Food was exceptional and the staff even better!! My family ate there today, and unfortunately my son became sick while we were there. There was no grumbling or upset. They not only cleaned everything up, but they made sure he was taken care of as well with kindness and thoughtfulness! Thank for turning a very embarrassing and uncomfortable situation into one where we felt cared for!! read more

We were jonesing hard for some pizza and almost went for a chain place back at our hotel when we looked up this place and couldn't have been happier with our decision. They carry your typical Pepsi products, but that's where they break from the ordinary pizza shop. I got a Paia, which for all the non-believers out there, is Hawaiian with mandarin oranges. The ONLY downside was the extra juices got soaked up by the thin crust. But by no means is this a knock; any other topping choice would've been A+ regardless. The taste was amazing. My girlfriend ordered the Yardsale, and it looked just like one. Imagine a 'supreme'. Now pile on twice the amount of toppings. Really phenomenal both for value and for taste. We also split and devoured some 'Extreme' Fries (your usual loaded fries). Crisp, plenty of cheese and bacon; what more could you ask for? Will ALWAYS choose Extreme Pizza whenever we want Pizza in Myrtle. read more

We love this place! We make the trip to myrtle once a year when we play in the winter worlds softball tourney and always eat here when we arrive, they have a ton of pizza options for everyone's taste! read more

The bbq pizza arrived and had slid around in the box. It was half flipped over and the toppings were everywhere. The kids enjoyed the pepperoni pizza. No one liked the twisted breadstick things. If they didn't have cheese in them they would toast so much better. We won't order again when in town. read more

Awful pizza. Frozen dough cooked on a conveyor belt oven, canned vegetables, and frozen meat. It's like a totinos pizza they put more toppings on and served to people. The price for this is outrageous as well, $30 for a large piece that is worse than a Digornos? No thanks. Our server was a sweet Serbian girl who facilitated every request we had and she was the saving grace. But why would ANYONE pay so much for an awful pizza when Mellow Mushroom is less than a mile away and cost less to get a pie made with fresh dough and ingredients cooked on a stone oven? This place is a tourist trap. Eat elsewhere unless you enjoy paying premium prices for inferior pizza. read more

Chicken wings were beyond amazing, so if that's what you're looking to eat this is your place. The pizza however is very cheesy, so if that's how you like it....go for it. It just wasn't my type of pizza. Overall taste was good. Would come here again for the wings. Staff is super friendly, and the food came fast. Place is also very clean. read more

Phenomenal!! Fresh ingredients and you can taste them all. Every town I visit I try their local pizza shop. This was the place for the day and they did not disappoint. Our server was a young Ukrainian gentlemen and what a pleasant visit he made it. He was talkative, attentive and even through out a few jokes. A breathe of fresh air. Will drive two hours again for extreme pizza! You guys ROCK! read more

Extreme Pizza - Picture says it all!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

A totally underrated pizza place! It's tucked away and not very busy at all, but great! Their pizzas are very good and they're willing to do anything you'd like! The service was very good and we loved our waiter (Alex is hilarious!) I'd highly recommend! read more

Decent pizza. Nice server in from the Ukraine on summer work program. Expensive for what you get. Sit on the patio for best experience and view! read more

Great service. Great food. Great atmosphere. Loved the experience. Worth the drive from the Bluegrass State.

Pizza was soggy.. i asked for it to be WELL DONE it wasn't ...sauce taste like out came out of a can..$42 down the drain..i usually rely on the reviews but DONT... read more

Wifey and I wanted to have another pizza, but there were issues...so we ended up at Extreme Pizza. Wifey got a pepperoni pizza and I got an Italian sandwich. My sandwich was quite good...actually surprisingly so! It also had fries, which is unusual, but I like having fries with my Italian...so I enjoyed it! Not the greatest Italian I have ever had but good and solid! Same description for wifey's pizza...good and solid... If you are at Broadway at the Beach...and want some pizza...go for it! read more

We came in close to closing, as the waitress was taking our orders one of us had walked in late and wasn't to ready to order as yet...as she was walking away she referred to her as a "f.cking b.tch" under her breath, when we asked for a manager they said she was the manager and she continued to have an attitude. Both tables left the establishment without commotion. Won't return. read more

My family and I got a just a regular pepperoni pizza was a good pizza, but nothing way out of the ordinary. We also got the cheese sticks and we really enjoyed them along with the marinara sauce. Some Of the best we have had. Nice atmosphere. It's worth a try. read more

Today this was our second choice, but it'll be our first choice from now on. The pizza was insanely good, fast, and fresh. Loved the unique recipes too! Thank you all! read more

Sooooo good. It was a busy night so the service was kind of bad but they were nice about it. I loved that there was outside seating close to the water! read more

Twisted bread was amazing. Pizza is delicious with unique toppings and combinations. Highly recommend!!

