Local hang out. The food is ok. I don't think they boil their bagels so they end up having the texture and consistency of a real nyc bagel. They do have a nice patio if the weather Is nice. read more

Me and my husband came to the New York Deli on Sunday and were surprised to find that they serve vegetarian dishes in addition to their regular menu. I ordered a Beyond burger on a sesame bagel with sweet potato fries. It was delich!! I was impressed with the service as well!! I highly recommend this place. The coffee was wonderful. Even the Decaf tasted great!! We are locals and will definitely be back. I have to mention Mira, the manager who is so knowledgeable, caring and hard working (she was busy helping the stuff!!) Thanks for the wonderful experience. read more

Great food. Shady outdoor seating, friendly service, good prices, Huevos Yucatecas and authentic bagels! What else could you ask for?

The WORST customer service!! Go here if you enjoy a big side of attitude with your meal! Truly terrible management, does not listen to customers nor care for feedback. They will go out of business with such terrible customer service, paired with "blah" food, which is also overpriced. Not sure what kind of experience the manager has, if any, managing a business, other than working here. Will NOT be returning unless there is a change of management in the future. In short: Save yourself the time & money and SKIP THIS PLACE! read more

The food is always amazing. This is the go to spot for a great breakfast or lunch. I highly recommend NY Deli.

Meh. We ate in and the individual who took our order repeated back twice " no sauerkraut, right", then proceeded to make the sandwich with sauerkraut. The same person charged us for 6 bagels to go and when we got home we discovered there were only 5 in the bag. Suggest they pay attention t the orders. read more

We were in Santa Fe last year and had breakfast here several times and loved it. This is still a favorite. Tip: If your breakfast order comes with hash brown potatoes remind them that you like them crispy or they will be a little dull. read more

Made a simple carryout order here, two sandwiches and a cookie. When we opened the order, one of the sandwiches was missing cheese, and there was no giant cookie. Incredibly poor service for a $25 lunch for two. read more

Excellent breakfast. Bagels were perfect and the scallion cream cheese was excellent. California omelette was stuffed with all ingredients, not skimping on anything. read more

If you want a homemade breakfast or lunch this is the place to go! I came to Santa Fe on vacation and had to come back multiple times during our stay! Each dish is so flavorful and does not disappoint. Not to mention the staff is so inviting and incredibly helpful! read more

So, its not Bagelmania, but is it really that much different? Doesn't really feel that different to me, which is fine by me, because the first time I went there, I thought I was going to Bagelmania. So, its not cheap, or even reasonable for that matter, but few things are in Santa Fe. That said, what I have had from there has been pretty decent, and is still some place I would head toward when craving a bagel in the Santa Fe Plaza region. read more

I loved this place! Unpretentious, comfortable, and yummy! In the week we were in town we went twice and would have gone more but they are closed after 3. The Benedict sampler was Wonderful. I prefer my hollandaise more lemony, but the eggs were cooked perfectly and getting to try 3 different types was such fun. My husband loved his gyro--lots of meat and very crispy fries, as he asked. Such a welcome respite from all chiles all the time! read more

They used to be the best breakfast place for bacon and eggs. No more. They used to have the best toast, super crunchy but chewy. Now, you can tell it's just some store bought cheap bread, even has a weird aftertaste. Yuck. We've been coming here for years. It used to be packed fir breakfast with locals.... no more. I guess we'll be looking fo4 a new place too. read more

I was there today, November 2, 2019 a little after 1:00 P.M. I am a regular customer there. Unfortunately, today when I arrived the staff was gathered at the large table just inside the door. They were shouting, yelling, cursing, and arguing with each other and saying things to the manager such as, "You texted your wait staff sucks" and other things about the management. No one was being waited on in the dining room and people were leaving while the cooks were cowering in the kitchen. After several minutes, I became more than a little concerned and left with several other customers. I won't return. Ever. Don't be surprised that if the next time you visit New York Deli Catron Street is closed. read more

Good well priced meal . Accommodating staff. We had breakfast. No vegan options here.

