Fabio On Fire

4.3 (148 reviews)

ModerateGelato, Sandwiches

Open • 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Order Fabio On Fire Takeout or Delivery

Order Takeout or Delivery

Fabio On Fire Photos

Fabio On Fire - Gelato Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Fabio On Fire - Insite - Gelato Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Fabio On Fire - Large Cup of Gelato - Bronte Pistachio, Cappuccino, Limoncello - Gelato Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

+272

Fabio On Fire - Counter & cold case - Gelato Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Business Info

Health Information

View Health Score

Fabio On Fire Popular Dishes

11 Photos7 Reviews

7 Photos8 Reviews

2 Photos8 Reviews

Fabio On Fire menu photos

See all

FABIO ON FIRE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

Inside

31 Photos

Outside

10 Photos

Moderate noise

Outdoor seating

Dogs allowed

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Fabio On Fire

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

Brenda S.

We love Fabio on Fire! Food is always good and [[HIGHLIGHT]]the vibe is always great[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]! Definitely recommend it.

Stracha....something... affogato- delicious

Silvia D.

Everything was fantastic. Service: young lady gave us samples and recommendations.... while doing everything else. Food: gelato/affogatos were delicious but one needed more espresso and I was TRULY bummed that they ran out of pistachio... [[HIGHLIGHT]]Ambiance: lady had her loud kid inside so we came outside to enjoy the hot summer heat (then the loud kid came out too) lol.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]They have plenty of outdoor seating.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Hoping for pistachio next time.

Susan W.

[[HIGHLIGHT]]This is a tiny lunch counter style restaurant with only a handful of tables but they make up for it with their amazing panini, pizza, and gellato menu.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] You order your food choice, receive a number, and wait at one of the tables if they're not all occupied. We were lucky, a table was empty. I was feeling a bit irked at the lack of personal attention, but then I sank my teeth into a delicious Toscana panini. (See more choices on the big menu board, or the laminated menus at the cashier counter.) Transport to Heaven!! It's HUGE. Then the gellato... so many flavors, each more delicious than the last. And don't forget the tiramisu. In short, it's great. Go try it out!!

Kimi S.

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Cutest shop in the neighborhood.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] When the crew is speaking Italian and cheek kissing the shift change workers, you know it's going to be a lovely experience. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Place is spotless, service is friendly, so happy they are in our 'hood.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Split a panini w/my hubby to go. The gelato looked yummy, but we will save it for our next visit. The pizzas per everyone's photos on here look yummy too. This is a new hot spot for us, don't know why we didn't try it sooner.

Dolores D.

Such a yummy spot. Got some gelato. There's one that's with vanilla and chocolate chips in it but they sell out, quick. I got 2 flavors, sea salt and chocolate. They also have cake and it looks good. They also have sandwiches and it looks yummy.

Victoria G.

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Cute ambiance in this little cafe.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Not many tables and chairs but we got lucky.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] They have a great special for the summer: buy 2 pizzas and get 2 free gelatos. It was fantastic! The pizza dough was like what you would get in Italy. I got the vegetarian and it was enough for 2 people. Lots of gelato options - all very tasty. The service was great without too much of a wait. Definitely will go back!

Grace X.

Incredibly delicious and authentic paninis. The giardino panini is entirely vegan, and is filled with roasted vegetables, vegan mayo, olive pate, and arugula. It was extremely good, and this place is definitely a new favorite for me in AZ. The bread itself is also amazing, apparently the yeast they use is over 110 years old now. The interior is very welcoming, and you can see them preparing your sandwiches through the glass. They also have desserts and other deli items on display for purchase. The sandwiches are pretty large, I ordered a whole and saved half for later. 10/10!

Stephanie F.

I liked the tiramisu and the panini I had. I love pizza, and even enjoy brick oven pizza, but I did not like the burnt taste of this pizza. I'm also apparently not a fan of gelato, but I love ice cream. My friends enjoyed it and I'm glad I tried it, but I won't be coming back. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It is a cute little spot and the service was good.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]

Front of store. In the spot where Wow Wow Lemonade used to be.

Jeannine S.

Such a cute place! I recently was in Italy and this place definitely has very similar food (pizzas, gelato). I love that they have some authentic Italian items to purchase and bring home, such as authentic pasta, olive oil, etc. We tried 4 different sandwiches and they were large and well worth the price. 3 of the 4 of us saved the other half of the sandwich to eat later. My picky teenage son loved the Puglia panini and ate the whole thing in one sitting minus my small bite so I could give it a try. It was my favorite of the 4 we ordered (eggplant parm, Puglia, Capri, and Luciano). The eggplant part was my least favorite because it made the bread mushy. Definitely going back to try the pizza and pasta and more of the cold sandwiches. Probably will bring home some goodies from the shop/market items, as well. Pros 1. Food is just like it is in Italy 2. Simple and fresh ingredients makes for very tasty and clean food 3. The items you can purchase to take home such as pasta, olive oil, fresh whole stems/leaves of dried oregano, etc. 4. The gelato looked legit. I learned in Italy how to tell real gelato from the kind that is made to sell more and sacrifices taste and texture. The gelato at Fabio is the real deal. Cons 1. Hot sandwich that I had (eggplant parm) made the wonderful bread mushy so it didn't taste nearly as good as the cold sandwich like my son had (the Puglia).

Elle S.

The Piccante Panini is an absolute knockout. The combo of peppery arugula, creamy buffalo mozzarella, and sweet caramelized white onions is perfectly balanced--rich, fresh, and just the right amount of indulgent. Everything melts together beautifully, with bold flavor in every bite and zero heaviness.

