. 110 degrees inside the pizzeria. Given the pizza close to 30 minutes. A kind gesture would have been suffice and eliminated from a review because it's understandable on how to open a restaurant, but the fact that the phrase "here" was used instead of thank you or sorry is pathetically unprofessional. Never coming to this spot again. I work for Bar Stool also. Should have done a video read more

Nick L.

10 years ago

the most fun staff every i come in the every one is having a fun time good atmosphere good place to help out the have love in their hearts for feeding and giving him someplace warm during the day instead of the car sherief and liz are good hearted people and for that i honer them for it helping the homless people read more

Ardit A.

9 years ago

the food at ametis is always quality and for the time they deliver the food for the amount of time it takes to prepare such quality fresh food is quick! if you are thinking (love) your thinking about (pizza) /// if your thinking your most likely thinking of ametis read more

Luis R.

4 years ago

Wife went in there to get pizza and the white guy with the beard curse my wife out and called her a mut. He does delivery. I'll never go there again. Disrespected my family. We always order pizza from here, but never again. read more

Dakima J.

7 years ago

I really like this place for delivery. The food always comes on time and tastes great. The pizzas are fairly big with lots of cheese and many different toppings to choose from. The delivery people are really nice. read more

Alan M.

6 years ago

Past two orders had to be canceled and refunded for being over an hour late. Food was great the first time we ordered, but are seriously disappointed with the past two orders. read more

David K.

150

6 years ago

our go to. The best of the locals, great food great staff quick delivery very good prices. great overall take-out spot!

John P.

13 years ago

their pizza is very good however they no longer take American Express so for me I can no longer deal with them...

Kyle R.

9 years ago

The go to place for takeout. Great food, always consistent. Delivery can be slow but it's definitely worth it.

Christina P.

7 years ago

I am no longer a pizza person, but this place changed my mind! Brought me back to my hometown pizzeria memories!

Rolando R.

9 years ago

Everything is amazing. This is my go to place when I don't want to cook and they don't fail with their meals.

Lawrence W.

10 years ago

Delicious pizza and very reasonably priced. the dudes here are really nice! Love this place, best pizza.

Baby S.

6 years ago

Always great. We have gotten pizza and sandwiches from them. Very quick and polite. Great prices as well

Matt A.

9 years ago

Very Oily and undercooked the time i visited, maybe i went on a bad day it was so bad i cant go back

Sam J.

8 years ago

great pizza, great prices. went in last wednesday on a whim and was not disappointed.

Marie C.

12 years ago

The pizza was great and the delivery was fast. Highly recommended!

Michael B.

14 years ago

Great food, great prices, great service - and great neighbors!

Thomas L.

14 years ago

The food is good. Affordable!! The Best! read more

Ameti's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Ameti's Pizza also viewed

Ritacco Brothers Brick Oven Pizza

3.6

(111 reviews)

I completed loved the Sicilian honey drizzled pepperoni slice it was so delicious. It was on the…read moreslightly sweeter side but that's what made it fantastic to me ! It was a good crunch too... everything about this slice was great even as I write this review my mouth waters . Service was amazing the lady at the counter was friendly and patient. Good ambiance came around 2 and it was slightly busy but overall good vibes .

My experience with ritacco pizza in nutley wow dont go their the pizza is to expensive $20 for a…read morelarge when I can go to cucina rockys pay like $14 for large. Im warning you all do not bye pizza from ritacco

Loue's Place Pizza & Pasta

3.5

(62 reviews)

Ordered through the Slice App. 1hr after not receiving, I called them directly to check on my…read moreorder. The woman who picked up the phone tonight was not hospitable & in fact admitted to Not entering the order & w/ no remorse bluntly asked if I wanted it or not. I ended up saying yes b/c I needed to feed my kids before bed which was in 35min. When I conte ted Slice they advised they tried to get a discount from Loue's admitted error on their part & they said No. This is the 2nd time most recently where I ordered from them & the 1st time they messed up my order before, but I let it go. 2nd time it happens again & the woman admitted to it & not even a discount or something on the house. They need to learn what genuine hospitality is. I'll be sure to continue to order for Rocky's and Pick-up at Ralph's. Food: the Garlic knots they gave us was Burnt. My daughter used to love them & threw it out. The cheese calzone was underwhelming & the pizza was soggier than a wet sock. Awful hospitality & not worth the aggravation of ordering from them ever again & anyone who asks where to order I'll be sure not let them know never to go here.

Wow what a disaster I loved the place when it opened not now . Don't order a sandwich you will get…read morea microwaved soggy mess . And they can't get you order right very sad

Viva La Pizza

4.3

(103 reviews)

My favorite pizza slice in the neighborhood. Just the right amount of cheese and tomato!read more

Went there late on a Wednesday afternoon and the Buffalo chicken slice was great!…read more Will return for a whole pie, soon.

Clifton Village Pizza

4.1

(197 reviews)

So torn on this place. It's good and I keep going back…read morebecause it's around the corner but the prices are just out of hand on some things. It's mostly the toppings that get me. Anyway it's the best spot for specialty slices since they have 40 different ones. Their salads are ok.

Amazing pizza! The crust is perfect and the sauce has so much flavor…read more they have a huge variety of pizza and if your lookiing for something special they will accomodate you. They have a hug menu and i would highly recommend this place for pizza and any kind of italian food.

