Best slice I had in NJ or NY. Sauce is so good, slice as big as my head, how can I complain! Service was great, but payment is cash only, atms are nearby so an easy fix that was worth it for the pizza. read more

Great slice, huuuggeeeee! Price is good as well, good spot for students in a pinch. Definitely recommend.

I haven't been to Benny's in a solid ten years and let me tell you nothing has changed, in a good way! After a late meeting in Jersey City, it seemed like a great time to visit one of the old haunts from my Stevens days for a quick slice. I was thrilled to see they are just as big and just as delicious. It was like I was transported back in time to scarfing down a slice at 11pm on the curb outside as any college student would. Still an affordable option in Hoboken since one slice is actually the equivalent of 3. You won't go hungry here. read more

Benny Tudino's - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

Honestly overrated for how much I've heard about this place. Cheese pizza just mid. Wouldn't go back - think I can find better in NY read more

See all

Same ol' $5 pizza slice. Still saucy til the last though. Enjoy! You do need a $20 minimum before you can use your credit card though. read more

See all

Benny Tudino's/Cheese Slice This is home of the largest pizza slice in New Jersey! Needing two plates to cover the base of this monster, you definitely can't eat this bad boy with one hand! read more

Benny Tudino's - Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

See all

Talk about a huge slice of pizza! Quick service and dining inside and out. This enormous slice is thinner crusted but actually has good flavor. High turnover so you always get fresher slice. read more

See all

Phew, lawd! This big ass slice of pizza hit the damn spot. Service was great. It wasn't packed. We got two slices of cheese pizza to go. Ate this slice on the way back to the car. I savored every single bite. It's been a while since I last had a slice from there. Ambiance? Man, it's a pizzeria! You know the vibes when you walk in there. read more

Benny Tudino's - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

Prices went up a bit since my last review (inflation man), but still great pizza! Who doesn't love a pizza slice bigger than your head? Always friendly service from my experience and we've been coming here for years. This most recent time I decided to try buffalo chicken as a topping and phewwww they loaded it up!! Put a whole order of chicken tenders on top of my slice. Doesn't get better than this. read more

See all

Excellent. Service Excellent pizza huge slices Garlic bread and mussels are delicious Can't wait to go back read more

See all

When you serve pizza by the slice, it doesn't matter the size of the cheese is flat and uninspiring. The service was near non existent, the decor hasn't been touched in decades.... And the restroom was not much bigger than a coat closet. My rear on the seat and my knees on the door. Maneuvering to cleanup, and then later to wash my hands... abysmal. read more

Two Slices with meatballs. I added oregano on mine. Cash only I was told but then I saw the Grubhub sticker on the door so I just ordered online. I liked the sauce a lot. Super cute establishment. Nice gentleman running the place. read more

See all

Soooo cash only . They have an atm . $2.99 fee . The slices are hugeeeeee but paper thin. Dave portnoy would have a heart attack lol .. $5 a slice we got two. The one looked bit lol I know it wasn't but I had said hey u took a bite out of this one and the guy said yeah and gave me an extra slice on the house lol. Heard about it for awhile pretty cool. Reasonably priced . The ambiance is nice for sure . read more

Benny Tudino's - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

See all

This pizza was excellent. We did a comparison between Benny's and 10th street pizza. Benny's was far better. It was a little under cooked for me but that's fine. I brought the HUGE slice home and popped it in the over. It was the size of almost 1/2 the PIE at 10th street pizza. I ordered my GIGANTIC slice With 2 topping. The guy told me $7. Cool. Then when my slice was ready I went to pay and he said- $8. I was confused why it went up $1. I had $8 in my hand anyway since i was tipping $1 anyway but in this case i just gave the $8. That's pretty much the reason I gave 4 stars. Even though I thought the slice was fantastic. I would definitely go back. And will see what they charge me then :) The place is definitely old school the way I like it. Kinda tight but fine. Again the pizza was way better than 10th street. That pizza didn't taste as good. At all! read more

Benny Tudino's - Benny's huge slice. Loved it. - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

