The two sandwiches I ordered online for in-store pickup were done incorrectly. The #17 was something completely different and the #2 was not done Mike's way with oil and vinegar. The manager was not there. I requested they deliver the correct order or refund me the cost of the order since only the chips were correct. They refused to do either. Even though the store made the mistake, they wanted me to drive back to the store to pick up a #17 and prove they had forgotten the oil and vinegar on the #2. I will attempt to contact the manager tomorrow, but we'll never order from that store again. I spoke to the manager this morning 3/1. He was willing to refund the cost of the #17 because the staff knew they had given me the wrong sandwich but not the #2 unless I had been willing to drive back to the store to prove they had made it incorrectly. Definitely never ordering from that store again. read more

Rude employees, they give so much attitude, ESPECIALLY the short guy. The others don't seem well trained.

If I could give negative stars I would. The employees here are so un-interested in customer service it's incredible. They are more interested in playing grab a$$, that they act BOTHERED when you walk in. The blond young lady is the worst of the bunch. Nono e says welcome or hello and no one says thank you goodbye. When it's time to dress your sandwich you just get stared at. Worst service I've ever received. I've given this place several attempts to get better and it gets worse. No more for me. Someone needs to fix this, because the food is great. read more

Love Jersey Mikes, and my food has been good quality despite others reviews. The Customer Service at this location is horrible. They are rude, ignore you, I went in to pick up a pre paid order and felt invisible. I grew up in the customer service industry.. the service in this place (I gave it three tries) can ruin the business. Foundation of a business is the customers.. Will go to another location even tho this one is close to home. Very disappointing. read more

I placed my order for online pickup, said no mayo and they covered my wrap in mayo. Wasted $15 as it went in the trash. Do yourself a favor and avoid this location, they cant follow instructions on a sandwich. read more

We have been to many many Jersey Mike's all over the country and this particular store is the absolute worst one!!! We ordered 3 regular subs (approx $30) for pick up and this is where everything went down hill. Got to the store only to have to wait another 25 mins just to pick up the subs. Even though there were 4 or 5 workers, there was a line of at least 15 people waiting to order, plus another line of 7-8 people for the online pickup. None of the workers seemed to really care nor did they seem to have a handle on the assembly line - very chaotic and disorganized. We get home and sit down to eat....3 subs, all 3 completely wrong. First, none of the subs had any condiments, none, zip, zilch. No lettuce, no tomato, no mayo, no mustard, no nothing. And the bread....the bread looked like something that has been dropped on the floor a few times and had a jar of pickles sitting on it - yes, the bread smelled like pickles, was soggy like it sat in pickle juice, but yet no pickles on the sub...what?!? We love Jersey Mike's, but we will NOT be back to this place. This is the 3rd time at this shop that food and service has been mediocre at best, certainly not up to par with the Jersey Mike's reputation. My advice, skip the disappointment and go to the shop on Bell. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - You decide...do these look like the subs in the advertisement?!? - Fast Food Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

If I could give zero stars i would. We ordered online and every single sandwich was wrong. upon calling, it was said they were out of everything and just replaced it without asking. after not making it until 10 mins after pickup time. we were standing in store and they couldn't ask if a substitute was ok. then, manager joe claimed he sent us a refund and it would be in our account in 3-5 days. A week later, manager Zack says there's no refund on tap and we must come back a third time with a receipt. We asked if there was an email of number to send it to and he rudely responded no no no and was snotty to us. Super rude and unhelpful. the whole situation is a disaster due to ignorant staffing. read more

Better than freaky fast! Zach and Tristan are so friendly! The food is always amazing. Thank you for being open!

Beyond horrible customer service. There were four of us in line and the employees decided to work on a HUGE online order before helping any of us. The person who ordered was NOT in the store the entire time we were there. No apology or anything. It took 19 min to get one regular sub. Because of the online orders that apparently take priority over customers in the store all the toppings were at the bottom of their containers. The nice lady behind me asked for fresh lettuce because what was left was old and browning and they looked at her like she was crazy and said "you want me to pull more from the fridge?" Like questioning if she really wanted them to do so. She she's yes of course and the employee rolled his eyes. I didn't even complain about the brown lettuce on my sub. Jimmy Johns it is from here on out m. At least they take care of the customers in store first. read more

Never again I was standing in line to have my order taken. I should have just walked out after what I saw. The person cutting the cheese and meat just stood back and sneezed. He did step back but he didn't cover up but wipe his nose with his sleeved and the when back to his making the sandwiches. I guess when he sneezed he doesn't sprays. Now it is my turn to order. I told him the number, size, and bread type. He got the size correct but he made the sandwich which he wanted. He told me he can't hear. So the next step they place it on the counter where he sneezed on which wasn't clean after he did that. I guess at Mikes paper linings are very expensive. Next I was asked do I want it like Mike dose. Sure but don't put on any tomatoes. Well she made it the way she wanted it too. I did hear her said to others that she can't hear too. When she was done she done she put it on the counter where every sandwich is made. Next the wrap up time. I said I like it for here. Well every table that was empty was not clean. So I had to clean for them. At the checkout they asked if you want to leave a tip? I am glad that I didn't tip them like they wanted me to do. So if I want to eat it there I have to clean the tables for them? Next time if I am in this area I going to go next door to Rubio's. When they take your order you get it correct. Here is the amazing thing, they bring it to you and the tables are clean. If it wrong they will fixed it. read more

Our sandwiches were delicious! Fresh ingredients crisp lettuce made it a perfect experience! We will definitely come back.

