I said last year we would not come back because I was mad they were out of the pomegranate martini and charged us for it anyway, and we didn't realize it until we got home. However, we decided to give it another try. There were 3 of us, and on this trip the bar was full, but there were plenty of tables. Our server was Steph and she was friendly. We ordered a pound of bang, bang shrimp, 2 crab cake sandwiches, and a lobster tower. It was very enjoyable, and we finished with the toffee bread pudding. It was not bad for a seafood restaurant nowhere near the ocean and in the middle of winter. read more

See all

Being a little generous with a three star rating. Stopped in on a Sunday night, ample parking decent size place. They were not very crowded, maybe a handful of tables occupied and the bar was a little on the full side. Hostess was nice, found a seat for us immediately. The service was a little underwhelming seemed like our waitress was also cooking the food. 20 minutes after we ordered, I was told they were out of my entrée, the crabcakes, a bit ironic, eh? So instead ordered a few appetizers. Overall, the food was fine, main problem we had that the bussers and waitresses kept trying to take our plates before we were finished with them, very strange, almost like they were trying to rush us out. Was not checked on very much-only had one drink each. Though I ordered 15 wings only 10 were served, but they only charged me for 10. Not a very attentive waitstaff to say the least. At least I tried it, now I know, a bit disappointed. read more

See all

Different Cheesesteak #1228. The Surf and Turf Cheesesteak - make it your own. I went on a Saturday night at dinner time. The young women manager should be celebrated and taught in schools. She chatted with customers, directed staff, and when the bar got a little backed up, she jumped in to pour drinks and take orders. It was refreshing to see her take pride in her work. I got a cheesesteak with a side crab cake. The sum was greater than the parts. The Cheesesteak was average. My Crab cake was a touch dry. Together, they were spectacular!! The cheesesteak meat and onions were finely chopped. This made them a nice complement to the crab. The cheesesteak had a sneaky good amount of cheese. It was enough to loosen up the crab cake. The Hilltop Surf and Turf Cheesesteak House!! It could be big!! read more

See all

Wish I could give 0 stars. Drinks were meh at best. The pineapple martini was sickeningly sweet. We ordered the crab dip appetizer. There was so much salt on the dippers, we couldn't eat them. When I commented to the server that the cook was a little heavy handed with the salt, the response was "I guess he's trying to close your arteries." No offer to fix it or get new dippers. The crab cake sandwich was ice cold. Too much roll; not enough crab cake. The price I was charged for the sandwich was higher than the price on the menu. Not even the fries were good. With everything costing so much these days, it's a real disappointment to spend so much money for a crappy meal. read more

Hilltop Crab House - Salt on the dippers for the crab dip appetizer - Seafood Near Me - Toughkenamon, Pennsylvania

I love Sunday's they have good specials and bartender are so hard working / need to check specials Saturday and live music and all You can eat crabs mmmm read more

Hilltop Crab House - Seafood Near Me - Toughkenamon, Pennsylvania

For was very good. The place is jumping and a friendly atmosphere. I had jambalaya and hush puppies. The better half had salmon all was delicious. read more

This place is still great! Easy to find and right off of route 41. It has a very cozy old school feeling. Nice sized bar and menu. We come here for the seafood, especially the all you can eat crab legs. The food is always good and fresh. The service is friendly and quick. They automatically add gratuity to the bill, which is nice when the service is great. read more

Hilltop Crab House - Seafood Near Me - Toughkenamon, Pennsylvania

Sub sub par seafood. Crabs were a joke. Highly nor recommended. Pleasant staff., but forgetful. More than anything, total disappointment with the crabs.! read more

Would give ZERO stars if possible. Been twice, one more than I should have. The worst service I have experienced. No hostess, so sat at high top next to bar. 30 minutes no staff came by, though they served tables on both side of me. Had to walk out. Incredibly disorganized and disappointing. read more

Got beer on draft looked off color and tasted water down. Don't get Stella or what was supposed to be Stella.

