The pizza had a burn taste to it. If you're into charcoal taste pizza then this is your place. It's on Madison Avenue read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - This the pizza they sell me - Pizza Near Me - Bridgeport, Connecticut

I've had way better pizza than Goodfellas. The sauce wasn't good. Taste more garlic and bread I won't be back

An unexpected gem in horrible weather! We were stuck on the Merritt Parkway on Friday during the snowstorm and needed to get off to eat and rest. Found Goodfellas Pizzeria and was pleasantly surprised that they were open and the pizza was delicious! Thanks Goodfellas! read more

Ordered takeout from here at work and I am not sure the pizza was worth the high price tag! The plain cheese was better than the pizza with bacon and meatball. It was like the ratio of sauce to toppings to cheese was off so everything was kinda falling off the pizza. The delivery was quick though. For the price, I might as well have ordered from nearby Pepe's. read more

See all

Pizza is fire thin but cooked well cheese to sauce ratio is perfect Dave port it would like this

First off I would like to say they gave me a nice quantity of wings I ordered 16. There were some small wings so they made up for it by giving me one or two more wings. The quality of the wings were garbage frozen shit. What happened to the days where you get actual chicken bake the chicken wings then fry them. This place buys grocery store bottom shelf wings and heats them up. If I wanted fast food garbage quality wings I would have gone to McDonalds In addition to that the guy on the phone wasn't the best, really fast speaking and mumbled couldn't understand a thing he was saying. Oh and the icing on the cake 23.60$ for 16 wings, I'm not a cheap person but that's crazy. In addition to that 23.60 for frozen garbage I should have just gone to the grocery store and bought two big ass bags for the same price. It's a real shame I'm a sacred heart student and will be telling my friends not to bother with this place. So much better food in ct. read more

In my opinion, this is the best football pizza in the area. While it's not in the same league as places like Sally's or Pepe's, it shines in its own category and absolutely deserves 5 stars for what it offers. read more

The Pizza is great and the other food choices are also del I'll go there again. Fast delivery too. read more

Went from 1 of the best pizza places in the area to the worst. Insane prices. Threw out the pizza it was so bad. Pizza crust is so thin, barely any sauce or cheese. Picture says it all. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bridgeport, Connecticut

First impressions mealball parm food flavor and lots of cheese 4 stars love the thin crust pizza-- its the perfect ratio and a taste of ny slice 4 stars clean place i wish they had online ordering read more

Yummy. Pizza was good!! It's pizza. I just wish it was a little less expensive for the Penne Ala Vodka with chicken wasn't $20. But, I bet it's good!!!!! read more

The pizza was straight out of the oven. The customer service was pleasant. Pizza is really thin but I thought it was delicious. First time here decided to drop in while getting gas next door. read more

See all

Goodfellas pizza is one of the best in the area, especially the hot oil and sausage pizza. Thin crust and just the right amount of sauce. This is our Friday night go to. They never disappoint. read more

This place is your average pizza shop. The subs are huge though! The pizza is a bit more saucier than I prefer, but the slices are good sized portions. Service was pretty meh. I had ordered a sandwich and a slice and I had to go up and ask for my slice after being halfway through my sandwich and the girls response was "oh did you order one?". She was also the person who took my order 15 min prior. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Chicken cutlet sub - Pizza Near Me - Bridgeport, Connecticut

Decent pizza! It's not as good as a boutique, upper-crust pizza joint that does brick oven pizza...but it's a solid neighborhood joint. We ordered a chicken parm pie with half spicy peppers and it was really good! Good sauce, good cheese melt, and generous peppers on half! We also ordered a caesar salad which I was not too impressed with... The lettuce was wilted and tasted kind of old/dirty. I will say, however, it was generously loaded with parm shavings and croutons. Had the lettuce been fresh & crisp it would have been a winner, but unfortunately it was just ok. read more

Venue: Goodfellas Pizzeria Decor: Takeout (Ish Service: Good! Environment: Home neighborhood feel Food: Pizza, Italian Prices: Good Debbie Downers: Should Conclusion: A staple. A taste you simply get addicted too. You grow accustomed to it over the years. Almost like feening for it. Excellent slices. That CT Style pie - official. Great portions for the price. Good Sauce on a pie! The staff is still cool. Food will put you to sleep. Local legendary spot on the North End. Would put this as a top ten pie in the port. Salutes to the Goodfellas, lot of options like subs and calzones. Plus they deliver.. huge plus! **** BOOM **** !!! Overall: B+ / A- read more

So happy to be adding an update today because I can honestly say that not only did Goodfellas redeem themselves with the food but the customer service is outstanding. After ordering some Alfredo pasta last week and having some trouble with the consistency, they replaced their cheese and gave me a full refund on my previous order. We ordered the same thing today to give it another try after the cheese replacement and it's even better than I could remember! My children and I devoured it. A lot of restaurants say they care about their customers but don't really. This is definitely not one of those places. They really do care. Very impressed! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bridgeport, Connecticut

