Fancy birthday dinner for the wife (no kids!). We started with some cocktails. Unfortunately, they were out of the one I wanted (kinda weird for a cocktail), but, the ones we ordered were tasty (and beautiful). I followed that up with a wedge salad (no Caesar option). It's huge and decadent! The bacon was delicious and the blue cheese dressing wasn't too overpowering. Still would prefer a Caesar option, but, this one sufficed for the night. For our main we got the NY Strip special. I would caution that they come out on the rare side - we ordered med rare and it was definitely full rare (cold in the middle). Luckily it was 24 oz so we didn't finish the middle and I cooked it up the next day. The mushrooms that came with the steak were well cooked but needed salt (not on the table). Mashed potatoes were a bit disappointing however. When I come to a fancy steakhouse, I expect decadent, smooth, buttery mash. What I got was rustic, skin on, chunky mash. It wasn't unpleasant, just didn't match with the level of meal I'm paying for. My wife picked out a white cake with lemon honey for dessert. First, the lemon honey was really awesome. I'm going to have to buy some flavored honey - it's not a gimmick. Unfortunately, the flavor was a bit marred by the icing being kind of gritty. Decor, service, ambiance (piano player) was all top notch - a few tweaks and this is place the top option for steak around. read more

See all

Service: 5/5 Food: 4/5 Ambiance: 5/5 TL;DR: Make a reservation, scallop appetizer is chef's kiss, service is top-notch, steak has lots of char, sides are totally shareable, expect special occasion pricing, the bar has a seating cap, get the key lime pie, ambiance is romantic. Went to City Post to celebrate my significant other's birthday recently. We arrived early for our reservation, hoping to enjoy some pre-dinner drinks at the bar. Unfortunately, it was full, and the staff suggested waiting in the seating area near the door (it was too cold for a stroll around the square). On the bright side, our table was ready shortly after we arrived, and they were kind enough to seat us even though our entire party hadn't arrived. Food - The star of the night was the scallop appetizer, which I had as my main course; the orange sauce was next level! Another standout was the pepper steak; I preferred it to the ribeye which had a bit too much char for me. For sides we had: mushrooms, asparagus, a City Post salad (small), and a loaded baked potato. The sides were tasty, and there was more than enough for the three of us. The loaded twice-baked potato was a bit tricky to share though. Maybe putting it in a dish could make it easier to divvy up. Drinks - We had a couple of old fashioneds (4/5), the Founders Club (3.5/5), and a non-alcoholic Ginger Spice (5/5). Service and Dessert - The service throughout the evening was attentive, informative, and polite. There were thoughtful touches throughout the evening, like a birthday card at the table signed by the staff, and a slice of key lime pie to cap off the celebration! read more

Food was incredible service was outstanding the perfect balance of attentiveness but not overwhelming

We came here for dinner with another couple that made reservations and I will say it's pretty cool the restaurant is an old historic Post Office that now has turned into a restaurant. The restaurant is decent size. We were placed towards the back corner in a booth and I will say it was super hot. No air at all so very uncomfortable to enjoy dinner and drinks. We ordered Woodford on the rocks, the Farewell which was decent and the Post Poppy which was a very delicious cocktail. We all ordered Wedge salads and had those spilt. It wasn't bad at all, my favorite was the bacon bits! I ordered the chimichurri steak and it came out medium as asked but I was not a fan of their chimichurri. It was sour and you would get the green pieces , I thought it should have been blended so you don't taste the grainy greens. My husband ordered the porkchop and he said it wasn't anything special. He mentioned it should have came out with the char mark like our steaks but looked as it was just popped in the oven. We ordered 3 sides which is family style you can share. The mashed potatoes was just eh, the Brussels sprouts was okay too. And the Lobster Max & Cheese was just okay . Nothing special on the sides. We also ordered a warm apple pie over vanilla ice cream to share which was delicious! I would say the food, drinks, salads was super over priced for the quality and presentation. I think you're just paying to be in a historic building. The place wasn't bad just way over priced and trying to be a hoity toity read more

