OMG!!! My partner was having surgery across the street and it was cold and I Didn't want to walk far so I came here. This is the best pizza I've ever had. I had a buratta, arugula, and cherry tomatoes Sicilian slice.. it was so damn good! I think what made it better was the fact that it was fresh out the oven.. the service was also very good. I would definitely go back! read more

We were in the area to see a play nearby. Read about the pizza here on yelp. Decided to meet a friend for pre-matinee snackage, since it looked so good and pricing seemed reasonable. Worked out even better than I expected. The crust is light, fluffy, and crunchy! Loads of yummy toppings, too. I had the capricciosa. My friends got 3 slices of margherita. We would all return for more pizza, if in the area. The paninis and salads, and desserts cooler looked great! Pistachio gelato, mmmm. Next time! The guy behind the counter was a sweetie. Only minus: space is tight. No restrooms. When they say they are 'to go' they don't need you hanging around. read more

Il Baretto To Go - Margherita - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Always delicious!! I love that they also have gelato and other sweet treats. You can grab and go or sit outside and eat. read more

Il Baretto To Go - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This place is the real deal for anyone who loves authentic italian pizza. The hazelnut gelato is amazing as well. Probably my favorite thing here are the puree'd veggie soups served with italian bread. For panini I love the caprese (fresh mozzarella, tomato and pesto on focaccia). I also love the ciabatta 'Baretto' which is a panini with truffle paste, Taleggio cheese, arugula, tomato & prosciutto di Parma. Yum! read more

Horribly disappointing pizza. Looked and tasted like day old leftovers. I forced myaelf to eat it. read more

Il Baretto To Go - Is this cheese? Not even sure what it is. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Ohmygod- what a sleeper hit! I had never come to Il Barettp before but was fortunate enough to get their food during a catering event. We ordered several of the pizzas and foccacia sandwiches. The pizza was pretty good- lots of toppings with a soft, thick dough. It reminds me of grandma style pizza, which I've always been a fan of. The foccacia sandwich- however- blew me away. We ordered the parma and the caprese. The parma had SUPER tender and fresh proscuitto, the stretchy mozzarella I've missed from NJ delis, freshly sliced tomatoes. However, the star was that foccacia. It was buttery, crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, with the fragrance of olive oil permeating through the shell. I was so impressed by the foccacia I could have had just a meal with that and been happy. Would def returb read more

Il Baretto To Go - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Hidden little gem. Delicious pizza , other food looked good but I just had to try the pizza coming fresh. Very authentic Italian. Also have to go pastries in the fridge. Definitely a must. read more

Il Baretto To Go - the interior of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Fettuccine Bolognese had two specks of meat in it. Tasted like a college student whipped it up in their dorm, and probably cost them 1$ to make. Not ordering again read more

The best Caprese Foccaccia I've ever had. The bread with tomatoes, mozzarella and pesto was so delicious. We sat at the counter and really enjoyed our quick lunch. read more

See all

Great place for all-around Italian take out and creative focaccia pizzas. Favorites are the zucchini pizza, Parma focaccia panino and the carbonara pasta. Also, really friendly owner who's there everyday! read more

Il Baretto To Go - Sausage slice and Di Parma panini - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered a pizza, a Caesar, a sandwich, and a dessert. Four stars for the pizza, which was great. The other items were ok: the dessert (a tiramisu) was freezer-burned; the salad was boring. The sandwich was fine -- pretty small. But we really enjoyed the pizza, and will probably try this place again in the future (but stick to the pizza). read more

Authentic Italian pizza a totally different New York taste also the Gelato and dishes Almost entirely take out they do have like a few high sit chairs read more

Stopped by here after the Daily Show and loved it! Tastes authentic and the owner is great. He is amiable and a pleasure to talk to. Once slice is about $5.5 and is filling. There are 4 high seats inside facing the store front so you can people watch and a few outdoor tables. read more

