Order Fat Sully's Pizza Takeout or Delivery
Fat Sully's Pizza Photos
FAT SULLY'S PIZZA ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Fat Sully's Pizza
Recommended Reviews - Fat Sully's Pizza
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
We were craving some pizza and decided to check this place out. It had a cool sport's bar type vibe. You order your pizza by the slice and they are not small at all. If you like a super thin doughy type crust this place is for you. The service was great but we weren't really impressed with the pizza. The garlic knots on the other hand are where the flavor is. IF I went back it would only be for the knots.
Everyone was welcoming and food was delicious. The highlight was the Parmesan garlic wings and the buffalo wings , especially the parmesan garlic. The pesto garlic knots are also to die for! They ran out of a-lot of items we wanted but that's because they had an art festive in the day but they accommodated us the beat they could.
I was disappointed to find out that they stop serving biscuits at 3pm and it's only Fat Sullys. It took a while for them to take our order, we were acknowledged immediately, but the guy was busy at the time. No problem at all. I ordered anyway. I got mushrooms, black olives, Italian sausage, and tender belly. My sister ordered onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, and spinach. Both slices looked very dry. To our surprise the pizza had a good taste. It was $17 for our two slices. I'm glad I got it but I wouldn't be in a rush to order again. There was a takeout window that we ordered out with some outside seating. It was a pretty chill ambiance. But I am looking forward to getting biscuits in the morning.
Walked past here the other day, and just had to stop by. Loved the dining area with the massive open windows, it made for a relaxing, casual spot to be on such a sunny day. Ordered a couple beers, plus a slice of pizza, a side Caesar salad, and some wings. The pizza slice was GIANT, and the wing portion was more than filling, ended up with some leftover. Really enjoyed the NYC style pizza, not too thick, and a good balance of cheese and sauce! Our server was friendly, prompt, and even offered some Denver-made hot sauces to go with the slice - so good! Will definitely be back another sunny day.
Best Pizza in Missouri!! Hands down the best. We were visiting Kansas City for five days and we ate at this restaurant 3 1/2 of the five days. It was that delicious incredible. The customer service was excellent and the ambience with all the glass windows and rollup garage doors made you feel like you're sitting outside. The pizzas were all incredible. Love that you got to pick your own toppings. BEST Pizza, Missouri
We were in KC visiting friends and family. We meet up with Jason and Emily for a brunch. What a great choice to have brunch. When we got there J and E were wait outside for us. We waited for about 20-30 minutes before we sat down. The weather was super nice at that time. We aren't used to cold weather, but it was nice that time of day. The parking is mostly street parking. They have a really small parking area, but there is plenty of room inside. Restaurant is super nice inside, a full bar and plenty of beer on tap and liquor. It was also brunch time, so they had mimosas.i got me a Pabst Blue Ribbon, just cause I've never had one on tap. It was great. Maria asked for coffee, they said it was self serve, so Maria said she's on vacation and didn't get coffee, my wife is silly. Our waiter had a great sense of humor and made our time there great. Once we got to our table, I noticed that my seat and the floor was dirty. This is the only knock on this place. I just wiped down the seat and sat down. I had the Nashville hot chicken biscuit, wow. It was juicy and not too spicy. I was one the fence on what to try so I just went with this one. Maria had the Lola, which was chicken in a biscuit with bacon and covered in maple syrup. This is more my speed, but I was worried about the syrup and chicken combo. I don't know why, I like sweet and salty. Maria made a great choice. J had a smash burger. He said it was great. E had biscuits and gravy, bacon and hash browns. It all looked great. I normally eat off every one plate, but this was our first meeting and I didn't want to come of as a pig. lol Made it to the bathrooms, and they were clean. I look forward to going back here as soon as possible.
Great pizza! Got a slice of pizza for the first time here today. It was so good!! It is huge like bigger than your face. you get to pick your sauce and toppings. such a great size. service was really nice and fast. there's a drive thru window thing that you order from outside. it takes about 10 minutes. will be back!
