They have a menu with a wide variety of food, so everyone in our group gets something they like - fish fry, burgers, quesadillas, wraps, etc. I especially like the chicken quesadilla with jalapenos. Portions are huge, so plan on taking some home. You probably don't need to get the optional soup and salad bar unless you've got a big appetite. Business is good on the weekend but not overly crowded. Staff is friendly. read more

Great food with HUGE portions at great prices! Decent selections on tap. Definitely worth stopping in. The Cuban sandwich was great! read more

Elma Towne Grille - The Bar - American Near Me - Elma, New York

I give their fish frys' 5 stars! My husband and I both ordered the half fish fry and it was plenty big! My husband is no small eater either, but with the macaroni salad, Cole slaw, French fries and rye bread, it was a large meal. Also, it came out in record time, I don't think we had to wait 10 minutes! The fish was fresh and super hot and crisp. We will be regulars for sure! read more

Elma Town Grille has been my favorite Sunday afternoon dinner location at least once a month. I love fresh cut fries and my two favorite entrees are carved hot turkey $10.99 and the breaded pork chops $11.99. They also have early bird menu of the same that is just slightly smaller in portions during the week. The regular size portions I always can not finish there so I have a 2nd meal at home. I do miss the Birch Beer. I many not be a connoisseur of food but I like a hearty meal for a good value. read more

I have eaten here many times & never had a bad experience. Food was great "home cooked", generous portions, lots of choices, reasonable prices & friendly staff. The building was the Jerge family farmhouse with lots of Elma history. read more

I happened to be on line to get the Elma Towne Grille's banquet menu for my daughter's upcoming baby shower when I happened across a review that I just couldn't believe!! I know that everybody has different opinions, so I wanted to share my opinion of the Elma Towne Grille. My family and I have been enjoying the Elma Towne Grille since it opened a little over 2 years ago. We dine there on a regular basis, I have used their drop off catering service at work and, as I mentioned, I am planning to have my daughter's baby shower there. I honestly can't say enough good things about it, but I'm going to try!! I have never had anything bad at the Elma Towne Grille, but I will tell you some of my favorites: Quesadillas (chicken preferably unless crab cakes are on the specials!), Pulled Pork, Roast Beef and Chicken Bruschetta and the salad bar. Their fresh cut french fries are wonderful too (these are new) I also love that they have a full service bar with a good selection of beers and wines (by the glass or bottle) In addition to to the regular menu, they also have daily lunch and dinner specials (prime rib on weekends) and a great fish fry! The service is always terrific! I like that I see servers that have been there since we started going there. The atmosphere in the dining room is casual and relaxed. They also offer dining in the tavern area which offers the same menu items as in the dining room in addition to a special pub menu available only in the bar. Big screen TV's for sports events and specials during Sabres games! I really could go on, but I will simply recommend to anyone that they go and try it out. They won't be disappointed! read more

Not as good as they think they are. Very pricey and they advertise the best buffalo chicken wing soup umm that's a negative , would say it's actually the opposite of the best ! read more

A great place for good food, a lot of it, at a reasonable price. We will be back to sample as much of the menu as we can over the next year. I had 10oz hand made burger with a sizable amount of homemade skin on fries. $9.99 . Have enough left over for midnight snack ! read more

We recently did a re-visit to this star of Elma and we weren't disappointed! My GRAND daughter's BLT was made to order with crispy bacon and fresh lettuce & tomatoes. The fresh cut fries are served with most meals and are reminiscent of those served at the Erie County Fair. The soups are always delicious and the service....what can I say! Leah aka "T Swizzle" did another outstanding job attending to our every need! Don't miss this gem! read more

We've been a fan from when these guys took over! Owners friendly and want you to enjoy your meal. I've had a variety of items from their menus - one of my favorites is their Pittsburgh Salad with steak - the Riviera Dressing is warm and oh so good! Fish fries are generous and german potato salad wonderful. They have a great soup & Salad bar too. Have used their catering services for various occasions as well. Desserts are home made & very tasty. They are accommodating and generous - Home town family feeling! read more

Me and my husband eat here at least 4xs a year and it's always great. The staff are all friendly and eager to please