Mario's Famous Pizzeria

3.2

(78 reviews)

Randomly drove past and decided I wanted pizza. Greeted upon entering and ordered my pepperoni…read moreslice to go for $4. They have seating if you want to eat there. The pizza itself was good. I didn't love the sauce but overall still a really yummy slice. Had enough pepperonis and cheese but my fave was the thickness and texture of the crust.

I was in the area and decided to stop at Mario's for a slice, pizza was pretty good couldn't…read morecomplain staff was friendly and the place had that hardcore Italian vibe i definitely suggest

Amore Pizza by jack calandra

3.8

(77 reviews)

Very underwhelming. This place has been on my list for a…read morewhile and while I'm glad I tried it I probably wouldn't go back. The classic pie was good, very garlicky. Good amount of sauce and cheese but not my favorite pizza ever. The calzone was ok as well. Very garlicky also and sometimes you just want a classic calzone flavor. Garlic isn't a bad thing but it was a little overwhelming for me. The nail in the coffin was the cheesesteak. Don't even offer it on the menu if you're just gonna sell me some good bread with just peppers and onions. There was literally barely any meat in the sandwich. It was super disappointing. Take the fries off and add more protein. We picked up the food and that was easy, nice parking lot and the staff was friendly. They have a nice little outdoor seating area also.

Went here for the first time last nite on a date night with the wife. Yes I am a lucky man when we…read moreboth enjoy a great pie outside for a date! Firstly, the food is prepared surprisingly fast. The pictures of the pizzas above the ordering window are mostly described as crispy or thin or both- so many to choose from. My kinda place. The Italia had the perfect ratio of cheese and flavorful sauce with the kinda crisp/char I love on the edges. Hey if you like pizzas where you dont eat the crust, I don't wanna hear it lol. Heres my tip: Get the fries as well! I love fries as much as I love pizza and these were so crisp on the outside with the perfect amount of salt that I could have eaten them without the ketchup! Jack Calandra - I am coming back for those fries and a pie- my only problem- which pizza do I try next

Rocky's Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.7

(64 reviews)

They were mean to me. And they lied about a lot of stuff too. It used to be better before these new…read moreworkers came in too.

Rocky's has a great cheese pie! Picked one up in a hurry…read morefor dinner one night and was pleasantly surprised. The sauce was delicious, thin crust and just the right amount of cheese. The interior of this place could use a little facelift but the staff is friendly and efficient. I'll definitely stop by to grab a pie in the future.

Se7te Woodfire Pizza

3.9

(136 reviews)

I have been passing Se7te for years and not thinking twice about it. After being around town and…read morehearing about their great authentic Italian food, I decided to pop in with friends and give it a try- it did NOT disappoint! A hidden gem on Union Blvd for sure! I'd definitely recommend making a reservation, since we walked in and it was already busy. The dining room is on the smaller side and it's clear this spot is a local favorite. Portions are very generous, so come hungry. The white pizza is a must-try! It features thin, crispy crust topped with airy ricotta and fresh mozzarella that makes every bite light and flavorful. You can tell they use fresh, high-quality ingredients for all of their dishes. I ordered the chicken Francese as my main entree and it was absolutely perfect! The chicken was light and covered in a flavorful lemony sauce that wasn't too thick for my liking. It was one of those meals you think about after because it was THAT good! Overall, I will definitely be back. If you're around the area, it's worth the visit!

This is one of my favorite go to places - BYOB. Pizzas is SO good although you can order any other…read moredish from the menu. We also love their pasta. Great food and great place to sit and take your time eating. Would def recommend.

Bell Paese Deli Pizzeria and Trattoria

3.8

(105 reviews)

Post Covid, it seems like the Marinara Sauce in NJ has become somewhat like what they serve in…read moreCalifornia. Hence, I was happy to learn about Bell Paese (196 Franklin Ave Nutley NJ), a place known for their sauce and fresh seafood, I walked in Bell Paese and right away noticed Scungilli and Calamari in Marinara Sauce on the menu. Still somewhat skeptical, I ordered a slice of pizza. Indeed, both the crust and sauce were different. One slice and I was a believer. I next requested Joe (one of the owners) to make me a Scungilli & Calamari Sub. After some 10, maybe 12 minutes of robust discussion, Joe convinced me to try their Shrimp Parm Sub instead. Dominick (the other brother and co-owner) offered a sample portion of Spicy Mussel Marinara for being a good sport. Let me pause here and tell you that a sign at the counter at Bell Paese warns you that yelling, and screaming are possible (think, "The Bear"). The sign requests you to ignore everything, to sit back, and enjoy the food. For sure this is a family run establishment, the emphasis is solely on good food. The Shrimp Parm Sub was exceptional. Amazing sauce. The spicy Mussel Marinara was out of this world good. It was made by Dominick. Joe assured me that the next time I visit, the Mussel Marinara will be better because typically he makes it. Needless to say, we had another round of robust discussion as to who, Joe or Dominick, makes a better Spicy Marinara. I cannot wait to go back for the Scungilli & Calamari and also for Zupa de Pesce. At Bell Paese you get real food, made by real people. Places like Bell Paese are hard to find. Go there with an appetite, enjoy the food and enjoy the company.

The best chicken parm sandwich aroud and their hot dog, potato and egg sandwicheich is hard to…read morebeat! Love everything I have ordered from there.

Zi Zia Pizzeria

4.3

(261 reviews)