I walk into the location at Happy Valley and Lake Pleasant pkwy at 8pm on 5/16 and was informed that they had run out of bread. I understand things happen, but the 15 minutes it took me to drive to get your awesome sandwiches, I left with nothing. The two boys behind the counter couldn't even offer an apology for my inconvenience. When I asked what they were planning on doing for the next hour they were open, the response was "nothing" followed by laughter. Great job Jersy Mikes! read more

I've never had a problem with Jersey Mikes. But today I ordered for pickup 2 stickball subs , have had them before and they were delicious. This time when I got home and opened the wrapper the bread was hard and there was like only one ounce of meat on the whole sandwich. It was like eating 2 pieces of bread with a little bit of lettuce and a tomato. The top of the bread was hard and crumbly. I would give them a zero if I could for this order. Will be going to Jimmy Johns across the street. read more

Chicken Philly was more like the consistency of a chicken salad. The only thing I saw in it were chopped red bell pepper and onion. No cheese,tomato,or anything else. Really,the worst sub that I have eaten from any sub shop. I always liked Jersey Mike's in the Midwest,but this one is a joke. read more

contacting me. To day I placed an order almost 2 hours before I scheduled to pick it up and when I arrived they told me they could not make my order because they were out of bread. In the meantime they served a family with 4 sandwiches and 3 other guests. And in the same breath told me that they couldn't make my sandwich because they were out of bread and that my refund would take 2-3 days to process. This is unacceptable and unprofessional! read more

Just wanted to post a quick review. We got there at the end of the lunch rush and I ordered the veggie sub. Hazel offered to clean off the slicer for me and that was such a thoughtful gesture I did not want it to go unnoticed. Thank you! read more

The staff could not make the 20 USD sub correctly. The tried twice. Called and informed them after driving home. I bought the sub at 1:36 and just returned home at 3:29. Imagine running a business where u not only can't fulfill the agreement but then refuse to honor the agreement, but u tie up you customer for two hours of their time bc your staff is incapable and combative. They told me to bring it back. They inspected the sub, tried to argue with me, provided refund for incorrect amount. Manager was combative and incredibly rude. What is going on in food service where customers don't get what they order. It is a simple transaction, the younger people just don't care about providing a fair exchange. Money for a product, it is simple but we have so hurt these young people that they get offended when we tell then they made a mistake. It Is insane. Manager also used political slander during the converstation. I won't go back to any Jersey Mike's again. read more

The management allowed a customer wearing a MAGA hat AND NO MASK to be served. When the manager was confronted about it, pointing out their MASK REQUIRED sign, he said he didn't notice the customer wasn't wearing a mask. LIAR! COWARD! They are so afraid of losing one customer that they just lost many more. Do not eat here. The management clearly doesn't carr about your health snd safety and you'll get sick. read more

Horrible management, it seems like the managers there would rather bully their employees and bicker rather than take care of their customers. I don't recommend you come here due to the lack of attention that's given to the customers who have been waiting for over 10 minutes to order over employees highschool drama. It seems like this place is ran by kindergarteners at best. read more

This place is just has lazy employees. You customers waiting to place orders yet two or three employees playing footie in the back. They finally came out after the one guy who killin himself behind the counter calls for them. Yet they maintain to have zero urgency or care in the world. Their interaction with customers was simply poor and dismissive. The establishment as a whole does not appear to be sanitary and smells. While I enjoy the franchise I'll go across the street to Jimmy John's and not get dysentery. read more

The subs are good and hot. The inside is a mess. No napkins at the tables. Trash can is overflowing. The tables themselves and seats were dirty. The service was slightly slow. Since it's a new restaurant and hopefully the bugs will be ironed out, but for right now I can't really recommend it unless you get it to go. read more

Just placed an order for delivery through postmates. One of my sandwiches did not come as ordered online. I contacted the store and they said they couldn't do a refund since it was ordered through postmates. They would make another sandwich but could not deliver it. read more

Was there today, nice people but darn turn the music down we couldnt even hear ourselves talking. Sandwich was sub par will not be going back. Firehouse subs much better. On top of that the cashier seemed to have trouble working the cc machine i checked my credit card tonite and he charged it 3 times now I have to make sure it comes off the card. What a pain in butt and waste of money. read more

If I wasn't starving I would have thrown the food out!!! Bread was totally stale and overcooked. Staff ~ Omgosh so unwelcoming and not good at all!!! Had to remind them that the sandwich we ordered had bacon on it ~ I don't recommend and won't be back. I know this is common nowadays with staffing shortages etc but it's not worth the price to eat here ever again! read more