See all

One of our favorites in GTown. The chef is the best and so friendly too. Always remembers us when we come in and the food is out of this world. Clean, fun and delish read more

I had high expectations. The service was exceptional. Exactly what you would expect from a chophouse. The ambiance was perfect for a date night. Not too loud but loud enough to have a private conversation. Great seating layout and staff. Where it falls down is the food. When spending $290 for two with juts two glasses of wine and two cocktails two 8 Oz filets and two sides plus a shared salad I will expect a food experience. While the steaks were cooked right and tender I can do that or I can get a similar steak at Saltgrass for a lot less and that is not saying much. The wedge salad was tasty Witt the bits of ham in it. The sides were nothing special. I want a memorable experience and food wise it did not happen. I will give it another try but at this time I can't recommend it for food but I can for service and ambiance. read more

When I say outstanding all around!!!! I'm not exaggerating! But..... let's get one thing clear up front... make sure you have your coins ready... eating good cost! lol! So, my husband and I dined here for lunch and I think we seriously tried to sample everything on the menu. But we are foodies! So it's the norm for us! Julia was our server and she's a charm! It was day two for her, but honestly you couldn't tell. She was on point. We made several orders, asked a lot of questions and she was on it! Didn't miss a beat. The overall ambience was historic, but yet modern. Noise level was pretty quiet for a mid day lunch. I like that you can see the kitchen, which makes it personable to a degree. We had the opportunity to meet Chef Adrian, which was pretty cool and talk to a few other staff there. The future for this place... OMG, I can't wait!!! Now to the good stuff, the food!!! So as I keep reminding everyone, I'm pescatarian, so you know I'm going in on everything Seafood. We started out with the clam chowder (contains smoked pork fat), oysters, tuna poke and shrimp cocktail. When I say it was all delicious.... Yo, it was DELICIOUS!!! Those shrimps was on steroid!!! Very large! Loved it. The tuna poke had a nice hint of spice to it. The oysters was very fresh. And the clam chowder, I cleaned the cup!!! Literally! ****My only complaint is to inform folks the clam chowder has pork. I had no idea. It's been 19 years since I had pork *** You would think after all that we were done. lol! Not us! We then ordered the CP Wagyu Burger and Chilean Sea Bass. My husband said the bacon on the burger tasted like they had the pig out back. He said it was the best piece of bacon (and freshest) he EVER had. My husband also never takes anything home from a restaurant, he not only took a 1/4 of the Burger he didn't finish, he also ordered the Wagyu Sausage Roll. lol! For the Chilean Sea Bass. Well it's a lot you can do to mess it up, but Chef Adrian understood the assignment. It was nice and flaky with a hint of lemon. I killed it. Well as far as recommendations goes!!! I definitely recommend this place. In fact, I'm locking in our next date here following this post. We will return for a surprise birthday dinner. My son coming home from the Army next month. Yay! read more

See all

We recently went to celebrate a birthday and it was our first time there. Great food, service and environment. We will definitely be back. read more

City Post Chophouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Georgetown, Texas

We thoroughly enjoyed our time here. We finally got a chance to try this place. It is small and only open on weekends for now. The building is a historic part of Georgetown. This is not a cheap place but the service and the food are worth it. I enjoyed the wines and my wife loved her cocktail. The service here is the star. From the time time you walk in to the time to you walk out the staff is attentive and professional. While not what you might lean toward at a steakhouse, the half hen was awesome. I had the NY strip. It was more on the rare side of the medium I ordered but still delicious. We are looking forward to our next visit. read more

City Post Chophouse - Crème violet - Steakhouses Near Me - Georgetown, Texas

See all

Horrible restaurant! The chef is a POS, in my opinion. I spent $300 just for myself where the steak, filet, was tough and the lobster was rubbery. This place is one of the worst I have even eaten at. So many places around with better atmosphere, better service and way better food. Over erpriced and underwhelming. Skip this placed and you will be better off. read more

Food and service exceeded our expectations. Entire staff work together to get food to the table in a timely manner. We will return.

