I definitely have to admit that this is the better diner out of the few that are in the area & I like the Broadway themed menu paying homage to musicals such as Cats & Phantom on the cover of the menu. Broadway themed diner on Broadway in Hicksville; cute. I ordered the French Dip lunch special & it came with a bowl of soup. I ordered the chicken noodle soup but wasn't too crazy about it since it was a chicken broth that was certainly high in sodium & had no chicken itself. They should really call it chicken broth noodle soup. The French Dip itself was decent, but not great by any means. The mozzarella wasn't really melted too much on the roast beef & the roast beef itself was pretty well done & a tda dry. Thankfully, it's served with au jus on the side & that was quite good so that made it tasty. My friend ordered the buffalo chicken salad & it was gigantic & a lot of lettuce. She ate all the chicken & cucumbers & a bit of lettuce & there was a lot left over. I usually get eggs or challah french toast at a diner & I should've gone that route instead. I will be back & I will order a breakfast special next time. The service was adequate. Our sever was very sweet but she wasn't as attentive as I would've liked & I never was offered a refill or even had the opportunity to ask her because after our food came out, the next time we saw her when we were done. It's a diner, so I suppose I should come to expect mediocrity, right? read more

Broadway Diner - French Dip - Diners Near Me - Hicksville, New York

Rude waiter, argued over a missing salad dressing and hung up the phone on me after insisting salad dressing was in my takeout order! Disrespectful customer service read more

Not bad. Came here for breakfast. Had a over easy egg with toast and canadian bacon. Tasted okay. Food was good for what it is. Prices are decent, and service was friendly. Can't say much about the speed of the service since we were not even any kind of rush. It was as I expected. read more

Horrible service and even worse food. Came here for dinner with my mom and I ordered an omelet, after a few bites I noticed there was hair cooked into my omelet! When I told the waiter, he did absolutely nothing about it and handed me the check. I complained to the manager and the best they could do was give me a "discount" on the omelet. I would 100% avoid this diner like the plague!!! read more

Broadway diner was renovated a while ago as many are saying, so everything is very proper now. If you are local of the east end of long island, you don't have many choices any more, so this place is really the only good to place if you are looking to get some great food. I really can't comment on much but the BBQ sauce is really amazing here! A bite pricey, but what can you expect it's a diner, they are all the same. I have never experienced a sit down in this place, since I take out, but this place really has some charm to it. Just double check your order if you can because when kids are in the element especially if it's a big order, it will most likely get messed up. read more

This diner was average priced. It is in a pretty good location .. Right across from Broadway Mall. Upon entering re decor was typical diner fashion.. Shiny Metals , mirrors and flowers. The drinks and wait staff came quick. Food was ok .. Mediocre at best. I got a burger, my wife ordered chicken gyro and we ordered a grilled cheese for our son . We would probably give it another try if we were in the area. Diners will be diners.. No pics phone battery was almost dead.. read more

Pretty clean inside but the place is a bit outdated. The food was so good tho! I got a burger and it was the best one I've had in years! It comes with onion rings too which was a plus! read more

Just horrible.... I ordered the classic food for a diner, which is fries, and they looked like mush soaked in oil, and just to round out the image... they looked old. I refused to order anything else, and had to wait forever for a check for what we did consume. read more

This diner is 5/5. The food was spectacular, it hit the spot. Pancakes were amazing!! I recommend the ultimate cheese fries. Service was great. Waitress was attentive. Couldn't have asked for a better experience. Will be back soon! read more

I love the 50s Decor. Very clean diner with plenty of television monitors to stare at. Place can get crowded at times their small triangular parking lot can fill up quickly. Love this place for breakfast the home fries are something to remember. My only gripe this time was the waiter did not come around to check to see how everything was after my order. He was busy chatting with his other coworkers. But other than that he still got a decent tip for me. Overall a little pricey than other diners in the area but the plus side is they're open late when other diners in Hicksville area are closed. read more

See all

Absolute fan of their breakfast menu. Perhaps due to the fact that I'm a picky eater and prefer breakfast items all day. We try to make their breakfast special weekly. This includes coffee/tea, juice or fruit, and a traditional breakfast item for a really good price. I typically order soft boiled eggs with home fries. Every now and then a waiter or waitress won't know what it is and somehow mess it up, but overall it's really good. I also find that some of the wait staff will omit the fruit option if you don't ask for it. Almost like they're trying to cheat you out of it. But the food itself, and the service are really good. I've also tried their lunch special and was amazed at how much food was included. I found myself taking half of it home because it was so big. read more

Been coming here for years but today we got the worst service ever. Was never asked about drinks, with the kids meal they are supposed to get a cookie and we had to ask for the cookie, the waiter laughed at us when we made a complaint and the woman behind the register started a fight with us when we told her what happened saying the service was our fault it was bad. The manager gave us the cookie which was not the point of why we told her and said he would look into it. Basically just brushed us off. When we told the woman she lost loyal customers she laughed and basically said she didn't care. read more