Large Pistachio, Biscoff Cookie, Limoncello Cup of Gelato

Stephanie V.

We ordered a 12" Salsiccia & Funghi Pizza to go through the website tonight. It was very easy and quick to order this way. When we arrived at the estimated ready time, our pizza was waiting. This pizza is absolutely delicious! The dough is light and airy, with browned edges from wood-fired baking. The cheese is creamy and fresh. We loved the sausage and mushroom on top. Definitely, a top pizza in our area.

Kemlyn B.

AZ Restaurant Week!!! Yummiest woodired paninis. We enjoyed the 2 paninis and 2 small gelatos for $44 deal. We added one more panini and another small gelato. Toscana: delicious pork belly melted cheese and grilled zucchini. Merviglia: salami with cheese. Salty goodness! Eggplant Parmigiana: smoky, saucy eggplant goodness! Gelato was heavenly! I loved the Capuccino gelato.

April A.

Came in to grab a sandwich and ended up grabbing 3 to go. I have to say the Donna Di Cuori was so yummy love the pistachios. All the sandwiches were great. The restaurant was cute and the ladies in the front were fantastic and helpful.

See all

Review Insights

K V.

2 years ago

A bright little Italian deli with great big, delicious paninis! My friends and I split 3 different sandwiches and one of us had a pizza. Everything was made fresh, with excellent ingredients. The panini bread itself is fantastic! We will absolutely be visiting again. read more

Fabio On Fire - The gorgeous wood fired oven with a fresh panini coming out! - Gelato Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Fabio On Fire - Did I mention the gelato ? Just like Italia! - Gelato Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Torsten S.

3 years ago

The food is delicious and every time my wife and friends try it, we are more than satisfied. read more

Fabio On Fire - Chef Fabio let me sample his delicious food. - Gelato Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Kirk W.

3 years ago

Horrible Service Food not Good Server dropped Our food Did not tell us what Happened Let us wait for ever for our food read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rodney F.

2 years ago

This is a fantastic and cozy spot. The puglia panini is great, and their sweet treats are the best in the world. Much better than that place at Norterra Osteria Mia. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Abel P.

1 year ago

Delicious like like his other restaurant. Great panini's and gelato, Fabio is truly on fire!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chris B.

1 year ago

Great paninis and gelato. Kids liked the pizza as well. Really liked that the food was fresh and the gelato selection for desert was great.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Damian L.

2 years ago

Just ordered the new pizza (Spicy Salami) was wonderful! Great flavor and the crust wasn't too thin. If you're looking for a tasty and great Panini the Donna Di Cuori is great also. The whole is easily shared for two! One of my favorite places around the four corners! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 2

Love this 2

Oh no 0

k n.

2 years ago

Amazing paninis and home made gelato. It's an authentic Italian experience. I highly recommend

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Rick F.

115

3 years ago

The panini I had was terrific! Really enjoyed the paprika flavored potato chips. Didn't get a chance to try the gelato but looking forward to next time! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Lindsay H.

152

2 years ago

Honestly I was disappointed when I came here. i am a huge fabio on fire lover...and I was so disappointed by this location and food. The seating is very uncomfortable for seniors and kids. The food was bland and not worth the price in my opinion. I normally love Fabio's bread and quality of service and products at their restaurant so when I went here, I was really sad and disappointed. The panini was lackluster. Service was slow and the furniture is uncomfortable and the presentation and decor was really lackluster. Won't be coming back, sorry Fabio. I will still be coming to the OG location though! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 1

Jeff F.

3 years ago

Expected more from Fabio on Fire. Sandwiches were just ok and pricey. Will not be going back read more

Helpful 4

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Bella B.

1 year ago

Young girl has an outstanding gross attitude working the counter along with the owner. Can't hold any accountability. If you want to pay money for gross food and a side of attitude this is your place! I'm not sure how this place still has customers with how the owner acts and carries herself. Just can't say anything nice about it this place. 0 stars if I could. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Alan L.

Elite 25

395

3 years ago

It was my wife's birthday and wanted to try the other Fabio on Fire Panini style restaurant . It's a much different restaurant than their other place down the road. Smaller, bar chair seating only. More of a lunch type / take out eatery. My brother and sister in law came along for the celebration. We had a bunch of Paninis. Capri $13.95 Bufalo mozzarella + slices of tomatoes + organic pesto + arugula + extra-virgin olive oil Parmigiana $11.95 eggplant + parmigiano Reggiano + bufala mozzarella + basilico + tomato sauce + extra-virgin olive oil Piccante $14.95 Thinly-sliced spicy salami + bufala mozzarella + arugula + wood-roasted, carmelized white onions + parmigiana spread + extra-virgin olive oil Donna Di Cuori $15.95 Mortadella with pistachios + creamy mozzarella + Sicilian pistachio spread + arugula + extra-virgin olive oil Toscano $15.95 Wood-roasted pork belly + provolone + parmigiano spread + fried zucchini + extra-virgin olive oil I had them cut the Parmigiana in 4 pieces so that became out appetizer. I had the Toscano. For me it had too much of a rosemary taste which I wasn't a fan of. Meat wise the porkbelly was tender . I did enjoy Parmigiana Panini. It had great flavor. Everyone enjoyed there sandwhich and thought the bread was the star of the show. The gelato wasn't as good as the other Fabio on Fire restaurant. The pistachio wasn't the same texture. It was disappointing. Would definitely come back for the Pamigiana Penini whole size. read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Igor L.

