WINGS. GET THEM. Pizza was tastey, and deliver was awesome! Back in Virginia it would take about an hour, Don's only took just over half an hour. Be sure to check out their daily specials. read more

I really wanted to like Don's however it was disappointing. The pizza and wings both lacked flavor. Delivery was quick tho.

The chicken bacon ranch pizza is OP! Also the wings are great too. Delivery is pretty fast locally.

Really good pizza. We have tried the Margarita pizza. Suuuuper fresh and delicious. Sometimes they are a bit busy, but definitely worth the wait. read more

Delicious pizza and wings. They were pretty fast in making my 3 pie order and 44 wings. My family really enjoyed the crispy crust and amazing flavors. I enjoyed the team behind the counter and look forward to enjoying more pizza from this restaurant in the future. I recommend these folks to anyone looking for a tasty slice of pizza. read more

Lasagna there is amazing, service is super fast and the food is affordable!!! The customer service is always great

Subpar pizza. Barely ate one piece. Wasted $22! Employees were kind, just not my kind of pizza.

Hands down the best pizza place in all of phoenix. I would definitely recommend getting the "pizza roll" it's similar to a calzone, it comes out beautifully every time! read more

Love this place the chicken Caesar salad is my all time favorite!! However they marinade the chicken really sets the salad off! Always quick friendly service have been this salad weekly since I discovered it. This place does not disappoint they have delicious baked ziti also read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Medium Chicken Caesar salad!! - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

This was our first visit. The hubs had a taste for lasagna and Yelper's voted this as #1. They were not wrong. The lasagna comes with salad and garlic knots. The flavors were amazing and the portions are more than generous. A single serving could easily be shared between 2 adults or 4-6 children. (Depending on ages and appetites) The salad boasts lettuce, red onions, black olives, tomatoes, cucumber, and a banana pepper. The informal atmosphere makes it an ideal family night out. Not in the mood for lasagna? The couple sitting next to us gave the pizza two thumbs up. And everyone went home with leftovers. read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

I'm finally writing this review after years of eating here and I have yet to had a bad experience. All of the food is cooked perfectly and the staff is excellent about overcoming difficult time crunches. The simple pepperoni pizza tastes better than any other pizza that I've had in Phoenix yet. The buffalo wings, cheese logs, and cannoli are all excellent sides and they have enough menu offerings to satisfy any craving that you have. read more

My boyfriend and I have ordered from here quite a few times. Yes the pizza is good, but there is also a lot of places that taste exactly the same. The main reason we would order from here is because Brothers doesn't deliver. When we ordered I was told it would take "55-60 minutes". That was fine because we understand that it is a Friday night and they are busy. After waiting for and hour and a half, I called. Because I have the right to know and make sure that my order went through and something didn't go wrong. The man on the phone seemed VERY annoyed that I would even have the audacity to call and ask about my food. He said it was just about done and we be leaving right after we got off the phone. Again, he was very annoyed. He said "I mean thats just how it is, we're busy!" If he was apologetic about it, I feel like things would have been different. After waiting another 30 minutes I called and cancelled. There were again, no apologies, just an "it's cancelled" and we hung up. We then ordered from somewhere else. While waiting and over 2 hours after we ordered, the delivery man showed up...meaning they couldn't even let him know that we cancelled. THIS guy was very nice and apologetic. I feel like if the customer service was better, if they were more apologetic to their customers instead of being annoyed, I would have been okay with it taking longer. I hope they read this review and just maybe do some training on how to treat customers. You can be busy and have bad nights or drop the ball. Most people will understand and work with you if you treat them well. I never ever leave reviews.. ever. I am so annoyed with the customer service I got tonight that here I am, writing a review. read more

I'm a native NY'ker and a pizza snob. The biggest compliment I can give Don's is - I drive about 30 minutes one way to pick up their pizza, along the way I probably pass 15 other pizza places. They nail that close to home flavor I love. Good job guys! read more

The pizza was absolutely delicious! I was a little anxious seeing only 1 employee out of the 6 working that was properly wearing a mask. Also, there were no gloves being used when making the pizzas. I will not be returning again until proper health safety precautions are taken by every employee. read more

When you walk into Dons you walk into a place where the people care. A friendly staff that never fails to make me feel like part of the family. With a versatile menu i never get bored or struggle to find something to eat. Pizzas and pasta that you can taste and tell are fresh. Truly a pizza place second to none Don's has won over a customer for life. read more

Everyone needs to take these place us. favorite place to bring the family and enjoy the Buffalo Chicken PizzaBuffalo WingsFettuccine Alfredo read more

I love your pizza it's amazing but it was ruined Thursday october 6th. My husband bought pizza around 9pm when I was at work. I came home and opened the pizza ready to eat and noticed that maybe your driver or maker was in a hurry. Half of the pizza toppings were stuck to the top of the box and the side of it were smooshed by the edges of the box. I will continue ordering from here cause I love this place but please take care of the pizza its love and when love is ruined its no good. read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

I love Don's! Their calzones are amazing, my family enjoys their wings and pizza, and we fight over the garlic knots. Incredible customer service, staff is always super friendly and delivery is quite speedy. read more

I was having high hopes for this pizza joint since it is conveniently located near my home but based on taste I would only give it half a star. So I ordered the NY supreme I think that was the name. Cheese was waxy, not sure if it was real mozzarella or the cheap imitation cheese. Bell pepper was soggy and tasted like canned, although I've never even seen canned just didn't taste fresh. No wow factor to the pizza, I should have just stuck to Papa John's or Domino's. Pizza was expensive so yes of course I was expecting good pizza at least decent pizza. So why 2 stars you ask? Well based on customer service they actually deserve 5 stars, everyone was so friendly and welcoming but lets be honest I just wanted some good pizza, won't be ordering from them any time soon. read more