So I need to start buy saying that all pizza is good, just different levels of good. I would 1000% get the garlic knots and go back for the garlic knots. The cheese, red sauce, pesto and garlic with bread is done perfectly. The pizza slice is a fine. The toppings are high quality but the dough didn't get crispy and lacked flavor for me. This is in the ranking that all pizza is good, I would eat it again.
Be prepared -- the pizzas are HUGE! Don't send your tiny roommate to pick up 2 pizzas by herself! The 2 ft diameter pizzas will feed you for days, and they are pretty tasty! We like to order feta and artichoke hearts on ours. I like that the pizzas are "well done" because you get some nice char on the underside of the thin crust! You can also order by the slice for certain toppings that are available! I definitely recommend getting the loaded garlic knots! The basil pesto that is drizzled on top is delicious! We also really enjoyed the loaded fries because of the delicious vegetarian gravy and the cheese sauce, but the fries got a little soggy. Love the seasoning on the fries though! Salty and sweet. The cinnamon dessert balls were pretty good as well! Not super exciting. For some reason, ordering online and picking up is always a little confusing. At least with Fat Sully's, the food usually shows up at the pick up window located on the patio (unlike Denver Biscuit Co where I never know where the food is going to be picked up from)! But the last time we ordered online, the restaurant claimed they hadn't received the order despite me getting a confirmation email and my card getting charged! Eventually we got it all straightened out and received everything we ordered, but it never seems to be a seamless process when we order from here online.
This New York style pizza joint is slowly but surely replacing my go-to in the city, I won't dare mention the name or a local legend (maybe by the name of Stretch or maybe not...) probably will disown me from being a true Kansas Citian. Maybe, its just the fact that the beers on tap at Sully's impress me a lot over the fact that the chipotle ranch there is just the bomb.com but, call me crazy I think I prefer to be Fat over than to be Grinded. The beers are always rotating and the bar at Fat Sully's never seems to be too full, even during a Chiefs game, which in Westport is an anomaly. My favorite beer has to be the Bootstrap Lushpuppy IPA, if you aren't adverse to IPAs that have fruity notes to them then you will definitely enjoy this beer. Now enough with the yapping about beers and name dropping other New York style pizzerias smack dab in the middle of the Midwest, let us get into the meaty stuff, quite literally and figuratively. The food at Fat Sully's isn't anything too adventurous however, what they do they do well. The "big ass slice" never disappoints especially when it is loaded down with so many quality toppings that it becomes hard to fold in half and eat like a so-called true New Yorker, though I've never met one myself... At Fat Sully's though each topping does cost a whopping 70 cents, which I do find a tad too close to $1 but, they are not shy when it comes to piling on the peppers (or pepperonis) and also having fun toppings like feta and jalapenos, not to mention my personal favorite the adorable mini meatballs, makes making a slice interesting. I have two three topping slice recommendations for the newbie, first would be feta, green pepper and those cute little mini meatballs and the next would be jalapenos, feta and mushrooms (sounds weird but believe me it's delicious.) and don't forget the mandatory sides of spicy ranch that is indeed housemade, not made anywhere near the valley that's hidden. Hold on though! If a huge slice of 'za doesn't tickle your fancy not to fear...Fat Sully's is also a biscuit bar by day and offers other bar bite staples on the menu such as a kick ass burger and a flavor packed pile of waffle fries covered in scrumptious disco gravy. And, the best part of it is these two dishes are part of their awesome extensive happy hour menu where drafts are $5 and cocktails are $6 and that mouth watering double meat mountain is only $6 as well, but if you are ever craving that burger and it isn't happy hours don't fret because it rings in under $10 anyways. Making that double diner patty style burger sure to coat your fingers with buttery goodness one of my top contenders for best bargain burger in the city.
Attempting to try another pizza place while I'm visiting Kansas on a quick work trip. I ordered delivery so I can't tell you if the atmosphere is worthy but I can tell you about the pizza. It's meh. Not horrible but nothing I'd order again. The sauce has a bit of a sour taste. The crust is traditional but the combo was mediocre. The salad was good.
If you're looking for a pizza place around Westport to eat at, Fat Sully's Pizza is a great choice! Inside of the place is cool. The "Big ass pizza" and burgers were hands down appetizing! Service and ambiance was awesome! Will return if I crave for a good pizza!