3 years ago

The panini bread is great! It's truly good! Deli meat is good - but that's all the positives - the cashier stand is covered with a piece of tarpoline- looks like I'm in some makeshift food stand! Bought a box of bacci chocolates for 20 dollars which is overpriced - but ok - they were so old and stale!!!the entire BOx was trash! But that's nothing compared to service! Not a single adult on stuff- young teenagers being in some la-la land work at a speed of geriatric turtle!! They are so slooooooww!!! They communicate with each other more than they work ! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 2

Julie J.

2 years ago

We've been here three times. The paninis are out of this world delicious. I will say to the owner, be careful about your new trainees. The attention to detail is not quite the same. I highly recommended this darling, excellent Italian panini shop. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 2

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Summer C.

Elite 25

577

1363

5080

3 years ago

Get ready for your mouth to water. This place is legit! I have never been to Italy, but I could imagine it is as close as you can get here in Peoria. The chef (Fabio) was handed down recipes from his grandparents, who were from Southern Italy. He has been trained and worked in Italy and other countries in the culinary arts. This is his second location. This location is paninis and Gelato. They flew in their meats and cheese from Italy, and their gelato machine is from Italy. It's a small location and busy every time I've been there. There is some seating inside and outside. There is a hostess stand where they take your order, and it is right next to a refrigerated case filled with meat, cheese, and gelato. I've eaten a variety of their paninis, and all are delicious! I've had the Piccante, Capri, porchetta, and Puglia. Mmmm, I want some right now - so good! The gelato is so creamy, delicious, and refreshing. You can sample any of the flavors. I'm a chocolate girl and love their chocolate gelato. However, all of the flavors I've tried are yummy! Seriously come try this place if you haven't! read more

Helpful 6

Thanks 0

Love this 8

Oh no 0

Anthony M.

2 years ago

Incredible food! Im surprised there wasn't a line wrapped around the corner! The residents of North Peoria are very lucky to have this restaurant in their area. read more

Business owner information

Fabio C.

We appreciate it very much !! Maybe wrong location !!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brian C.

Elite 18

152

3 years ago

Very good sandwiches and gelato. Sandwiches are large and my wide and I split one. Its a small place with serval tables and it get crowded. Outside seating too if its not too hot. Take out is an option too. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Julie S.

2 years ago

Great sandwiches. The bread tastes fresh like it was made in house. I usually get the picante and it never disappoints.

Business owner information

Fabio C.

Grazie yes we make it right before you eat the sandwich

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

J. L.

107

3 years ago

Amazing gelato! The sandwich and deli counter reminds me of a small deli on Long Island. Gives me all the strong Italian vibes Service was amazing. The staff was quick, helpful, and kind. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Lindsay F.

2 years ago

Absolutely love their gelato! The cashier was also so friendly and kind, especially with the line of people waiting to purchase. Definitely want to try a panini next time I'm in. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Victor M.

3 years ago

Been going to Fabio on Fire since it opened. Excited to see this new location so close to us and was even more excited to see my favorite food group Gelato! Have been in twice now and have tried a couple of flavors. The Gelato is smooth and creamy as it should be. Problem is the price! Fabio, your just charging too much for what you get. small is $4.95, medium is $6.95, and the large is $8.95. A small blizzard is still larger than the large at it cost $4.69. Also another Gelateria in town that also makes great gelato has a two scoop cup for $5.50 and it's larger than the "3 scoops large" here. Fabio, please reevaluate the price. I would give 5 stars otherwise. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 2

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Eric J.

3 years ago

Staff was friendly and food didn't take too long. However, I hate to mention this but both the paninis the wife and I had were somewhat bland. For just the 2 sandwiches, it came to about $40 after she added arugula and I added a meat. Gelato looked good but we didn't try any. read more

Fabio On Fire - Menu 7/11/23 - Gelato Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 1

Rachel G.

3 years ago

Truly Italian gold in the west valley. We are so fortunate to have a locally owned restaurant providing us with authentic, high quality, and delicious meals! This is officially my go-to spot for lunch and dinner in the area. The bread is homemade, the spreads for the paninis are top notch, the gelato is decadent, they have a plethora of Italian sweet treats for purchase, and the owners are so kind! Check this place out; you won't regret it! read more

Fabio On Fire - The piccante - Gelato Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Steve O.

2 years ago

Porcini is to die for!!! An absolute must have! Be back for lunch! Friendly staff and great food.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Laurie A.

Elite 25

277

225

3 years ago

This is a great place to stop by for a quick panini and sweet treat gelato. You can watch them make your panini. Everything looks so fresh. We all shared a variety of different ones and I couldn't tell you which one was the best. They are pretty large portions. Enough for two meals. They all tasted so delicious. Save room for the gelato. We had the walnut brownie and the salted caramel. So So good and refreshing. Service was great too. One person in our party had a TON of questions to ask and the employees were very friendly and informative. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Sara K.

3 years ago

The Panini's are very good! The bread is so tasty. And the Gelato is amazing!!! I had the Cherry Gelato. Not too sweet. Very yummy.

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chunky M.

2 years ago

The food here was great and the meat to cheese ratio was perfect I would give this place 6 stars if I could

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Sybil B.

2 years ago

This place has great food, service and most importantly Gelato! The Pistachio Gelato is amazing!!

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Tanya L.

268

2 years ago

Wow! This place is amazing. We stopped in for lunch and gelato, then decided to stop back in for dinner and dessert in the same day. Everything was delicious and service exceeded our expectations. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Shelly K.

