Extreme Pizza

First, this place is much nicer on the inside than it looks from the outside…read more We ordered "The Godfather" and a Margherita Pizza and were blown away. The toppings were fresh, the sauce was amazing, the crust was perfectly cooked. Very attentive and friendly staff. If we lived nearby, we'd definitely come here regularly. Thanks for making our vacation this much better!

I went in side and the inside was clean and beautiful, my waiter Mark was Amazing! I ordered…read moreLobster Ravioli, in Alfredo sauce. The sauce tasted bad, and it was a mushy pink past inside the ravioli. The entire dish tasted degusting. I sent it back and ask for a different dish and they refused, they would only refund me and charged me .75 extra for the salad dressing. The other 4 people who joined me for dinner there wasn't satisfied with there dish either, they said the food was bland. We will never go back.

Quaint and fully stocked bar with a long list of custom specialty drinks. Somebody is a mixologist!!

Caramel cheesecake

See all

Manhattan's with black cherries.

Vicini's Restaurant and Pizza

4.7(424 reviews)

2.2 mi

Just had a great meal at Vicini's. Food was great; the lasagna was excellent, as was the chicken…read moreparm. Our server, Marisa, was delightful and took very good care of us. A great place to go if you want a small, quiet place with authentic Italian cooking!!

We were close by and decided to get pizza for dinner. We…read moreread the reviews and decided to try this pizza. Called and placed our order for take out as we still had a few stops on our way home. The pizza met and exceeded what we expected. Fresh ihome made ngredients are the difference between VICINI'S and other pizza's. Yes their pizza costs a bit more, there is reason for this " Quality". Next time we are in the area and want authentic Italian food Vicini's will be on our radar

Chef/owner Sokol

See all

Gino's Real New York Pizza

4.0(189 reviews)

3.9 mi

New York City is in Myrtle Beach! This is hands down the best pizza I've had outside of NY and NJ…read more In fact, it's better than most places in NY and NJ. This is real NYC pizza and calzones in South Carolina. The owner hails from Astoria, Queens and has an original location still operating there. This is one of those places that is so good you shouldn't even bother trying anything else in the area.

The prices published on this restaurant's own website are apparently nowhere near the prices they…read moreare actually charging. When I brought up the discrepancy and asked about honoring the prices advertised on their own website, the response I received was simply, "Do you want to order or not?" That is an unacceptable way to handle a legitimate customer concern. Customers should be able to rely on pricing that a business chooses to publish on its official website. If those prices are outdated, update the website. Until then, management should take responsibility for the information it is advertising rather than dismissing customers who question it. I have submitted a complaint to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) regarding the advertised pricing and the discrepancy I encountered. Regardless of how that complaint is ultimately handled, this restaurant needs to correct its online menu immediately and address how customers are treated when they raise reasonable concerns about advertised prices.

Pizza & Wings Was So Good & So Fresh. Didn't Even Leave The Parking Lot Yet . #CoraWasTheBest

See all

AJ's Pizza

4.5(519 reviews)

3.1 mi

We stopped in for lunch and placed an order, then went to shop at a cute little vintage store next…read moredoor while we waited. Our order was ready before we were finished shopping and it was delicious. I got a chicken Alfredo personal pizza and they definitely did not skimp on the toppings. It was wonderful and reasonably priced. My boyfriend got an Italian sub which was also good. I highly recommend to anyone in the area!

We've had 7 pizza places in Myrtle Beach and AJs is by far the best near the ocean! NOT A TOURIST…read moreTRAP! Really great prices, pwrfect cheese and pepperoni pizza, and Hawaiian pizza. Super fast hot delivery from friendly staff. If you're debating between them and ultimate California pizza choose AJs! They were far superior over California, you can check my review of them too, they were mid and a tourist trap. NYer approved!

Inside

Well done mild wings

See all

Hawaiian pizza and spinach pizza

Charlie M’s Pizza

5.0(1 review)

1.7 mi

Authentic as is gets Needed 10 pies for a party and will order 15 next time pizza was incredible…read more MINGYA

See all

Crave Italian Oven & Bar

4.4(878 reviews)

4.1 mi

CRAVE has quickly become such a special place for our little family! We brought our baby girl here…read moreto celebrate her turning 2 months old and just came back for her 3-month milestone. I think we officially have a new tradition! We always have an incredible experience. The food is amazing, the atmosphere is great, and they make one of the BEST dirty martinis in Myrtle Beach -- which this mama definitely needs every once in a while! The service is also always wonderful. On our most recent visit, Ashton went above and beyond for us and truly made our experience 10x better! Coming from Italian roots, I love a good Italian restaurant, and you can really see the authenticity, care, and hard work that goes into this place. It keeps us coming back every time. I truly do CRAVE CRAVE. See you for the 4-month milestone!

