My husband and I went to the bank next to Fantasy Pizza yesterday and decided to try a slice. My husband is from NY and is very picky about his pizza, but he loved the pizza we were served. We had the lunch special, two slices and a drink and we added Italian sausage and onions. All the ingredients were fresh, and it was cooked to a perfection. The atmosphere is also nice. The restaurant displays sports memorabilia from south Florida teams and events including car races. They have several TVs, but they are on mute. I am guessing they are muted so patrons can listen the radio. I was not there during game time, but I am sure if there was a game being televised, the volume would be up on the TV instead. For me, the deciding factor in returning to a restaurant is whether it is clean. Fantasy Pizza is very clean, including the bathrooms. We liked it so much, we decided to go back today and take our daughter. Our 'kids' are adults now, but they are true pizza connoisseurs too. read more

Ok so i am so impressed with this place's customer service that I went out of my way to download this app, create an account and write this review, just to give them the credit they deserve. Im not going to go into detail but there's was an issue in the kitchen with our large meat lovers and they took care of it right away and went above and beyond. Their service has gained a customer for life. And That's not even mentioning how amazing the actual pizza was. Good New York style pie with an amazing crust. It's rare to find a crust that isn't like you're chewing through an old catchers mitt but these guys mastered a crust that is crispy and not a struggle to eat. Impressive :) read more

There aren't enough great things we can say about the pizza we had tonight. We had the Ultra Supreme Pizza. It was OMG good!!!!! It was perfect!!! Full of flavor. Loaded with toppings. The crust was phenomenal. Then we tried the home made garlic rolls. WOW!!!! Then as if it couldn't get any better, we tried the home made Zeppoles. Those were heaven on Earth !!! The place was very clean and nicely decorated. Dave is the owner and the chef. He was very friendly. It's DEFINATELY a must go to place!!! WE'LL BE BACK!!! read more

I stop by to eat at dennys past sunday, but the place was packed. so, I decided to eat next door at fantasy Pizza. What a Great Idea. Food was awesome and the service was great. I ate a philly cheese steak like I never ate b4. I saw the guy making right in front of me, he sautee all the veggies and steak at the time that i ordered. I never saw any place making subs fresh at order. the best thing was. 6.99 with a free soda. My kids ate Pizza , that was pretty good too. I will be back for SURE. Thank you guys. read more

This is a nice NY style sports-themed pizzeria. The dining room is spacious, and the atmosphere is laid-back. This was our first time, and our waitress was super friendly and helpful. They have family specials and also serve slices. The pizza is thin, big, and greasy - just the way I like it! The crust is nicely toasted and crispy, too. If you're not in the mood for pizza, they also have subs, salads, and pasta dishes. Do yourself a favor, I know it sounds wierd, but check out the bathroom. It's a hoot! read more

This is my favorite pizza place so far. It was my first time eating at FANTASY PIZZA. Great place, nice and clean. Our waitress was very nice and she helped us deciding what to eat. The food was AMAZING. We went for Lunch. They've $7.99 lunch deal. We ate Chicken Parmigiana and Chicken alla Vodka simply delicious, it came with soup or salad and Homemade Garlic Rolls. I recommend this place. It was an amazing food experience for me and I'm sure for you too. read more

Coming from Chicago, the bar for me was set pretty high as far as pizza goes. Fantasy Pizza met my expectations with their New York thin crust pizza. When dinning in, the service is friendly and fast! They even cut up the pizza in tiny pieces for young kids if needed. If you want to eat at home, you could order online and they call to confirm your order within minutes. Delivery of your order is also fast. This is one of my favorite places to eat pizza. read more

We live in Pembroke Pines and have been coming to Fantasy Pizza since they first opened. The pizza is the best. The lasagnia, chicken wings and garlic rolls are second to none. The staff are always friendly. Jarrod always treats us like family. Some pizza places tend to choose cheaper ingredients and recipes after a few years of business. Not Fantasy Pizza. Fantasy Pizza has chosen to provide the best quality pizza since day one. Thanks read more

Great service! Great food! Nice atmosphere. I was very impressed with the taste and quality. It reminds me of true New York style cuisine. The prices were inexpensive for the quality of the food being offered. This restaurant offered a great variation of delicious menu options. I almost could not decide! I wanted it all lol. I definitely recommend this restaurant to any and all in the area. My friends and I will definitely be back soon! read more

ok so to start this place is a little gem. The dining room is decorated in helmet's and jerseys its a sports fanatics dream. the two tvs show nothing but sports and as a guy its heaven. the pizza is fantastic its the perfect sauce to cheese ratio and crispy and I couldn't picture it getting better. we got breaded wings and I might have been in buffalo because darn they taste authentic. we will definetly make this place a sunday hangout. read more

Weve been eating here for the last year and we still love it!! I love the pizza here!! This is the best pizza I've found in the Pembroke pines area and we tried every place even the expensive ones! But just some words of wisdom The pizza is the best when you and for extra sause It makes me hungry just thinking about it and my pizza dident even come yet I'm actually sitting here right now waiting and omg I'm excited read more

I'm not only from NY but I'm from Brooklyn (Bensonhurst) NY where they know how to make pizza. I am in the area visiting and happen to come to this pizzeria and I must say in the 4 years I've lived in Florida I must say this is the best pizza I've had since living here. So do yourself a favor if you're looking for pizza look no further than Fantasy Pizza you won't regret it. I promise!! read more

Fantasy pizza is a delicious pizzeria. Everyone who works here is friendly the food is delicious And the service is great from the moment I walked in the door I could not feel any more welcomed. It was more welcoming than my own house. I might move here but I don't think they would let me. On a serious note everything is great and I recommend it anyone in the area craving a good pizza read more

Great pizza! We've been searching for a new pizza haunt since we moved here four months ago but have yet to find our spot; I think we just found it. A lot of places promise New York style in the area, but leave you wanting. This place is the Real Deal Holyfield! Prices are very reasonable, too. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. I will definitely be going back! read more

The food here is amazing! Always clean. The pizza actually taste like an even distribution of pizza instead of just loads of grease. I really love the Great prices. Stopped by once just being curious, hooked ever since. Definitely tell you mother, father, sister, brother, even your friends. Just don't tell your neighbors it'll be a little awkward, trust me. read more

My wife and I absolutely loved this place. Its really a hidden jewel. The staff are always so hospitable and welcoming. They have a lunch specials all week long before 4pm. My favorite is the 2 slices and drink for $4.99. Great kids menu too. This place does not get the recognition it deserves, truly your neighborhood pizaa joint, but its far from average. read more

I love bringing my kids to fantasy pizza after school. Everyone is so friendly. The pizza is always fresh, my kids especially enjoy watching the pizza man toss the pizza in the air. The slices are huge. I frequently come to fantasy and the waitresses are always so attentive. I would recommend fantasy to everyone and best of all they have great prices. read more

Best pizza spot in Pines! The 2 slice & soda lunch for $6 is my go to on my lunch breaks. Pizza is always hot & fresh & the waits are always minimal. Place is always clean which is rare for pizza spots! Great service as well, Natalia the cashier is very friendly & offers awesome customer service. Highly recommended. If i could give 6 stars i would! read more

Amazing pizza; the closest to NY style pizza in all of Florida. the pasta is great as well, I usually get the sausage and peppers pasta and that never fails to taste great and fill me up. They have veal as well but I have not et to try it. Soon I will and I do not doubt that it will be amazing just like everything else on the menu! read more