Fish City Grill was amazing. Wonderful staff, tasty food and drinks. My waitress was Jessica and she was awesome. I had charbroiled oysters, and the jumbo lump crab cake. The crab cake was large and all Lucious crabmeat, not mush. It was my first time dining there, and the manager Chris brought over a plate with soup samples (the soups are delicious - my favorites were the jalapeño and the lobster bisque) and a sampling of the fried oyster nachos which were also very tasty. My cocktail was prickly pear margarita, which I really enjoyed. I'll certainly be returning. So happy this restaurant is right in my backyard. read more

Fish City Grill - Complimentary Soup flight and Fried Oyster Nachos - Seafood Near Me - Prosper, Texas

See all

Tried this new location on opening night and it did not disappoint. We have eaten at 9 locations for years. Food We had several dishes and they were perfect. Did not get a pic of the bread pudding because we ate it before we got a pic. Service Service was great and our waitress was friendly, quick, knowledgeable and our drinks were never empty. Ambiance Love the way this new location looks. Nice bright and inviting We will be back read more

See all

Honestly just average. The drinks are weak. The wine pours are greedy. The calamari is delicious. The crab is underwhelming and lots of work due to the tiny legs. Tonight, I had the sockeye salmon with wilted spinach and rice and it was just really bland. Food came out partially hot and cold. It was as if the plate had sat and they threw hot salmon on top. The place smelled of paint thinner. Anyone with asthma was likely feeling it. Also it took forever to get drinks and the bar only had a few people. read more

Our server, Kimberly, was extremely attentive and on top of everything for our group of nine. It was a great meal!

They've chand the recipe of the shrimp and grits I usually order. It wasn't as good and I don't know if I would order it again. We ordered to go. Smaller portions too. read more

My wife and I shared the sampler appetizer and an entree. It was all amazing. And the Chocolate Addiction dessert was the perfect ending to our meal. Great food and awesome service from Kimberly! She was the best. Look forward to coming back soon! read more

Got the opportunity to be served by their in house Super Star server Kimberly! The food was great & we're glad to have this little gem of a seafood spot this close to home in Prosper. Recommend trying their exclusive oysters. Will be back frequently when we need that seafood fix. read more

Great place to eat and very nice environment! Stuffed flounder was fantastic! Might need to thaw the peel and eat shrimp a little more but overall delicious! read more

Amazing food! The clam chowder was delicious. Everything we ordered was excellent. The chef checked to see if we were enjoying our food. The service was great. Bright and sunny atmosphere. read more

Best fish/seafood place in Prosper and area. Used to drive to Plano to half shells. Glad the drive isn't needed anymore. always great service and management team. No bad meals ever except one time soup wasn't hot. Never repeated. read more

Food was good. We had the fish and chips, lobster grilled cheese and for drinks we had margaritas which were all very good. Friendly staff and overall good experience, will come back. read more

What a great experience. Fernando the manager and Will the bartender were so amazing! Thank you for a great night.

Staff and Service was awesome. Friendly environment and nice place to bring family and friends. The fish is fresh and made to order. In my opinion, you cannot go wrong with any of the menu items. There soups are delicious as well. read more

Fish City Grill - Beer Battered Cod - Seafood Near Me - Prosper, Texas

See all

Omg soooo good!! Can't wait to go back! The server, Shelby, was awesome! Since it was my first visit, she brought me a sample of their soups and oyster nachos. Omg next time I visit I am getting the nachos! So I had the crawfish etouffee and it was phenomenal! They have specials each day that are not on the menu so you could eat there everyday and have different meals every day hahaha read more

Great service by Kim. Fish and Chips were great! Friendly, fast service. We will be back.

Every entrée we've had is very delicious and fresh. They hire the best people who know how to serve. One of our new favorite places!!

My husband and I just love this place!!! We love the Garlic Caper Salmon! Kimberly was our server tonight and was attentive and pleasant! We will ask for her section next time! read more

A nice little refreshing place in Prosper finally! I've been here several times since they've opened. Not a single issue so far with the service, the food or the staff! The lobster grill cheese is excellent, wait staff and hosts are friendly and helpful and a huge plus....it's clean! We continue to dine here frequently! read more

Consistency in food and service. Kimberly was an excellent server. Love the Mystic Mermaid oysters. Been to other places that serve raw oysters, have to say these are my new fav! read more

great food and service. Kimberly was very attentive and gave great recommendations for food!

Love'd it. Will be back, crab cake was great, total service exceeded my expectations .server was great too!