A hidden gem! Literally ran into this place while looking for shelter from the cold and wind after walking away from the Hudson River. There's not much for food and drink in this area, so my friend I were happy to find anything at this point. Well, gosh darn it good thing the cold forced us to seek shelter. This is a seriously charming and yummy place to visit. At first glance you see pizzas waiting to be chosen by the next patron. Then you realize there's a chalkboard menu with a list of fresh pasta items...and the combinations offered made me salivate. We shared the following: 1. Paccheri with Lobster and Shrimp - delish!!! Lots of good sized bits of lobster and fresh shrimp. The pasta had the most perfect chew. 2. Pappardelle alla Bolognese - Well executed classic. 3. Burrata pizza - Could-like dough. So good. I thought it would be a thick and heavy dough, and really loved the airy texture and topping combo. Speedy and friendly service. Fantastic value. Just try it! read more

Pizza is so good, soo crispy and square. Delicious. I got the Bianca slice it had mozzarella ricotta and zuchini

Their Margherita Pie was everything I hoped for! I enjoy the simplicity about a good margherita pizza, and this was it. The crust was the perfect thickness with a good flavor. The tomato sauce was perfect with lots of flavor, and in general the pie was seasoned to perfection! I really enjoyed this pie and glad that I chose it, with the help from the previous yelp reviews! Delivery time was fast, and the pie was still hot! Nicely done! Big thumbs up! read more

Il Baretto To Go - Margherita Pie - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This place is bit out of the way, being on the far west side of town but if you're in the area, do stop by and try the pizza. The slices are surprisingly delicious and not like your typical square slice. The crust was like some fluffy clouds with a nice crusty, crunchy bottom and the toppings fresh and tasty. The 2 slices I got was the Salsiccia and Burrata. The burrata slice had this mild, super fluffy melty cheese topped with arugula and cherry tomato and with every bite the silky cheese just wanted to slide off but it was so good that you just wanted to not lose any piece and catch every bite of it. So if you are ever far west of 55 and 11th, good pizza awaits. read more

Il Baretto To Go - Salsiccia Slice Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Delicious! I've ordered from here a few times and my orders are always correct and quickly delivered. Salads are fresh. Dressing are delicious. The rosemary bread is INCREDIBLE. I could eat pounds of it! I love it. im addicted to it haha. I wish I could order more of it. I'll definitely be ordering from here again. The pesto is yummy! I usually order the arugula and artichoke salad and caprese salad. The rosemary bread comes with them. Amazing! read more

See all

I've never been so hungry after ordering $20 worth of food from a restaurant. I ordered the eggplant parm, which was a new item on their menu. What I got was a few slices of eggplant, a tiny bit of cheese that was barely visible, and a bunch of sauce. I've never received a smaller portion of eggplant parm than I did today. If it was actually good, then perhaps the extremely small portion could be forgiven, but it just wasn't that good. Also, it doesn't come with any pasta. It's unfortunate because other items at this restaurant are good, this just isn't. And I get eggplant parm all the time all over this city. This comes in at the bottom for value and taste. read more

Il Baretto To Go - Eggplant parm, more like sauce with a bit of eggplant. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Very delicious food. Authentic ITALIAN Italian. Prices are very good. I chose this venue over the overpriced Greek venue a block away. I'm glad I came here. Outdoor dining available. My new neighborhood favorite! read more

Love this place! Can't get enough. My go to daily spot! 2 pies on a snowy night, perfect! The food is delicious and the people that work there all amazing and friendly read more

Il Baretto To Go - 12" x 17" Margherita Pie. Vegetarian. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I paid $43.00 for 7 slices of pizza. What kills me is that I could off gone somewhere els for a pie that coast less then what I paid. I ask the owner why 43 for 7 slices of pizza he did not know what his employee charge me till I told him this will be the last time I go to that pizza shop. And to top it off the pizza was not cook all the way it was still cold. But I put it in my air fryer to get it nice and hot. But to be honest I will never go there because of the price gouging and they act like it's normal to charge so much for a slice. I DO NOT RECOMEND because you will be wasting your money. P.S. I gave 1 star but I don't give any stars because they don't deserve it. read more