Holy Pasta, Batman - this place rocks! Service was stellar and the ambiance was beautiful. The…read moreadded touch - no charge valet adds a certain North End Italian neighborhood feel. The real star is the menu and quality of the selections. Fresh homemade pastas and homemade cheeses reminds me of my mother's cooking The stuffed seafood manicotti rivaled anything we ate in Rome yeah that Rome- the one in Italy. Considering the new 2026 massive inflation issues, the prices were reasonable. We will be back and I encourage you to try it out.

Ambiance

PASTA PRIMAVERA w/grilled shrimp & chicken

See all

Calamari

Corrado's Pizza

4.7(58 reviews)

8.5 mi

Great place for a slice after matinee. All four of us…read moreenjoyed our food. Nice crispy bottom, good sauce.

Great place to order a whole pizza or sit and eat a couple slices...guys are always friendly and…read moreefficient...

18'' Large Pizza

See all

Hot Tomato Italian Restaurant & Brick Oven

3.8(625 reviews)

1.3 mi

I went last night with my daughter, her husband, son, his girlfriend, my niece, nephew and grand…read moreniece. Everything was delicious. I had the burata arrigula pizza. I don't eat a lot and I ate almost all of it!! My son shared the calamari and fungi pie with his girlfriend. My daughter and husband shared to prosciutto pie and a chicken saltimiboca. My niece, nephew and grand niece calabrian pie. Everybody loved everything, including the bottles of red wine lol WoW those cannolis and I'm in love with tge tiramisu. When we got there it was early but while we were there, the place filled up mostly with families and couples. Ambience felt like welcome home. Thank you Mckenzie for taking great care of us!!

We went to the new location tonight and I'm pretty sure I had the best fettuccine Alfredo I have…read moreever had. Seriously delicious. We will absolutely be back

Hot Tomato Italian Restaurant & Brick Oven

Side Salad

See all

Roasted garlic oil & fresh homemade bread

Pizza Ala Roma III

4.0(119 reviews)

2.0 mi

I was in town for a week from Texas and really wanted pizza. I was born and raised in NJ, so I'm…read morevery picky when it comes to good pizza. My husband is a huge pizza connoisseur (he even makes his own), so finding a solid spot was a must. We ordered a medium white pie, a medium BBQ chicken, and a small cheese for our son. The sizes were great compared to other pizza places. The white pie was delicious! Personally, I think it could have used just a touch more garlic, but overall it was really good. The BBQ chicken was a pleasant surprise--my husband isn't usually a fan, but he really enjoyed it. The onions were sliced perfectly, the toppings were spread evenly, and the BBQ sauce wasn't overpowering. Even my very picky son ate three slices of the cheese pizza, which says a lot. The dough was excellent--not too thin or too thick. The crust was airy, flavorful, and had a nice chew without being bland like many other places. There was very little flop on the white pie, which I loved. Ordering through the Slice app was super convenient, and the restaurant itself was easy to find. When I walked in to pick up, I was greeted immediately, and our pizzas were ready right on time. Highly recommend this place! We'll definitely be back the next time we're in town.

Fresh Ingredients , friendly staff , a must for your visit…read more Will definitely make this a usual on my visits !

Garlic Bread

See all

Great vibe. So cute inside.

Scotto’s Pizzeria

4.0(185 reviews)

2.7 mi

Great service and food. Muscle Marinara is a great choice. Pizza and desserts are a win.read more

The food was good - we liked them BUT then we recently ordered a pizza. My husband went to pick it…read moreup and I gave him my debit card to use. It was ready when he walked in. I looked at the receipt and noticed there was a $3.00 tip on there. I asked him why he tipped them when it was a pick up order. He said he didn't. Called them and they were rude, said he authorized it, didn't care that he reiterated that he was never asked if he wanted to leave a tip, etc. it's bad enough that they charge you their processing fee when you use a debit or credit card but now they arbitrarily sneak a tip on take-out and then act like he knew about it. So we will never go there again - will NOT recommend it. Too bad they lost a good customer over $3.00. I'm responding to the business owner comment below. Perhaps you should not argue this point...as he tried to explain that he was not aware of your process. A good business would perhaps apologize for the situation...maybe this has happened with other customers. You know, customers who patronize your business. You were wrong and handled it poorly. Your loss.

Things to do in Myrtle Beach

Pizzas ready to eat

See all

Reheated the Stromboli on our well seasoned pizza stone.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

11 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Christina W.