2 years ago

Our second time visiting and we loved it! The first time we ordered to go and wished we had dined in. This time we grabbed some friends and enjoyed the no-nonsense atmosphere to sit and visit for dinner and dessert! Even though they were busy, our server was kind, friendly, and outgoing. We ordered the pear salad and a couple of different paninis, and they were great. The bread was incredible, and the spicy salami was amazing. Would never have imagined partnering some of the ingredients in the way they do but it was so flavorful and in huge quantity. I was also impressed with the bright, clean environment and the freshness of the food. A sit on the patio is perfect in the evenings, but you miss a bit of the great smells from inside. Go for the bread, stay for the gelato! read more

Business owner information

Fabio C.

I’m so happy you like are unique sandwich that we make w so much love…

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Jessica S.

2 years ago

Fabulous paninis and delicious gelato in a cozy setting. Come hungry! Very friendly staff.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gigi D.

2 years ago

super good paninis and their gelato is amazing. highly recommend!!!! service is nice too! read more

Fabio On Fire - kinder bar gelato - Gelato Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marge G.

2 years ago

Everything made fresh and the vintage homemade bread is to die for! Delicioso! Put Fabio's Panini Pizzaria on your bucket list!

Business owner information

Fabio C.

We appriciate it very much

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Stacey O.

3 years ago

I really wanted to like this place, especially after having such a wonderful experience at Fabio On Fire. I expected the panini to be hot, but the center was still cold and the cheese wasn't melted. However, the pistachio gelato saved the day. It's the best I've ever had. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Antonio N.

3 years ago

These paninis and gelato flavors are really tasty. Only SMALL drawback is that the location has limited inside seating. The food gets 5 stars. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gillian Z.

3 years ago

The food was tasty the prices are way too high the service was slow and rude when in there two weeks ago and it was a good experience we asked for anything for the children and they said oh we can make them a ham and cheese Panini which was fine we didn't mind paying full price for it kids loved it went back today they told us oh we don't make anything for kids we don't do just a ham and cheese Panini and looked at me like I was crazy they obviously did not want my money I think it's way overpriced for what you get but the food is tasty we will not be back read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Shirlee F.

2 years ago

We Love Fabio's The Food Is Amazing Especially On The West Side! Very upscale Their Hours Are Horrible They Are Not Open For Lunch During The Week And They Are Not Open For Lunch Saturday And Sunday For Lunch 11-2 Only We Would Have Gone There Many More Times If They Had Normal Hours We Love The Food They Have great Pizza You Can Eat Anytime! Happy Hour Would Be A Great Addition with Good Prices On Wine!! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Mary H.

3 years ago

Delicious! I'm so happy to have a new eatery in the area that is original in concept and delivery, and uses fresh, flavorful ingredients. So, so, good! The paninis are large enough to share, or take half home for later. We'll be back again and again and again. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Alan V.

3 years ago

Tried this new Resturant at 4corners area. Food was good and service was good. Paninis were well sized for the price and lots of gelato flavors to choose from. Give it a try read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 3 of 4

24775 N Lake Pleasant Pkwy
Peoria, AZ 85383
Directions
(623) 238-3664
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.fabioonfire.com/panini---gelateria.html

Full menu

Hours

What time does Fabio On Fire open?

Fabio On Fire opens at 11:00 AM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Sunday, Friday and Saturday.

What time does Fabio On Fire close?

Fabio On Fire is closed on Monday.Fabio On Fire closes at 8:00 PM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday.Fabio On Fire closes at 9:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.

Mon ClosedTue-Thu, Sun 11:00 AM - 8:00 PMFri-Sat 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Fabio On Fire take credit cards?

Yes, Fabio On Fire takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Fabio On Fire have catering options?

Yes, Fabio On Fire does have catering options.

Does Fabio On Fire have a drive thru?

No, Fabio On Fire does not have a drive thru.

Does Fabio On Fire serve alcohol?

No, Fabio On Fire does not serve alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Fabio On Fire allow dogs?

Yes, Fabio On Fire allows dogs.

Does Fabio On Fire have TVs?

No, Fabio On Fire does not have TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Fabio On Fire have outdoor seating?

Yes, Fabio On Fire has outdoor seating options.

Does Fabio On Fire have parking?

Yes, Fabio On Fire has parking options. Validated Parking

Other Amenities

Is Fabio On Fire wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Fabio On Fire is wheelchair accessible.

Does Fabio On Fire have free WiFi?

No, Fabio On Fire does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Chef Fabio’s newest concept and 2nd location serving wood-fired panini (authentic Italian sandwiches) - bread baked throughout the day - using select meats and cheese imported from Italy and locally grown vegetables. With the grand finale.. Chef Fabio’s house-made gelato - made fresh daily. Ci vediamo presto | See you soon!

More Info

Health Score

Ask the Community - Fabio On Fire

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria

I've never tried this place or the butcher, but I saw it on too good to go and have been eyeing the…read morebag for a very long time! I finally got the one that is daily up for grans, and I was so excited! My sister and I can't figure out why there's only one bag per day, but it's very coveted so we were excited to see what was actually inside! We walked in to the bakery with the intention of ordering more treats, in addition to what was in the too good to go surprise. When we walked in, it was 10:05, and they closed at 10:30. They had already put away half of their gelato and baked goods in the cabinet. I understand closing time is at 10:30, but if you still have almost half an hour left, I'm sure there are customers that are gonna come in and buy things. There were three parties of people that walked in while we were in there and then sitting out on the really nice patio. There is a little bit of seating inside, but the patio was very nice and there was plenty of seating out there too. The vibe is super cute, and I love the decor. Hopefully next time we go back, we can actually try things because they won't be put away!