We are in the middle of a coronavirus assault and I give Il Baretto's my goddamn business for them to send me a portion size fit for half a Weight Watcher's diet meal. I just ate all the pappardelle, all the bread, and I'm STARVING. How could you starve me like this? I'm in my bubble at home because if I get sick, I will die. Now, I have no food because Il Baretto's wants me to wither like a flower in October. Most Italian restaurants will give you a circular tin filled with pasta but this one gives you a small plastic rectangle of hatred and hunger. Don't eat here, don't order here. They'll starve you to the grave. read more

Excellent !!! Fresh ingredients freshly made ! Pleasant help!! Highly recommend this little hidden gem on the west side read more

Ordered from here on seamless. At first I thought they forgot our pizza and just brought us a salad because just a salad and bread were delivered. so I submitted a refund claim on seamless. Immediately after doing so, the pizza showed up in a separate delivery still nice and hot! Food was great, and I'm now trying to get seamless to reverse the credit they gave me so I'm not accidentally stealing from this restaurant read more

They got it right! Best tasting pizza. Truly Italian crafted. Great spot, and kind staff. Good location too as it's right by the pier.

We have been going to this place for years and recently the overall experience has not been that nice. Orders placed on their websites or through third party platforms are skipped, we have to call every time we order and they are always 10-20min and this is when they viewed your order. It happened twice that we walked in for a pick up and the order had not been even started. No apologies were offered or commercial gesture. Bedsides from a taste perspective ingredients are forgotten such as Parmesan on a whole pizza pie. When you find out about it and you have been waiting for your pizza for so long, you have no time to go back especially when prior complains were not considered. I would suggest to avoid this place until improvements have been made to reach their usual standards. read more

I was quite impressed with the caprese panini, which was a decent size and fairly priced and tasted good. The only problem I had with this place was how warm it was inside. read more

Delicious pizza... fresh and even better than regular New York style pizza (which I already like!) Can't wait to try the pasta sometime.

Amazing food. Service was top notch. Definitely recommend for anyone that is in the area.

Excellent pesto tagliatelle with potatoes and string beans as well as pancetta penne pomodoro. Great Italian on 11th Avenue. read more

See all

Without a doubt....the BEST pizza in nyc! This small pick up store is Italian authentic, serving by far the best pizza in town. The dough is perfection and ingredients are quality!! All of that, for regular price pizza or even cheaper than usual. I recommend that place if you love pizza. read more

Really love this place! Delicious delicious food. I've tried their pizzas pastas salads espresso .. All of it is fresh, fast and truly Italian perfect for a pre Terminal 5 dinner ! Sad they are closed Sundays, I am craving their Amitriciana pasta! Thank you Il Baretto! read more

Ordered delivery last night fir the first time from this restaurant. As I am gluten free, it can be hard to find a great Italian restaurant making gluten free pasta. We ordered the lobster Mac and WOW it was delicious! I was so impressed! My gluten eating husband said he never would have guessed that it was gluten free pasta. Large chunks of lobster and huge serving size. My son loved the focaccia (he's having it for breakfast too as there was SO much food!) he also enjoyed the steak w/mushrooms, spinach and mashed potato. I'll be making this a part of my ordering in rotation! read more

Very nice and tasty Italian Pizza with artichokes and ham! Definitely will order again. Delivery was quick. read more

Quick delicious food! I'm so happy to get a fresh made hot meal on 11th ave. The salads, pasta and pizza awesome always!! My new favorite go to for Italian eats. Thanks Albeiro for a great conversation and delicious food. read more

I can honestly say that this was the best pizza I've ever had! I had their pizza a couple times and it amazing.

BEST PIZZA I EVER HAD IN MY LIFE - If That's What Pizza Is Supposed To Taste Like I've Been Cheated My Whole Life - Staff Was Also Very Friendly read more

Il Baretto To Go - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

It's a rare find with a great Menu! Seldom you meet the owner who is willing to go out of his way to create your custom order just for you!

Unacceptable for margarita pizza, it was just a cheese pizza, mostly thick dough, sauce tasted like tomato sauce and no basil, when I tried to call to see if they got the order right they never answered the phone. I would not recommend or order from here again. read more