Stopped in again with a co-worker recently while in town for business. He is from New York City and loved the decor and menu. We both had a great lunch and spent an enjoyable time there. read more

The food was good. The bagels were nicely toasted. It wasn't all that but it was definitely OK, especially if you're trying to get away from some green chilies for a while. Where things went really south really fast was they came to our table they took our drink order it took her food order and then freaking forgot about me. Husband got his coffee and water, and I didn't. We pointed out to the server I'd Ordered also. But that didn't seem to matter. We told someone else, they went and took an order from another table. Husband had to go to the counter and ask for My coffee. Don't mess with someone who hasn't had their coffee. We were nice about it though, because, well, we're in a New York deli. I don't want somebody to spit In my food. read more

Nice little spot! Beautiful remodel! Bagels are incredible!!! Mayra is super sweet. Thank u

They have a good, varied, and extensive menu, and the food is decent, although nothing to write home about. The service was slow and careless. Certainly not a New York deli--Upstate New York, maybe. read more

Not sure what everyone ate at this place to warrant great reviews. We had New York deli fare. A turkey Rubin on rye with sweet potato fries and slaw. The turkey was off. Not bad but off. It just did t really have a taste but it did have a smell. The bread was good. Not great. Not fantastic not even average. It was just a plain ole sandwich. My husband ordered the roast beef sandwich he said it was alright. Again, not fabulous. Just a sandwich. I was expecting a New York deli sandwich. like the ones in New York. Or maybe k(L?)enny and ziggys in Houston. Now those are delicious and would knock your socks off. I did notice everyone ate pancakes and eggs. A few other breakfast items but mostly pancakes. I also would like to mention the wait staff ignored us for 10 minutes without getting our drink order. And that happened when I flagged one down. So all in all 3 stars feels about right. Nothing horrible. It was just so so and cost 40.00$. read more

Brooklyn comes to God's Country. This is an ideal spot, tucked away from Touristville. Nice that they kept the razor-wire fence from the former auto shop this place is housed in. Green chile bagels with green chile cream cheese like Bubbie used to make ... if Bubbie were a New Mexican. read more

Visiting Santa Fe on a trip to ABQ. Had a plan to check out a vegan place for brunch but it was a very long wait. Got back on yelp to try to find a place in the area that hopefully was not as crowded or at least didn't have the long wait and found this place. The food was good, nothing crazy special and there was no wait. read more

As a New Yorker born and raised on bagels, corn beef hash, lox and all the other great NY deli menu items, Santa Fe's New York Deli falls quite short. It's a caricature of NY food. Boar's Head meats, etc. could be found anywhere. read more

I love bagels in the morning, and the assortment of bagels is just superb. I love that there is always a selection to choose from, and with so many it makes it hard to decide which to have, though I tend to favor the green chili and everything bagels. As if the bagel selection wasn't enough, their assortment of cream cheeses gives me even more variety in my mornings. I can pair my green chili with green chili, or honey walnut with cinnamon raisin. Yum yum. read more

I was so pleased with the healthy food choices NY Deli had to offer me! I chose a healthy (and delicious) salad... and then I must admit that I had bagel chips too. Those might become an addiction. Great food, great service. I'm going back! read more

Delicious food served quickly. Visited from out of state and was very impressed with the quality of the food on their menu. I love their bagels. read more

I have been coming to this restaurant for over 10 years. The quality had decreased and it now longer feels rhe same. The potato pancakes were confirmed to be frozen. The food was bland and the decor is no longer charming and feels cold and corporate like. Why must we alway have a restaurant serve New Mexican food even though the name is furthest from New Mexican. I will not be eating here ever again. read more

My casual neighborhood go to place! Nice variety of breakfast and lunch menu choices. Friendly service. Seasonal outdoor seating.

Some of the best tortilla soup in town. Sandwiches to go or eat in are delicious. If you are in the mood for a pastrami, this is the place to go. read more

We were extremely disappointed and will not ever go back! New York deli has poor quality ingredients. New York Deli has the most expensive pancakes in Santa Fe $ 7.95 for 2 pancakes and charges extra for maple syrup. 2 pancakes 3 pieces of bacon (bacon is poor quality) and coffee was $14,26. We had to waited over 25 minutes. The chicken liver sandwich tasted awful and is still unable to digest. read more

I have nothing nice to say about NY Deli. I've been there many times over the years...was not much better when it was the Bagelmania. Same idea, same meh food, same lousy experience. Someone took a bite of my food one time, 1 bite! When we got the check, the waitress had charged us a split plate fee...over 1 bite. Sharing is not caring. Had we have asked for an extra plate, had he have taken more than 1 bite..actually if he'd have taken 2 bites of my food I might be as bitter...but talk about stingy. read more

Don't let the 'New York' name fool you. Best southwestern breakfast in Santa Fe! The service is great! The huevoes rancheros is fantastic. We went back twice! read more

