Incas Restaurant

Fantastic venue to watch sunset although obscured by the Sunset Key as it gets low in the sky…read more Service was sketchy. Non English speaker who forgot a simple request for mayo so we could try to choke down our chicken sandwich. Food was uniquely terrible. Chicken sandwich was small for $21 and I swear it was frozen and microwaved prior to bringing out to the table. It was so dry and obviously over microwaved, but we did not say anything we just asked for mayo to try to chock it down, but the mayo never came. This is an overpriced venue that cannot even get bar food right. For the price, food quality, lackluster service, too loud music, and obstructed view, do yourself a favor and go to the Tiki Bar at the Galleon for picture perfect sunsets, followed by dinner on the marina. Spent over 2 weeks here this time and have each June for the past 20. Last year I met my Son and Daughter in law there for drinks but did not eat. Tonight is our last night here and I wanted to do something different with my girlfriend. Should have taken my own advice and stayed at the Galleon. I am in food service so tipped for food I could not each but as a KW regular I will vote with my feet and not return . Below is the sunset view from the Galleon.

Best Sunset views! Waterfront dining Fun vibes, live music,…read moregood food *Ocean Key Resort and Spa* Don't have to stay at Resort in order to come to Sunset Pier Hours 11:30am- 8:30pm Daily Weather permitting *Call/check seasonal/weather* ***Best Time: Arrive about 60-90 minutes before sunset to secure a table*** We went about 6:30pm- sunset was beautiful around 7:50pm! Service was slow but they were busy. We knew that going in. Still good service! Menu looked good- Caribbean, American food! *Had a vegan option on the menu* Ordered: Mango Mule- really good! Pineapple Ace Cider- delicious! Angry Orchard was the main cider in FL where we were so I was happy to see Ace! Shared a burger with fries- good portions, double patty, plenty of toppings *Ordered the pickle juice mayo on the side- highly recommend!* *Angus Stack Burger* $22 beef patties, lettuce, tomato, american cheese, ssp remoulade sauce, toasted potato bun, french fries The band was AMAZING! They had the crowd dancing, of all ages = a great band! Lots of seating- bar seating or dining seating- first come, first serve! Really busy so plan on the possibility of waiting for a table. Party area (Reserved for parties/events) on the back of the pier seating area Bathrooms in resort parking area- a little walk from restaurant Parking- street metered parking, paid parking lots *We paid $50 in a parking lot blocks away, it was all day until 3am- security 24/7 *bartender said that's a good price in that area* Don't miss this spot in Key West!

He joined the fun.

Mahi Mahi sandwich

See all

View from the pier

Key West Conch Fritters

4.0(94 reviews)

•$

Needed a quick snack before heading out of Key West and the docents at the Customs House museum…read morerecommended this place. Conch fritters were delicious - might have been a hair overcooked on the outside and a hair undercooked on the inside but great flavor. Dipping sauces were great - we had spicy mayo and key lime mustard. It's an outdoor food truck in the middle of town - great central location. The guy who took our order was so friendly and fun - everything cooked to order!

This traditional Key West style pink and white shack is next to the aquarium and sponge market…read more Before going into the aquarium, grabbed a cold homemade Key Limeaid drink for $4.00, seems Key Lime is the big flavor around these parts. It was a large Pepsi cup (would have liked a business logo stamped cup) and helped to quench my thirst but maybe too sugary of a sweet treat. Walking around Key West it is always a good idea to have fluids with you to avoid heatstroke. As for eats, they specialize in fried conch and chicken fritters with shrimp, clam and fish baskets. Like everywhere else around the Keys, they also offer key lime pie on the stick. No line out front so not really how sure the quality of the food other than from customer reviews with a 4 star rating, but a great spot with cheap fried food and soft drinks.

Sauces

Fritters

See all

Yummy crab - Key West

4.1(91 reviews)

This restaurant is located on the second floor. It has your classic seafood boil decor inside. I…read moredid find it strange they did not offer whole shrimp vs. headless shrimp. I was also shocked with the price at $32 per pound for that shrimp. Seasoning was decent, but it really didn't taste fresh and felt frozen. Service was ok. Our server didn't check up on us too often. I always had to ask for a refill on my soda. Would I go back to this place, probably not. I can get a better seafood boil in Miami.

