Great Choice! Got 3 large pizza's. 2 thin crust and 1 rolled crust. Get the rolled crust, holds up well with toppings and the chew of the crust was perfect. Thin crusts were also great, but i now wish I'd gotten all 3 rolled. Got a sandwich that my 17 year old couldn't put a dent in, and a family size Greek Salad that could feed 8 to 10 easily. Price reflects the quality. No cheap ingredients here. Well done we will be back, btw, call me if you ever need a chef! #MurrayMountainTrip2020 read more

Hernando's Pizza Pub - Happy Family, Great Scenery, Great Food - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

Outstanding pizza and salads. The female bartender was 100% top-notch, friendly, knowledgeable, and very accommodating.

Delightful atmosphere-very casual and kid friendly . Modest cost. Pizza was terrific we got the Hawaiian. Great crust and sauce . Delightful efficient service !! Would go back in a heart beat !! read more

Amazing pizza every time!! Never disappointed. Food, service, and ambiance are great!

Perfect spot after a day skiing! Pizza is really good. Gets busier after 430 and parking goes into the neighborhood.

Hernandos.... I apologize for not being a regular sooner!!! We have been passing this place for 10 years on our way to our cabin. Why we haven't stopped I have no idea. Pizza was amazing. Rivals possibly the best in Colorado. Tied for first day n my pizza book. We had the rolled crust Colorado style, but they also have a thin option. Had the 14 inch and had tons leftover. It was huge! Toppings are plentiful and loads of cheese. Red sauce was delicious. Pro tip: it's happy hour at the bar all day every day. So if you are at a table and want to order shots, head to the bar and order them separate. Can't wait to come back! read more

Maybe it was all the snowboarding, but this place was AWESOME!! Would recommend to anyone at winter park! Delicious! Also, can complain about kona brewing on tap read more

My family and i have been going to this restaurant for years. The food and the service have always been top notch, however, we made a reservation for 13 for dinner. First, we had to wait 15 mins to get our table even though we made a reservation and then when we were told, only as we were ordering, that we could only have 3 pasta dishes per group. That makes sense for a small or normal sized group but for a group of 13 that is going to be ordering more food and and paying more money, it makes no sense that you would limit a group that big. At least consider making it a percentage for the size of group, or increasing the number for bigger groups. I understand that you are short staffed, so many places are, but this is a pasta and pizza restaurant and more than half of our group couldn't order pasta. The food is delicious and the atmosphere is unique and welcoming but this new rule in place is very disappointing. I hope they consider changing it to accommodate larger groups. read more

This pizza is deeeeeeelish. I would highly recommend giving Hernando a chance after a day at WP.

The garlic bread and pizza was absolutely to die for. The decore throught the place had a very artsy feeling, and the service was amazing. I definitely recommend read more

See all

Visiting Winter Park and were craving pizza and Gluten Free Pizza and glad we picked Hernando's. First off the rustic decor with the fireplace in the middle of the dining room is very cozy especially when it's 7 degrees outside. We loved all the signed dollar bills hanging all over the walls. It's fun to read some of the messages on them and get a laugh. We were seated quickly and our waitress was really nice and helped us with any questions we had. They do offer gluten free pizza as well as gluten free wing sauce so that's great. You don't feel left out . I ordered a gluten free pizza and Greek salad and my husband ordered shrimp Alfredo pasta. I loved my food. The gluten free pizza crust was crisp and amazing the salad was great. My husband said his shrimp Alfredo did not have much flavor Other than that we loved our visit here. Try it out you won't be disappointed read more

Great pizza great service! Love the atmosphere. Great for families or just having a beer and pizza with friends!

Great place with quality food. We are there at least once a month post-ski. The owner is a ski coach at Winter Park and he's a pretty stand up guy! What's not to love? read more

MUST GO!!! We came on a snowboarding trip to Winter Park and were craving pizza. We came to Hernando's based on the reviews of how they had amazing pizza. And boy was that true!!! THE BEST PIZZA I'VE EVER HAD! We got the custom hand tossed rolled crust pizza. We had it one night, I had left overs the next morning and went again the next night! That's how good it was. Make sure to stop by this place while here and dip the crust in honey :) read more

Hernando's Pizza Pub - Custom pizza: Roma tomatoes, broccoli, red pepper, red onions - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