The food was delicious! We ordered the hot shrimp as an appetizer and had to take an order to go! I had the red snapper special with seasonal veggies. The fish was cooked perfectly and well seasoned, as well as the veggies. The broccoli could've been a tad more cooked but overall, delicious! My boyfriend had the catfish with fries and he also really enjoyed it! The hostess and waitress were friendly, helpful and responded in a timely manner. I also loved the ambiance! read more

This was our first visit and I must say this place was great. The food was good and seasoned very well. We had Kimberly as our server and she was an awesome server and very pleasant. This place is a short distance from our home and we will definitely be back. read more

AMAZING food! AWESOME service - Shelby was great and took such good care of us! Their rotating daily specials are always delicious! Super fresh seafood! Nice spot, great ambiance, everything is so crisp, clean, and pretty inside! read more

Great service from the sweet hostess to our fantastic server Ariel. We just moved to town and definitely felt the "small town" hospitality having come from Dallas. We had soup(crab/clam chowder) and it was meh, the sampler platter was really good, I had the shrimp and scallops which were great and my husband had the shrimp tacos and liked them. I had 2 glasses of wine and he had a cocktail and our total was $100 will DEFINITELY be back and recommend 10/10 read more

Fish City Grill - Old Bay Shrimp and scallops with mashed potatoes and spinach - Seafood Near Me - Prosper, Texas

The food was amazing and our server, Kim McQuiston was best of the best. We will definitely be back! read more

The food was amazing. They have a big staff that can at times be a bit too social with one another rather than attentive to drink refills, but the food made up for that! read more

Thank you for a wonderful meal and great service from Kimberly! We love the oyster nachos!

We went here for the first time with no expectations and was impressed with what they had to offer. The food options would meet anybody's needs. Though small, the seats are well situated to accommodate large groups especially with the availability of seating outside. The bar was impressive with plenty of seating as well and the service was good but still in training in regards to knowledge of the menu items. We would go back though. read more

The food and staff are always Amazing! We visit as often as possible. We are fortunate we always get VIP service. Even though they don't have a program. Kimberly is Super Sweet! read more

A smaller location so there was a wait for my party of 5 on a weekday but that goes to show this is a busy place and for good reason. Good ambiance made excellent with servers like Brayden who went above and beyond in helping us with our dietary needs. He proactively removed the wine based sauces, steered us away from beer battered fries and recommended the pan fried fries to avoid cross contamination. I have not had such an experienced server in a long time and I believe him to be too young to have been doing this a long time - a natural! We ordered the spicy shrimp tacos (it's SPICEY!), the blackened Rainbow Trout, the shrimp/crab stuffed Flounder (my favorite!) and the lobster and shrimp grilled cheese sandwich (sans bacon). We were full but celebrating an anniversary so went for the chocolate addiction dessert and that was awesome too. Fernando the manager came around and chatted with us for a bit and I can tell why the service and ambiance is so meticulous...he runs a tight ship and the entire crew is amazing. We like fish city grill but we love this location! read more

Everything went well from the moment we were taken to our table to the moment we walked out the door. Service was great. Food was amazing. Drinks were pretty good too. read more

Food is so delicious! I really love the blackened shrimp Cobb salad. Our waitress Taylor, was the best!! She really made the experience great. She was attentive and super welcoming to my toddler! Highly recommend read more

Staff too interested in flirting with her manager. Positions were small for the price. Oysters were all batter. Typically I'm very positive in my reviews, however this one deserved a poor review. Was excited to see these folks come to town, however a second visit is not warranted. My wife and I have seen all we need to see. A bunch of kids pretending to know how to wait tables and a management team(one person) who sat and flirted with staff the entire visit(8pm on a Thursday. We won't be back unless all other options have been exhausted. read more

Food was amazing, the daily specials hit the spot. Shelby was a great server for our first time really helped to make it a great experience.

Dined here several times with the most recent one yesterday May 26th. The last 2 times have not been the best quality of food, but yesterday was just plain terrible. Not only was the food bad the service was worse. To make matters worse, after returning home, I got very sick from what I had here. Never returning here it's just not good. read more

I have been here a couple times. Food is amazing and price is very reasonable. I will definitely keep coming back.

The food was incredible....but omg the service was incredible even though they were busy the food far surpassed the photos people have taken. And always check the boards they have specials and they sound incredible read more

The food was wonderful. Loved the six dollar gold margaritas for happy hour. Definitely will come back.

Shelby our server was fantastic! We loved all the recommendations and all items were delicious! We had the seared yellowfin tuna tacos and the scallops and bacon wrapped shrimp. Highly recommend, we will be back! read more