10 years ago

Perfect place and pizza even better then Italian pizza!!! :) I am from Italy and I just came to Myrtle beach with my family and we saw Extreme pizza so we wanted to check how do they make pizza and to compare with Italian one :) I just have to say THEY MAKE IT BETTER THEN ITALIAN PIZZA!!! Everything was so delicious, we took 4 different small pizza, Everest, Yard sale, Mont Blanc and Baja 1000 and we will definitely go back to try some more on menu. Our server was really kind and offered us a pizza chips appatizer with sauce, it was deliciouse too ! :) read more

Cannon H.

10 years ago

Just recently found this gem while walking with friends at Broadway. Getting seated was fast and easy, and the service was outstanding. The pizza we got was as fresh and delicious as it gets! However, if you're not a fan of pizza don't be turned away by the name they serve way more than pizza. The Cesar salad that I got was very delicious, and the sub my friend got looked amazing too. The big cookie at the end for dessert was the cherry on top. My friends and I will be returning very soon. read more

Jade S.

8 years ago

3 stars because the food was actually very good. The salad was fresh and the home made ranch dressing made the difference. Pizza was delicious too! -2 stars because their "fantastic prices" are not so fantastic. The $9 whole pizza is no bigger than a big slice at a NY Pizzeria. You should have seen my friend's face when he looked down at the pizza box (about as wide as his opened hand) and said half-jokingly, "Now this is what I would call a French pizza! Not Italian!" read more

Holly B.

10 years ago

Came here while during our short stay in Myrtle Beach and I can say we were not disappointed! Friendly staff and delicious pizza! My husband and I were not agreeing to which pizza we should try ( so many great selections). I had the Ragin' Rooster while my husband had the Everest. Both pizza's had an abundance amount of toppings! Next time we come back, we will definitely eat here again! read more

Aimee M.

10 years ago

My family and I were very excited to try Extreme Pizza! We tried 3 different pizzas and were pleased with each one. I was pleasantly surprised with how fresh the ingredients were and the prices are certainly comparable to other specialty pizza places in the area. We had wonderful service from our server, Holly, and the location is beautiful. read more

Jimmy V.

10 years ago

I came to this place to make sure how it is and I enjoyed my time here!!! My pizza was delicious, I had a beautiful view and great service in Extreme pizza. Price was ok too! Check them out, i will come back for sure! read more

Esn B.

2 years ago

Pizza was great.Try the broccoli and chicken pizza. But there was a strange smell on the table. I don't think the ones used for cleaning are clean. We had to clear the table ourselves. read more

ProjectSlump K.

5 years ago

First of all it was hotter than satans nutsack, pizza was subpar at best and the portions for the 8 inch pizza was a joke, like this restaurant read more

Hunter H.

8 years ago

Had an amazing time with my family here, food was delicious and my server Amy was amazing ! Keep up the great work!!

Wooga W.

8 years ago

Amazing pizza, and great service I would definitely recommend it here loved the over all service

Pearson Ball B.

5 years ago

ma ma ma Mid. pizza? mid. service? mid.

Extreme Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

Best of Myrtle Beach

People found Extreme Pizza by searching for…

People who viewed Extreme Pizza also viewed

Ultimate California Pizza

(83 reviews)

You don't come here for the ambiance, you come here for the pizza! Quality products, great crust,…read moreand lots of different options to choose from. When we're at the beach, we always try to stop here at least once.

Love it and they have great salads and pizzas and you can set outside or inside and the people are…read morein I mean I only been to the one in South Carolina so I have been there all my life and will always go back.

Chanti’s Pizza

3.5

(50 reviews)

Food and service are usually good. PIZZAs are different and fun ambiance as well…read more Usually enjoy!!!

Sauce was good. Pizza was overcooked, and doesn't use fresh ingredients. Chicken cubes were hard…read more You could tell it was leftover from from the other day. Sausage was the same. Tasted like it was grabbed from a bowl that had been refrigerated for awhile. The appearance of the pizza was like that of a frozen pizza or leftover from the night before, and then reheated causing it to be tough and hard to bite into. Service was just ok. It took a long time to get our food. We could see into the kitchen area from our table. There were 3 cooks in there, just standing. One of them had his arms crossed. It just seemed like nobody there cared. They obviously thought it was ok to serve us overcooked pizza that basically had the consistency of cardboard. The kitchen needs a major overhaul as far as food. No more for us!

NY Pizza Kitchen Bar&Grill

(58 reviews)

Chef salads and grilled chicken salad were great. Would definitely order again. We ordered it as…read moretakeout. Was very fast in getting it ready.