See all

Ambiance: 5/5 Lots of tables in the back and you can see the chefs hard at work up front. Service: 5/5 Food: 5/5 I don't know how they do it! First of all, the slices are HUGE! The bottom is crunchy while the top is soft and filled with a savory sauce and a layer of the perfect amount of cheese. Even after eating it cold later on, it still tasted great! read more

See all

Benny Tudinos was on my list. I was in the area Nike store. Found parking. Place is old school hole in the wall. Service was nasty. I ordered a slice. $5.00. Lmao. What a rip off. Pizza wasn't baked good. Cheap cheese cheap sauce. They just don't care. I def won't be back. read more

Small pizza place. Love all the pictures on the wall. Waitresses are nice the guys making the pizza can be seen as rude but for me they're your typical Italian men who are trying to run a business and keep it moving. Place is cash only. Food is awesome! They're pizza slices are huge! Their other food is also really good! We got the penne vodka with grilled chicken and ham calzone. Good size portions! read more

Benny Tudino's - Ham Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

See all

Truly great pizza. Absolutely delicious and huge! Love the plain pie. Very friendly staff and quick service. Love that there's outdoor seating. Cozy inside. read more

Benny Tudino's - Plain Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

Located right on Washington St, close to Stevens institute of technology; this place is known for the biggest pizza slice in NJ while being really cheap too! The restaurant doesn't have any ambiance as such while the servers were friendly, the only disappointment for me was they are a cash only restaurant which should look to change as most of the people prefer being cashless these days! Coming to the pizza, I ordered a regular cheese slice. While the slice was really big and filling, I liked the crust being crisp as it was freshly made in front of me while the cheese was good,also the ingredients were in the right quantities. Overall, it's a cheap slice for $5 given the size of it also a good place to grab a quick lunch! read more

Benny Tudino's - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

Not the same as before. The number one thing I noticed was the chicken wings. Totally changed, they used to have a nice soft crunchy texture. Now its still crunchy but very hard and also have a burnt smell to them. Pizza slice is still great but I wont be back. read more

Four stars for Benny's in Hoboken! Customer service? Spot-on. The staff is super friendly, and the pizza slices? Almost as big as the box--no joke! Just a heads-up: it's cash or Apple Pay only, so don't show up with just a card. I'll definitely be back for the great vibes and massive slices! read more

Benny Tudino's - Pizza slices almost as big as their pizza boxes lol - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

Not sure what happened to this place, it used to be the biggest slice in the area , now it's the same as couple of other spots . $4.75 for a slice . I thought the slice was average at best. read more

Benny Tudino's - Pizza Slice $4.75 - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

Went in because I seen the biggest slice sign and yes the slice is hugeee. It was good from the cheese to the tomato sauce. The ambiance is like a vintage Italian pizzeria which was nice aesthetically. My only dislike was how the manager spoke to his staff in front of customers. It was rude & nasty for no good reason. read more

First stop on the Hoboken pizza tour we have Benny's. Let me start by saying this is a tough call between 2-3 stars here. Food: When judging pizza properly - one must order a plain cheese slice, there's no hiding. To start - by no means was this pizza bad, it just wasn't overwhelmingly great. The X-factor here is the slice is ENORMOUS, you can absolutely order one slice and be full, which is awesome. The slice had a great cheese to sauce ratio but the sauce left something to be desired. The cheese had great pull and there was plenty of it... Unfortunately, I think the pizza was just a little doughy and floppy for my liking and kind of plain in flavor (probably due to the sauce). Overall a decent slice, but this is NJ, there is no bad pizza... with some steep competition right down the block there's no denying the only thing that will keep people coming here is the fact they make the biggest slice on the block. Service: Service was totally fine. The place was completely empty so the waitstaff was very attentive and there were really no issues at all. They were quite adamant about how the check could not be split and it had to be all on one check (which could be annoying in another scenario)... and another major red flag this place is CASH ONLY. I'm sorry but in 2023 this is unacceptable. Atmosphere: The place is classic NJ Italian. i actually loved it. It's outdated but i felt like i was in the Soprano's so that's cool. I did not go to the bathroom so i cannot comment on cleanliness but overall the place seemed just fine. Overall, I wasn't super impressed with this place. I've heard it's gone downhill after the passing of the old owner. I wish I tried it back in the day. It's decent pizza but there's so many good spots in the area it's hard to justify coming here. Size isn't everything :P read more