Pizza is greasy, ordered a small caesars salid for $3.50 and got 4 bites of romaine lettuce and 5 croutons. read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - This burger box of cesars cost $3.50 - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

Found Don's a little while ago. It's great to have an Italian place that does more than just pizza. I have tried several things, Don's special, lasagna.. havent had anything bad yet. Quickly becoming our go to. read more

Our family eat here last night and everything was amazing. The people were so friendly and I hooked. Differently coming back . We got xl pepperoni pizza chicken Alfredo salad fried zucchini. Family of five and still had left over. Great food and prices. read more

My fiancée and I were passing through doing some shopping and we were looking for a good spot for some pizza. Being from New York the two of us can get pretty picky when it comes to getting some pizza. We were very happy after that first bite of our slices!The staff here were fantastic and very friendly. They also make a homemade ranch dressing that goes really well when paired with your pizza. It felt like I was back in one of my hometown pizzerias in NY. We will definitely be returning once we are in the area again! read more

Thank you Don's I always get the extra large chicken mozzarella and spinach. Never been disappointed the pizza is excellent.

This place is awesome. We found it after a baseball game as we were rushing to the airport. It's a family owned Restaurant, where you feel like you're part of the family. Everything that we ordered was awesome. Pizza, wings, salad's, pasta... Everything was great. I would highly recommend stopping at Dunns Pizza on Peoria. It's amazing and I will be back every time I come to Arizona Just came back a week later and it was perfect again!! This place is awesome!!!! read more

Best PIZZA by far. Had pizza from NYC. Brooklyn, say no more great place plus Friendly. Very glad found place. Thanks for doing what you do. Don's NEW YORK. read more

Whenever I find myself on the west side, I stop in to Dons. The pizza is very good but what really sold me was the spicy Alfredo. It is delicious! It also is a huge size so there is plenty for leftovers or to share. Great pie, food and service! read more

Friendly on the phone. Arrived quickly. Looked and tasted great. Things they could work on... teach the crew to cut through the crust, and cut in 6-8 slices, not 12. Feels wrong not being able to fold a slice from an 18" ny pizza. Other than that, was awesome! read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - 18". Half pepperoni, half mushroom. Great tasting pizza, thanks! - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Pizza is excellent every time. The wings are always cooked perfectly. I love this place

If you're in the area and hungry for a slice of pizza, wings, an AMZAZING Salad, sandwich, pasta, or desserts such as phenomenal cannoli's, or tiramisu, then you NEED to stop by Don's!!!!! This restaurant exceeds in SO MANY areas... super clean, nice atmosphere, and MOST importantly the owners Joe and Laura are the most compassionate and customer service oriented people you will ever meet.. their entire crew is!!!! I work and live in the City Of Peoria and this is my restaurant of choice every chance I get!!!! Keep up the OUTSTANDING work guys!!!! -Zach L. read more

This is the best NY style pizza I've ever had in Arizona. It reminds me of the pizza from back home. Delicious! I will definitely be bringing my friends and family here. Also, reasonable prices and very clean! You won't be disappointed. read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Plain Cheese. When it's this good you don't need additional toppings - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

I've tried several items over the past weeks, and WOW! I recommend the Pizza Rolls or the cheese steaks read more

Went into Don's this past weekend, called in our order in advance. The young woman at the counter was NOT wearing a mask. The folks preparing food were wearing the 1/2 mask, not covering the nose. One other customer waiting for pick up was also not wearing a mask. I took my order home, enjoyed Don's for the last time! read more

Lived in this house ten years and never knew this was down the street. Awesome food. Pizza is cheesy, wings were piping hot, and the chicken on that ceasar salad was seasoned well. Family of 4, we had the 18" pizza special that came with 24 wings and soda. I had 2 wings. Hub had 4. The kids ate the rest. They like wings, but not usually that much. Hub and i shared the large chkn ceasar. Not much in the way of leftovers. Everything was gobbled up. Delivery guy was on time and polite. Will definitely be reordering! read more

Great pizza, fried zucchini and very good ranch to dip it all in! I called in to order and it was right on time, they even called me to let me know it was ready! I ordered a 2-liter Pepsi which was forgotten about, but that was my fault too. Didn't even realize until I got home, no biggie though. The food was great and that's what matters! read more

I just had the lasagna it comes with 4 garlic knots and a salad, it was really really good. Once again I have not been disappointed, the staff is really nice and considerate. More and more people are coming in. read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Inside looking at where they prepared the pies - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

So affordable, awesome food & ingredients, awesome staff, awesome atmosphere. A+ !! I love this place. The pizza is my favorite.

Hands down the best classic pizza and wings! We ordered the xl pepperoni, wings, and fried zucchini. The pizza was the size of a tire! The crust won us over because it wasn't a loaf of bread but wasn't so thin it was a cracker. It was crisp and soft all at once. You literally watch them toss it and make it as you're waiting. That takes confidence in your product to be willing to show exactly how it's done! We've had over done wings that let you sad and depressed. These wings were moist and juicy. We drove quite a ways for this place and it is now our #1 and we will def be back to try other items from their extensive menu. read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Sooooo good!! Definitely NY pizza! Family friendly and great staff lots of options they even brought my kids a dessert for free!! Looking forward to coming back. read more

Best pizza I have had here. And I am from New England and my family is Italian great job guys!