Sat Jan 23rd. We have heard good things about the size of their pizza. I took the kids down to pick up the biggest Pizza that we could get. Garlic, Pepperoni & Bacon are the toppings that we choose. I added a little parmesan dust to the pizza, the size is amazing, but the flavor of the crust texture, toppings were 3/5. I can not say that I was wowed enough to try it again over other options. There is a unique atmosphere, ordering at the window, combined with another restaurant...all pretty cool. You should come out and try your pallet choices on the menu.
2 years ago
Amazing joint for the classics! I ordered the slice of pizza (beware it it huge) and parmesan garlic wings and both tasted so fresh and tasty! Service was awesome. Atmosphere is perfect for late night casual outing with friends or even a date night as there is a bar and some table games available. I really enjoyed my food, glad to have discovered this spot! read more
1 year ago
One of my favorite pizza spots! The slices are huge, the crust is perfect, and it's always super satisfying. Great place to grab a quick, delicious bite doesn't disappoint read more
Food - good for NY style pizza and they have a late night window too on 80th for quick drive in/by orders. Service - good Ambiance - big spacious place with a good size bar to sit at. Pizza/Burgers/Biscuit sandwiches (till 2pm) all in the same place! Had the single smash the other day - tasty Tried a MYO slice today, Pepperoni, Garlic, Mushrooms. A big 'u sure u can handle this?' Slice of very thin crust NY style pizza. Tascio's and Buffalo State may have some competition here. If you don't order cheese on the slice, then there may not be any on it. Good taste with a healthy addition of parmesean, pepper flakes, and pepper/salt, per your taste. Good bar options for beverages/beer/happy hour drinks etc. Parking is a little dicey as you have to either park @ Mi Ranchito/Homer's, along 80th street, or maybe as "far" as down by Strang Hall. They do charge per topping (about .40) when ordering a slice OR a whole pie (more for the whole pizza), ends up (possibly) more than Minsky's for same 2, 3 or more toppings. Small side o' Ranch is an up-charge as well. read more
1 year ago
We were craving some pizza and decided to check this place out. It had a cool sport's bar type vibe. You order your pizza by the slice and they are not small at all. If you like a super thin doughy type crust this place is for you. The service was great but we weren't really impressed with the pizza. The garlic knots on the other hand are where the flavor is. IF I went back it would only be for the knots. read more
2 years ago
Everyone was welcoming and food was delicious. The highlight was the Parmesan garlic wings and the buffalo wings , especially the parmesan garlic. The pesto garlic knots are also to die for! They ran out of a-lot of items we wanted but that's because they had an art festive in the day but they accommodated us the beat they could. read more
I was disappointed to find out that they stop serving biscuits at 3pm and it's only Fat Sullys. It took a while for them to take our order, we were acknowledged immediately, but the guy was busy at the time. No problem at all. I ordered anyway. I got mushrooms, black olives, Italian sausage, and tender belly. My sister ordered onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, and spinach. Both slices looked very dry. To our surprise the pizza had a good taste. It was $17 for our two slices. I'm glad I got it but I wouldn't be in a rush to order again. There was a takeout window that we ordered out with some outside seating. It was a pretty chill ambiance. But I am looking forward to getting biscuits in the morning. read more
3 years ago
Walked past here the other day, and just had to stop by. Loved the dining area with the massive open windows, it made for a relaxing, casual spot to be on such a sunny day. Ordered a couple beers, plus a slice of pizza, a side Caesar salad, and some wings. The pizza slice was GIANT, and the wing portion was more than filling, ended up with some leftover. Really enjoyed the NYC style pizza, not too thick, and a good balance of cheese and sauce! Our server was friendly, prompt, and even offered some Denver-made hot sauces to go with the slice - so good! Will definitely be back another sunny day. read more
2 years ago
Best Pizza in Missouri!! Hands down the best. We were visiting Kansas City for five days and we ate at this restaurant 3 1/2 of the five days. It was that delicious incredible. The customer service was excellent and the ambience with all the glass windows and rollup garage doors made you feel like you're sitting outside. The pizzas were all incredible. Love that you got to pick your own toppings. BEST Pizza, Missouri read more