Funny enough, my sister & I were watching Nonnas & the first ten minutes made us want the pastries…read more So, we stopped to think where could we get a pastry? I remembered this place. It happened to be a little under twenty minutes away from us so we decided let's do it & they were open late. Hell yeah. There's not a crazy amount of pastries but the selection was great. We got two tiramisus, one vanilla custard lobster tail, some mini cannolis, & the wedding cookies. Everything came out to about $50 so beware, prices aren't exactly cheap. But for one, if you're going to do "bad" then do it right & we also shared with our family of 5 so plenty to go around. & Holy cow, everything was incredible. So indulgent, decadent & rich in flavor. My nephews liked the cannolis, personally they're not my favorite, but if you're into it the mini's are a great option to quench the craving. The lobster tail with the vanilla custard took me by surprise. I didn't think I was going to care for it, but the cold custard was refreshing & the flakiness of the bread was crazy, my taster buds were confused by the textures, but in the best way. They complemented each other well. My ultimate favorite was the tiramisu & the wedding cookies. I honestly wish I had gotten more of the wedding cookies, those things took me back. I grew up eating the Mexican ones & the Italians did it right *applause* But damn, the tiramisu was to die for. I would order that again & again. Perfectly chilled, the dusting of the cocoa powder didn't taste like nesquik--incredible. At first the price had me thinking if we were doing too much, like damn, should we have just gone to Sprouts bakery? But after being able to indulge in a great quality dessert, it was worth every dollar. My only feedback, careful when you're paying at the register. If you're not paying attention, the tip automatically defaults to 18% on the tablet. Only thing I didn't care for. I could see if I was eating at the restaurant, but I just popped in to take pastries to go. So, that was kind of annoying. The service was fine, the girl that helped me was nice, but again I just pointed at desserts I wanted & went home. The location is part of the main restaurant, but it has its own entrance & little room making it feel separate to the Sicilian Butcher. They also carry gelato which I haven't tried yet. I believe they have little tables to sit at also. Highly recommend checking this out so save room for dessert!

Photos

Hmmmmmm.....bring some of these delicious treats

See all

Sign

Gelato Dolce Vita

This place has the best affogatos I've ever had!!! They smush the generous, flavor bomb helping of…read moregelato into the cup so the rich espresso doesn't melt it too quickly. Savor. (My mouth is watering right now) Pleeeez open at 10a in the summer so early morning river runners can have a shot of your heavenly gift.

Yep, this is a local favorite as evidenced by the queue and it is now a favorite of ours!…read more I ordered a small cup containing South African Dark Chocolate and I was richly rewarded. When next our sweet tooth barks at us, Gelato Dolce Vita will be high on our list.

Photos

Stupefy

See all

2 Flavor Medium Container Gelato

That's Amore Gelato

Delicious gelato in Scottsdale! My friends and I came here for an after dinner treat and I'm so…read moreglad we did. The flavor selection is incredible! I had to sample a few before deciding on the biscotto dark. It's a vanilla base swirled with chocolate biscotti flavors that was SO GOOD! I got it in a waffle cone which was equally delicious. The staff working the counter was super sweet and happy to let us sample some flavors. Will definitely be back next time I'm in the area!

The gelato here is phenomenal and the staff is always so kind. As you can see, the selection of…read moregelato is very large! I loved the 3 flavors I have tried so far-coconut, banana and coffee. I also enjoyed their affogato, made with a shot of espresso and amaretto gelato. They also offer paninis and a caprese salad plate. This place is a must if your cravings something sweet.

Photos

Amaretto, Coconut, Key Lime

See all

Frost Gelato at the Biltmore

It was very busy on a Saturday night But they have like…read moreeight employees and an assembly line set up It was fast Tons of choices excellent service I loved my cookies and cream waffle cone

My family picked up four flavors to go at this location. My kids found the whole vibe and…read moreexperience and responsive sample service magical. But most importantly, the gelato was good... although I take SERIOUS issue with bubblegum being a gelato flavor. Can I get an amen?? Not from my kids; that's for sure.

Photos

Beautiful Gelato Cakes

See all

FROST Bites (handmade gelato bon-bons dipped in pure chocolate!

Frost Gelato

What a fun shop in an upscale outdoor shopping mall! The gelato is the best I've ever had and tops…read moreTalenti by several pegs. Service was quick, tasting spoons are provided, and it's very clean and well-lit. The flavors rotate and all gelato is made daily. At our visit tonight the six of us tried multiple flavors. In a small cup you can get a single flavor, two flavors in a medium, and I think three (or four?) in a large. We had three smalls and three mediums for about $45. My son had Sea Salt Caramel and Espresso Bean, my DIL had Sea Salt Caramel, grandkids - twin 2 had a medium of peach sorbet ("Very peachy!"), twin 1 had coconut and raspberry sorbets, Jack had Crème de Biscotti (cookies and cream). I had Sea Salt Caramel and Dark Chocolate and the chocolate was dark as chocolate syrup, rich, creamy, and boasted dark chocolate chunks. I devoured it all. The mall area around us was like a plaza, with white light-wrapped palm trees, umbrella tables with chairs and several artificial turf play areas where littles were tumbling and playing. A great family atmosphere.