The Spicy Route pizza is a must try!! Excellent flavor and great fresh ingredients. When we arrived to our hotel, we ordered take out and the pizza was a hit. At first we were skeptical on how the pizza would taste as it had a Indian spicy curry flavoring but upon trying it was amazing! read more

The place is nice the staff and service were great. The only issue was the food. The pizza was awful. The crust was so thin it was like eating greasy cheese on a stale pretzel. Pizza Hut is so much better. read more

Edit based on response from owner: The response shows your attitude towards feedback. The issue was that the booth cushion was not affixed to the booth seat. Why would I lie about what the server said?! And for someone that wasn't there, your understanding of "with great detail" is very different from mine. I do appreciate you want to defend your staff, but please consider what your customers say. Perhaps stopping by my table after I sent the salad back instead of waiting for me to find the manager would've been a better approach. Unbelievable. That's how I describe my experience. We sat in a booth that wasn't fully attached to the wall so every time someone stood up, it tipped. When I said something, the girl said, "oh, a guy was supposed to come look at that today." We were literally one of 3 tables, so it's not like that was the only available seat. Food was crap and service was blah. I ordered the High Flying Thai Salad. I asked for the dressing on the side (trying to be healthy) with no noodles. She asked me if I wanted the marinade on the side too. I told her no, that's fine, just the dressing. She told me it was kind of spicy. I told her, as long as it was just on the chicken, that's fine. 6 people in my party; no one could eat the salad because it was so spicy and the marinade was poured all over the salad. She sauggested I pour ranch on it so it wasn't so spicy (not healthy). I sent it back. They charged me full price regardless. I asked for reimbursement. She took off the difference between a full and half salad only because "well, we made it for you." We also got an x-large pizza. It was fine. Nothing great. The kids didn't even finish their one slice because they didn't love it. The hot wing pizza was fine, but just fine. The other, veggie, can't recall the name was also just fine. Nothing Extreme. Nothing to tell anyone about. Cost me $30. My husband had the caress salad and said it was "whatever". Our meal cost us over $50. I'd rather have my money back. Don't waste your time and money. Go a couple doors down to Eat At Joe's where the staff is friendly and the food is great for the same money. We come to Myrtle Beach twice a year and we will NoT be back. read more

Everything from service to appetizers to pizza was wonderful!! Highly recommend the twisted bread sticks and Wham Bam Thank you Ma'am Pizza!! read more

We ordered the BBQ chicken pizza and the "Yard Sale" pizza. The BBQ chicken had a little too much BBQ sauce on it (in my opinion) but was still good and we thought the "Yard Sale" pizza was phenomenal! Great blend of flavors with just the right amount of individual ingredients. We thought the crust was great and not "doughy" as some reviewers suggested. My son, who is a picky eater, loved his slice of cheese pizza. Our waitress was attentive & offered great suggestions before we ordered. I would recommend this place & I will being going back on our next visit to the beach. read more

When we first came in and sat down our server came over and took our drink order. We didn't know what to eat right away, since we had never been there before. She didn't come back for 20mn to take our order. We ordered appetizers. They didn't come until our meal finally came which took another 45 min. The fries where cold and the cheese had dried in clumps. other tables that had arrived after us, had already gotten their food. And we were still waiting on ours. By the time everything was said and done, our meal took 2 hours. I would never go for a sit down meal there again. however, I will say the pizza is good. But the rest was not worth the price. read more

Too bad I can't leave -5 stars. This place is pathetic. Got half the food and then waited more than an hour for the rest of our food to come out and then even longer for the ticket. If I was the manager I'd fire everyone in there and and start from scratch. Place is a joke read more

Pizza was way over priced to start with. The pizza tasted like any other frozen brand of pizza. We thought we would just try it. Never again even if prices were cut 70%. Please look at their prices then decide if a frozen pizza is worth that much. The positive was the waiter. He was very friendly and helpful. read more

