Completely overpriced and not worth it at all. There are so many other places to go in the neighborhood to get a bagel:breakfast that you don't need to come here and spend $10 on 2 Bacon egg & cheese sandwiches. read more

So we are in NYC the capital of bagels and it shouldn't be difficult to find a good bagel. NOT TRUE! The bagels in bagel boy put most other bagels to shame. Their paninis are yummy, their soups are always fresh and never too salty, and their "make-your-own salad" options are consistently fresh. Freshness is a simple thing, but it is not always available in these types of places. I cannot tell you how many times I ended up throwing out wilted greens and frostbitten tomatoes and cucumbers from other establishments. I just wish that they delivered on the weekend. Just writing this review makes me want a low-carb sesame bagel with some vegie cream cheese. Keep up the great work, and please don't change a thing. read more

This place has a ton of breakfast and lunch food choices. The bagels are good, not great but definitely above average. They have prepared sandwiches and pasta dishes in the refrigerator section as well as a wide selection of drinks, packaged local baked goods, chips, nuts, etc. I know a lot of bagel places have a quasi grocery section which normally sucks but their selection is pretty good. It stays really busy in the morning (8-10) and lunch (1130-2) but the lines move fast and the workers are fairly friendly for a deli. There are only about 5-7 chairs to sit at so I wouldn't plan on eating here. I normally would get an everything or whole wheat everything bagel, sandwich on a roll, or salad. Veggies are always fresh. I have tried a few of their deli salads (mushroom salad, olives, tuna, etc) which were all just ok. I hate to point this out, but I referred a few of our summer interns to go there last summer and a few of them complained about getting an upset stomach, then other people in my office replied with "oh yeah I never go there, it always makes me sick". That surprised me bc I have eaten here often over 4 years and never got sick, but they all seem to have gotten prepared food (the paninis and such from the deli fridge) so maybe that's why? So I guess stay away from the prepared sandwiches! Oh, and the chocolate danishes and corn bread muffins are awesome!! read more

Came for a morning fixture of breakfast. I've had breakfast sandwiches from here twice and finally got to experience ordering myself. Upon entering you walk to the center of the counter, wait for a cue from the staff behind the counter to take your order. Tell them what you want and then you walk to your right and wait behind the register. Depending on how complicated your order is, it might take awhile, so don't fret about them forgetting about your food. Finally, my food was ready and it was handed over to the girls behind the register to ring me up...I'm not sure how effective this process can be when it's super busy though. I had a bacon, egg and cheese on a roll with salt and pepper and ketchup. It's a simple breakfast sandwich which costed me $4.46 (tax included already). It's a bit steep for me since we're in Brooklyn. I've yet to try their bagels but they do look promising. I'm not crazy about the ordering process but so far, the quality of the food is quite good. Maybe if they hand me a number and when it's ready by the register just call my number? I just don't appreciate patrons hovering around the register when they just ordered and impatiently waiting to pay for their food and bounce. read more

Bagel boy has been around for years, since I was a kid. This is definitely a local spot. The bagels are pretty cheap but nothing special. It's more about the locality because you remember your parents always coming here, your teachers, just about everyone comes here. This place is always busy but the people here are quick and get your orders right. I only come for the bagels here. There's a huge selection. I'm not too sure about the other food like their pastas and chicken and all the stuff that's not covered and has been sitting in the fridge for what looks like a while. It doesn't look too clean to me (it's been out for a while, to the point where the edges of the tin container start to harden up) so I wouldn't try it. They do sell the fancy apple juice in the glass jars and Greek yogurt, but it's expensive. You're better off going to stop and shop two blocks down and picking it up there. The location is also fantastic. It's right by the Q and B line so if you're ever in sheepshead, be sure to pick up a bagel here! read more

Out of the 100's of bagel stores in Brooklyn, Bagel Boy is the #1 in selection, price, and service. They have a huge store located in Sheepshead Bay which serves bagels, sandwiches, salads, paninis, wraps, soups, coffee, iced coffee and much more. There is a very small area to sit down and eat your food but for the most part it's a take out spot. I took one star off only for that reason. Otherwise you get your food super fast when waiting on an average line size of 15 or more people each visit. You will always be satisfied with the quality! read more