Frost is a fun gelato shop located conveniently in the middle of Kierland Commons. I've been a…read morecouple times and gotten the Lotus Cookie (basically Biscoff / cookie butter) both times. It's very good. I've also tried the Peach which was great as well. You can try samples of whichever flavors you want. You can also get two flavors in the same cup. Something about gelato feels lighter than traditional ice cream - but maybe it's just in my head. Staff are always friendly and helpful.

Photos

Voted Best gelato in America Mint chocolate chip and sea salt caramel for my fave Yelper

Totally SPLURGE WORTHY!!!

See all

Entrance

The Gelato Tavern

Family-owned & operated

As Tecora has stated, who would have thought downtown Buckeye would have such wonderful shops such…read moreas The Gelato Tavern?! The Gelato variety is amazing, and I had a mixed-berry. Sinful, with berry pieces in it. I kidded with Joe, the owner (see the photos) that his store looks like an escapee from Scottsdale, without Scottsdale prices. He laughed. There are so many other fun things you can buy there. Joe's so incredibly friendly, and he gave me a sample to try. There's more seating, lots of it, than the pictures imply. It's all beautifully decorated, so you'll enjoy the experience for more than just the gelato. Wherever you dine in the Buckeye area, leave room and stop over at The Gelato Tavern for a fun and incredibly tasty experience! And go next door to Barbon Asadero for a wonderful Mexican lunch or dinner. We dined there first, and had gelato for dessert. As I said, leave room for a gelato dessert wherever you dine!

On the way home from Scottsdale and we didn't want to leave without some gelato to cook us down and…read morewe found the perfect spot! Such a charming, beautiful shop, the owner was so nice and welcoming and gave us samples to try! I love that they have a mini size, it was perfect for me! The one scoop size was very generous! I had the pistachio and it was heavenly, I love that there was no food coloring or anything artificial and with real chunks of pistachio! It really tasted homemade and not too sweet! The blood orange and the mango were so refreshing! The shop has a super comfy couch area perfect for the kids who enjoyed playing jenga while having their gelato! If it wasn't so late I would have been all over the coffee, it smelled soooo good!

Photos

GT Colada

See all

Gelato Tavern New Signage

Gelato Cimmino

4.6

(196 reviews)

24.8 mi

Yum! First time visitor. Decent selection. Opted for 6oz 2 flavors Pistachio and peanut…read morebutter/chocolate. Very good but sweet. I was appreciative that when I asked for the Pistachio the employee asked if I had had it before because it tasted different than what most people expect. The small taste made we want more and so I ordered it and enjoyed it during my stop walking around Scottsdale Old Town.

Date of visit: June 6, 2026…read more This was the final stop on our Arizona Food Tour and was a great way to end the tour. We tried two different flavors and I have to say that both of mine were delicious--really hard to pick which one is better! I went with the chocolate peanut butter cup and the dark chocolate, the two really complimenting each other very well. After hearing the backstory of the family that started the business, I would definitely put Cimmino alongside some of the gelato that I tried in Italy. Staff was friendly and while the space is unassuming, it was a perfectly fine place to hang out until venturing out into the desert heat. So why four stars instead of five? They don't do shakes and that's always my favorite way to enjoy gelato.

Photos

Cookies and cream, strawberry 6 oz $8.50

See all

Bobazona

2/12/2026- Hands down, the best strawberry matcha with vanilla cold foam in Goodyear. I was in…read moreArizona for a week, and this was easily the best matcha I had the entire trip. The balance was perfect -- smooth, earthy matcha, sweet strawberry, and that vanilla cold foam on top just brought it all together. Not too sweet, not too bitter... just right. The employees were incredibly helpful and clearly know how to craft a great matcha. You can tell they care about what they're serving. The ambience was inviting both inside and out -- a great place to sit, relax, and enjoy your drink. If you're anywhere near Goodyear and craving a quality matcha or coffee, don't hesitate to stop by. This one's worth it.

The staff is always friendly and there's always monthly drinks with new concoctions. Your standard…read moredrinks like taro or Thai tea are always hit, but sometimes the new drinks are hit or miss. I recently got a pink blossom which was a Jasmine milk tea with either cherry or strawberry. It was very pretty but tasted a bit medicinal.

Photos

Taro Milk Tea and Guava Jasmine Tea

See all

Bobazona

3.6

(5 reviews)

5.7 mi

So I've been here a few times since my last review. I got prompt service, quick drinks, and they…read moreare exactly what I want. Had to re review this place for sure.

I like the look of this location! It has a unique style and the music choice was great! I didn't…read moreget the name of the young man working however he was working hard and friendly. There were 4 people ahead of us and he helped us all quickly and efficiently, considering he was alone! He said the strawberry sorbet is GF, it was delicious! I have yet to check out their other locations, but if they're anything like this one worth it to stop by!

Photos

See all

Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Always have the best cold stuff to beat the heat I'm glad they are actually varying the flavors now.read more

The manager, calling to defend an employee who got physically angry in front of the customers,…read moreinsulted them, and treated them poorly, isn't somebody who should be manager at all. Count our family out. This is an acceptable behavior from my children, let alone an adult.

Photos

See all

Driftwood Coffee

Everything about this coffee spot was correct. The ambiance, the service, and of course the coffee…read more The barista was excellent, and she even followed up on how our drinks tasted. I'd definitely go back if I lived in this state.

I never knew this coffee shop existed! It's such a cute place in downtown Peoria. Although I live…read morein Peoria, I hadn't explored much of it. It was cool to encounter this place! The service was great, the staff even brought the coffee over to me, I was expected to just be called to grab. I love the mural and the coffee was delicious!

