Andy's serves the beyond burger and it was wonderful! (G/F rolls available) so happy to have this option at a friendly round year local spot! read more

It was our first visit and it won't be our last. Great service, ambience and food. Love finding new places in Greenport!

Got two burgers with accoutrements and it ran $40+. I know its Long Island, but it wasnt laced with gold, so that runs even a lil high for me. Burger was good so cant complain, and the hostess was too nice to write poorly of the place. Place was lacking in atmosphere for sure. read more

Nice environment, friendly staff, but just didn't have the greatest food. Their menu had potential but just seemed underwhelming to me and my group. read more

We ordered the following appetizers: chip of the day (potato chips and onion dip), pickle jar, elote corn cob, and the potato skin shooters. Pickle jar was ok, an assortment of vegetables in a sweet pickling. I think there was some jalapeño in there because it was a little spicy. Potato skin shooters were great. Elote corn was amazing. Super sweet corn with great sauce. Chips and dip were decent, nothing that special. I had the kicking chicken Sammy and it was AMAZING. My son had the burger and loved it. Wife had the grilled chicken sandwich with a gluten free bun and she loved it. The ambience was good. Service and hostess were very friendly. We'll definitely be back! read more

Andy's starts off your meal with a small bag of freshly made popcorn for the table (which left mine very quickly). The service was pretty quick and the food was delicious and came out pretty quick! I highly recommend trying out their buffalo chicken wings - my favorites! The parking on the street Andy's is located isn't that great (parking only on one side) and the parking on Main Street is usually filled. But it was worth the trip to look for a parking spot on a Saturday night! I will definitely have to stop back here again the next time I'm in Greenport. read more

Good food, good service, nice atmosphere. Bartenders always very friendly. One of Greenport's more comfortable establishments to watch a game and enjoy a bite and a cocktail. read more

I felt I should take the time to write this review. I visited this place on 8/24 with my wife and son. This was the first time we ever went to this place and we went based on overall reviews while we were dining the waitress we had seemed annoyed, that she had to serve us, one thing I picked up on was and this may seem petty but everyone received popcorn except for us. When we placed our orders I noticed someone eating baby back ribs, but I didn't see it on the menu. I asked her about it and she said oh yeah I forgot to mention that. We ordered an appetizer which was delivered by someone else not our waitress. Overall the entire experience with her and the place was cold, now my wife and stepson are Hispanic and I am caucasian, and I was obvious that this person had an issue with that. We felt very uncomfortable and will never return or recommend anyone to this place. I've never wrote a review like this before but noticed that I'm not the first. I hope that the owner takes this very seriously and addresses this as soon as possible as no one should ever have to feel this way no matter where they visit. read more

Amazing food, the mozz sticks and wings were great. The fried chicken sandwhich was huge and so good and crispy HOWEVER the bun needs to be a brioche, it's a huge piece of chicken and the bun was just falling apart the whole time. The fish tacos were also awesome. Very nice service read more

Great spot. Food was great. Only had apps but can imagine it's all amazing based off the apps we tried. Great ambiance, music was right up our ally and made us want to stick around. Staff was friendly and polite, very quick as well. Would all around recommend. read more

Atmosphere is great. Casual, fun and sporty. Food was overpriced...it's Greenport not Greenwich. Special fish and steak were expensive. Surcharge for scotch on the rocks was silly and irritating. read more

I don't know what to say. We talked them into taking a reservation for16 people. Then two more called and asked to be added and then two more. So even though they don't take reservations they did take reservation for 20. And they did separate checks. In addition to that other members of our boat trip came in two more tables. The service was so expedient. And those several members of our party were somewhat demanding all of our needs were met. There was one issue with one piece of chicken not being quite cooked. Well they came back with double the amount! The place is fun and vibrant. The food is very good. Thank you Andy accommodating us even though we were late. And thank you for the waitress that served 20 people without batting an eye. read more

Cool place. I got the BLT&A and my Fiancé got the special - fresh cod tacos, everything was delicious and our waitress was really friendly. I also thought the foam under the tables is genius. I would definitely come back! read more

Honestly this place was lackluster at best. Food was the most Middle of the road experience I've ever had long Island. Prices are ridiculous! Service is OK but the music selection is not the best. The restaurant as a whole doesn't seem to have a direction. Overall would not recommend unless you end up trapped here and have the urge for a milkshake, 2/5 read more

I can't imagine why anyone would choose Andy's when so many other better options are just steps away given the experience that we had. I have never encountered Bartenders that have been so slow, unfriendly, rude, and unapologetic for all of the above at the the same time (and I live in Boston.) After politely asking if my drink was still coming after 25 minutes (during which they seemingly purposely stood idle, laughed, talked, checked phones and served local friends right in front of us, then to cap it off within earshot they spoke of how annoying it was when people order drinks when we can see how busy they are. Yet the blame was on me of course....they said I had ordered the most difficult drink on the menu (margarita.) if you have some precious time to spend in such a wonderful town as Greenport, don't waste it at Andy's. read more

Awful. The service was slow. We sat at the bar. It was a bit busy but there should've been better staffing. Given the price of the food I was expecting a much better meal. I got the slider meal and my burger was raw. Nothing was done to compensate me for it. The buns looked like cheap grocery store potato rolls. My boyfriend got the fish tacos. They claimed it was fresh seafood and it most certainly was not. Tilapia. Awful. Will not be returning. read more

They ruin the food with various sauces and it is quite pricey but it wasn't horrible.