If it was perfectly healthy to eat bagels and cream cheese all day, I would! This place makes the best bagels in nyc. Other bagels I tried just do not compare. It is the perfect texture of chewy yet still soft in the center. It tastes slighly salty and sweet, so very satisfying. I find Bagel Boy offers the most variety in bagels. My favorite is the everything egg bagel. read more

I had not been in here for a long time. So when I decided I'd give them a try again, I walked in and within 3 minutes walked out. If there are more than 3 people on the line, figure you will be there at least 20 min. I needed two plain bagels and the people in front of me were making bigger orders and I know from prior experience in this place even the simplest of an order takes these guys forever to prepare and more often than not, they make mistakes. And the bagels are really nothing special. read more

Best bagels I've ever had in my life. It's a bit expensive ($3.00 for a bagel with their special cream cheese!?) but it's good. I usually get the He-Man which is 2 eggs, bacon, sausage, and cheese on a bagel (or whatever bread you want). Their selection of bagels is huge as well. Coffee is tasty! Annoying things to deal with is the line. So many people in the morning! Service is pretty good. They are fast at what they are doing. No one seemed rude, but they were intent on killing the line. I had their philly cheese steak once for dinner, and that was decent. It was very meaty, they way I like it. but the aluminum foil smelled like bleach. I think it was because they were closing when I walked in. read more

ADVICE: Check your order before leaving the place! How many times can you get the order wrong?????? A regular at bagel boy because the bagels, cream cheeses and their tuna plus white fish salad is really good, however for the last FOUR (I am not kidding) times they got the order wrong! Really??? I understand it's busy but isn't it why they are writing everything down and still manage to mess it up! I live in Bensonhurst and it's a b***ch to go back to change. I'm just gonna stop going there, want to enjoy my morning and my breakfast. read more

Great bagels and sandwiches, love it. Weekend mornings long line. Municipal parking is around the corner for people coming with car.

My morning is not complete unless I make a stop here for my favorite bacon, egg and cheese on everything bagel, with a side of coffee. I love this place. They have all kinds of food for any time of the day, from breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner. They have a fresh make-your-own salad bar, as well as fresh pre-made salads. Delicious soups and sandwiches. Service is quick, but despite that, if you walk in here during the morning rush, prepare to spend about 30 minutes waiting in line. read more

Absolutely terrible, I ordered a salad and they charged me 8$ for it. The salad came in a half bowl, one that would come no where near filling me up. When i called to ask about this they told me that they had been using the same bowl for 25 years. I call bullsh*** , I've been ordering for two years from them and the salad bowls were always much deeper, about twice the size of the tiny thing they sent. I will not be ordering from here ever again. They just want to keep raising prices, but keep being cheap on how much they'll actually give you. Thanks but no thanks. It has nothing to do with the money, but with the fact that you're making the portions smaller, without lowering the price on your baby portions. read more

Bagel Boy - The size of their NEW ( but they've been using these bowls for 25 years) salads. Waste of money, totally not worth it. - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Love their breakfast. Everything I've ordered has been on point. My go to spot every morning. Best bagels!!

Been coming to this place for a while now and never disappointed. Great service like clockwork. Not only their food is always fresh but their customer service is so systematic and on point timing is never an issue. Management does a great job with their team. Friendly and genuine service. My favorite, tuna on a scooped and toasted sesame bagel and cream cheese with lux and tomatoe on sesame bagel. read more

Bagel Boy - Cream cheese with lux and tomatoes on a scooped out toasted sesame bagel. - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Bagel boy is ALWAYS packed. If you order expect it to come in over 1 hour. I hate the lines there it takes forever to get your food. I dont like the wraps they dont really taste fresh. The salads are OK. my personal favorite is the garden salad with a scoop of chicken/tuna sald with balsamic vinaigrette. Everything else is pretty good though if you want a sandwich or a bagel or a soup which are pretty good. Prices are decent. read more

One of the best bagel shops in the area! Clean, friendly, great selection, salads, muffins, excellent coffee! Honestly, no complaints. read more

My favorite bagel place!!!! Been coming here for years since they was on ocean Ave Place is beautiful, employees are great and food is awesome!! Great bagels, egg sandwiches, salads and a huge variety of meal ideas. Actually only bagel store I go to even if it's a drive to get here! read more

The best pea soup and grilled cheese sandwich, which hits the right spot especially on a cold day.