After reading some very negative reviews we were hesitant to go the Elma Grill for dinner. Happy we didn't let the reviews dissuade us. All our meals were delicious. Pork Roast and breaded Pork chops were perfectly done. Portions were large. We started with the soup and salad bar. Vegetables were fresh and ample as were the toppings and dressings. Three choices of soup were fresh and hot. Our server, Robin was very attentive. On seeing that we could not finish our meals she brought and filled the take home boxes. Will definitely go back read more

don't even bother. the food is bad enough (undercooked) but if you complain then it is even worse. "you made the waitress uncomfortable" (when we complained)...."try us again" if you can't get it right why would i want to try again!!?? read more

Although the portions are quite generous, the french fries are in need of drastic improvement. They are soggy, dark brown and taste as though they were fried in old oil. Cute place with good service. read more

After a long Sunday of yardwork, the wife and I were in no mood to cook. We decided to head over to the Elma Towne Grill for a quick dinner around 6:00. The place wasn't busy, maybe 3 other tables. The waitress came to seat us, and right away I could tell she wasn't exactly the most personable (no eye contact, curtish...my wife picked up on it too.), but whatever, we weren't there for conversation. After tossing our menus on the table (we hadn't even sat down yet), she told us she would be back to get our drink order. She came back a few minutes later, I ordered a draft beer. My wife asked if they had one of those hard cider drinks, and was met with ".....nope." Now, seeing as this place is also a bar, my wife thought that was kind of odd but didn't question it, she just ordered something else. So after a few minutes she returns with our drinks, and we were still deciding what we wanted. I took one look at my draft beer and could see something was a little off. No head on it, not real cold, and flat. After that we decided it probably wasn't a good sign to eat there. When the waitress returned, I told her about the beer and that we were leaving. Her response was a little underwhelming. We have eaten there before and have even had a banquet in their place, the food is good. Btw, we ended up at another place where the waitress was cordial and nice, they had 'Strongbow' cider and my draft beer was not flat. read more

Literally the best food I have ever had in my entire life. HIGHLY recommend. HUGE portion size and amazing staff!

Had good food but terrible service. Waitress angrily complained about splitting checks and then never came back to pick up checks. So disappointed with the service here. read more

I live about 1 mile from this place, so I go here often. I've never been disappointed (except by the alfredo sauce--too bland) The pittsburgh steak salad is my all time favorite, as are the mini sandiwiches in the beef on weck. I'm suprised anyone would give this a bad review. If you are looking for quiet, sit at the restaurant, if you want a more upbeat atmosphere, go to the bar side. The drinks are great. read more

Put cheddar cheese on souvlaki. Didn't put toilet paper in the rest room when asked. Won't be back.

We ordered take out once and dined in once.The service was terrible when we dined in and the floor looked dirty and greasy. The chicken breast sandwich and fries were really good, but everything else was mediocre. The pretzel sticks we had for an appetizer were almost burnt. We won't be going back. read more

if you want"good barbecue ribs" as only jay wolf can cook them try elma town grill--melts in your mouth good.also he caters out a superb party meal--chicken--5 star ribs 5 star you won't be sorry,we weren't!! read more

very good food. good salad with the salad bar and the chicken fingers were very good. great service too food came right out and the waitresses and waiters were very nice read more

Horrible servers and customer service. I am a server myself and I would never treat customers the way we were treated. Very rude and snippy. Also. My food was brought out cold and my parents steaks were horrible!!! Please don't go here!!! read more

Good food plenty of substance great price for what you get in return. Economical for groups sized gatherings. Go a couple times a year.

A true american restaurant to take your family to. The meal size are big and kids eat free on Tuesday. The menu has something to satisfy the whole family. read more

Stopped for a quick lunch and were pleasantly surprised by the high quality of the food. Fresh cut French fries, gourmet grilled cheese and the most tasty Cuban sandwich I think I have ever had. Decor was nice too. Quantity was quite large - took half of the Cuban and fries home, and still great as leftovers! Prices are reasonable and service was friendly and attentive. I reserve 5 stars for places where we've sampled more of the menu- but we'll be back to give other items a try and if everything is as tasty as this, I'll revise! read more