My absolute favorite sub shop. I love that they slice everything fresh right as you order it. All of the standard subs can be in a soft bun, a wrap or a salad. The seasonings and dressing is delicious! read more

They seemed to be a bit flustered. And I didn't like the way they slid the bread on the counter top to get the condiments on. I would like to see the bread placed on the sandwich paper and then prepare my sandwich. Instead of the meat slicer person continued to touch my bread and everything else he touches. He wrote a order then touch the meat. Not good! The least mount of things you touch the better. read more

Ordered online. Went to pick up at the time it was supposed to be ready and waited 10 more minutes. Would have been faster to go in and order. The people I would have been in line ordering behind were done much quicker. When I got there the young man says they were still working on it. After 10 minutes i asked another young man and he said here you go. It was sitting there ready the entire time. Then the employees were not very nice about it when I advised them to let the employee at the front register know that it had been ready when I had arrived so I wouldn't have had to wait for nothing. Subs were ok. Not worth the high prices. read more

Ordered 3 wraps for an order in. Place wax busy and definitely under staffed. One of my wraps was completely wrong and ended up as a sandwich. Tried to tell the cashier but he ignored me as there about 4 other people waiting for their food. Gonna have to call manager later after the lunch rush. read more

I love Jersey Mike's but today was disappointing. The music was so loud we had to go eat in our car. I always get a sandwich in a tub. Today they did not offer to cut the tomatoes or onions (nor do they have knives in their silverware packets) which seems smAll until you're trying to eat a giant tomato slice in your salad. They also left the bacon off, lets be real that's the best part. To top it off, the girl checking us out (who was friendly) wore the same gloves to cash out the person in front of us as she did to make our food. Gross. Very very disappointed. read more

Jersey Mike's never disappoints and this location is no exception. Shift lead austin was very friendly and made me a delicious sub! Thank you for the hard work guys! read more

The problem is not just Jersey Mike's but also Door Dash. First, this location can't seem to get the orders right. Missing items that cost extra not just once. Gave them another chance. Next Door Dash: notified the "contact us" as soon as the errors were found. Agent said that no correction as it's been more than 24 hours. Are you kidding me??? It hasn't been 24 MINUTES. YOU LOST OUR BUSINESS read more

Had a great meal at the food court at Luke AFB and was happy went the store in peoria opened. The sandwich I tried was nothing like the one at LukeAFB.. Meat was overly salted and rather skimpy. Glad i used the coupon. read more

The employees in the shop tonight were possibly the friendliest food service workers I've ever encountered. It was very clean inside as well. Great experience. read more

This location truly has the rudest employees. They never acknowledge customers that walk in and they constantly mumble rude comments about customers under their breath. If I was the manager I would fire everyone and start looking for new employees! read more

Excellent sandwich. The Turkey is delicious and always fresh. The sandwiches are made quickly and efficiently. The veggie sandwich is delicious as well. The shop is clean. My only complaint is the price is a little high for a sandwich. read more

I love jersey mikes. It's 10x better than subway. But today was not one of those days. I was told by multiple managers that if you take off two meats you can replace it with another. I get a number 13 no prosciuttini or cappacuolo add turkey. Makes sense to be able to do that because Italian meats are always much more expensive than turkey. I go to pay and I am charged 2.50 for turkey. I asked why. They said it's a "heavier" meat. I got one slab of turkey on my sandwich when I opened it. What do you mean heavier??? And it STILL had cappacuolo on it. I ask for light oil and vinegar, but still too much oil and vinegar that my bread was falling apart on the bottom. read more

I use to go to subway for my subs and I still was not happy so I went to a local meat market to find a true Italian sub, but then a Jersey Mike's was opened near my home and I gave it a try and I fell head over heels with the quality and service Adam kaylee grace Joe and those I can't remember their names sorry but this store is the greatest. Food and service they try to remember you and what you get so they can get it right every time. I will always recommend them. read more

I see a lot of negative comments on this page, however, I would like to praise this location for their hard work and positive attitudes. I've been coming in since grand opening, and I have never had an issue. The employees always seem to be super helpful and respectable. I know that me, and a lot of other customers respect them for their hard work. They don't deserve or earn all of these negative comments - no one writes about all the positives. Thank you Lake Pleasant Jersey Mikes for continuing to serve your community! read more

Came in today in for lunch and food was great. I asked them about catering meal for 50 people but one person couldn't answer and person in charge didn't seem interested in giving me more info so we will have subway do the catering. read more

First time in here at 5:00 on Sunday night it was horrible the lady who got my order was so rude and in a rush she didn't even ask me what I wanted in it when I asked to add stuff I asked for a second and she rushed me again. Got my order wrong I wanted it toasted and it wasn't and the prices are kinda ridiculous for a sandwich. I don't know why they moved subway and replaced it with this place subway is way faster, nicer, and cheaper. Plus this place doesn't even have Dr Pepper. I was gonna give them the benefit of the doubt but when that lady was that rude nope not going back there again. I wish I got here name brown hair teenager don't even wanna give one star zero stars I'm that annoyed with how I was treated and how gross my sandwich is. read more