So disappointing, I seen that this place had good reviews…read moreso family and I decided to try this place. Plus seaside has to be good and fresh. Well we're a big group we did get seating fairly fast beside them having to out tables together they weren't busy at all. Once we got seating we wait for a good 10 mins or so for menus we had to eventually grab our selves. A couple walked in few minutes after us and got their menu as they sat down Now the boil. The spice they had for the boil had a sweet taste might have been the premade seafood boil seasoning. Thats what it tasted like to me .Wasn't to my liking. Something was eh about it. The fried oysters had a but if a fishy taste no go. I know a lot of places weights the seafood but the portions when they came out it was more like they added more corn and potatoes. For the price definitely wasn't worth it.

#6 crawfish and snow crab

See all

1lbs. Shrimp and 1lbs. Snow Crab with Cajun seasoning.

Hot Tin Roof

4.1(725 reviews)

•$$$

Visited again as part of our tenth anniversary and we're very happy with everything…read more First starters, the restaurant had our table waiting with a sign wishing us a happy anniversary. Our server, Joann, did everything right. The food was amazing and so was the ambiance. Our original visit in 2019 was a five star review so this is just more of the same. My wife and I had the Burrata to start and then shared the Ossobuco. We also had the caramel apple cheesecake as dessert.

Ocean Key Resort is one of the best resorts in Key West. Hot Tin Roof is the restaurant inside…read moreOcean Key Resort. We only had breakfast, but the breakfast was at average at best. There was nothing wrong with the breakfast or service. It just tasted...average, and low quantity. The impression I get, and I may be wrong, is that Hot Tin Roof breakfasts are for those customers staying at Ocean Key, and most likely are comped or the breakfast is part of the package. I have no clue about lunch or dinners at Hot Tin Roof. I had bacon, eggs, and chopped up potatoes. The bacon and eggs were just fine, I mean how do you screw that up? The potatoes were plain and not very much. Noting the breakfasts of the wife and kid, I felt the same....average at best. It left me for looking for an early lunch on Duval street. I believe they add an 18% "service charge" on the check regardless of size of party.

See all

Ahi tuna tacos

The Conch Shack

4.0(539 reviews)

Location- excellent located on a main walking busy popular street…read more Food- it was okay, excellent service and quick We ordered Sample platter- mainly fries on the bottle, only 4 pieces of fried conch and 2-3 fried conch fritters. The conch was good size, the ratio of the batter to conch is not balance- too much batter and dry. The Sample conch ceviche is was tiny contain in a ketchup dipping sauce container.

This shack came highly recommended from social media so I was excited to try "Key West's best conch…read morefritters". However, this was not our experience. The conch fritters were overcooked and burnt. They were extremely hard and crunchy. We did notice that the cook stepped away for a long time while our conch fritters were in the deep fryer cooking, causing them to be overcooked. However, we were the only customers there, so they could have easily remade a fresh batch that was not overcooked. I would not try this shack again or recommend it to others.

Lobster roll

See all

Conch ceviche and conch fritters

Lucy's Cafe

4.7(34 reviews)

Stopped by for a quick bite with my son before Kino's for shoes. Ordered the chicken quesadilla and…read morefries for my son, and a medium Dulce con leche coffee for myself. The fries come out made to order and be forewarned they are HOT. They come with ketchup packets but the flavor is so good you don't need anything else. My son ate his quesadilla but as expected, got full (hence why this mother knew not to order any food for herself). I had the last piece of chicken quesadilla with the accompanying guacamole that had a perfect blend of tomato, onion and avocado. My dulce con leche coffee was also pretty good but not the best I've had though I'd recommend if you're in the mood for coffee. Easily a hole in the wall you'd miss if not looking for it and glad we stopped in. $30 for a chicken quesadilla, fries and coffee seems a bit steep but I guess it's to be expected in Key West

Lobster roll was disappointing, was a little chewy/ overcooked. Pretty but pretty small portion…read morefrom first glance when first opening to go container. Wish I would have tried some other recommended spot for the lobster roll honestly.

The inside

See all

Front entrance

Bagatelle

4.1(950 reviews)

10/10!! Literally…read moreamazing. No notes. Best views, the crab cake was amazing for our appetizer. I got the lobster fettuccine and it was so tasty. Our server was quick and polite. Drinks are on the pricier side - but in my opinion totally worth it.

