You know a pizza place isn't that good if the reviews are mostly about hamburgers and beef patty's. Pizzerias are for pizza. Had a pepperoni wheel the other day and nearly pooped my pants. Staff is awesome though. read more

There's no scarcity of pizza shops in the area but Benny's has the best pizza by far! The shop is small but attracts a lot of foot traffic and is often very busy. The layout is very simple and practical, a few tables and chairs. Unlike a lot of the other pizza shops, Benny's has a lot of more options than just plain and chicken slices. Their buffalo chicken and bbq chicken slices are my favorite speciality pizzas from there. They're large and generously filled with toppings. read more

Worst attitude, horrible service. I would give no stars if theyre penne wasnt good. Wish the two white guys werent grumps and just gave great customer service, would be 5 stars if they didnt have that nasty attitude read more

Visiting Queens & got in after a long day so wanted delivery. Just picked Benny's by chance. Delivery was on time and packaged well. Penne a la vodka and spaghetti & meatballs were delicious. Good pizza too. Bread that came with the pasta was very good. Highly recommend. read more

Their food is OK. Everyone at my office likes it due to the salad but it's overpriced and the deli in the corner can add more variety. These will charge you extra just for a pinch more of anything. And, other places will just give you blue cheese for the buffalo slices instead of charging for it... The son's attitude stinks! I hate coming here to even see his face but one time I decided to see for myself the place people at work order from. FU! read more

Absolutley terrible customer service. I'm not the type to write bad reviews but when the owner tells at you for asking to sample 1 out of the 5 soups on the menu after I've already ordered a salad, I think it's really a terrible way to treat customers. read more

I'm a regular at Benny's for 2 years now. I've tried just about everything on the menu. This is what New York Pizza is all about, good cheese, good sauce, and a nice crispy pie (unless you sit too long in the box but that's your fault). They also have deep dish style pizza and their mini spinach pin wheels on Friday are so good you have to fight to get some before they are all gone. Benny is a down to earth guy even though he owns the place. He is a no nonsense type of guy who is quick to smile and always gets my order right. He pay attention to detail so don't try to pull a fast one on him. The buffalo pizza is a personal favorite but the grandma and chicken marsala are close behind. Try a slice and take a seat, these types of pizzeria's are what make New York arguably the epicenter of Pizza in the US. read more

So this is the best penne alla vodka !!! And Irving was mad cool !!! It's so fresh and yummy !!! Clean place and good vibes

This place has outstanding inexpensive food and great owners. My teens are so thrilled when I am in the area and bring home food from here. Best cheese crepes period. Love all their food. In fact I have catered special events with their crepes, fried fish and other foods. read more

My go to place in hillside ave., whenever i'm craving for pasta and pizza. They always cook their pasta as you order it and they cook it to perfection. Their pizza slices are huge. One order of pasta is good enough to share with 3 to 4 people. I like their hawaiian, white pizza and penne ala vodka with chicken. They cook and deliver fast. I'll be back soon. read more

Their pizza is good great I would say. But their Greek salad is full of olives , lettuce is bad, and the cheese which I love there was only 2 small pieces. Oh I thought this salad had tomatoes, I guess they forgot becsuse there was none. I also ordered crispy chicken strips, smelled great but had no taste. When I took a bite I thought I was eating hospital food. And then to top it off I saw on the menu a beautiful pix of cheese cake. OMG. The most georgeous thing but when I received it ,This cake had no presentation, it was hard better said frozen,taste was ok but Benny presentation, presentation is key. Well that was my experience at Benny.. Yay Ben read more

This is one of my favorite pizza places in Queens. Their buffalo slice pizza is amazing. The sauce they use is light and creamy with a mild taste of buffalo. The pizza is paced with tons of chicken so that one slice alone would fill you up for hours. Their penne Alla vodka with shrimp is also one of my favorite pasta dishes. Theirs vodka sauce is creamy and flavorful, the shrimp always tastes fresh. Their pasta is restaurant quality with a fraction of the price. Benny's staff is always friendly and that makes the experience pleasant. read more

Benny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jamaica, New York

Food was simply just ok, a side salad & a hard burnt piece of bread for $13.00, the ziti was just awful so juicy, full of cheese & grease....chicken wasn't crispy at all, I'm never going back...2 Stars because the customer service was awsome. the food however is totally lacking read more

See all

One of this establishment's employees needs his foul manners to be addressed ASAP. Due to lack of Italian food choices in the area, this is the only spot I occasionally frequent. It's pretty subpar food, but I guess others like myself just settle out of convenience. I had my fiancé order a ziti with garlic and olive oil- it's just a dish you can't screw up-, which he ordered for me about a week ago. The employee rudely responds that they don't have it. My fiancé then asks for the menu and the man insists they don't serve that. I hope another Italian restaurant opens up near them and runs them out of business. read more

They were the best at one time, maybe like most businesses they lost a lot of money, but I don't know what kind of meat they are using for their burgers now. They are horrible now, do not waste your money read more

Best Pizza in Queens!! The gentlemen that work their are awesome, sweet and know how to cook! Their shrimp scampi is better than most Italian restaurants. Always a treat to eat from Bennys! read more

This is a great little pizzeria I've been to a few times. The layout of the restaurant is decent. It's clean, and the walls have Italian themed decorations. There are about 6 sets of tables, with up to 4 chairs to a table. There's a television for patrons to check out as well. In my visits, I haven't tried a variety of menu items. All I've had are regular slices, Sicilian slices, and zeppoles. They were all of the quality I expect from a good pizza joint, which is a compliment and my only negative about the shop. I've only eaten a few pizzas that stood out from the rest, and the pizza here doesn't join that rare club. Benny's just makes awesome food, and that's all I'm looking for. read more

They have the best Chipotle Chicken Pizza when it's cooked properly. Yes sometimes the old guy is mean. But the people are cool.