Amazing! The staff was knowledgeable about gluten allergies! The food was amazing. We had oysters, clam chowder, French onion soup(gluten free modified) all were delicious. You can go downstairs to the speak easy after dinner which is an awesome vibe. read more

Our favorite steak house in Georgetown. The drinks are fantastic. We love the oyster selections and always get the steak tartare. Our go to is the pork chop, but we've tried almost everything on the menu and never had a bad meal. It's hard to get into, but definitely worth the wait! read more

City Post Chophouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Georgetown, Texas

See all

Food... excellent. Service... exceptional. Loved the atmosphere of the old post office. Speakeasy after dinner was a nice surprise the waiter offered. Very nice touch. read more

I have heard wonderful things about this place and it did not disappoint! We went with another couple and we shared the beef tartare, which was exceptional. My husband and I split the French onion soup, which was very good. We did send it back at first because we wanted more brown on the cheese and they happily did so for us. My husband had the Coulotte & Chimichurri and I had the Angus Filet Mignon. Both we're cooked perfectly and had amazing flavors. The chimichurri was so dang good! We all split the portabella mushrooms (they were YUM, will definitely get again!) and the Brussels sprouts, which I'll pass on next time. They were okay, but not as good as some I've had other places. My husband and I also ordered the butter poached lobster to eat with our steak, and that will be something we'll get each time! It was heavenly! I'm a mezcal lover, so the Post Script was right up my alley. Heidi was our server and she was exceptional! Finally, I absolutely LOVED the way they built out the restaurant. It was so well done and the vibe was super elegant, while capturing and keeping the old school feel of the original post office. It truly is a special spot! read more

Was able to nab a reso for dinner last night, table for 6 please... We had a great table in the middle of the dining room, love the open kitchen with blazing fires in full view. We had oysters, tuna poke, city post salad, filet mignons, salmon, mashed potatoes, asparagus and chefs veg, paired nicely with bubbles and red wine.. Finished off with coffee, key lime pie and apple pie. Everything was excellent. Exceptional service was provided by JP aka JD, ask Chef Adrian about this ;D Also a shoutout to Tim who welcomed us back when we 1st arrived. Look forward to returning. read more

See all

Food was delicious! Got the filet, ribeye, Mac, mashed potatoes, and a charcuterie board plus drinks and enjoyed all of it! Service was great. You can't beat the atmosphere with the restored post office. read more

City Post Chophouse - Lobby - Steakhouses Near Me - Georgetown, Texas

Trinity our server was great. We sat in the main dining area. It was very loud and piano player added to noise level. Also the room was warm. Even Trinity, our waitress mentioned how warm it was. My friend ordered a steak. It was very grizzly. He couldn't eat it and didn't even want to take it home. My lobster roll was delicious - Connecticut style. I also ordered shrimp cocktail was great. The wine could've been chilled more. One to five it's a 2 1/2. read more

Our dining experience was excellent. We were looking for an upscale experience to celebrate a milestone. The City Post delivered on ambiance. The food was excellent. ( ribeye, chop and hen). I'd say the cocktails and desserts get the top marks, so don't skip them. The service was excellent (server JP) and we appreciated the execution of our meal service. Timing and attention were perfect. Beware: Most times you will need a reservation, they do have a dress code, and the main dining area is a bit loud. Lastly, yes, it's expensive. For Georgetown, it's the most "upscale" restaurant you'll find. I recommend it for any special occasion. read more

City Post definitely raises the bar for restaurants in Georgetown. Located in an old post office building just off the Georgetown square, this building has been smartly renovated in to a refined and inviting restaurant. The front of the building is currently the only part open with a limited menu of appetizer-type offerings and drinks. However, the full restaurant is set to open soon and I can't wait to come back. Try the Post Poppy- it's refreshingly delicious and appetizing. We also tried the charcuterie board which was tastefully curated and arranged. A welcome addition to the Square. read more