We were in KC visiting friends and family. We meet up with Jason and Emily for a brunch. What a great choice to have brunch. When we got there J and E were wait outside for us. We waited for about 20-30 minutes before we sat down. The weather was super nice at that time. We aren't used to cold weather, but it was nice that time of day. The parking is mostly street parking. They have a really small parking area, but there is plenty of room inside. Restaurant is super nice inside, a full bar and plenty of beer on tap and liquor. It was also brunch time, so they had mimosas.i got me a Pabst Blue Ribbon, just cause I've never had one on tap. It was great. Maria asked for coffee, they said it was self serve, so Maria said she's on vacation and didn't get coffee, my wife is silly. Our waiter had a great sense of humor and made our time there great. Once we got to our table, I noticed that my seat and the floor was dirty. This is the only knock on this place. I just wiped down the seat and sat down. I had the Nashville hot chicken biscuit, wow. It was juicy and not too spicy. I was one the fence on what to try so I just went with this one. Maria had the Lola, which was chicken in a biscuit with bacon and covered in maple syrup. This is more my speed, but I was worried about the syrup and chicken combo. I don't know why, I like sweet and salty. Maria made a great choice. J had a smash burger. He said it was great. E had biscuits and gravy, bacon and hash browns. It all looked great. I normally eat off every one plate, but this was our first meeting and I didn't want to come of as a pig. lol Made it to the bathrooms, and they were clean. I look forward to going back here as soon as possible. read more
Great pizza! Got a slice of pizza for the first time here today. It was so good!! It is huge like bigger than your face. you get to pick your sauce and toppings. such a great size. service was really nice and fast. there's a drive thru window thing that you order from outside. it takes about 10 minutes. will be back! read more
4 years ago
So I need to start buy saying that all pizza is good, just different levels of good. I would 1000% get the garlic knots and go back for the garlic knots. The cheese, red sauce, pesto and garlic with bread is done perfectly. The pizza slice is a fine. The toppings are high quality but the dough didn't get crispy and lacked flavor for me. This is in the ranking that all pizza is good, I would eat it again. read more
Be prepared -- the pizzas are HUGE! Don't send your tiny roommate to pick up 2 pizzas by herself! The 2 ft diameter pizzas will feed you for days, and they are pretty tasty! We like to order feta and artichoke hearts on ours. I like that the pizzas are "well done" because you get some nice char on the underside of the thin crust! You can also order by the slice for certain toppings that are available! I definitely recommend getting the loaded garlic knots! The basil pesto that is drizzled on top is delicious! We also really enjoyed the loaded fries because of the delicious vegetarian gravy and the cheese sauce, but the fries got a little soggy. Love the seasoning on the fries though! Salty and sweet. The cinnamon dessert balls were pretty good as well! Not super exciting. For some reason, ordering online and picking up is always a little confusing. At least with Fat Sully's, the food usually shows up at the pick up window located on the patio (unlike Denver Biscuit Co where I never know where the food is going to be picked up from)! But the last time we ordered online, the restaurant claimed they hadn't received the order despite me getting a confirmation email and my card getting charged! Eventually we got it all straightened out and received everything we ordered, but it never seems to be a seamless process when we order from here online. read more
This New York style pizza joint is slowly but surely replacing my go-to in the city, I won't dare mention the name or a local legend (maybe by the name of Stretch or maybe not...) probably will disown me from being a true Kansas Citian. Maybe, its just the fact that the beers on tap at Sully's impress me a lot over the fact that the chipotle ranch there is just the bomb.com but, call me crazy I think I prefer to be Fat over than to be Grinded. The beers are always rotating and the bar at Fat Sully's never seems to be too full, even during a Chiefs game, which in Westport is an anomaly. My favorite beer has to be the Bootstrap Lushpuppy IPA, if you aren't adverse to IPAs that have fruity notes to them then you will definitely enjoy this beer. Now enough with the yapping about beers and name dropping other New York style pizzerias smack dab in the middle of the Midwest, let us get into the meaty stuff, quite literally and figuratively. The food at Fat Sully's isn't anything too adventurous however, what they do they do well. The "big ass slice" never disappoints especially when it is loaded down with so many quality toppings that it becomes hard to fold