When I first drove past Brooklyn Pizza, I thought it was a rebirth of the pizza restaurant of the same name that was in Firewheel/Garland several years ago. This is not, it is a smaller restaurant that has sufficient seating but appears to me takeout oriented. Many pizza-by-the-slice options and a crust that comes somewhat close to the NYC experience with an overall very good product. Salads were good as well. A small place that does not try to be everything to everyone but succeeds in it's nitch. Recommended for a lunch special or takeout. read more

It truly is a five star pizza, the only reason I am giving you guys a four star is because three times I've ordered a $30 pizza with basil you guys have forgotten the basil every time. (If you don't have basil in the store that's fine just take it off your menu). Be vigilant on the smaller things. Im not going to stop ordering your pizza cause it's actually delicious just pay attention to the smaller stuff. Try this place for the pizza. The pepperoni sticks with their marinara are just ok. Marinara is average. And to much dough. Salads are super small and nothing crazy. But once again, the actual pizza which is what I am reviewing is pretty good. Thin, crispy, flavorful. Pretty expensive but worth it. Inside is pretty cool. New York vibe to it. read more

Delicious pizza, meatballs and Greek salad. Our new favorite pizza spot! Delivery shows up hot- highly recommend.

I saw all the great reviews which is why I stopped by. There were no pepperoni pizzas in the display case, so they took a cheese pizza added some pepperoni on top of it, and then threw whatever substance that is on top of it, put it in the brick oven for like 2 seconds...and this is what I have. It honestly looks so gross, that I'm not going to eat it. I think it would make me sick if I did. Five dollars down the drain. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Reheated Pepperoni Pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Dallas, Texas

Pizza was great. Got pizza and stromboli to take back to the hotel. Flavors were on point. Atmosphere was warm and welcoming. TV's had NCAA basketball on. They were out of slices so that was a bummer. I hope to try again when in the area. Respectfully, Bryan Oklahoma City read more

See all

Nice little place to stop for a slice after the baseball game as i headed back to my hotel. Very friendly service and got me a nice beer roadie to take out. Very friendly read more

twice in Two weeks I had a craving for a good NY Style pizza. crust was crispy and cheese tasted great and the pizza had a great "flop" too. pizza rolls were tasty too. Ill definitely be back for more pizza! read more

See all

I went to check out this place because I looked up pizza places with great reviews and this one came up. I went in on a sunday evening and it was pretty dead. I asked for a supreme slice. What they did was they got a cheese slice that had been sitting there and proceeded to add the "supreme" toppings. This was the lazy way to make a supreme pizza and it made my slice not taste good. The pizza was not fresh underneath but had fresh rawish veggies on top. You can see from the photo! You can see staleish pizza and fresher sorta uncooked veggies on top. This created an unappealing taste. The atmosphere was fine. It was empty and tv's were not loud. The decor was nice. Would i go back? Definetly not. I would steer clear from any place that short cuts the way into making a great pizza. All the restaurants around yours have closed down! Yours maybe be next. You would assume that you would want to provive better food quality to retain or attract customer but with food quality short cuts like this your driving away new customers that will not return. read more

We ordered two pizza's delivered to our house and both were outstanding. One of the best pizza's in the Dallas area.

Pizza was fresh and amazing!!! We got the Verona and a garlic cheese pie which was the perfect amount for two people to take home some left overs. Probably the best crust I've ever had and I'm not exaggerating. The employees were so friendly and we were recommended this place from a friend and we can see why! In addition the ambience is great and it's a good little spot for a weekday dinner. We also saw postings for lunch day specials which seemed like a good deal. We will be back! read more

See all

I always get a slice at lunch when im in the area. Their pizza is excellent. I travel often to NJ and this pizza is very close to the thin crust I get when I travel there. read more

Pizza and salad were amazing. Had a great time. The staff were friendly and very helpful. I would recommend this pizza place to all . Love the ambiance NY feels. Thank you read more