Went to Benny Tudino's pizzeria after so many years... Well we'll to my surprise how things have changed... The Staff is unfriendly and don't even check on you at your table to see if you need anything. The " LARGEST" pizza slice has gotten a lot smaller..... There is no sign that says " No Credit / Debit so when I went to pay I was told CASH ONLY!!!!! Not everyone walks around with CASH!!!!!! Get it together ! read more

See all

The smells & friendly staff at Benny Tudino's made us feel as if we were home. Tammy, our server, especially made us feel welcome. She went out of her way to help me order (post-illness dietary restrictions), & brought our order out with a smile. The famous single slices are about the size of most places' small whole pizzas! Bring your appetite. We recommend meatballs as a topping. So good, & house-made. Order a side of tomato sauce, if you're like us & like to dip. read more

Benny Tudino's - Outside Benny Tudino's - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

Best pizza I've ever had! Wow! Will definitely revisit! Service was great! Great for family! read more

See all

Slice was huge so i did not really like it because it was very cheesy. But overlay good place to see a lot of history to it.

Truly a Hoboken staple! My family comes here every single time we come to New Jersey, and it's something of our tradition. We're so glad to consider Benny Tudino's pizza as if it's our family. Of course, the staff is efficient, quick, and are very straight forward. It is a very classic and rustic environment, with photos on the wall, and a bustling crowd. I enjoy the environment because it feels more homelike. The pizzas here are truly amazing! With a crispy crust, thin, and light, their sizes will IMPRESS you. They have a photo on their wall with a slice as large as a baby! We haven't tried other menu items, but I'm very excited to see what else they have to offer, and will be so ready to go pay them another visit. Everybody left full, satisfied, and happy. read more

Benny Tudino's - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

See all

One slice at Benny Tudino's is the size of two regular slices at any other pizza shop. I am SO here for it. Quantity doesn't always mean better quality, but in this case it does. A plain cheese slice was super crispy and delicious with perfect sauce and cheese ratios. It was hard to finish one slice without toppings, so any with toppings would be a huge meal. My friends tried mushroom and onion and pepperoni and bacon and they both really enjoyed. They are cash only, so make sure to plan ahead. There is plenty of outdoor seating, and they also have a liquor license which I was surprised to see. You can order beer, wine, sangria, etc. Something else important to note - they are only offering sit-down service. I thought we'd be able to quickly order slices to go at a counter, but you'll actually need to sit on the patio and order with a server. Just worth noting if you are short on time! I can definitely see myself returning for a slice, hopefully sooner rather than later! read more

See all

YUM. Places like Benny Tudino's are the reason I become such a big NJ pizza snob whenever I leave the state, (trying to work on it)!!! But how can I not when their slices are twice the size of my head and just really damn good? Stopped by for the first time the other day for a quick lunch and got a slice of onion and mushroom. I was a little nervous when I first saw it because the onions didn't look cooked enough but I was proved wrong immediately after my first bite. Perfectly crispy thin crust, delicious cheese, sauce packed with flavor and toppings definitely cooked just right. When I say the slice was big, I am not joking. I had a lot of trouble just finishing one but couldn't stop eating because it was so good. We sat outside because it was a beautiful day and in the shade, not too hot and got a table right away. Our waitress was super friendly and made some good suggestions for toppings. Little tip! They are cash only but right across the street from an ATM so no big stress. There are a ton of great pizza spots in Hoboken but I just found another favorite. read more

Benny Tudino's - Slices bigger than our head - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

See all

Hoboken was my family's first home in America back in the 70's. So going back is always a nostalgic and fun experience. On my last 2 trips, I stopped at Benny Tudino's on Washington and ordered a large pizza to go to CALIFORNIA! The owner was so nice and kindly wrapped it up into 4 sections and packed it nicely in aluminum foil. People were stopping and looking and asking where was I taking it? California! They laughed and said I guess they don't have pizza in California lol! Which is not true, but they don't have pizza this good in California for sure! Unfortunately, I am gluten free but my family enjoys it. They also packed me a gluten free pie, but, I'll be honest - it does not travel well. Gluten free you gotta eat it right there while it's nice and hot. Thank you, Benny Tudino's! See you next time I am there! read more

