Probably the most expensive bacon egg and cheese I've bought. Place was clean and staff was nice but nothing crazy that warrants an outstanding review. read more

Excellent Bagel Deli! Great quality food and prices. Workers always pleasant to deal with. Clean and updated places to eat also. Totally recommend. Disregard old reviews. Not accurate. read more

Terrible service! Overprice will never be returning, never seem to get a order correct and takes forever to make the food

HORRIBLE !! Almost 16 dollars for a cold bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel plus a Snapple. I walked in placed my order and 6 minutes later I was walking out. The food was super cold and the cheese wasn't even melted. Don't eat here you'll be completely disappointed. read more

Are you hungry for a mediocre breakfast with a side of getting ripped off? If so, Everyday Bagels in Smithtown is the place for you! Let me preface by saying that the place is super clean and the staff is very friendly. That being said, my breakfast sandwich was subpar in terms of flavor and quality of the ingredients. The bacon was definitely over cooked and the roll was mealy and not fresh. To top it off, they wanted $13.01 for a bacon, sausage, egg & pepperjack sandwich. I could've fed my family for the price of this 1 star meal. Needless to say, this was a learning experience and I will get breakfast in my home town from now on. I can get much higher quality for LITERALLY half the price. Everyday Bagels...you suck. read more

Everyday Bagel - Bacon, sausage, egg & cheese - Bagels Near Me - Saint James, New York

I have to say this place is definitely a hit or miss and lately it have been miss. The customer service is always great but not the quality of the food. read more

Everyday Bagel - a woman holding a bagel in her hand - Bagels Near Me - Saint James, New York

See all

I ordered it toasted but didn't get it that way. It was half fast toasted. Make believe bc it was warm. Also the breakfast sandwiches were pricey. The place looked clean. read more

Everyday Bagel - Mini everything bagel with cream cheese toasted - Bagels Near Me - Saint James, New York

This place is below average in terms of quality & service. Outrageously overpriced for subpar freshness & overall taste. The macaroni salad never tastes fresh, meanwhile it's a ridiculous charge for a quarter pound. The sandwiches are always edible, just never memorable. The only reason I come here time to time is because it is on my way to work in the area. Otherwise, I would never have returned after my first visit. I'm always paying at least $15+ for a little sandwich, old macaroni salad & a water bottle. I can name numerous bagel stores in my neighborhood who exceeds all expectations in every area including friendliness. The workers aren't necessarily nasty, just can improve in the friendly department. I'll always remember the time one of the employees refused to toast my bagel as she started buttering it because I forgot to ask as I was ordering (& she forgot to offer.) I had to pay a ridiculous amount for a cold bagel with hard butter. This is such a nice area, it's a shame this place does not match it! read more

Holy god damn did this place increase it's prices. We ordered 2 bacon egg and cheese on rolls and egg whites on a wrap today and it cost $27!!! No coffee or juice included. Service sucks. Everyone just standing around not helping anyone. Will never go back here again. read more

There's nothing more NY than an egg sandwich, and this place seems to not be able to execute it correctly, and their unlisted coffee is not free on weekends is borderline scam. I bought a hungry man sandwich because I was going fishing and wasn't going to eat all day. A hungry man is $8 and $1 more for it on a hero. Really? Hungry man is always a hero. Their rolls are pretty cheap tasting, and do not have the crisp crust that other delis have. The eggs were well done, and there was only 2-3 pieces of bacon, a single slice of ham, and 1 piece of sausage. The icing on the cake here was that coffee is NOT included despite what the sign says and a 10oz coffee is 1.75! They did not mention this and when the total came out to $19 and change for a egg sandwich, and hungry man with coffee I asked. They told me only weekdays. No deli does that! Also all surrounding delis have free coffee, are cheaper, and have a better sandwich. I replied "That's stupid, I'll never be back again" and that is the truth. Little House of Heros is like 500ft away, no reason to go here. This is a competitive business and ripping off your customers with some unlisted stupid not valid on weekend exception isn't going to win you any business. read more