I have no idea why this place has any negative ratings. I can say I did not buy any bagels they looked amazing though. I ordered the blackstone benedict, and my husband frech toast. It was amazing, everybody was so nice. I will definitely be back next time I visit Santa Fe. read more

After a second return recently I find it's just ok if that. Chose an Eggs Benedict and found the hollondaise quite bland. No flavor to it. Previous visit was another breakfast time of which I chose an omlette with vegetables. Was fine but almost to room temperature. As was the case with yesterdays Eggs Benedict. I find with similar experiences that may answer the concerns of the slow delivery of service as well food. Meals left on counter with no heat lamp possibly. This particular location is going under some renovation and hope amongst their remodeling that they consider sound barrier walls. Is quite noisy and with open ceilings, concrete flooring allows for loudness. Not likely to make a return anytime soon. read more

Party of four- 2 adults and 2 kids. Service was excellent. We had the kid's grilled cheese sandwiches, a Reuben, egg salad sandwich, and matzoh ball soup. The Reuben was excellent - sauce was one of the best we've had at a deli. The matzoh ball soup was light (not overly salty). Reuben had a great flavor as did the sauce. The egg salad was good; I'm used to a little creamery homemade version. All in all this was an excellent find as we passed through Santa Fe! read more

All I know is if I got in my car and drove to the nearest McDonald's they would acknowledge my presence when I walked in. I stood there for 10 minutes right next to the wait to be seated sign until I finally flagged down a waitress who got me served immediately. Still really frustrating to have waiters walk by multiple times and then immediately acknowledge and serve the people that come in after you. I won't be back. The waitress that finally served me was great though. Then when I asked for my check the guy that brought it to me muttered something about bad news. I was just trying to eat an overpriced turkey sandwich. Worst service I've ever gotten anywhere. read more

Ok the stars are for the food hands down...NOT the service the foods is the only thing that will bring me back best gyro I've ever had and I've been to all but 12 of the fifty states....best lox bagel ever generous servings of fixings capers onions tomatoes olives yummy! But I'm an asshole so I told the server to his face he sucked and I tipped the cook! read more

We haven't had good luck at this location. We love the Cerillos location though. Saturday I ordered a Belgian Waffle. My wife and I are trying to be vegetarian, so I skipped the bacon or sausage. I got one thin (1/2 inch thick), small, maybe 7 inch round waffle. It was the same kind of waffle you get at a continental breakfast at a hotel that you make yourself, and a scrambled egg on the side. No bread, or any other sides, so I asked for a banana. My tiny waffle, egg and banana was $15 because the banana was extra even though I didn't get bacon or sausage. My wife got a huge omelet loaded with sauteed vegetables, a side of hash browns, side of fruit and a tomato bagel and creme cheese for $12. Granted, all she ate was the bagel and fruit because the omelet was too greasy to eat. We were in a hurry and had to ask the waiter (and help) for the check 4 times before he was capable of printing it and bringing it to us (at one point we saw him singing and dancing in the kitchen while we waited). My son ordered the same as my wife and after tip, our bill was $72 and we all left hungry. We weren't happy. Thank you to the busser that refilled my iced tea. At least I got that. If you want consistently good service and food, go to their other location. Their staff has been the same for maybe 10+ years! read more

Authentic bagels and full breakfast menu, organic bold coffee at very fair prices.

We've been going to the former Bagelmania for years and usually had good experiences. It seems to cater more to locals, which is just fine to us. The new management changed Bagelmania a little bit, but many holdovers remained on the menu. As a deli, it has a wide variety of choices, with some Santa Fe touches, such as green chili on some dishes. On a recent visit to the "new" New York Deli for breakfast, we were less than impressed. As soon as we sat down, a waiter brought us a cup of coffee and a cold Coke. That would have been great if we, you know, actually ORDERED this. It was for another table and when we said "this isn't our order", the waiter looked at us like we were crazy. "We haven't even ordered yet", we said. All the waiter could say was, "do you want this or not". We ordered Huevos Rancheros and a Plain Egg White Omelette. Both entrees were huge portions, more than anyone should eat for one meal. Many restaurants and delis are guilty of portion distortion, but we didn't recall this being a problem at Bagelmania. The huevos rancheros were really poorly done. Everything was sort of in one big pile. There were too many hash browns, and the cheese tasted processed, definitely not fresh. The cheese also covered almost everything. Not the way huevos rancheros are prepared. I ordered this with the green chile, but the waiter insisted on giving me Christmas chile (red and green) instead. After this visit, we will most likely seek out other local breakfast choices. The New York Deli is not a good substitute for the former Bagelmania. read more