This has a great atmosphere and it highly recommended by the locals. Had a pizza and salad. The dressing was great and the pizza was okay. However, I am a pizza snob and have had some of the best pizzas on the world. I will have to give it a second try and update my review. My husband had an Italian plate and loved it! Overall I will return! read more

Tell me the secret to your rolled crust HERNANDO'S!!! We were lucky to get seated at the penny bar due to limited seating and long wait times; call in to reserve seating! The pizza was delicious! Get the rolled crust!!! I wanted to eat all the crusts; if only my belly had more room, lol. Lightly crunchy on the outside, warm and chewy, overall so yummy! The pizza itself was a little flimsy so be careful when getting a slice because your toppings may slide off. Great place for dinner with family. read more

See all

Great service and food was good. Had the Greek salad and a Sonoma pizza. Would def get both again. Super cool place.

*disclaimer: i am from Louisiana, so do what you will with this information* THE.BEST.I. HAVE.EVER.ATE. Hands down this is the most delicious pizza I've ever had. The crust is nice and crispy. The edge crust was doughy and perfect. The edge was amazing with honey. Great atmosphere and good service. I will alway eat here when I visit. It is worth the stop! read more

Did twice during a visit, once as pick up and once as dine in. Love the ski bar vibe, the IPAs were reasonably priced and the service was pretty good for a Friday night so I can easily recommend the place. Had a mountain pie as a dine in and carry out. Not the best ever but certainly a good pie with a flavorful sauce. The crust was a touch underdone when ordered in but spot on as take out. They have an interesting take on Stromboli. I liked it but my Northeastern buddy was expecting the "real thing." (Damn Yankees-this ain't da Bronx). I know I will revisit on my next trip to WP. My buddy - eh - maybe I'm due for a replacement. read more

Worst Italian food I've ever had. My daughter and my friend both had the chicken alfredo and only ate one bite. It was cold, nearly frozen in the middle, and was extremely salty and peppery. I got the linguini Alfredo and it was sour, almost tasted like a green chili sauce. The pizza was halfway decent, and the cheese bread was amazing! read more

Hernando's Pizza Pub - Chicken alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

See all

This was a great dining option for our family. We had a friendly waiter who gave us great info about the area. Pizza was great and the crust was awesome with the honey provided on the table. Will eat here again prior to leaving the area. read more

Really glad some things don't change in Winter Park. The pizza and service are both wonderful. I'm glad to see a local restaurant that can still cater to both locals and tourists. read more

Hernando's Pizza Pub - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

Everything we ordered here tasted great from the cheezy bread, to the pizza for sure, to the desserts! Loved the dining area...very comfortable bench seats and good wait staff. We'll be back! read more

Hands down best pizza crust I've ever had! They make it fresh daily. The server, Dylan, suggested rolled and mentioned dipping the crust in honey. Highly recommend! Dylan was super friendly and a great server. The patio was nice. We did a custom pizza with the Simone base - oil and garlic. Again, highly recommend. The Old Grand Margarita was delicious as well. Great food, great experience. Can't wait to come back! read more

Hernando's Pizza Pub - Custom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

Great pizza! Ski towns usually don't have amazing food but this place beats many pizza places back home and anywhere else I've eaten. We were a party of 10 and it was really easy to settle in and order. My favorites were the Hawaiian, Mediterranean , and Supreme. Don't miss out! read more

Hernando's Pizza Pub - Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

See all

I went here and naturally left singing Hernando to the tune of Fernando, I really hope the Abba vibe hits other people when they come. This is some damn good pizza, I was pleasantly surprised as restaurants in mountain towns seem to be hit or miss! We went on a Saturday night and it was bonkers in there--I highly recommend making a reservation. Otherwise you will be standing in the hallway with 40 other people (the night we went seemed to have a bus load of kids there, fun). Our server was quick but think she got annoyed with us trying to do match and offered to split our check and made a snarky remark when she brought back our checks that they never do that....ummm ok....you offered to split it? Even though the pizza was great (crust baked on the inside!) and I loved the side salad, what I will remember about this place is that it's loud, busy and lots of kids. It was like a glorified Pizza Hut when they had the Book It program (totally dating myself there), it was a little out of control and really I just wanted to have my pizza and get out since the atmosphere was bunk. read more