Used to like going there, but since they changed owners their prices are 80% higher than other stores. got two egg sandwiches and coffees they charged over $18.00. when I told them that was high they tried to justify the price. today I went to Bagel Express which I like as well and duplicated the exact same order and it cane out to $10.00 what a difference. last time I go there. read more

I just paid $12.00 for a bacon 1 egg and cheese with hash brown on it. I was like that's expensive the gentlemen said well it has bacon and cheese and has brown on it. But $12 for a one egg breakfast sandwich. Myself or any of my fellow employees will no longer be coming here. We have a shop across the street. read more

Pretty impressed with this deli for the area. There's a lot of flukes around but this is a true, quality deli with variety. Just what we'd expect on Long Island. I recommend going there and picking up food over door dash! They are reliable and have correct orders in store, door dash seems to impede that. Also friendly but they don't talk your ear off and I appreciate that. Hate to update so soon but I just realized they charged me over $13 for an omelette that has a menu price of $8.89 read more

We try a new breakfast spot every weekend and this one didnt disappoint! The bagel was fresh and bacon well done, just like we ordered. Definitely coming back! read more

Everyday Bagel - Bacon egg and cheese on a sesame seed bagel - Bagels Near Me - Saint James, New York

We've been switching up our normal weekend breakfast spot for this one. The Greek omelet is a must try. Delivery is usually quick also. A ton of options and breakfast platters as well as bagels. read more

Wow! Since this place changed names the bagels here are just wow. I also love the way the cream cheese tastes here and love making my own coffee with any creamer I choose instead of explaining my coffee order. The staff is pleasant and quick. This is now my go to place for bagels. read more

1 BLT and 1 Egg White platter with 2 Orange Juice's... Was not worth the $32.00 i paid.Prices are out of control

Welcoming atmosphere, fresh bagels, fast service overall great experience ! What more could you ask for ? This location appears to have changed their name to Everyday Bagels from Cella. It is hard to find a solid bagel breakfast spot this is def one of them. read more

Everyday Bagel - Everything with turkey bacon,egg, and Muenster cheese soooooo good ! - Bagels Near Me - Saint James, New York

Was going frequently. Was never an issue. Today ordered an egg sandwich with extra ham. Didn't get the extra ham...but certainly paid the extra price..9.75 never again. Thats just crazy....probably on the way out. read more

My grandpa dropped me off a bagel from this bagel shop and the taste was good but not a perfect bagel of course that's why it's not getting 5 stars and they put way too much cream cheese which I had to scoop out a decent amount but I will try this place again and ask them to tone it down on the cream cheese. read more

rip off. first told us we coulnt get creme cheese on bagel w platter. so thats fine ill pay for another bagel w creme cheese. man did not understand. sat in the seating area while they packed my food to go when i said there so i baught drinks to go back to my house with. $40 for 4 bagels and 2 drinks read more

Love the food ,love the ambiance..love the cleanliness of this hidden gem.. Ordered a bacon egg and cheese to go ..it was made fresh and the bagels were sooo crispy and yummy.. Will def. be my to go for breakfast place couple mornings of the week.. read more

Very clean bagel store. Very fast service. Very friendly staff. Meals are great. Everyone should try one day read more

Several occurrences where employee and manager get orders incorrect and blames customer. Both employee and managers have an attitude when told of their errors. If your looking for hospitality and getting what you ordered, this isn't the place. read more

It wasn't bad food the bagels were good and big but the employees didn't seem the nicest and I and 2 others had issues with their food in 5 min. The bagels had no cream cheese on it at all. I do have to say it's a nice small quaint place but overall won't be going here again read more

Hidden gem... I eat lots of bagels and this place is delicious! There a nice size and always fresh. They move fast inside too. Give it a try you won't be disappointed ! read more

Everyday Bagel - a display case of bagels - Bagels Near Me - Saint James, New York

My go to spot every time I am in town! Best bagels I have found- fresh and good variety and the service is always great. I would recommend this spot. read more