I'm really conflicted on this review. Honestly, this review would be 4.5/5 stars if it hadn't been for the absolutely awful sewage smell that started about eight minutes after we sat down and persisted for the rest of the meal. It was awful! We were one of three groups eating there; I'm not sure if others smelled it. But whew! It was off putting! The server was great and attentive, the kitchen was a little slow (I was probably hoping things would come out faster so we could get out of the awful smell). If I had been by myself I would have left it was that bad. I got a kids pizza since it's Super Bowl Sunday and I'm pigging out tonight and my husband got an individual pizza. The pizza was really good but that smell. I just couldn't get past the smell. I'm thinking something was up with the drains or something. While waiting for our food we heard this loud noise sounding like someone was working a bad bilge bump twice. read more

decent service but the pizza was not good whatsoever. I forced myself to eat bc i was starving so i ate it. It was really greasy and the potatoes on the pizza were not fully cooked. A bit disappointing. But I'm not from the area so it was a one time thing anyways! read more

Everyone was so friendly and eager to help. Some of the best pizza we've ever eaten and we loved the fried pickles! We sat on the water and enjoyed our meal! read more

Went there for dinner while on vacation with my service dog. The pizza was excellent and they even allowed me to order for my dog! Waite staff was wonderful! read more

The food was excellent. The pizza was cooked well and flavorful. We loved the fun options they had to offer. The prices were very fair, had cheesy bacon fries, two individual pies, and a cookie (seriously get the cookie with ice cream!!) and it came to $32. Crazy!! Our server was extremely friendly, but unfortunately we sat outside and had the slowest service imaginable. It's as if they forgot about us. I had to go find someone because we waited a good 15 min for someone to take our order. I think it was possibly because we sat outside and no one else was out there, but it still was a bit upsetting considering how great the food was. Overall a delicious place, just needs more attentive service/better organization with the staff. read more

By far the best anchovie pizza I've eaten, perfectly flavored. Excellent crust as well.

The pizza was good. Late night, can't complain. But come on! It looked like the delivery man tossed it around like a frisbee for 20 minutes before delivering it to my place. read more

Extreme Pizza - You guys even trying? I mean, come on! - Pizza Near Me - Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

Andrei was very polite, very friendly and attentive. We sat outside and had a blast watching to water activities. The salads were good! The pizza had interesting and unique toppings read more

Best Pizza that I have had in a long time. A bit pricey, but after you see the mountain of toppings, you will understand why.

It's ok... but not great. First, I ordered buffalo wings (and even specified just normal wings) but I think the language barrier between the server and I is the reason I got boneless wings. Fine. I was hungry. I'll take it. But they were just blah. I ordered the "Poultry Geist" pizza and, while it was good, it too was blah. So much flavor potential with those ingredients but really I tasted the cheese and chicken only. The decor is neat, all skateboards and snowboards, but soul music was all that played the entire time so that felt disconnected. My son was given a kids menu with all sorts of activities but no crayons and was pretty much ignored the entire time, asking me if I wanted refills but not him. Generally not a place I will visit again but it filled the void. I was at the restaurant as I wrote this. read more

This is one of the best thin crust pizzas I have eaten. The cheese and toppings were perfect. If you are in the area, try it.

I must say the staff where friendly off first contact but had no clue about there points program. The pricing for a what I consider a standard pizza was extremely high. I spent 90 dollars for 1 extra large and two mediums plus a salad. When I compare this to MOD pizza that's more than double the price. I certainly can't say I received double the overall satisfaction for my money. The pizza quality was fair but the overpriced end result turned me off. I will not be returning. read more

This was the most disgusting food I've ever tasted. First off, they brought us our wrong order, when I said this isn't what I ordered, I was told we can fix you additional pizza. Wanting to charge for me for the food I didn't even order. Next the staff couldn't even speak English, so how in the hell can someone who cant speak English even write your order down correctly. Would highly recommended not eating here. I was charged 50 dollars for something I didn't even order and the manager would do nothing to fix it, just charge me for another pizza. Screw this place. read more

Amazing!!! I love this place I got a side salad with a pizza and it was very good! Also ordered a sex on the beach and it was delicious! Great service! I highly recommend! read more

Very, very slow service, even with the restaurant quite empty. I finally had to go up to the bar to request my check. Every aspect of the service was slow and apathetic. read more