Lunch special, which includes a slice of pizza, salad and a premium soft drink, is a great value in these inflationary times. If you have a big appetite, add a second slice for a few bucks more. Slices are two-handers, finished in the oven just like in NYC. Toppings are fairly generous for the money. Crust is fairly straightforward, and not quite as chewy as some of the better slices in New York - but still very enjoyable. Several choices of salad dressing, and also a selection of "Real Sugar" sodas. Beer and wine also available. Worth a stop! read more

See all

Pizza is amazing!! Spicy Honey wings are the bomb! I haven't tried the other flavors but this has that sweet and spiciness to it! The salad I was served did have too much ranch and tomatoes so that made it soggy but the rest of the food was great!! 8/10! The customer service was great outstanding and the Asian guy was very helpful! 10/10! The inside was clean and it had a nice atmosphere to it. 10/10! I can definitely see myself returning! read more

Pizza is similar to what you'd get in NYC. Ordering online was easy and the food was fresh. Will definitely be back.

Moved to North Dallas from downtown so wanted to find a new spot. I usually order a large with the works, so I ordered what I thought would be a loaded pie, when I picked it up it was feather light. Usually 2 slices and I am full, but with this pizza, it was so light on the toppings we each ate half the pie. This was a $30 dollar pie. This thing was 2 centimeters thick and they call this the Godfather?! Fuhgetaboutit. I won't be back. read more

Delicious pizza.. Great atmosphere.. and customer service is Fabulous. Martin who helped me.. was friendly, knowledgeable about the menu and filled me in on his favorites to order.. kudos to Martin read more

The pizza here is outstanding..... lived in New York a few years and the pizza there is delicious, and the pizza at Brooklyn's is so delicious it reminds me of New York pizza! Sometimes they have premade pizzas in the glass case, but if not, never fear wait 8 minutes and they'll have a pizza made for you, hot and delicious. My favorite is the Godfather with black olives!! I also love their Greek salad and the owner is a super nice guy. The ambience is OK, I will say often I'm one of only two people in the restaurant, but I also go at odd hours..... usually just after getting my nails and my lashes done next-door. I'm telling you don't miss out. This is a place that not many people know about but they have amazing pizza. read more

Fresh pizza and delicious flavor! I've ordered their Chicken Pesto pizza and it was delicious. The ambience is peaceful and great for socializing. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Medium Chicken Pesto - Pizza Near Me - Dallas, Texas

Brooklyn Pizzeria is mellow. It's relaxing. That's a good thing. The food is amazing! The service is incredible, and it is just a great time, and a great place for families. Come in, order a pizza, sit down, listen to some relaxing music, talk to your family and enjoy yourself. You know: like restaurants used to be. read more

The pizza was good with plenty ingredients but a little salty for me. The customer service was excellent.

Food is 10/10, highly recommend. Service is amazing every time, I'm pregnant and they offered to help me with my pizza boxes to the car! Can't appreciate them enough, you can't go wrong with eating here ever!! read more

Lots of options and great pizza. Lunch specials Very large slices of very good pizza! read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Dallas, Texas

First Yelp review ever- Ambiance is good, but the 2 pepperoni slices had a burned, yet still raw, uncooked taste. Upon removing the toppings and cheese, it was raw. This is likely a result of using a dough that was not fresh, which resulted it the crust not baking and rising. The single, only worker present was at the cash register. Considering that I told him it was my first time here and the fact that there was only one other set of patrons present besides myself, it was disappointing. He didn't bother to ask me how my food was. *Also, the fountain soda is not Coke or Pepsi branded products, but some "alternative" brand that doesn't taste good at all. read more

Huge slices of NY style pizza. Meatball sub is good not great. Inside is very clean and service is excellent.