We dined at bagatelle for a late dinner. We were seating on the upstairs porch/balcony looking out…read moreonto the street and it was very nice. We didn't try any of the drinks so I can't speak to that but they sounded good. I had a Diet Coke, which I'm including in my review because I noticed most places on Key West had Pepsi (I know it's silly but I'm a Pepsi hater!). We started with the tuna poke and shishito peppers. The tuna was fabulous and had a great sauce. I would skip the peppers next time, nothing was wrong with them but it didn't stand out for me. For entrees I had the whole snapper which was served with rice and vegetables. The snapper was in some kind of sweet chili sauce and the fish was so crispy. It was delicious and filling, I wish I could have eaten more! My friend had the filet, I didn't try it but she enjoyed it very much. The service was okay, not bad, not outstanding. Overall, I would highly recommend!

French toast (morning HH)

See all

Two Friends Patio

4.0(1.5k reviews)

I got the spicy seafood combo and the blackened Mahi with the spicy cocktail dipping sauce was…read morefreaking delicious! Fried Buffalo shrimp was superb and the scallops in the marinara sauce.... Now, let's just say I'm not a fan of marinara sauce, but the spicy definitely made me like it More! The dill sauce that was by the mashed potatoes and I was dipping them on was fantastic! My husband got the shellfish combo. They said the lobster was perfectly cooked, and he is currently inhaling the snow crab. Legs, and I can't even see the shrimp on the plate anymore. LOL so apparently he must have liked that... We set on the inside bar where the AC was. There was 3 bartenders for the tiny little bar, not much interaction from any of them. Its karaoke night so my hubby has to of course sing a song... We might even come back for breakfast tomorrow! FYI... the prices are not on the menu for reason ..

BLUF: delicious food with friendly service Went with a very…read morelarge group on a weekday night. They accommodated all of us, and the waiters really had to hussle, I can tell you that. To a person everyone enjoyed their food. They have a seafood platter that is a very generous portion of fish, scallops, and shrimp that was delicious. Highly recommend. Also got a side of steamed mussels: wow, they were nice meaty mussels in a delicious wine sauce that was perfect for dipping the two pieces of cheesy toast that come with it. They have a virgin version of most of their cocktails, and i can highly recommend the virgin mango daquiri. Key lime pie for dessert was delicious. I'd definitely go back and have recommended it to my friends

Great atmosphere live music

THE BEST Shrimp on the island

See all

Bloody Mary

Lagerheads

4.4(148 reviews)

Great little joint situated on a small beach. It is very small with a porch and a few stools. The…read moregrandeur is the beach/sand which is perfect for families with little kids. Some of the bigger kids and adults will jump off the landing into the water. Service is friendly and food is ok. I can't really comment as one of my fish tacos, the fish was undercooked and a bit slimy but the other one was cooked to perfection. We came here during our cruise port stop and it was really busy at 11am. Get here early if you want a spot.

This was our first stop on the trip to key west. Very cool little beach bar to get some quick…read moresnacks and drinks. Bartender was very nice and quick with drinks too. Get the pirate punch... you're welcome.

Where you order

Fish tacos

See all

Pickles Pub

3.5(252 reviews)

Lured in by the sandwich board sign out front advertising $5 pickle shots…read more Bartender served them up lickity split, shots were taken, and we were on our way. Interior was classic Key West dive bar vibe with neon signs, high tops and bar seating.

Brief stop over during our meandering walk around the area near Mallory Square. Dive bar vibe and…read moregreat venue to relax and enjoy a cold beverage. Friendly staff and plan to return to sample the menu.

Build Your Own Burger

See all

Pickle shots

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

14 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Armando C.