See all

It's not bad.... decent pizza and good I'd prefer in the immediate area though, San Remo read more

This place is a last resort for me. The cheese blend they use on their regular pie isn't great. Maybe there's provolone? Something way too assertive. It is off putting. The rest is just mediocre, especially for the price. read more

Good Food. I loved the Garlic Bread with Cheese and Bacon! I don't like the $10.00 minimum for credit cards. I went to pick up a meatball grinder and the guy behind the counter said i had to spend $10.00!?!?? I ended up buying more food just to hit the minimum. Either that or use an ATM and get whacked $2.00 in service charges. No Bueno. Please Fix this read more

Really good pizza. If New York pizza and New Haven style pizza were to have a baby pizza this would be their offspring. Not as big and chewy as New York slice and not as small and thin crispy as a New Haven slice just a really solid nice blend of the two styles pizza. Staff is always professorial and pleasant. If I could I would give this 4.5 stars. It's not the best pizza ever I have had but it very very solid and with consistently good food and service. This is a place I stop on a regular basis. They have tiny area to sit and eat but this really a take out place. read more

Perfect pizza/sandwich place close to Sacred Heart. They accept the SHU card which is awesome, and their food is always great. I love the pizza & the chicken parm grinder! read more

Goodfella's is the best thin crust pizza in town, as their slogan claims. Flavorful sauce, and pepperoni that is actually hidden under the cheese (looks like it's not even there!) Had to ding a star due to their sometimes unprofessional staff and inconsistent side orders (meatballs and boneless wings are hit or miss in terms of tenderness/hardness). There is one cashier in particular who is rude. read more

Horrible customer service. Guy at the front with gages was extremely rude. Food was mediocre at best. Go somewhere else there's much better places nearby !! read more

Coming from New York I often set my pizza standards high. This often leads to tremendous letdowns, however with Goodfellas that was no the case. This pizza exceeded my expectations and I would definitely go here for a bite again. read more

Pizza is great. There are not to many pizza places in Bridgeport that my kids will eat from. Goodfellas is my go to place when my kids and I want good pizza. The garlic bread is also great. Cooked perfectly and not overcooked. read more

I was hungry for a hot sandwich close by my house and being new to the area I wanted a chicken Parmesan hero. This place did not disappoint at all. I plan to come back here to order more food at a later time. The staff is also very friendly. read more

Goodfellas has the best food, business owners, and service in the area. I've worked with the owners for three years now and they are always on time and never make mistakes especially on big orders. Amazing food as well don't think twice this is the place to be in Bridgeport! read more

Pizza is average - not good or bad. I find it to be a little "doughy" but my preference is a thin crust.

Really goood pizza, really delicious, good produce. We also ordered a salad, light fresh and I love the set up of it on the plate. Plus I love when a good looking staff makes my food:))) good service for a take out pizza, especially when you are the last customer of the day on Sunday. read more

A wonderful find. Pizza, gyros, Sals's, hinders. Chicken is grilled! The staff is friendly, personizatin of your meal is FINE! Made to order, so expect it to be hot and delicious! read more

Came here for a quick bite after visiting nearby SHU. Food was very good especially a salad topped with fried eggplant. Also had chicken parm and quesadillas, so a pretty varied order. Only negative was that their credit card reader is broken and I had to pay cash. Place is small and is really just for takeout, btw. read more

Those two tiny slices of pizza did nothing but piss me off. I guess you told us you don't need our money any more . No problem. Take care

Goodfellas has mediocre food, overpriced by any account. Do not order the cheesecake. A tiny slice costs $4.50! Probably $2.00 anywhere else. Try Mario the Baker, Captain's or Brick Oven instead. read more

I love their pizza. Very delicate but tasty. Their pasta is very good and decent portions. I can't get enough of their fettuccine Alfredo. Love it. read more

CT, especially New Haven, has excellent pizza. This is NOT one of those spots. The crust tastes like cardboard the sauce seems to be of low quality. Skip this spot and make the trip to Two Boots or Pepe's in Fairfield. read more

Salads and chicken tenders were very, very good but pizza was disappointing. If you like thin crust you might like it but toppings were VERY sparse. Don't think there were even 2 pieces of pepperoni per slice. They were also pretty stingy when it came to steak on the subs. read more

Wow the pizza here is very good I would recommend this place to anyone. But the staff was kinda weird.

What is expected from a pizza shop. Nothing amazing but nothing bad. Have had the pizza, wings, and wraps. I suggest it if you want to mix it up for a night. read more

Goodfellas pizza is a great place to go for a good thin crust pizza. The sauce is amazing and the crust is thin and crispy just the way it should be. The grinders and dinners are good sized and taste great. Sandwiches are filled and delicious. Customer service is great, employees are kind and delivery is fast. I definitely recommend to try. read more