I've lived in this part of Queens all my life. And when if comes to family - this is more than good than you'll get! Everyone who enters here will feel at home, with a full, YES, a FULL Italian menu. Benny's has been around for quite awhile, and he will never fail you when it comes to Italian cuisine. But to make things even MORE original, are the employees! (You know who you two are!) The stuff Benny's has to offer? Aside from usual pizza.... he has some rather "unique" pizza to choose from... such as the signature Hillside pizza! (Named after the area Benny's Pizzeria is located in) Signature Artisan Salads, and even better to mention - Benny's very own spin on a salad: Benny's Special Salad! Made with mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, carrots, sundried tomatoes, (please visit Benny's for more info on this choice!) Footlong heroes! Original Pastas! Homemade soup! And who can say "No" to original zepplois?! Stop by anytime! You're always welcome! read more

The best penne allá vodka and really yummy pizza. Everything you order is really enjoyable. The only reason I gave this place 3 stars its because the service is horrible. It seems like you only get a nice attitude if you've been a long time costumer. Worse if you order on the phone the staff is just really uninterested, and barely try helping. read more

Really good NY style pizza. The crust nice and crispy. Not soggy. It is perfect. I've tried the plain, white, and spinach slices. A+ offering Seltzer for us non soda drinkers!! It does get crowded in the evening with phone orders and people in person. I always manage to get a seat though. There's about 6 tables. read more

Benny's Pizza - Spinach slice and White slice. $7 total. - Pizza Near Me - Jamaica, New York

See all

Customer service is good. Pizza is nothing special for queens. Go for pepperoni pizza.

This is our go to pizza place. We always order the Buffalo Chicken pizza and it never fails to satisfy us. Whenever you're in the neighborhood try this place out. read more

We have ordered take out from here over a hundred times in 5 years, this spot never let me down. Their pasta game is official.

Great place and very good food. Been there a couple of times and the food always tastes fresh. Price is fair based on the quality and the quantity of it. Also the costumer service is great. read more

Pizza! Pizza! Pizza! Love the cheese, sauce, dough! Oh heck I enjoyed my pizza Can't wait for my next visit

I highly enjoyed the pizza at Bennys. I had the bbq chicken and the chipotle slice. Very good indeed. Prices are good and clean quiet environment to eat in. read more

The food is good. But be careful when odering off of their menu for delivery, they like to hike up the prices. They dont reflect the menu prices. read more

The Penne a la vodka pizza is amazing. The service here is always top notch and it is one of my favorite spots in the area.

Craving some pasta and decided to trust my fellow yelpers to steer me in the right direction. I found Benny's, I live 5mins away and never even knew about this place until now. Placing an order over the phone is a bit challenging since the guys speaks strong Italian. I ordered the buffalo chicken wings and the ziti that I heard so many rave reviews about. My order took 45mins to come which I really don't understand since its a 5mins walking distance. My food finally came and I got a portion of salad and bread which made my ziti extra yummier, the wings were also good. read more

They make the best Buffalo chicken pizza. It has a lot of chicken and a good amount of sauce. They make a bunch of other great food too. I have only tried the buffalo chicken pizza and a chicken sandwich. The pizza is too good so i never choose anything else. read more

The food is delicious however I dont appreciate the attitudes from the workers. Very nasty

The food is ok but they're overpriced and their attitudes are terrible. They also don't have a good variety of special slices on most days.

Okay pizza, good selection. HORRIBLE attitude, one worker in particular. Definitely wont be returning because of that alone.

Buffalo Pizza - 5 Stars. The other I items I have tasted 3 stars. To be fair I have not tried any of the pasta dishes but most of the pizza related dishes get a hard 3 stars. ññññññññññññññññ read more

Ive been a regular at Benny's for the past 10 years since I was a freshman in highschool. The food has always been excellent. All these years later and I still order the same thing... a buffalo slice and a spinach stick. The service is always short and sweet and before I forget I recently had the baked ziti with chicken cutlet that was heaven in my mouth. read more

This is my favorite pizza spot in nyc. Pizza is great especially the buffalo pies. I also like the clam chowder sometimes I wish they would notify me when they have it since it's basically a seasonal specialty. Always good to see Benny himself and his two sons working there. read more

While Margherita Pizza on Jamaica Avenue steals the thunder (and it does have the best around), Jamaica does have another good pizza joint and that is Benny's on Hillside Avenue near 179th St. Though it sometimes lacks consistency (sometimes really good, other times OK), it is still good pizza. Good sauce, cheese and crust. I wish Benny would clean up the place a little better and make it a bit nicer inside. While not up to par with Margherita, which is a big feat, Benny's holds its own, especially in Jamaica, which does not have the best pizza joints. Cannot comment on any of the other food, since I have only gotten slices there. Worth a visit. read more

Great tasting pizza and large slices, but they're a little pricey, especially if you order a whole pie including toppings you can end up paying over $20. read more

I came here last year to try this place out and friend told me they make good hot wings..so I gave it a try the wings was good but they made too hot. I never try their pizza yet...but I will try it out next time.. read more