10 years ago

This restaurant is not GOOD DON'T COME, they over charge people. Don't come, one meal that cost $13.75 & you ask for extra meat & sauce 4 sauces 2oz a piece cost $6.50. a piece. You end up paying $35.00 dollars it's outrageous. Be careful ! ! ! I pay that like I got 3 meals for 1 ! ! ! no stars. Que lastima, un dia anterior hable y la persona a cargo del telephone me colgo (se nego a contestar Me descomunico) sin embargo VOLVI A HABLAR. Y Ordene lo que tanto me Gusta ceviche mixto con extra sauce. Picante. OK llegue a Su nice restaurant y el trato fue. 09/23/2016 Inaceptable aun asi, le di un poco de propina. Y pense esta busy, ocupada, no tenia a nadie solo una mesa con una persona. OK hoy Ordene los tallarines con huancaina extra Carne y extra huancaina salsa. Me dijo que eran $6.95 por la carne. Si le dije que el precio no es problema. $6.50 por salsa, no me lo dijo y salio su esposo (dueño) con una Cara que queria matarme!!! Me COBRO $34.35 dollars. Llego a Mi casa y NO tenia la extra Carne!!! Como lo sentiria USTED !!! No lo PUEDO CREER!!! INACEPTABLE!!! COMPRENDE AHORA !!! Si asi tratan BIEN!!! ME DESPIDO DE USTEDES!!! NO ES JUSTO !!! Y me dice que deberia pagar $48.00 le voy a hablar al code enforcement !!! GOD BLESS YOU ! ! ! Rip off !!! Y ademas Me dijo que NO MAS SERVICIO!!! Buena forma de hacer clientes (negocio). QUE LASTIMA. But, what goes around comes around ! ! ! read more

Rebeca R.

14 years ago

Loved the food, I got addicted to it since the first time I tried it, now I go there almost every day for my aguadito de pollo, but that not the only thing I like, i've tried almost everything in the Menu and it rocks, my kids love the salchipapas and my husband the ceviche. Don't hesitate to try it, you won't regret it. read more

Miguel R.

13 years ago

Some of the best Authentic Peruvian food you will taste in Florida. The service and attention is second to none. Food is prepared to order. Best prices . You need to have the Lomo Salteado or el Ceviche unless you go to Peru you will not have anything better. read more

Doris C.

13 years ago

The best food I tried last week while at key west was at this restaurant. Very good. Really recommend it! La mejor comida que comimos la semana pasada en key west fue en este restaurante. La cominda estaba excelente y el servicio muy amable! read more

Ricardo S.

13 years ago

What a tasty dinner. Lovely little spot in Old Town that is reasonable, immaculate and friendly. We live in Key West 1/2 the year and have many restaurant choices. Incas is worthy! Volveremos read more

Kathryn H.

13 years ago

Ceviche excellent. Three times price anywhere else. All seafood awesome fresh. Went with son and Peruvian girlfriend and they were very happy with meal. Special dessert gratis!! Wow! read more

ReechUp T.

156

2 years ago

We never got a chance to try their food. They were closed during their regular business hours with no explanation. No note on the door.

Elizabeth L.

7 years ago

The sign and yelp says that they close at 9 arrived before 8:30 and they were closed. 20 minute walk was a waste...

Raymond V.

540

8 years ago

We love this place! Great little spot in Key West, off the beaten path with spectacular food!

Vicki P.

10 years ago

Absolutely worth it...so good and home made every dish made terrifically! Will be back...

Kenia G.

10 years ago

Love the food, more than I was expecting it was absolutely delicious...will recommend 100%

Veronica K.

14 years ago

Excellent food. Nice interior. Will be back

Robert R.

13 years ago

Great food, great customer service.

Z. Michelle O.

10 years ago

Fantastic ceviche and great service

Incas Restaurant - peruvian - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Incas Restaurant also viewed

Chico's Cantina

3.9

(255 reviews)

An independent business that you feel great about supporting…read more Robin was our excellent waitress, and truly knew the entire menu, and made perfect suggestions based on our tastes. Luis kept our waters filled, and that is no easy task for my family and I who drink a lot of water. Drink selections are ambitious, and I would absolutely come back.

The food was delicious!!!! We are from Texas and this was the first Mexican food we've enjoyed in…read moreSouth Florida. Service was excellent. It's just a cute mom and pop hole in the wall place with really good cheese dip!