See all

I've been going to this restaurant since a kid and I must say Hernando's never disappoints. Everything was amazing, from the service to the atmosphere to the food. The cheese and mozzarella bread sticks were very good. In the picture are the bread sticks individual size (I already had a bite, so there is one less breadstick ). Seriously some of the best pizza I've had. My girlfriend and I split the 10" pizza, which was the perfect size for us after having the breadsticks. The best touch was the bowl of freshly graded Parmesan that I could spoon onto the pizza. The ranch was also great for dipping. Of course the honey on the crust is a must. The price was pretty standard for pizza these days. Overall, I would highly recommend! read more

Hernando's Pizza Pub - Cheese & mozzarella breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

My family and I have been visiting Winter Park for over 20 years now. It's had become tradition that every time we visit we HAVE to eat at Hernando's! The pizza here is amazing. The crust is so unique and it's baked perfectly. We visited WP for Christmas this year and actually ended up eating here twice during our stay. Everything we ordered other than the pizza was great as well. Waiters and workers were all so nice. Highly recommend Hernando's! Also highly recommend making reservations to eat here!! read more

Hernando's Pizza Pub - Pizzas! - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

Mannnnnnnnnn THE best pizza you could ever lay a tongue on lol! No but seriously, deliciously good , eye candy actually, then they have this honey bottle on the table so that u can eat it with your crust, new to me, but I like it!! read more

We bought 2 large pizzas, both tasting like a frozen pizza from your local Safeway. Even though we ate all the pizza, we recommend you buy or build a brick oven. The skiers who travel to Winter Park deserve to have a better pizza for their vacationing stay. Sincerely Alex and Jim read more

Hernando's is a Winter Perk institution- and rightly so. It's been here for 30 years and the food delivers. It's not fine cuisine, it's good belly filling comfort food. Perfectly for some calories on a cold day. It's nice that they are seating indoors during Covid and the pizza is a good. Stop by and have a supreme slice and cold beer. read more

Amazing pizza! Tasty & crispy thin crust & delicious toppings! Antipasto salad was delicious!

SO good!! Love the pizza, the atmosphere, and the staff was great too! Just wish they were open later! (Why can't a guy get a pizza after 9 pm in Winter Park?) read more

Great experience ordering takeout pizza on a night we didn't feel like going out. Easy ordering over phone, quickly made within 30 minutes and everything was delicious! read more

See all

Great ambiance, great pizza, great prices! We always make at least one trip to Hernando's when in Winter Park. The pizza is great, a kind of sweet sauce that is plentiful and a good crust. The place is wallpapered with dollar bills. Add yours. Prices are reasonable. House wine is good and cheap. What more do you want after a hard day on the slopes? read more

Five star pizza joint. Heavy pours and great pies. The bar tender (who I think may have been the owner?) was slammed but still took care of us. Being a resort town my standards for food are low but everything here was top notch. Very busy every night though so get here early! read more

Wow! The server Molly was incredible! We love Hernandos pizza, but the service was the best we have ever experienced. She helped us decide on our wine and pizza, and she was super kind to our 3.5 year old son, called him by name, and made our dinner stay so much fun. We enjoyed her energy and of course the honey on our pizza ;) read more

We are here twice during our stay in Fraser, CO. We ordered take out once, then dined in the second time. We ordered pizzas both times, and were very pleased with the quality, amount of food, and atmosphere of the establishment! read more

Im not sure how any reviewer of this pizza restsurant can honestly rate this a 3 or higher. The crust is frozen, then reheated, the sauce is bland and nearly invisible and the 'cheese' is neither mozzarella nor provolone...it is a horribly cheap cheese solution with an objectionable texture. Adding insult is the price for this 'pizza.'. $51 for a 14" cheese and a 14" pepp..Please. Since we didn't sample the pasta or salads (thankful;y) we can only base our notion on the core product - pizza. Based upon that, there is no way we would eat here again. The bartenders were friendly and offered typical service for an immediate tip based employee. read more

My supreme was great. All fresh, nothing canned. My server was also great. Her name was Arynn and no attitude or issues with her at all. Always smiling :) I live in Grand Lake and drove here instead of the other two places there because of the pizza and the fact they have Guinness! Plus the price is still actually less or even when adding in my gas cost. read more