Called to order a couple dozen blue crabs to go. Was told #1 males were $48 per dozen. Said cool, give me 2 dozen with extra seasoning. This is what I got. Clearly not #1s. Hard crabs must be 5 inches point to point to be considered legal catches. These were not. read more

Hilltop Crab House - Seafood Near Me - Toughkenamon, Pennsylvania

In a region known for crab cakes, I expect excellence--and Hilltop delivered. Unlike most local spots, their crab cake was phenomenal: large chunks of crab, minimal filler, and perfectly broiled or fried to your preference. I started with a spring salad special packed with fresh fruit and a light dressing--surprisingly delicious for someone who doesn't usually enjoy fruit in salads. My husband loved the fried mushrooms, which were crisp and not greasy, served with a standout dill dressing (which I also enjoyed with my crab cake). He followed that with a burger he found excellent. Service exceeded expectations. Lori, our attentive server, made us feel welcome from the start, and the owner was hands-on and energetic. A mix-up with my entree was fixed instantly, without me even asking--something rare in most places. We enjoy wine with dinner and they had a decent wine list. The only recommendation is to have better wine glasses and not the teeny juice glasses. Though Hilltop wasn't on our usual list, it is now. We'll definitely be back. read more

Hilltop was a great find on a random Chester County afternoon. Mother and I had a fantastic lunch and a few drinks too, and everything from the service to the food was great. For starters we got crab bisque and baked oysters. The bisque is a must! The oysters were great too, especially after a little hot sauce. For lunch I got a crab cake sandwich which was pretty good. I probably wouldn't get it again just because it wasn't really anything special, and all the crab legs walking past me looked a lot better honestly. But it was decent. My mom randomly got a reuben which she enjoyed. The waitresses were great, if a bit overextended. The bartender took turns tending bar and waiting tables as there seemed to be only two staff for the whole joint (which also meant I head to wait forever for my cocktail sauce). But they were really nice hard working ladies. If I ever find myself in this neck of the woods I'd return for sure. read more

Crab legs were good, nick the server was on top of it. Kept an eye on everyone, I table of 6 and several smaller tables. I saw that someone badmouthed about the all you can eat for 60.00 due to tip. Reading the menu it plainly stated, 20 read more

It was good till it wasn't... the crab legs were amazing. Loveeed them. Only problem I had was the price. I called beforehand they told me it was $60 per person for all you can eat. So all together they said it would b $120 plus tax. After I get the receipt it's $158.63 because of the gratuity fee.. I paid that and left. I woke up this morning to see my card was negative $32 and a notification on my phone said that the price for Hilltop changed because of a tip? N I remember putting $0 on the tip cs I paid $25 tip I didn't know I already had to pay. Crabs were good but they scammed me just as good. read more

Hilltop Crab House - All you can eat crab legs - Seafood Near Me - Toughkenamon, Pennsylvania

The snow crab legs were excellent- three clusters for $18. They were meaty and tasty! I also got the French fries - the portion was generous and salty! My friend got a dozen large crabs - two of them were mushy but they were overall tasty. I Wish the service was better for the clean up. All in all - this place is good. The bathrooms are clean and food is tasty. read more

Hilltop Crab House - a plate of cooked crabs - Seafood Near Me - Toughkenamon, Pennsylvania

Took a while to get seated as the hostess was MIA. Once seated our waiter Greg was amazing. Greg was attentive and quick. Crab dip was good, calamari was good but lacked presentation as the dipping sauce was just plopped on the side of calamari. The mussels with linguini were decent but the sauce and mussels didn't have much flavor. The French dip Sammy was good but the au ju sauce was very oily not appealing. read more