Photos

Decor was great....brought me back to my childhood

See all

Angelica's special

Modo Mio

Family-owned & operated

Gluten-free friendly

Delicious. Will be back! Great service and cozy atmosphere…read more Excellent garlic knots Chicken Parm was excellent

Melissa is our Server, new but very nice and accommodating. The sun was in our face, she asked…read moresomeone to close one of the blinds, it didn't happen so she took it upon herself. House Cosmo is weak??? Trying the Veal Milanese, it was good, not super.

Photos

Basil Pesto Spaghetti with Chicken

Buffalo Wings with ranch

See all

Basil Pesto Spaghetti with Chicken

Bully Brew

4.4

(102 reviews)

16.2 mi

This is hands down my new favorite coffee shop. Espresso is served in a ceramic cup, people are…read morefriendly, lots of seating for working while enjoying coffee, and good music at a reasonable volume. I forgot to take any photos but I'll be back. I have a few hours every Tuesday I need to get some work done and for the foreseeable future this will be my workspace. Update: second trip was just as good as the first! Pictures added! Update 2: I've been here 4 times now and every time I've gotten excellent food and service. It remains a perfect place to work. Plenty of seating and music choice and volume are ideal. Love it here!

Matcha + breakfast tacos = yes please!! Bully Brew Co. in Peoria is such a welcoming coffee shop…read morewith ethically sourced coffee, creative specialty drinks, and a relaxed community vibe. It's the kind of spot where you can slow down, fuel up, or grab something quick and delicious. I went with the iced matcha and the breakfast taco trio (bacon, egg, and cheddar wrapped in taco tortillas) and both were SO good together. Simple, flavorful, and the perfect little breakfast combo.

Photos

Iced Matcha & 8oz Cappuccino

Rear seating area

See all

Hallway with seating

Bee Happy Boba Tea

Came specifically for their BBH. I was happy about was the meat and pork hock!! All ingredients…read morewere there. The chili oil tasted home made. Broth flavor wasn't for me. Vietnamese coffee - mocha flavor condensed milk. Im a bit of a coffee snob so I prefer ca phe den with just a little condensed milk. I let the cashier know to take it easy on the condensed milk. Beautiful patio area. Lots of flies though. Don't recommend eating outside. Casual drinks and talks for sure. Indoors had a great seating area. I'll have to try it out again.

Came to Bee Happy Boba Tea on a Sunday evening. The location was clean, bright, and welcoming, with…read moreseating available both indoors and outdoors. The side patio was especially nice, decorated with string lights and offering outdoor games like Connect 4, which gave the space a relaxed and fun atmosphere for family or friends! We ordered a classic Thai tea with honey boba. The drink itself was prepared very quickly, which was appreciated. The tea had a balanced sweetness and creaminess that made it both flavorful and refreshing. The boba, however, was smaller than average in size, which may have affected the overall chewiness and texture. The outside was soft and sweet, while the inside had a slightly starchy texture. I'm not sure if this experience was because we came close to closing time, but that was really my only complaint. This visit, we didn't order the pho, although it seemed very popular among other customers in the shop. The aroma of the broth filled the restaurant and honestly smelled really good and tempting throughout our visit. Overall, I'd return to give the boba another try and possibly try the pho next time as well.

Photos

Vietnamese egg rolls, 2 for $5

Order counter

See all

Mango Smoothie and Vietnamese Coffee Smoothie with Sea Salt

Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream

4.4

(70 reviews)

10.7 mi

This is a treat you need! They have so many great ice cream flavors and ways to serve them. There…read moreare misters and kids playground out front to enjoy there. The people that serve are really helpful in suggestions for a new flavor. Go to a movie and then come to Handel's afterward. Great date night.

We placed an order through Uber for pickup since we had some credits to use, and the process was…read morevery easy. We ordered the two-scoop special for under $8--strawberry cheesecake and Oreo ice cream. We were able to go straight to the pickup area and avoid the line, and our order was prepared right away. We enjoyed our ice cream while sitting off to the side. There are chairs and tables in an open area where kids can play, or you can simply relax and enjoy your treats. The location is in a plaza surrounded by other businesses like Grimaldi's Pizzeria, Cold Beers & Cheeseburgers, and Bath & Body Works, which makes it a nice spot to visit.

Photos

Storefront

Blueberry Cobbler in a cake cone. This is a SMALL!! =O

See all

808 Social

Live Aloha and drink coffee is my kind of motto to stand by! We took my boys to Hawaii last summer…read moreand now they want more than anything to go back. Since that's not always possible it's nice finding gems like 808 Social to bring some Aloha spirit back into our mundane daily routines. My husband and I both enjoyed some island flavored coffee while the kids had some refreshing pretty drinks that looked like Aloha magic. (Edible glitter) We came to 808 Social on one of their pop up days and were able to catch other vendors that made this trip a one stop visit. We were able to get flavorful ono lunch, tasty dessert, and yummy drinks to finish it all off. Everyone was so welcoming and service was top tier. The ambiance was family friendly and you could definitely feel the ohana vibes. We adore 808 Social a LATTE and can't wait to come back!