in half and eat like a so-called true New Yorker, though I've never met one myself... At Fat Sully's though each topping does cost a whopping 70 cents, which I do find a tad too close to $1 but, they are not shy when it comes to piling on the peppers (or pepperonis) and also having fun toppings like feta and jalapenos, not to mention my personal favorite the adorable mini meatballs, makes making a slice interesting. I have two three topping slice recommendations for the newbie, first would be feta, green pepper and those cute little mini meatballs and the next would be jalapenos, feta and mushrooms (sounds weird but believe me it's delicious.) and don't forget the mandatory sides of spicy ranch that is indeed housemade, not made anywhere near the valley that's hidden. Hold on though! If a huge slice of 'za doesn't tickle your fancy not to fear...Fat Sully's is also a biscuit bar by day and offers other bar bite staples on the menu such as a kick ass burger and a flavor packed pile of waffle fries covered in scrumptious disco gravy. And, the best part of it is these two dishes are part of their awesome extensive happy hour menu where drafts are $5 and cocktails are $6 and that mouth watering double meat mountain is only $6 as well, but if you are ever craving that burger and it isn't happy hours don't fret because it rings in under $10 anyways. Making that double diner patty style burger sure to coat your fingers with buttery goodness one of my top contenders for best bargain burger in the city. read more
3 years ago
Attempting to try another pizza place while I'm visiting Kansas on a quick work trip. I ordered delivery so I can't tell you if the atmosphere is worthy but I can tell you about the pizza. It's meh. Not horrible but nothing I'd order again. The sauce has a bit of a sour taste. The crust is traditional but the combo was mediocre. The salad was good. read more
If you're looking for a pizza place around Westport to eat at, Fat Sully's Pizza is a great choice! Inside of the place is cool. The "Big ass pizza" and burgers were hands down appetizing! Service and ambiance was awesome! Will return if I crave for a good pizza! read more
Business owner information
Atomic C.
Thanks for the review! Look forward to seeing you again!
Sat Jan 23rd. We have heard good things about the size of their pizza. I took the kids down to pick up the biggest Pizza that we could get. Garlic, Pepperoni & Bacon are the toppings that we choose. I added a little parmesan dust to the pizza, the size is amazing, but the flavor of the crust texture, toppings were 3/5. I can not say that I was wowed enough to try it again over other options. There is a unique atmosphere, ordering at the window, combined with another restaurant...all pretty cool. You should come out and try your pallet choices on the menu. read more
4 years ago
Such a fun location for good food and hangouts! I came by with a friend after work, just minutes before they were starting trivia. I had absolutely no idea that they hosted trivia nights, but I'll definitely have to come back for it some time! I got a slice of pizza with pineapples (I said what I said) and jalapeños, and wow! I did not realize it was this huge! The pizza was absolutely full of flavor, and the best part was that it still had a bit of dough despite being New York style. I'm usually not the biggest fan of it because it's too thin, but Fat Sully's pizza was perfect. I also got the loaded garlic knots and tried them with both sauces - they were delicious both ways and I took them to go as well. I had an amazing time and can't wait to come back! read more
Not many combos better than pizza and beer! Fat Sully's does it right. MASSIVE slices of NY style thin crust pizza with every topping you could think of. Really appreciated the bartenders who were very friendly and helpful deciphering between the different menus. Highly recommend the Sully's fries which are waffle fries with gravy (we did a combo of sausage and mushroom), pimento cheese, bacon, and green onions. They also had a strong draft list with plenty of rotating tap options. Love it! read more
3 years ago
Very good New York style pizza. Pepperoni and extra cheese this time. Only complaint is that it arrived cold, but probably due to the distance it had to be delivered. If it were hot, I'll bet it would have been even better. Also, the pizzas are huge. Caesar salad was better than most as well for a pizza place. read more
Come here with 4 people and try to tear up 26" of pure awesomeness....I dare you. Plain ole pepperoni. What more do you need? Maybe one of their delicious drinks. I LOVE their smokin' cocktail (name??) that has habanero syrup in it. I can't stop at only having 1. So good. Good enough to buy one of their cool t-shirts for my husband. That's all you need to know. Come give them your business! read more
Business owner information
Atomic C.