Quire simply put, they miss the mark on a lot of things. Service, atmosphere, food. I've eaten at ETG several times. Its been OK each time. Last chance was on 04/02/2016. Here's my main gripe. As a born and raised on chicken wings Buffalonian, I know what I like in a good chicken wing, and how simple it is to achieve. Listen to your customer when they place the order. If I ask for extra crispy, well then, I want them crispy. When I ask for extra, extra, extra crispy, they better crunch when i bite into them. That's how I order my wings everywhere. Most places get it and do it. Some even cook the wings an extra 2 minutes for every extra you say. ETG chose to ignore all of my "extras" in my order on 4/2/16. These wings arrived at the table very quickly, and didn't even make to the class of crispy. They were chewy, fatty, and limp. Barely even making it to the level of cooked. Now how do we get to this point when the discussion with the server was emphasized by two people at the table? Blame the kitchen staff? Well, if they didn't get the message then blame the server, or both. Bottom line, if you want to be a place with good food, you must be consistent. If you want people to keep coming back for socialization (beers and wings) do what the customer asks. read more

If i could give this a less than 1 star I would. I live in the Lancaster area and always drive by wanting to try and stop in. Tonight my family and I had dinner and it was less than enjoyable to say the least. We sat at hostess station for 10 mins before a server came over and told us to "take a seat, it's going to be a few before we would get sat". The restaurant was not full by any means. There were some tables However it was 5pm on a Saturday. Once we sat, the server came over acting flustered,after about 5 mins of waiting. She asked for our drink order, i asked if we could order everything at once bc i had a 19 month old and 6 month old child with us....she told me no we could not bc the kitchen was behind???...,ok....5 more mins she took our order...we waited over 45 mins for our food which consisted of chicken wings a soup salad bar a Caesar salad and a kids cheeseburger. All in the while people who came well after us were served their food and packing to go. My husbands wings came out not as ordered but we didn't have the time to send them back. I had to flag her down for a to go box and the check, horrible experience...will not be back. read more

love the food, have never been disappointed,have gone back many times. the soup and salad bar is good, the ribs are great. the portions are huge. the taco salad is big enough for three people. fish fry is also a winner.the waitresses are very friendly and the service is fast. read more

I've been going here for a little over two years now for take-out. Every time they manage to make it a disappointing experience for me and foolishly, I keep giving them another chance. They've sent me on a wild goose chase as to where to pick up my food. On busier days they rush in order to make the food it seems no matter what I get (usually a roast beef sandwich or pulled pork) the meat is tough and unappealing. The fries have been cold and chewy. Most recently when they screwed up my order, instead of apologizing or giving me some of money back or anything that showed there remorse they had me hold half my order while I waited for the missing half. By the time I was able to eat it the first half was cold and the second half was also not terribly warm despite them just making it, on top of that I almost choked on a toothpick that is usually through the whole sandwich and not laying in the middle as this one was. The customer service has gone very down hill and due to the lack of quality in the food and the continuously sloping customer service I personally would NOT recommend this restaurant to anyone. read more

Went here last night. Will NEVER EVER eat there again. Ordered the shrimp pasta which was advertised as a NEW item. It was shrimp over spaghetti pasta with broccoli and tomatoes in a butter garlic sauce for $13.99. Sounds good right? I thought so. Well I can get over a lot of things like no tomatoes and the tails left on the shrimp and basically no taste. So I asked the waitress if they had forgotten the tomatoes and she went over to the salad bar to get me some. Cold. Fine - no problem. I mixed them in. Not happy but no problem. The shrimp were definitely over cooked and fishy. Fine. No problem. BUT when I turned over one shrimp I noticed it was black in one area almost all the way through. It wasn't burnt. It was rotted! I have never seen anything like it! ! I told the waitress and she said she would tell the owner. She came back and said the owner agreed to take half off our meal or give us another meal. We said fine. We weren't happy about it but whatever. We just wanted to get out of there. Then we got the bill and he had taken $5 off. I just couldn't believe it. That wasn't even half off. We were so disgusted. I could have gotten terribly sick from rotted shrimp. The owner came over and said some half ass sorry about the shrimp. I said you didn't even take half off. He said "what, $5.00 off, it was only one shrimp!" He was indignant. Like how dare I say anything! I said you don't serve rotted food!! and walked out. So if that is the standard of food quality at the Elma towne grill --- beware of this place! read more