Apparently a long time establishment in the area. I had the fish and chips. Way too my breading on it. Otherwise it was a nice little place. Would have tried the other dishes. read more

My first visit to Andy's was fabulous from the first minute I met server Jen at the door super service she gave us a great recommendation for the special flounder fish n chips served with the best sweet potato fries and edamame not what you expect from from a burger joint. The fresh tomato soup with grill cheese was also great the local rose wine was very good we will return. read more

Great service and great food. If your in Greenport and want an environment fit for family, stop in and have a meal in Andy's

I never like going to Restaurants when they first open but I decided to go here with my girlfriend Sunday night We showed up around 6 PM and the place was busy but still had some empty tables we sat down and waited 20 minutes for a waiter to show up we ordered and then waited for another 15 to 20 minutes for our food The service was bad and the atmosphere was very bland and loud . I must say the menu was very interesting with many great sounding dishes I had the pork chop and my girlfriend had the tuna they wee both good I would hope they get the service straightened out because this place could be amazing. Good luck read more

Had dinner last nite at Andy's. (Formerly Rumbline). Wow! What a taste experience and talk about good service! Elaine and Juliana were so super! Constantly filling our water glasses, which in some restaurants has become a novelty and checking if everything was to our liking. I had the Charred Octopus Salad and I'm telling u I'm going back again this week while I'm here. It was exquisite. That's all I can say. If u like Octopus, u have got to try this. The lemon vinaigrette dressing is just right. My husband's good ole American standby: a Cheeseburger and fries was excellent. He asked for well done fries and for a change, that's exactly what he got. And he describes his burger as really fresh and came just as he ordered it. Nice huh? As I said, we r coming back again this week for sure. Nice to see new places that r up to par while many of our favorite haunts have gone by the wayside in food and service and bathroom cleanliness. read more

Excellent salads, which was all we had for lunch. Couldn't be better. With the French windows open, it felt like we were outside.

Amazing spot! Ordered during peak Covid and the food and service was amazing. Definitely recommend the octopus salad and lobster roll. Next time I'm back in town this will be my first visit read more

New place, and it's great! loved the calamari and octopus salad. They have a very comfortable feel, and Andy is a great guy who cares about his customers. read more

Off the charts deliciousness!! Perfect pricing for top notch food. Loved the Bubble bread app and lemony good calamari. Give this place a visit- u won't be sorry read more

Great place to hangout. Visiting from Manhattan and had a great time. The popcorn is a nice touch. The bartender and waitress' were great!

Nice new casual addition to Greenport. Service efficient and very friendly. Food nicely prepared and presented - and tasted good! Only complaint is noise. Acoustics terrible - need to get some acoustical tiles or something! Recommend!! read more

Great family restaurant ! Love the staff and the food!! The burger was the best I've had !

Our family had dinner here last night. Overall the atmosphere was great and very kid friendly. I loved the front seating area and the basket of games. Our night out to dinner also turned in to family game night. On the other side of it I thought the kids meals were pricey at $10. I think $6 or $7 is probably in the "affordable prices" category. Also for the cost, only getting 6 hot wings was disappointing even though they were delicious. This is a brand new place working out the kinks and with a few tweaks this place can kill it all year long. Go Andy! read more

Food was not cooked fresh. Got the elite corn. Was ok. Wings were ok. But the ribs were old. Sauce looked like they had been in the ribs for a while. Water was yellow. I FEEL SICK!!!! Don't go. read more

Yay! Andy has created a great blend of comfortable rustic chic. From the atmosphere to the food and the drinks. Great food. Great drinks. Love the inclusion of the local ingredients in the subtle twists on traditional favorites. Congratulations! I can't wait to come back. read more

I really enjoyed the atmosphere in this restaurant. The staff was friendly and amenable and made me and my party feel very welcome. The food was very good as well , I would have given 5 stars if it were slightly less expensive ... I found it hard to cope with the 11 dollar price tag on the clam chowder, but I must admit it was fantastic! read more

Finally got to go to Andys tonight. I have heard so many good things about it. They were all true! Food was outrageous!! Our waiter was great! He was so personable and very helpful! Can't wait to come back with friends. read more

Service was literally so terrible. People who came in after us were eating already and we hadn't even ordered and all of our glasses of water were empty. We didn't get refills on the water, we were not given napkins, forks, or knives until after an hour of sitting there we asked if we could order and said we didn't have any drinks napkins or forks and knives and then the service improved slightly after saying something but I would NEVER go back. read more

It is so loud, all four of us couldn't wait to get out of there. And it was only half full-I can't imagine how loud it is when it's busy. We waited a long time before anyone came over to our table for drink order. One person at our table didn't get their meal with the rest-we were told his takes longer to cook- so the rest waited and ten minutes later his arrived and ours was cold. Hopefully they can address the noise issue. I see other complaints on this site from weeks back-quick fix, get some plants, fabrics , and a few sound boards on the ceiling. It's a new place so hopefully they can fix the noise and service issues. read more

As per Jesse James... this place is awesome! The food is awesome!! Personal favorite are the Potato Skin Shooters!! When in Greenport, this is the place to eat at. Great for families and to watch the game! read more

I live local and stopped in with my son on a whim. I'd have to say what a wonderful, refreshing change visually from what was located there before. Very kid friendly. The connect four and pop corn was a big hit! New England clam chowder was some of the best I've tasted and the calamari was seasoned and cooked perfectly. The staff was extremely friendly. Great place for a nice meal without getting raked over the coals. We'll be back! read more

Pleasant service staff. Food ok. Burgers nice. Oyster Po boy served with a not ripened tomato. Probably try someplace else next time.

This is a great new restaurant in Greenport. The food is absolutely amazing!! The service is very friendly. The atmosphere is very fun and inviting! I would definitely recommend to anyone to try Andy's!! Will definitely be back again! read more