I'm a huge fan of their egg bagels. Their bagels are consistently great, always taste fresh. Also recommend the ice tea or ice coffee. Bagel boy has been around for awhile, they're a great place to grab a quick lunch or breakfast. Employees are usually really nice, especially the ones that take and make your order. BUT, the cashier today, had the rudest stank face on and she couldn't seem to say a word without dripping attitude and giving strange looks. We were going to sit and eat there but decided to leave asap after paying because we couldn't stand the weird glances she kept giving us. read more

Before this bagel factory was built, Bagel Boy was a small bagel shop on Ocean Avenue. This was around 5 years ago (it might be more, and I have since moved out of Brooklyn). I'm speaking from nostalgia, but I remember going to Bagel Boy every weekend, buying fresh bagels with regular, vegetable, and lax cream cheese. Needless to say, they were delicious and the place was a bit more homey. Anyways, let's proceed to discuss this newer Bagel Boy. It's huge for a bagel shop, and it moves like an assembly line. There is almost always a line inside the store, but the service is quick, albeit aloof and impersonal. It's a bagel factory. I wouldn't mind this, except for the fact that the bagels took a hit on freshness and taste, as well as size. While Bagel Boy serves bagels that are better than say, Dunkin Donuts, they don't come close to what they used to be. They are often stale and not as soft as a good bagel should be. Still, the bagels edible and better than others found nearby. The coffee, in simplest and most lucid terms, is terrible. It's somewhere in between instant coffee and a drip machine, which is to say an absolute disgust. Even a K-Cup machine, which most coffee aficionados scold, makes a much better cup than Bagel Boy. If you own an Aero Press, this coffee will make gasp in pain. Overall, Bagel Boy offers decent bagels at a slight premium charge. If you are in the area, or live close by, it's worth stopping by. Otherwise, nothing special here. If you want a good cup of joe, look elsewhere. read more

This place should be marked as the iconic NY bagel, because it represents everything a bagel should be. Hot, fresh, and perfect combination of crispiness and softness. They make the bagels on premise, and if you order a bagel after they're just made, then you have just entered bagel heaven. I ordered the primavera on numerous occasions and it has yet to disappoint. All the ingredients they use are always super fresh. The primavera has chicken, fresh mozzarella, pesto, and tomato. They are also open all the time for those late night cravings or post night out dine ins. read more

Bagel Boy - The Primavera, the best sandwich known to mankind, get it on the everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I love Bagel Boy... it's my go-to bagel place in the area. So far I've tried their lox cream cheese and bacon and scallion cream cheese - both are delicious. I usually opt for the whole wheat everything bagels to make me feel a little bit better about eating bagels all the time. I've had their bacon, egg, and cheese bagel as well, but prefer good ol' cream cheese to the BEC. The wait time can be pretty long during the morning weekends and get quite crowded. read more

Bagel Boy - Bacon, egg, & cheese on a whole wheat everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I am a huge bagel fan. The bagel here are the definition of perfection! They're delicious. I will be back!!!