Great bagels and perfect egg sandwiches. Place has a cool vibe and the staff is friendly. Prices are fair and in range if other places. Get there before 9 and coffee is free with sandwich read more

I lived in Queens most of my life, when we moved to Long Island in 2011 finding a bagel shop out here that makes bagels as good as NYC bagels was near impossible until Cella opened - Cella's bagels are so good I believe they are superior to many of the bagel shops in Queens & Manhattan. read more

This place has the tastiest and best quality food/bagels! They actually listen to your order and make your food to your liking... and DON'T complain about it !! The staff is friendly and make you feel at home!! Love this place! read more

Actually ZERO stars.... Ordered lunch on UBEREATS, I asked for a plain bagel with veggie cream cheese, a coffee and an iced tea. My order arrived, the coffee mustve opened inside the bag and soaked the bagel, I opened the bagel and I was given a bagel with butter, which costs less money than the bagel with a flavored cream cheese. I had to throw out the mushy coffee soaked bagel and have an iced tea for lunch. I filed a complaint through UBER EATS and someone named Eshanya Sachdeva responded to me stating since I cannot provide a photo I cannot get a refund. This is absurd. DO NOT SHOP HERE - TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE. I work for Stony Brook Hospital, we order food all the time, I am telling everyone not to order from this place!!! read more

Just to put it out there I don't even do yelp reviews but felt so strongly about this I had to share. Racist. Rude. Ignorant. Frequently visited this establishment until recently when myself and a friend (who is middle eastern) went one morning for coffee and bagels. My friend is extremely quite and reserved and these two older gentleman had ZERO problem making sure she was uncomfortable as possible. When we went to pay the man wanted to remake her drink "special" because they happen to "mess it up" and proceeded into the back (away from eye distance) even though they made mine and hers right in front of us at first. When she politely asked for creamer they told her " Coffee is in the back and if you want it you can make it yourself"raising his voice with every word that came out of his mouth. Even after receiving my bagels the own pushed them across the counter and looked at us both saying BYE while staring us down as we left. Never in my life have I seen such blatant racism. PLEASE AVOID THIS PLACE AT ALLL COSTS. JUST BECAUSE THE THEME IS 50S DOESN'T MEAN ITS NOT 2017. read more

went to this bagel store for the first time on my way to work and it was just inedible I'm unsure if it was a left over from the day before or if they just messed up that batch but I had to throw it out! The bagel was hard and although It was an everything it only had poppy seeds-very odd, would not recommend read more

awful. i got a plain bagel, toasted, with american cheese. the bagel is EXTREMELY thin. that is not even a bagel. not to mention the bagel had no flavor. the cheese wasn't melted either. since it was so thin, i finished it in around 2 minutes and it did not keep me full. i would much rather pay $3 at another bagel shop that will give me a real, big, fluffy, warm bagel than pay for this crap. i will never be going here again. bagel was cold and unflavored. never go here. i have always had problems with this place before but NOTHING like this. read more

Everyday Bagel - a person holding a sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Saint James, New York

Terrible old hard bagels. Never going back. How does a bagel store NOT sell fresh bagels??? Don't go here!! read more

They have delicious bagels that tastes great every time! The owners are awesome as well!

The store is called everyday bagels now. I went in on a Saturday and ordered. The woman, who was VERY rude, over charged me. I asked why there was a difference on the price and was told Saturday and Sundays are "premium" days and everything is $1 extra and no free coffee or juice, but the sign never mentioned this. What a scam read more

We usually go to Selden Cella but my daughter and I stopped in to St James store in May after a Dr visit...we were VERY happy with our to go order! read more

Menu looks like a Little house of hero's knock off but the food is no where near the quality Little house of Hero's think twice before ordering read more

For a new business, it's hard to understand why the store is so empty on a Sunday morning. Could be the help who give off the attitude of please do not bother me or the poor (stale) bagels they sell. A member of the staff made a rather crude racial slur, and myself and another woman looked right at us and said we were free to take our business elsewhere, I did and suggest you do as well read more