Just arrived from traveling and wanted to grab a bite to eat before we checked into our room…read more Figured pizza would be a safe choice. To my surprise we walked into a completely empty restaurant (uh oh!); of course we had the option to sit anywhere. We sat and placed our order quickly. Took a bit longer than expected to get a house salad, 10 pc L&P wings, and a medium pepperoni & mushroom pizza. The staff was nice but it seemed that they couldn't get into gear after sitting around an empty restaurant for who knows how long. The pizza was ok. Pretty greasy and comparable to NY style pizza. The wings were lemon pepper packed but seemed over fried. I can tell that in the peak season, this place is probably buzzing

NY Pizza Kitchen Bar & Grill

(36 reviews)

I highly encourage you to venture slightly off the strip for good food in general, but definitely…read morefor pizza. Service was humorous & efficient, pizza was fresh and made to order..worth any delays. The medium is perfect for 2 people, potentially 3 if you get starters or sides. Like most places in the area they offer a discount when you pay with cash. Not pictured but the BBQ wings are delicious!

New York Pizza and Bar, Myrtle Beach…read more Visited Thursday, April 9 around 8:25 PM with a party of five. We were seated immediately and service was attentive and polite throughout. The location on N Kings Hwy leans more worn than charming. It feels functional, not inviting. Seating is tight and not particularly comfortable, very much a sit, eat, and move on setup. There is a very small bar, though it did not add much to the experience. We ordered a spread of pizzas plus a garden salad. Portions were as expected, and note that a small pizza is truly personal sized. Pizzas are stone baked, which gave the crust a decent texture, but flavor did not quite follow through. The garden salad was simple but fresh. Crisp lettuce with green peppers, olives, and a heavy hand on the onions. Not exciting, but it did its job. The pizza is where things start to slip a bit. The margherita pizza was bland and forgettable. The meat lovers and pesto with added pineapple had better flavor and were the most enjoyable of the group. A plain cheese pizza kept the teenagers happy, which was the main objective. Dinner came to about $77, and for a quick, no wait meal after a drive, it served its purpose. Food came out fast and everyone left fed. Would not return with so many stronger pizza options nearby. This is a practical stop for families with teenagers or anyone looking for a budget friendly, no fuss meal near the beach. Must order: Meat lovers pizza Heads up: The garden salad is very basic and heavy on onions

Pizza Chef

(64 reviews)

•$

I really liked this pizza. Very fresh, cheesy and great sauce taste. From ordering it took 15…read moreminutes and the inside of the restaurant was packed. The crust had some type of seasoning on it and made it taste very good! I would recommend coming here.

Vacations few weeks ago and ate here twice. Pizza was phenomenal. Spaghetti was so so imo…read more Add it to your list of restaurants to try on vaca!!

GiGi's PIZZA

3.0

(74 reviews)

Quick bites while at the bar. This restaurant is next to Gigis bar and hookah lounge and has the…read moresame owner. Clean establishment. They service pizza, wings, calzones, beverages and ice cream as well. Clean establishment and friendly staff. There is no inside seating but you can take the food into the bar next door. The food was good.

This is not pizza I was served a slice of the pizza box…read more Worse than school lunch, hospital food , from what I've heard even prison food. A slice of cardboard for $4.65 that's not edible. Go try it... then leave a review. Don't try it , save $10 buck with a $5.00 bottle of cheap bottled water Which the bottle reads California water not spring not purified water. This place makes Friendly's taste like The freshest gourmet food ever microwaved.

Nevados Pizza

4.2

(45 reviews)

Another night, no one wants to cook, so we are at Nevados again. Tonight, 8 of us showed up…read more Service is always great, food is always awesome. Pizza, ravioli, salads and a steak sub. Get in your car and get here!!!!

Love Nevado's! Only complaint is wish they delivered. Pizza is great as well as the wings and…read morestuffed shells.

Rapone Brick Oven

4.6

(345 reviews)

I have not had Salvadoran food before. This place was great! I followed waitress recommendations…read moreand got the surf and turf. My kids stuff off the kids menu: chicken tenders which I also tried and tasted homemade. Kids chicken soup was also great. Of course I let my kids try my steak and they wanted to eat it all because it was so good. Nice ambiance as well, relaxing.

Amazing pizza. Owner and staff wonderful and friendly. He told us about the .00 flour they import…read morefrom Italy. Makes all the difference in the crust. The bar is a little too small. We went to take out but ended up eating right there at the bar. Our new go to for Pizza and looking forward to try the Pasta dishes!!

Surfside Beach Pizza & Restaurant

4.3

(336 reviews)