Great service wonderful bagels all types of spreads to fill that hungry belly. Sunday morning coffee and fresh bagels aaah nice way to relax!!! read more

Bagel Boy - Bagel with a schmear!!! - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've been a patron at this particular Bagel Boy location since they resided on Ocean Avenue. The food and service has always been great, but as of the past few years, it's been impeccable. The food is fresh. My favorite is the fresh lox which tastes great on a toasted bagel with cream cheese. Salads are also available, with fresh salads consisting of lettuce, spinach, and mixed green bases to toppings ranging from delicious protein to chickpeas and beets and honey-glazed walnuts. The walnuts are a MUST. There's also the salads in the group of egg salad, beets, chopped chicken liver, etc. All delicious. This is my go-to place. Oh, and as of late they also have a fresh orange-squeezing machine for orange juice! Yum. Shout out to Mike, who is the king of customer service. Look no further if you need a quick bite or a full meal. This is where you want to be. Cheers to many more years! -A loyal customer read more

They have delish bagels but sometimes the wait time is ridic!! Other than that, they are good. Angelina Bklyn, NY read more

delicious bagels, reasonable prices, but the stuff are very slow and not good service. I had to remind several times what I ordered. Employees are not attentive read more

Bagel Boy - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We were really excited to try the bagels here. They looked fluffy and tasty. We bought garlic, onion and plain - and they all tasted subpar. Not sure if it's because it was a holiday but the bagels tasted like the ones you get from a public school breakfast. Lmao read more

Ordered a cream cheese sandwich with basil and tomato toasted on a whole wheat bread. It was alright, kind of small... and it didn't have basil. :'( that's the best part ! Oh well. Maybe the bagels aren't so bad, I'll give this place another try. read more

Pity, this store has everything - huge selection, respectful speedy service, even a motto over the door thanking us, customers for the patronage and promising to deliver the best - and yet..... the bagels are crap.. Bagels are quickly baked without boiling them first and thus taste like a light, airy round Italian bread with slightly thicker crust. If you think that Domino's pizza defines pizza, then Bagel Boy is a bagel for you. However, my search for a good bagel in Sheepshead Bay continues. I have to go read some negative reviews of this place hoping that they might lead to a decent bagel place, even if it doesn't offer 85 salads and has a grumpy owner. read more

My dad's side of the family live in Brooklyn and my family recently visited. They brought me home a dozen bagels from Bagel Boy and I'm loving them. There are a few random places I want to try in the Boston area, but if they don't compare, I'll have Bagel Boy ship me a dozen. (I'll pay for delivery charges) Thank you! read more

We got chicken parmigiana and chicken fajitas at 18$ wouldn't get that again. Nicely packed. Didn't get the order right and I feel like I got a food borne bacteria. You've been warned. read more

Fresh bagels daily and love the specials. Only gripe I had is I paid $10 for one pound of tuna salad and it was dry and tasteless. Will stick to scallion cream cheese instead. read more

I only ever get breakfast here so can't speak for later in the day. The total time it takes you to get your order from when you enter might be up to 20 minutes if it's busy (faster if you only get plain bagels) but their quality of food is fantastic. I can have an egg white turkey bacon and swiss on a scooped out bagel 7 days a week if I had to here. read more

My absolute favorite bagels!! I also love all of the pasta salads and macaroni salad. Everything is always so fresh no matter what time you go. read more

Picked up half a dozen bagels and cream cheese before visiting Grandma. Bagels were some of the best I've ever had. We sliced and toasted them ourselves at home. The everything bagels were heavy on the everything, which I prefer. The place was busy and the folks working behind the counter were friendly and fast. Would definitely return. read more

I am super picky. I ordered an egg salad sandwich with lettuce tomato and onion. It came quickly. But no lettuce. Like I said I'm picky so I won't eat it. I called. They offered to fix it if I brought it back. I basically told them if I could do that I wouldn't have asked for delivery. And the Linzer tort cookie was prepackaged. Very disappointing I expected a fresh cookie from a bagel store. My mistake It's Monday morning and I just saw my bagel order wad screwed up as well. read more

Terrible customer service...i was going to pay for my $60.00 order and noticed something on my receipt listed as "open"...i politely asked the cashier what the item listed as "open" was for and she proceeded to roll her eyes and laugh in my face along with another worker. No customer should have to be subjected to such disrespectful demeanor...i have the right to know what I'm being charged for especially for an item listed with no other description as "ooen"... if you don't like your job I suggest you consider a different field other than serving the public. read more

I come here on weekends for breakfast. Coffee is fresh. I get whole-wheat bagel with cream cheese. The staff is always nice.