808 Coffee has the kind of welcoming atmosphere that makes a great first impression. From the…read moremoment I walked in, the space felt bright, inviting, and effortlessly laid-back. It's the type of coffee shop where you can easily lose track of time, whether you're catching up with a friend, getting some work done, or simply taking a break to enjoy a really good cup of coffee. What stood out most to me was the quality of the coffee. Every sip tasted thoughtfully crafted, smooth, and balanced, with the kind of attention to detail that's easy to appreciate. You can tell this isn't a place that's simply serving coffee--it's a place that's passionate about the craft behind it. The staff was genuinely friendly and welcoming, adding to the overall experience without making it feel rushed. It's those little interactions, paired with a cozy atmosphere and well-made drinks, that turn a coffee stop into somewhere you actually look forward to returning. 808 Coffee is the kind of neighborhood café that reminds me why I enjoy exploring local coffee shops. It's approachable, unpretentious, and focused on doing the basics exceptionally well. If you're someone who appreciates quality coffee, a comfortable atmosphere, and warm hospitality, this is absolutely a spot worth checking out.

Photos

Entrance area is clean and pleasant looking

See all

808 Latte

The Well Coffee Company

Great coffee quality, with reasonable price, and the staff were friendly. I had their honey…read morelavender latte and hot americano, love their honey lavender syrup, I got half sweet and the sweetness was perfect. Definitely will come back and try more coffees.

Such a beautiful spot, what I love most about this place is how spacious it is, indoor outdoor…read moreseating. Their seasonal menu is always fun, I have enjoyed everything I have tried and there is so much space to set up and work / study. Service is fast!

Photos

Inside

Chocolate covered coffee beans!

See all

4PeakChallenge cookies with a Peanut Brittle Latte

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Beth S.

Elite 24

3 years ago

Fabio on Fire, Gelateria and Panini in Peoria, Arizona, has quickly become my favorite spot for a delightful culinary experience. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the kind and attentive staff, setting the stage for an unforgettable visit. What truly sets Fabio on Fire apart is the exceptional freshness of their ingredients. From the first bite, it's evident that they prioritize quality and flavor. The gelato, in particular, is a true masterpiece. Each scoop is rich, creamy, and bursting with authentic Italian flavors. From classic favorites like pistachio and stracciatella to unique creations like salted caramel and tiramisu, there is a flavor to satisfy every palate. The panini offerings at Fabio on Fire are equally impressive. The ingredients are carefully selected and expertly combined to create mouthwatering sandwiches. The bread is perfectly toasted, providing a delightful crunch, while the fillings are generous and flavorful. Whether you opt for a traditional Caprese or venture into their specialty panini options, you can expect a satisfying and delicious meal. The staff at Fabio on Fire is incredibly kind, friendly, and passionate about their craft. They are always ready to offer recommendations and ensure that every customer has a memorable experience. Their warm hospitality adds an extra layer of enjoyment to the already fantastic food. The gelateria itself is clean, inviting, and exudes a charming Italian ambiance. It's the perfect place to relax and indulge in the delightful flavors of gelato while enjoying the company of friends or family. In terms of value, Fabio on Fire offers a fantastic balance between quality and affordability. The portions are generous, and the prices are reasonable, making it a great choice for a satisfying and enjoyable treat. If you find yourself in Peoria, Arizona, and craving a taste of Italy, Fabio on Fire, Gelateria and Panini is an absolute must-visit. With their incredibly fresh ingredients, kind staff, and delicious gelato and panini offerings, it's a culinary journey that will leave you craving for more. I can't recommend this place enough, and I'm already planning my next visit to explore more of their delightful menu. read more

Nina S.

174

414

1 year ago

Huge fan of Fabio on Fire and have been a customer for years. This location feels like a cozy little shop in Italy. Today, Fabio himself brought my order out to my car. It doesn't get more authentic than that, until you try the food! If you're going for a panini, my favorite is the Luciano. The Margherita pizza is a non-negotiable. The dough is both soft and crispy, baked just right every time. They have some drinks and pastas imported from Italy available to purchase. I'll be back next week to finally try out their gelato so stay tuned for that update! read more

Fabio On Fire - gelato - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Fabio On Fire also viewed

That Place Subs and Salads

179 reviews

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria

109 reviews

A Gourmet Sandwiches

57 reviews

AGourmet

100 reviews

Betty's Rooste Sun City West

103 reviews

Panini Bread and Grill

330 reviews

Black and White Cafe

337 reviews

Yummy Yummy Crepes & Snacks

65 reviews

Westy's Organic Kitchen & Juice

45 reviews

Cafe Solaz

8 reviews

Fabio On Fire

Order Fabio On Fire Takeout or Delivery

Fabio On Fire Photos

Business Info

Fabio On Fire Popular Dishes

Fabio On Fire menu photos

FABIO ON FIRE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Fabio On Fire

Reviews With Photos

Review Insights

More info about Fabio On Fire

Payment methods

Food & Alcohol

Indoor Amenities

Outdoor Amenities

Other Amenities

Ask the Community - Fabio On Fire

You might also consider

More businesses like Fabio On Fire

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria

Gelato Dolce Vita

That's Amore Gelato

Frost Gelato at the Biltmore

Frost Gelato

The Gelato Tavern

Gelato Cimmino

Bobazona

Bobazona

Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Trending businesses in Fabio On Fire's area

Driftwood Coffee

Modo Mio

Bully Brew

Bee Happy Boba Tea

Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream

808 Social

The Well Coffee Company

2 Fabio On Fire reviews that are not currently recommended

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

Fabio On Fire - gelato - Updated July 2026

Best of Peoria

People found Fabio On Fire by searching for…

Trending Searches in Peoria, AZ

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Peoria, AZ

Browse Articles

People who viewed Fabio On Fire also viewed