Thanks for the awesome review! Come try our Burger, pinky promise you…
I have been searching for a quality pizza here in Kc. I am from the east coast so one thing I know is great pizza. I was a bit confused when I walked in....was I going to Denver Biscuit, Sulleys or Frozen Gold? They are all three together in one. If you don't want to dine in you can go to the pick up window and place an order for your pizza. One slice if pizza is $4.50 and to add toppings are .70 I think my slice ended up being $7 with tax because of all the toppings I put on. I wouldn't recommend too many toppings because the pizza is so thin. I could eat two slices, but I have a big appetite. The flavor was great and they make it fresh. This type of thin crust was not the type to cut up your mouth but it was great, and thats coming from someone who hates thin crust. But I really like this pizza. Shannon was a great server and I will be back! read more
Loved Denver Biscuit when we were in Denver, so we were excited to see on in KC when in town for the day. There are 3 different concepts in the restaurant you can order off on one menu. Pizza was very large, had to fold in half to eat. I don't know if I forgot to order cheese on my pizza, or if there was some on there but not a lot, or what but it tasted like bread and toppings, and the toppings just fell off because there was like no sauce or cheese on it. Menu didn't make it easy to see if I ordered wrong or what happened. My husband liked his biscuit sandwich, didn't rave about it, said it was just fine. The French fries though brought us back to life, delicious! They must be very short staffed because when we walked in there were people waiting for tables everywhere, but when we walked in the place was maybe half full, and we were told about a 25 minute wait, but probably got in in about 10-15, they have the text messaging service most places do so we went and sat outside and waited! read more
I usually don't rave about pizza joints bc I, personally, thought it was hard to ever do pizza "wrong." But my bro in law raved and raved about this place, so we decided to give it a try. And wow! Ok. We're believers now. The pizza is bomb!! The thin yet doughy/melt in your mouth crust is our favorite part of the pizza. Our last visit to KC was for 4 days. In the span of those 4 days, we stopped by to have Fat Sully's pizza twice hehe read more
This restaurant is located in Westport off Pennsylvania Ave near the Siam Thai restaurant. It is known as 3-in-1 restaurants all in one building. My friends heard great things about the pizza and wanted to try it out. The inside was very new, nice, and organized with plenty of seating tables sectioned off in different rooms of the building. There is a big bar in the middle of the place which is convenient. There are 2 pool tables as well. We went fairly late around 10pm so it wasn't that busy. There were two other groups dining inside when we arrived, which was good use of social distancing. Our host was very professional and explained the mask rule to us and the use of scanning the QR code for the menu which was helpful, since it was our first time there. Dustin was our server. It was great service, he was very helpful with suggesting the 3 or less toppings on our pizza. If there were more than three toppings added then it would taste soggy. The pizza slices were thin crust and huge like NY style pizzas. I ordered a slice of pizza with 4 toppings: Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Bacon, and Jalapeños. The presentation of my slice of pizza looked very delicious. However, the taste was a bit lacking for me. I couldn't taste much of the sauce, it was very lightly coated. I tasted more cheese and the toppings. In addition, some of the toppings weren't toasted enough, such as the Jalapeños, they weren't cooked much with the rest of the toppings on my pizza, it felt like it was thrown on top after they cooked it. The bread didn't have flavor and it tasted very dry. Normally, I love eating the crust, but with barely any sauce on my pizza and no taste to the bread, I decided it wasn't worth eating. But overall, the place is great inside including Dustin's service. I would come back to give their other menu options a chance like their chicken wings! read more
Business owner information
Atomic C.
Hi Ting! thank you so much for your review and your valuable…
4 years ago
Fat Sully's is so good that I couldn't resist returning. A week and a half went by and I found myself driving there again. I got another combination slice of big ass pizza (that's literally what it's called) and another house salad with honey lemon and balsamic dressing. Absolutely Slap-Ya-Mama Good! I ran across a customer that ordered breakfast. Omg! It looked scrumptious. I now know what's on my agenda the next time I have a hankering for a great breakfast spot (they also have complimentary coffee). Check out the photo here. It speaks for itself. Mosey on down folks. Fat Sully and YOU will be Glad YOU did! read more
Business owner information
Atomic C.