Benny Tudino's - Storefront - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

The is a nice pizza joint. There is metered street parking that may be challenging to find a spot. During this COVID time, they are offering carry out and patio dining on the sidewalk out front. I knew what I wanted before I even got there. Two of the largest slices of pizza that I have ever had. And yes, the slices were huge. I could barley eat one of them. So, they packed up the other slice for me and I had it for lunch the next day. You can order your slice fresh. I got one with sausage and pepperoni and the other with meatballs and sweet peppers. They lived up to the hype. They were tasty, flavorful, fresh, filling, huge, and delicious. They also have a kids menu and serve subs and Italian entries, amount many other items. The restaurant patio stays full during peak hours and they have a steady flow of customers in and out. Please be aware that this place is CASH only and does not take credit/debit cards. This place was very laid back and I throughly enjoyed my pizza. read more

The best Pizza ever! This place is an absolute must for anyone who has never tried true thin crust NY/NJ pizza. The slice s are huge! Great local spot in downtown Hoboken. read more

Benny Tudino's - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

See all

it's been YEARS since i have made my way up to Benny's, to be fair i could have sworn i have given them a review before, but guess not? anyway, came in recently, was pretty let down. first off, all the "cheese" on the tables are NOT cheese. not parm cheese to sprinkle onto your pizza, it's like dollar store knock off fake cheese PRODUCT to put on your pizza. my date and i both tried putting some on our pizza, and it basically disappeared. weird. so i took off the top, and it came out like light, fluffy, powder. tasted disgusting. i ended up pulling off the real mozz cheese and eating just the bread and tomatoe sauce at one point. I took some bites of my cheese slice prior to the fake cheese incident and the pizza was just okay. gravy was bland. the crust was so crunchy. no flop whatsoever. cheese was super rubbery. Honestly, i dont think the pizza is as good as it used to be and the whole fake cheese on the tables really turned me off. $6 for a HUGE cheese slice will fill ya up, but id rather pay about the same for better a better quality, typical size slice. still cash only. read more

Paid $4.50 for a massive slice of cheese pizza (I believe it's from the 32" pie). I've been coming here since I was probably about 4-5 years old and always love coming back. Having been away from the NJ/NY area for about 10 years, coming back to this old jaunt just reminds me how pizza outside this area can't even compete. Seems like they also have a large slice and large beer combo that I'll be trying the next time I'm in town! read more

Benny's still remains a legend. The size does not diminish the quality but any means. Perfect sauce with the perfect stretch to the cheese. Stay golden Benny. read more

Big slice of Pizza but actual pizza is just ok. Better spots in Hoboken for better tasting pizza. read more

Benny Tudino's - Plain slice - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

Great restaurant with a lot of character. Arbend, the owner visited our table and thanked us for stopping by. Laurie our waitress was wonderful. When I attempted to order two slices of pizza, she said you have not been here before? Why don't you start off with one and then see if you want another slice. She was so right. It was delicious! Loved the idea that you could design you own slice. Can't wait to get back! Thanks everyone. See you soon! read more

Very annoying that this joint is CASH ONLY. To have a decent meal here costs at least $60+. Who the hell carries cash these days anymore?!?! Even street vendors take cc man. If you wanna keep cheating on your taxes, by all means. I sat outside and ordered $14 crispy calamari. It was good but definitely not worth $14 bucks Jfc. Also got a personal pie for $10 because I wanted a fresh pie all to myself and didn't wanna buy the $18 large pie. Then It would be carb overload. I didn't workout that day just to backtrack 4 days. All their entrees are ridiculously expensive. For that much, I'd rather go to a nice sit down italian place, not a dingy pizza parlor. Service was excellent though and we left her a more than 20% tip because she deserves it. That is if the establishment isn't taking 80% of it. Hmph. read more

Benny Tudino's - Personal $10 plain pie - Pizza Near Me - Hoboken, New Jersey

See all