Really good, will definitely be back. Get the garlic cheese bread and Caesar salad for sure read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dallas, Texas

See all

I don't know how they have got a 100% rating . The pizza I got tonight was horrible. Cold and tasted horrible . I done know if it was a bad night or what but I wasted 12.00 dollars read more

Ordered a cheese pizza and a Caesar salad. The Caesar salad had chicken on it that was identical to the processed precooked fajita chicken you get at the grocery store near the bacon. Horrible!!!! Is it that hard to grill a piece of chicken? The pizza was meh, it's unclear if the dough was made fresh, and the sauce was sour. Skip this place and go to Costco and get pizza. read more

Average pizza. Terrible / indifferent service. Apology at the end but 40 mins for a pizza is crazy. I could have made that from scratch at home quicker. Crust was average. Sauce tasteless. Place may have just had an off night as it has lots of good reviews. But it was a really off night. read more

This was my first time trying out Brooklyn Pizzeria. I ordered The Venetian for delivery. It came piping hot and everything tasted so fresh and delicious! I can't wait to try other menu items. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - The Venetian - Pizza Near Me - Dallas, Texas

We went to Angelo and Vito's for years and we're very disappointed when they closed. After they reopened as Brooklyn Pizzeria we decided to give them a try. They had refreshed the place, new benches, a little more light but basically the same except for a neon sign I didn't remember. It was 7:00pm on a Sunday, not exactly prime time, but it was pretty empty and the phone didn't ring even once. However, the pizza and the salad were both excellent (and they were reheated slices). Maybe even a little better than A&V. We'll definitely be back and will likely try delivery next time. Give these guys a try. I'm glad we took a chance. I was delighted that we have decent New York pizza in the neighborhood again! read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Dallas, Texas

So good. SO GOOD! I ordered from here one night while staying at a friend's and I'm incredibly sad there's not a location by me. I got extra cheese because I love cheese and it was everything I wanted it to be. I did sponge off a significant amount of grease, but that's to be expected with that much cheese. Yum! The pepperoni rolls were very good though there wasn't as much cheese and pepperoni inside as I had hoped. It was mostly the bread. Still, they were good and the marinara accompanying them is something I wish I had access to regularly!! I wish there had been an option to use a delivery app for ordering as I pay for one of those so as to not pay delivery fees, but this was something I would pay for again if I were in that area. Consider opening more locations PLEASE!! read more

Good pizza for the money. We will certainly try it again. The white pizza was my families favorite

Amazing pizza! Came for the lunch special. Always hot and solid! And the salad, though just a side lunch special salad, was tossed just for me, and not from a pretossed large salad bowl. 11/10, will definitely be back! read more

Wow! Let me get the reviews rolling on this place! It's right around the corner from my house and my husband and I decided to stop in and see what it's about. This Greek salad is the BEST Greek salad hands down I've had from a pizza joint here in Dallas. It's super fresh and the feta is everything! Mushrooms tomatoes olives YUM! Comes with balsamic and it's perfect just that way. We got a large pineapple pepperoni and sausage pizza with extra cheese and it literally was so beyond incredible we are going back tomorrow. Mouth watering! Had to take a nap after and went to sleep dreaming about this pizza. Definitely will be our go-to pizza joint from here out. Also-bathrooms are very nice and very clean. All around 5 stars check this place out you won't be disappointed read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pineapple sausage pepperoni extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Dallas, Texas

Surprise find in my neighborhood. Good vibe. Friendly service. Hot, fresh and tasty pizza rolls.

I got a large Godfather pizza to go. It was OK except for the fact that the crust was burned. I feel that the price is way too high for what I consider a ruined pizza. I feel that the person who baked it knew that the crust was burned. I tried to make it palatable by micro-waving a couple of slices. I could still taste the burned crust. Warming it up in the oven didn't help, either. I ordered a house salad. I should have saved my money and just bought an already prepared salad in a bag at the grocery store. It would have saved me a lot of money. I used to order pizza and pasta dishes all the time when this place operated under a different name. I won't buy anything from here again. read more

Service was friendly and efficient and the decor/ambience is pleasant. The house salad and garlic cream dressing were quite good. The pizza toppings were very good - high quality and generous amounts. But, it's all about the crust for me and this was average at best. Not crispy at all except on the very outer edges, no chew whatsoever, and not much flavor. Just didn't do it for me. read more

Dough is good, cheese is good, toppings are good....but the sauce is kind of weird...it is pasty/thick....I will order again but I will get HALF the sauce and see how that works....great staff and help up there. read more

We usually do carry out since it's close to home and we enjoy the pizza and the staff are always friendly too!