Eggplant parm hero! Totally mouthwatering!!!!! I became a vegan so I can't eat it with the cheese anymore, but if you get Daiya mozzarella cheese I will never stop coming!!!!!!! Best diner around. Nice staff, great food. read more

FOOD POISONING . Yes, my daughter and I both, in 2017. I posted a review about it on 8/29/17. The proper authorities were contacted and health violations were found. The reason I am updating this info is because I saw another review, on 8/7/18 , from Kathy W , of Plainview, reporting her illness also, after going to the Broadway Diner. Broadway Diner, CLEAN UP YOUR ACT, or close down ! read more

Had a very nice dinner for 5. Our server was fast and efficient. All 5 meals were served hot and were good. The Black Jack burger was huge and really nicely put together. The French toast platter was a little small, but tasty. The Dimitri wrap was good, with grilled chic, lettuce, tomato and bacon. I got it with feta cheese, which was a nice addition. It could have used some dressing, so I ordered a side of blue cheese. Pickles were excellent and the slaw was tasty. read more

Excellent food and service. This is my first time here and it was awesome. I was seated quickly.. the food was great. Service matched. And this place was packed. Still managed to do everything quickly. I recommend here. read more

Great food open late. Great take out. Fast friendly staff and a large menus and a lot of desserts. Plenty of seats and parking. read more

Broadway Diner - Desserts - Diners Near Me - Hicksville, New York

My wife and I, family and many friends frequent this amazing diner! Great food, and dinner specials and a very friendly attentive staff make this diner our favorite! The portions are huge and we usually end up taking home leftovers. They also have a Royalty Rewards Program. They send you coupons for $10.00 off your bill and/or buy one entree get the second one free, etc... Their prices are reasonable too! You'll love it! read more

The food and service at Broadway are always great. The vibe is also enjoyable, reflecting a vintage 50's feel. I always enjoy going there.

My pancakes were great, the waitress was very nice but brought the check out while we were still eating. I felt rushed to leave. And one of the people I was eating with found hair in their omelette. read more

Never received contact. But decided to try the place again. And time and time again its the same horrible service. Horrible food. Ihop just opened up and empire diner is two minutes away. They really don't care about business it seems read more

The food was explicit, and the waitress was very sweet, I will come back for more, the grilled salmon salad was very delicious, but I would suggest to cook the mushrooms a tad more, the lemonade was absolutely perfect and the waitress was very attentive and diligent, although one of the cashiers gave me a dirty look, I don't mind because I don't care what people think, but overall the service was great and the cookies and mint really give it the cherry on top. read more

Walked into the diner, went to the mens room before being seated. Inside mens room a gentlemen using the next urinal. When he was done, he left the mens room without washing his hands. When i was seated. I obsered this person walking into the kitchen. Definitly not a waiter. Probabl preparing the food. A table of 8 , we all left. Gross read more

I ordered a spaghetti with meatballs and I'm not sure if they seriously cooked it. I feel like I ate a spaghetti noodles slap with tomato sauce and a very bad meatballs. It was very badly cooked!! My husband and I thought we should try this place since it's in the neighborhood, but it'll be the first and last!! Really disappointed, I'm not expecting the best spaghetti meatballs but the one I had is totally a failsauce! like literally! read more

Typical Long Island diner! Don't even bother going around 3 PM - it's almost impossible to get service or a meal here at that time! The place is filthy and the menu is way too extensive and totally redundant! Do yourself a favor and drive a half a mile south and go to Empire diner! read more

My wife and I are regulars at the Broadway Diner... Good food and good service as well... We aways request our favorite waitress Amber... She is always polite and energetic and on point with our orders. She always pays attention to detail. read more

Rude. Rude. Rude. I'm amazed at my self control for not punching the older gentleman (owner/manager). I've been here a couple of times with my husband and toddler, our last visit was on fathers day. I know it's a holiday and the staff was busy but that's no excuse for greeting us with a scowl and barely acknowledging us. Our food was fine and server great. My son was playing with the pepper shaker and spilling some pepper on the table. The older man who greeted us, came over, YANKED the shaker out of my sons hand, and took away out salt shaker as well. No explanation. First of all, do not touch my child if you have a problem ask/address me not my 20 month old child. Second you are a DINER not a 5 star establishment so please don't get your panties in a bunch if some kid is playing with your pepper shaker. Never returning here! read more

Worst service ive ever had. I called in an order and literally everything was wrong. Beyond annoyed. The owner was so rude, he couldn't even tell me what a ribeye steak was and told me that they were not a steakhouse when I asked. I spoke to 4 different people when I ordered because they kept passing the phone around. Will NEVER order here again. They don't even deserve 1 star. read more