El Mocho Restaurant

4.3

(88 reviews)

•$

Great service and they do have the best bread. There cuban mixes i think are one of the best .read more

Was a little disappointed with m last visit - they don't tell you they are including the gratuity…read moreand then we included one and only after we received our receipt via text after did we realize that we had double tipped. Another FYI - we ate there and when we didn't finish, they charged us for a to go container - little things but they are memorable. Now....on to the food As others said, the Cuban bread is great for whatever you get with it. I believe the hash browns are like the frozen things you get at MccDonald's so pas on those unless you like that - at a mom and pop place, I'm expecting homemade. We sat outside and if you go to the counter and order, they will bring it out for you.

Mangoes

3.5

(668 reviews)

We were the only ones dining - arrive at 5pm just in time for the dinner menu…read more Staff was nice and the outdoor area is cute with a big mirror too. Decent vegetarian options I would say! Though a "Caribbean " restaurant, I wouldn't say there was much on the menu that screamed Caribbean lol The lobster roll was better than I expected (I have low expectations as many places do them wrong) but great toasted bun but wish I could taste more of that key lime Aioli (which ultimately made me get it !)

This was part of our walking food tour, so we didn't get to experience the full dining experience…read more One of the featured items during our stop was the fried conch, but due to an allergy issue, I opted out and was given two chicken tacos instead. The chicken tacos were actually pretty good -- mild yet flavorful. Surprisingly, the chicken was moist and tender rather than dry, which I appreciated. The area was louder than I expected, but it also seemed very popular with both tourists and locals alike. The restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating, along with a huge full bar. From what I saw on other people's tables, the portion sizes were very generous, making it feel like a good value for the money. Overall, I'd recommend this place, especially if it's included as part of a local food tour.

Yummy crab - Key West

4.1

(91 reviews)

Havana Island Cafe

4.7

(15 reviews)

Delicious spot! Hit the mark for a casual quick bite between walking up and down duval street. Came…read moremultiple times and each time was consistently delicious. The people working there are all very nice too. Our group enjoyed the fish and shrimp tacos, the sandwiches, and the quesadillas. I loved the birria tacos, sweet plantains and yucca fries. Only recommendation is the mayo juice is very watery. I would skip and instead bring your own beverage!

Such a hidden gem and great food! Stopped in for a quick lunch after a walk around town. The conch…read morebites were awesome - seriously they're slept on! We also had the steak burrito and Key West burrito - also phenomenal. The pricing was fair and the burritos are huge. Definitely check it out for a quick bite if you're able to.

Viva Argentinian Steakhouse

4.1

(498 reviews)

We sat at the bar with Matthew bartending. Enjoyed a fabulous spicy paloma and a viva mojito! We…read moregot to sit outside and enjoy love music! The mussels are from new Zealand and tatse amazing! We also enjoyed some warm brie. Definitely coming back!

Stopped in while in town and watched the Spain vs Austria game here. The good news was that happy…read morehour started at the same time as the game (3pm). Beers were tasty and cold. Service was warm and friendly. The small bites we tried were delicious.

Sandy's Cafe

4.5

(223 reviews)

Great amazing food. Made fresh. Locals spot for sure. Friendly staff…read more No food pictures because it was all gone by the time I remembered to take photos. Highly recommend

Pros: Cuban sandwich was outstanding, fast service Cons:…read moreonly 6 stools for seating, fries were mushy, cheese quesadilla was undercooked cheese not melted, cashier wasn't super friendly Overall it was just okay

Milagro Restaurant and Bar

4.6

(180 reviews)

What a gem of a place! A breath of fresh air in the middle of all the rough pubs, touristy bars,…read moreand raunchy places. Milagro feels casual yet elevated. Terrific food! Our octopus was some of the best we've had anywhere, the tacos were 10/10 in every bite, and the meatballs.. mmm!! Too bad we were too full to try anything else. We booked this place for our anniversary dinner while in town and we weren't disappointed. Julio is a master waiter, so attentive and full of class.

Honestly I hate leaving bad reviews but for how expensive the menu was- it was a must. The chicken…read moredinner was disappointing. Chicken had no flavor, vegetables were not cooked- specifically the carrots and green beans, the sauce was extremely bland. The only good thing was the Mac and cheese. The enchilada dinner was ok. Should have came with rice or something. Basically just meat and cheese. Caesar salad was ok, could have had more crotons. Served with 2 pierces of anchovies which was not described on the menu. Chairs were uncomfortable. Decor was nice and the bathrooms were clean.

Hurricane Hole

4.1

(127 reviews)