See all

I love this place for special occasions and date night. The food is excellent but pricy. The service is 5 stars and the restaurant is a repurposed post office with an upscale vintage feel. I definitely recommend giving it a try. read more

Great cocktails, excellent service, and amazing food! We were able to get a spot at the oyster bar as we j just flew in that same day, it was an awesome experience! Highly recommended read more

I had such high hopes of this being a great foodie restaurant here in Georgetown, since there are no really good chef places here. We just moved here from Atlanta so we know what good restaurants really should be. I will say the staff was incredible, friendly and attentive. I think our biggest mistake was going on a Sunday where the menu is only brunch which I didn't know until we arrived at 3pm expecting something other than breakfast/lunch. We did get a confirmation call and they did tell me that there is a dress code (Texas casual), new for me however we were like okay no problem. However the hostess had on doc martens and a mini dress sweatshirt so the dress code is pretty lax I would say. I am a cook, albeit a home cook but I cook a lot, if I am going to go out I expect food better than I can cook myself and I did not get this here AT ALL. Anyway forward .... My drink was awesome it was a mimosa, but my husband ordered the bloodymary and it was basically Clamato and cocktail sauce, a couple sips in and it was not so great, it had some good additives he could eat but the drink was a no go. I ordered the shrimp and polenta, it was not good the polenta was so dry it was a brick, the shrimp was over cooked and the sausage was so hard it was basically jerky. The sauce was heavy and over cooked like it had been cooking all day maybe Not sure how else to describe it. My husband ordered the eggs Benedict it was just okay he didn't like it something was just off in it. My mother in law and daughter ordered the kids menu burger and fries which was great ( if a chef messed this up I would really be shocked ) I did not take pictures I wish I would have but our 1 yr old was not allowing me to do much :) Our experience as far as ambience was great the building is awesome and the place was very clean and tidy. And Again the staff we encountered were all welcoming and very sweet. I would like to go back and try the weekday menu but going on a Sunday was a mistake. Some of the workers were packing up to leave while we were there (putting on their coats and looking like they were ready to leave ) so it seemed we were maybe the last ones before closing. read more

My other half and I just experienced a fantastic dinner I had the Sea Bass and he had the Ken Absolutely Delicious First time for dinner and we will definitely be back read more

We had a dual birthday party for about 50 people upstairs. Everything was exceptional from the planning stages until the end of the evening. Raleigh worked with us. We met several times. She was always prompt, knowledgeable, helpful in every way! The Food was amazing. I didn't have to think about anything! It was outstanding and refreshed without me thinking about it. The bartenders were also top notch! The drinks were perfect. They even altered one of their cocktail recipes to suit my taste.(Way to go Gabby!) I have done several large scale parties over the years. This was by far the most "hands off" party that I have ever hosted. I loved to be able to come and watch my friends enjoy themselves. It was the perfect event! It has now been almost a month since we had the event, and we are still getting compliments. YES, consider City Post for your next gathering. Nothing but class! read more

I can't imagine a restaurant can have EVERYTHING on the menu that taste great right I enjoyed the service. Enjoyed some dishes. I'd try them again. No sweet wine either. read more

City Post Chophouse - Salad with sliced pears, craisins, feta. A bit tart for my taste buds - Steakhouses Near Me - Georgetown, Texas

Came here for the wife's birthday dinner. 5/5 appetizer (seared scallops) 5/5 entree (lobster roll & filet mignon) 5/5 sides (lobster mac & asparagus) 5/5 drinks 5/5 dessert 6/5 service (forgot my servers name but the service was exceptional) We will be back 100%. read more