Very upset to hear a good friend of mine was flagged after two drinks at Hilltop. She was in no way intoxicated, she was with 3 other people who had same drinks and they were not flagged. Absolutely ridiculous, not to mention humiliating! I work locally and will think twice about planning happy hours at this location. Such a shame, I do generally enjoy going there In response to your comment. It was a very wrong and incorrect assumption. Sadly, you will no be recommended based on this review and the inadequate response by the ma read more

I have only experienced amazing customer service and great seafood when I come here. Even when my family and I order take out, the food is just as good. read more

We are new to the area and wanted to try this restaurant for our sons birthday. We were seated promptly, and that is the only good thing I have to say. The service was terrible. We ordered an appetizer but never received it. It was on our bill, however. One entree was delivered 10 minutes later than the other three, and this was after waiting an hour for our meal. Another entree had the incorrect sides. We had to ask for silverware after the entrees were delivered. When the band started, it was so loud you couldn't hold a conversation with the person next to you. I could go on and on. We had heard good things about the Crab House, and were looking forward to finding a new go-to place since it is close to our new home. I have never left a restaurant without leaving a tip, but I did tonight. read more

Employees are straight liars about the most ridiculous of things. This place is a complete waste of time and the girls at the bar are useless af. Everything about this place is subpar. read more

Food, service and drinks are very good. Prices are nice to families. A loved local spot where the atmosphere is where everyone knows your name. read more

Great food and service, and music on weekends check it out. Plenty of free parking just over the Delaware line in PA.

Hilltop crab house has great crab! We ordered to-go from Hilltop Crab House and it was absolutely delicious. The crab dip has the perfect blend of flavors. We also ordered the crab bisque and it was so creamy and delicious. Their crab fries are a HUGE mountain of fries and also delicious. The items were also packaged extremely well which is a nice plus! If you're in the mood for some good seafood, go here! read more

We were visiting from California so we know good food and we enjoy seafood. We were impressed by the food and service. I had linguini with clams which was the best I ever had. My husband had a mixed seafood plate - the shrimp was unbelievably fresh. Everything was delicious. My son had a massive steak and really liked it. We were there on a Thursday and there was good live music - lively but not ear splitting. The chef came around to check in and see if people were enjoying their meals. He seemed genuinely interested in what we thought. Apparently they are starting up a brunch menu and from our experience, I imagine that would be good as well. We will definitely be back. read more

Great food, vibe and service. It was a crab picking experience I missed and came back to after being gone for over 30 years! Nicely done.

I love this place. Ricky will show you to your seat. This place is jammed packed on Saturdays. Be prepared to wait for about 30 minutes to be seated. Great menu choices. However I go for the all you can eat crabs. Including your choice of King crab clusters or blue crab. They don't skimp on servings. They bring out large portions and dump them on the paper covered tables. A plastic pale is given for shell dumping. The staff is very nice and approachable. Vicky took great care of us. Go there and enjoy. Great atmosphere. read more

See all

Great restaurant and very popular with the locals, which is always a good sign for me. The service staff was friendly and helpful. The food was served hot. My wife had crab cakes. They were nice size and very little filler. I had a delicious Maryland crab soup and fried oysters. Left the restaurant with full bellies. Happy customers b read more

Overpriced. Food is only OK. Service is good, however the place is noisy, due to live music, so forget having a conversation

Delicious food and great service! Had the Blackened Ahi Tuna Steak and it was fantastic. The bartender Alex was super attentive and inviting as well. Heard they have live bands on the weekend, will have to come back for that. read more

Hilltop Crab House - Blackened Ahi Tuna - Seafood Near Me - Toughkenamon, Pennsylvania