Thanks for the awesome review Foogie!
4 years ago
I stumbled on this place a month ago and have been back weekly. The food is excellent! Started with the Huge Pizza slice. I'd say best pizza I've had outside of NYC. I literally never finish anything but on my second visit I had TWO slices. Today I had the impossible burger and the waffle fries. Finishing it now. Cool chill vibes. Friendly service. Just go. read more
Business owner information
Atomic C.
Awesome! Thanks so much for the feedback. We look forward to seeing…
5 years ago
I called the restaurant. I told the man that I found a hair in my pizza. I describe it as a black American hair. I am a hair stylist. I know my hair. He yelled at me . He told Me he was a African American man and had a crew cut.. He said he was so offended. He yelled at me and the Hung up.. The pizza was so salty it was inedible. I will never spend a dime here again.. The owner made a problem out of nothing. I was calling just to give feed back.. Door dash had already refunded my money read more
Business owner information
Atomic C.
Hi Rhonda,…
3 years ago
3 years ago
So happy with our huge slice of pizza!! Perfect thin crust!!! And our server Haleigh was super nice and helpful!! We will definitely be back next time in KC. Sorry no pics of our pizza, it looked too good to not immediately eat! read more
Go BIG or Go HOME. Ever since Fat Sully's landed in Westport I've been a fan...and that says a lot because I'm a true pizza lover. Whether its from The Big City (New York), Windy City (Chicago), Motor City (Detroit) or Kansas City... I love it all. Fat Sully's Pizza has perfected the NY style pizza. Large hand-tossed thin crust, sold in BIG A** slices or 26 inch pies. Topped with meat all to be folded and devoured. read more
This was definitely a good stop for a late night bite/pizza party with friends! We ordered a 26" pizza (half cheese half sausage) and boy was I surprised with how giant it was!! The slices were a new york size slice and a half! Our waiter was fantastic, I'm mad at myself for not catching his name but he was super friendly + joked around with us all night long!! I liked the neon lights + pizza bar vibe as well. Would definitely come back with some friends! read more
Tried Fat Sullys for the first time via delivery and it was worth the hype! My east coast boyfriend was in New York pizza heaven! The ingredients were fresh and amazing and the perfect amount of pizza "flop". I will say- this pizza is gigantic. Way too much for 2 people to finish in 2-3 days haha. This is obviously not a bad problem to have, the more pizza the better! I would love to go eat in person. It might seem pricey, but you are paying for quality AND quantity. It's amazing. Highly recommend! read more
Business owner information
Atomic C.
Thanks so much for the awesome review Julia! We are so happy to hear…
Was watching the news one day and they had pizza coming from this restaurant. what I saw on T.V. looked good, so I had to try it for myself. Asked a coworker if he wanted to try it out with me and so we went! there was 30 minute wait, because the location has, like, 3 eating spots in this one building. we finally get seated and we order. I order 3 slices and he orders 2. the waiter told us that 2 was sufficient, but I have never just ate 2 slices of pizza. so, the pizza slices come to the table and I understood why he recommend 2! The pizza was very good and, though I didn't pay, the price wasn't that bad either! This was my first time trying this place, but I plan to go back. The waiter we had was named Levi, and he took good care of us and was very friendly! I would recommend this place if you have a craving for pizza and want to try a new pizza place! read more
Business owner information
Atomic C.
Thanks so much for stopping in Reuben! We appreciate your review and…
Page 1 of 3
More info about Fat Sully's Pizza
Ask the Community - Fat Sully's Pizza
Are there vegan options for their pizza? vegan cheese? Plant based protein?
Hey _veganxkomal _! Our normal crust and califlower are both vegan. We don't have vegan cheese, but you are able to order a red pie with any veggie toppings you'd like. While we aren't currently offering any plant based proteins at this time, we are…
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
7 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
3 years ago
5 years ago
6 years ago
4 years ago
6 years ago
5 years ago
6 years ago