Went on a Sunday night, limited options for restaurants late at night. Waitress was rude, messed up order, whole experience was a big waste of time and money. Order egg sandwiches ( how do u mess up that order?) my sisters had cheese, which she didn't want and it took ten minutes to be redone. They charge $3 for extra bacon which isn't even real and this bacon in particular tastes like it went bad days ago. Hash browns were dry and when we asked why the egg sandwiches didn't have salt, pepper ketchup (like we ordered) the waitress pointed to the ketchup on the table! Do it yourself salt pepper ketchup! Do yourself a favor and choose Empire Diner a few blocks further instead. read more

Terrible! Visiting from out of town I saw this place and was in the mood for diner food. Ordered a Philly cheesesteak! Big mistake. First, they put it on a roll. No no no Broadway Diner...that is not how you do it. The sandwich was piled with meat that was oozing off the bread. Way too much for one sandwich. No wonder America is getting fatter. Fries had no flavor at all so I coated them with salt. Next, the tea was also bad! Who screws up tea??? You did Philadelphia a bad service by calling that sandwich a Philly Cheesesteak and the south a bad service by calling that drink "tea." Worst part of all....$30 for all of this including a below average piece of baklava. Thirty dollars for a cheesesteak, cold fries and baklava (for one person!). I guess we have to pay for the 30 TV's in this place. read more

Love this diner! Food is great and very fast service! The portions are very big and they have a great desert selection!

This was my grandfather's favorite diner along with Massapequa. The host is always super kind. The food is always delicious. The atmosphere just has something about it that separates itself from other diner locations. Absolutely a jewel in NY diners. read more

Stopped by the Broadway Diner because we were shopping at Ikea and just happened to be nearby. My boyfriend got his usual Chicken Parm wrap with a side of blue cheese and I got a salad. The place is nice and clean. Their menu is typical diner menu with some additional items that make it a bit more unique. read more

We were seated at a dirty booth. Next my daughter spilled her drink. They didn't offer napkins to help her dry off. Then they had an attitude about her spilling the drink. They would not give her a new drink. Then I asked for them to cook the mushrooms on my salad but said that was a $3.50 charge. We won't be back. read more

It's a diner - with typical diner fare. My daughter likes it, she thinks they invented bacon cheeseburgers here, it is the first place she had one. That would be memorable for anyone I guess, your first BACON CHEESEBURGER. Food's OK, not exceptional. I like a good soup - I didn't find any treasures here. I asked for a pizza - or sauce and cheese baked on a pita, or bagel, or the like - they served me a disgusting soggy wet mess. It was a wrap, like a samdwich wrap soaked in watery tomato sauce covered with mozzerella cheese and MICROWAVED. When I OBVIOUSLY didn't like it - the waiter (who had been embarassed to even serve it) made an attempt to get it removed from the bill - the management said... and I quote: "THATS WHAT SHE ORDERED NOT OUR FAULT SHE DON'T LIKE." I tipped well - he tried. read more

Came here late Saturday night for there nighttime menu. So glad we did. Prices were decent not cheap but not too expensive. They had a special for nutella pancakes... i was so tempted to get them but I did not. I got the buffalo chicken wrap with fries and gravy. My boyfriend got a coffee with some kind of breakfast wrap. I do not want to get all crazy over a buffalo wrap but I got to say it was the best I EVER have. And I have had so many. Most dinners make these so crappy, and they still taste like they came out of a freezer box. NOT THIS ONE. I swear it was so huge, juicy, fresh, and just uber yummy. Fries were good too, needed a little salt. But I literally think this place had the best buffalo wrap ever! My boyfriend gobbled his wrap in two seconds. SO idk... this place gets a bad rep sometimes... maybe they are trying to change things up? I say check out the late night menu. It is very small! Do not be fooled! It is small with one side of about 5 desserts, and another side of about 4 breakfast items and 1 wrap. read more

We only ordered breakfast from here because it was one of the few places open at 7am on the weekend. Unfortunately, we will never order from here ever! The potatoes were burnt badly that we had to return the food. Usually if it was a little burnt we would let it slide but the food was unacceptable. Wish we took a picture of it. I'm surprised that the chef served it to people. Even with the new batch, all we tasted was pepper. We will just drive a bit further for iHop next time! read more

Came here late at night with a friend because nothing else was open. The service was slow. The food came out cold. Hash browns tasted terrible The salad I had was unfresh and wilted. When I finally got waiter's attention he offered to microwave them. No thanks. Not sure I want to come back here ever again. read more

The beef stew is ahhmazing! Warm bread rolls availabl upon request are so tasty! Pie selection is to die forservice with a smile you can count on read more

Best Diner in Hicksville in my opinion. Great Service. Quick turnaround time for food. Food is up to par if not better than some similar diners I've been to. And bathrooms are spotless. The only downside to this place is the limited parking especially with the amount of traffic that comes to this diner. The Oreo cheesecake is a must try!!!! read more