We've eaten here for both dinner and brunch, the food is mediocre at best and the service is spotty. We do, however, come here occasionally for a cocktail in the late afternoon. We *always* call in advance. The last two visits, despite calling about seats for the bar and being told 'no problem, we'll see you soon', we arrived and were told by the hostess that they couldn't accommodate. We literally live down the street, and arrived within minutes. Last time we agreed to sit at 'the oyster bar', even though the actual bar had available seats, and that was a mistake. Terrible ambiance, as you're essentially sitting in the servers station, watching people do side work. Also our server spilled half of our drinks on the tray and didn't bother to offer new cocktails, or even clean the mess. Today we called in advance and arrived in less than five minutes, because we were told they had seats at the bar. When we showed at 4:30, it was completely dead, yet the hostess told us she couldn't seat us at the bar. There were two other employees with her, not sure if either was a manager. Whatever the case, considering the food is just so-so and they aren't organized enough to communicate with the hosts about seating, we won't come back. read more

I went here for Valentine's Day and was surprised there was a steakhouse in Georgetown that was this amazing. When you sit down, you first notice the old post office boxes on the walls which is really neat since it's the old Georgetown Post Office and they left the nicest features. Next you notice the modern take on an old style South American Parrilla which is nice as you can watch them cook the food using real wood and fire. I had Filet Mignon, lobster, and tartar which were all excellent. There was a back room that opened up at one point and we saw some Texas Senators back there having dinner. Service was quick and efficient. I've gone back again. read more

Great date night spot. Everything we ordered was amazing! We can't wait to go back and we will definitely order the scallop appetizer again. Service was great. Our server was friendly. We will be back. read more

City Post Chophouse - Scallops - incredible, must order! - Steakhouses Near Me - Georgetown, Texas

See all

Absolutely LOVED our dinner. I got the filet and my husband got the bone in ribeye. Our waiter, Tim, provided excellent service and definitely made our first time enjoyable. Can't wait to see how they grow! We will be back soon! read more

City Post Chophouse - Raspberry Reserved Mocktail - Steakhouses Near Me - Georgetown, Texas

Everything is exceptional. From the minute you arrive you know you are in for a high-quality experience. Attention to detail is evident. The offerings are expertly prepared. The chef, and all the staff make sure you receive top notch service. It is obvious they work as a team to provide an experience that will exceed your expectations. read more

Really tasty steaks and incredible MUSHROOMS! Seriously, get the mushrooms. Nice ambiance too.

We went for lunch today. The food was amazing as always- I had the four cheese soup and lobster roll. Our server, Mary, was wonderful, even though there were several hurdles for her to overcome. She handled herself professionally and I was impressed. read more

The food and drinks are great. Steak tartare is a must try. The staff is always great. read more

City Post Chophouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Georgetown, Texas

Food was absolutely amazing! We sat at the bar since it was a busy Saturday night but our bartender/waiter was great. Worth the price for sure! We both had steaks and shared two sides along with cheesecake for dessert! Highly recommend! read more

This is a lovely restaurant and a nice change of pace. The beautiful old building adds to the ambiance. The menu is interesting and the two times I've been there, the food was excellent. It is definitely an excellent place for dining in Georgetown. read more

High end dining experience. They have everything you'd expect from the stake house. And they run special events. Holiday parties there are fun! read more

Didn't live up to the hype, or price tag for me. Atmosphere was excellent but in my humble opinion the food was not up to the standards you'd expect for a fine chop house like Eddy v's... Specifically, lobster Mac was runny, oysters were gulf oysters which I don't expect to pay 36$ a dozen for, bread was awesome, old fashion was bland and I didn't like the prune juice in it, steak was good but again not the same quality of an Eddy V or Bob's and the price tag was very high. May be back to try a non steak item, may not. read more

Typically Valentines is a terrible day to try a new place. The last several years we've had bad experiences. City Post did well! The atmosphere is perfect. They've done an amazing job restoring this beautiful building and making it special. The service was impeccable. The staff all worked well together and the dining room was handled efficiently. The food was good with the exception of dessert. The oyster appetizer was heavenly. My steak (ribeye) was a bit thinner than I like but cooked and seasoned perfectly. My wife had the filet and reported is was good. The desserts were the only failure. They were specials for Valentine so we expected better. My wife's chocolate cake was inedibly dry with a raspberry filling that was more seeds than fruit. I had the Dutch babies that were rubbery and tasteless. We left both behind. We do plan to return soon. read more