I ate here for the first time last night for a friends birthday dinner, I wish I could give it a 3.5 stars because I'm not totally sure it's worth 4 stars but I'll give the benefit of the doubt. Disclaimer: I didn't get to take a ton of pictures because my hands were covered in the crab leg seasoning (which isn't necessarily a bad thing) so I apologize for lack of pics. We started out with the bucket of claims which I was pleased to find out were $10 rather than $16 because it was happy hour pricing. We opted to have the garlic in it which was probably a mistake. While the clams were fresh, there were HUGE clumps of garlic in some of them that almost made it inedible. I would recommend getting these without garlic. We then got the all you can eat crab legs for $34. The crabs were fresh but on the smaller side. I didn't have any of the blue crabs but the other people at my table said they were good. They offer a French fry/salad bar buffet that you can help yourself to. Fries were okay, a little mushy but the salad was fine. The reason for lack of stars is price, I think they were pretty pricey for seafood that was just ok/good...nothing spectacular. Also while our waitress was very nice and extremely informative, she had a ton of tables which led to water not being filled up the whole entire time and a couple times people had to go up to her to get another drink or whatever it may be. Again, not blaming her for this..she was just very busy. I think someone else there could have helped fill up waters and what not. Overall, if you're in the area (it's a HIKE from Philadelphia suburbs) it's worth a check out. Just be prepared to spend some money. read more

Hilltop Crab House - Menu - Seafood Near Me - Toughkenamon, Pennsylvania

its the best sea food place ever, I love the works shout out to.... Lori cashatt, Steph Gavin , Millisa!!!

Four stars. There's nothing even close so way to go. Hard shells and Alaskan crab on the table. Good prices. Good seafood. What else do u need to know. Go. read more

Hilltop Crab House - Crabs. Crabs. Crabs. - Seafood Near Me - Toughkenamon, Pennsylvania

If you're looking for some fancy seafood restaurant, do not come here. If you don't mind a pretty rundown hole-in-the-wall that serves amazing shellfish, I strongly suggest coming here. This place is for crab lovers. The whole point of the restaurant is to dump a couple pounds of crab on the table and there's your meal. Every time I come to this place, it's packed with locals. Their crab cakes come pretty close to the best I've ever had and their steamers are delicious. I can't say how good the other traditional dishes are, like some seafood pasta, since I've never had them. I don't think I've actually seen other people ever order those things either. Yes this place is divey. No it doesn't look pretty. No it doesn't exactly look clean either, considering you dump your shells in a bucket on the floor. But if you genuinely like crab and prefer good food over what the surroundings look like, then this place is for you. read more

Hilltop Crab House - Seafood Near Me - Toughkenamon, Pennsylvania

I went here for lunch with a friend and we had a very delightful time. Our waiter was a younger gentleman he was very knowledgeable and very attentive good luck. Create shared 2 pounds of crabs mashed potatoes and asparagus. Although the crabs were a bit on the smaller side they were cooked perfectly very fresh. I was even able to have a gluten-free beer which was a treat. Would definitely visit this place again read more

First time here for dinner with my mom out for a girls night. Service was friendly and prompt. We started with the drunken clams- delicious- could have drank the sauce!!! My mom got the broiled crab cake - absolutely loved it. I had the snow crab legs and a side of hush puppies, the crab legs were seasoned perfectly and super meaty. The hush puppies were divine- absolutely loved the dipping sauce. Came here on a Friday night- nice crowd and a nice one band band playing great music. Will definitely return! read more

Staff are great and drinks are very good. Was really disappointed in the food. Celebrated birthday there a year ago, and all was great including the food. Was looking forward to the rockfish again, but I could taste it wasn't rockfish this time. Oysters were below average. I wouldn't order any of these items again. Atmosphere is friendly and fun, but food is not what it was. read more

They simply do not honor reservations, and we had to leave an hour after we should have been seated. We were not the only people with reservations to leave. They are terribly mismanaged and understaffed. Unfortunately, we are unable to comment on the food. read more

Worst service ever. The manager was rude and unprofessional. She clearly was in over her head and was disrespectful to customers. Lost our business. I would give no stars if possible. Such a shame because it was great under previous ownership. read more

Always love this place, great, friendly staff! And great food at a good price! Best crabs around period