Order was correct, food was delicious. Very fast delivery. A bit pricey, but sandwich was big enough for two meals.

They made my sandwich wrong and the employees would not fix it because I took a bite of it. They just said sorry and gave my sandwich back. The Dutch Crunch bread was so hard it hurt your mouth to eat it. Rude employees. Small potions of meat. Hardly any condiment's. Sooo disappointing read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Dutch crunch bread. So hard it hurts your mouth to eat. Ask for my sandwich heated and they gave it to me cold. - Sandwiches Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

Did not like it. We ordered a Reuben with marble bread and the Goomba on Dutch crunch and a side of Mac salad. My Reuben was mehhhhh. Lacked 1000 and sauerkraut. My husbands Goomba was gross to me. Not an Italian - sweet tang to it I didn't like. He liked the amount of meat, but said the quality was not to compare to Jersey Mikes. Macaroni Salad tasted like - Kraft mayo, red onion and noodle. Gross. No thanks for us! read more

We ordered 2 turkey sandwiches through Uber Eats in a buy one get one promotion. The sandwiches were warm which is how they were supposed to come. They were mediocre at best. Way too much mayonnaise and not enough turkey. Not sure what kind of deli meat they used, it didn't seem high quality though. I'd give them another try, but get a different sandwich. read more

I'll excuse how hot it is inside this place but the charging for items and not giving paid for items to customers is a valid enough reason to not return. Or before you walk out check each individual item meticulously. That picture is $23 with a tip and clearly they need that tip money if they will steal from guest. The sandwich is $13.99 for what at most places would be their large but this it their whole. I put their cookie next to the sandwich to show size. It's a 6-8 inch sub at best for $14. Coleslaw is a reasonable $2.99 but make sure they put it in the bag or you'll be like me providing a rating of 0/5 because I paid for it but didn't get it. There's plenty of other better sandwich shops. I don't eat at subway but they would have been a better choice than Mr. stingy, I mean Pickle. read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Order missing coleslaw! - Sandwiches Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

I really wanted to like this place because I love sandwiches and we don't have a sandwich place that isn't a large chain brand. But we have tried three times now and it's just not that good- the quality of the meats and breads is just disappointing read more

First time. Ordered Mrs Pickles on sourdough. It's just ok not great. They give you a lot of turkey and it is fresh but toppings were sparse (lettuce/tomatoes/pickles/red onions) and they forgot the garlic sauce. The bread was too doughy and thick, too much bread in my opinion. Not sure if there is an option to "hollow out the bread"? I'd like to try the pastrami next but this would not be my "go to place" for sandwiches. I prefer Jimmy Johns. read more

The menu online doesn't at all do this place justice. Glad we tried it anyways. Not enough places to sit but it is a sandwich shop. The sandwiches selection is awesome - lots hot and cold! I would say the drink selection is mediocre. Parking is awful at this location which makes it hard for a run on and out. I had the hot CJ pastrami. It was not hot so it didn't start well. The bread is very thick and dense and the meat tasted like cheap deli meat in a bag. We also got the Big Jake cold and that was very good. I will give it another try but leaning towards and 'eh' for future. read more

See all

I think they must have just opened as everything is new and shiny and I've not noticed them in this location before. I'm thinking it was probably just too soon to stop in. It is a counter-service only style shop. Service is excruciatingly slow with numerous of us customers crammed into the small space represented by the space inside the door up to the counter. All I ordered was the Reuben to go and it took a verrrry long time. I counted seven (7) employees in this small sandwich shop all behind the counter, four (4) on the sandwich line alone. The Reuben sandwich actually wasn't bad at all, so I think I'll just wait a few more months and give them a try again then. PS: Do not be fooled by the name . . . you don't get a complimentary pickle spear with your sandwich. :) read more

Wonderful sandwiches!! Love the bread! The toppings were fresh and loaded up and the meats were high quality! I look forward to trying different sandwiches :) read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Chicken salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Always had a great experience and they make the sandwich custom to my liking. I highly recommend this place

I really enjoyed the sandwiches and bread was really good and it comes with a cookie which is very sweet . Ordered the cheesesteaks a bit unorthodox to use what seems deli meat nonetheless enjoyed and I ordered a chicken ranch with side of mango habanero was good , glad we have them in the valley to compete against the big sandwich companies . read more

Husband got a me a sammie to go with all dressings on the side. I didn't go in but he said service was ok. But the toppings were SERIOUSLY lacking. I got it "the works" and it had one and a half pickle slices and a singular pepperoncini.... The meat was really good. Could have been a great sandwhich. Instead it was just ok. read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - One singular pepperoncini and hardly any lettuce. - Sandwiches Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

I ordered the Mrs.Pickles which was listed as: turkey, bacon, Monterey Jack, avocado, and "the works" which included lettuce, tomato, onions, pepperoncini, mayonnaise, garlic aioli, and mustard. I requested no mayo or garlic aioli and selected sliced sourdough as my bread. The reason I list this sandwich as average is because it was made incorrectly, and the bread was toasted and hard on one side, but not toasted on the other side. It did not include the avocado as listed on the menu, and that's a big reason of why I ordered this sandwich. Is the sandwich good? Yes. Is it great? No. It would have been much better with the avocado and soft bread. This sandwich is supposed to be toasted, but I'd recommend not toasting the sourdough because the result is very hard bread that cuts the inside of your mouth. Service was fast and friendly, so perhaps the errors with the sandwich are the byproduct of growing pains. The store is relatively new. I'll try it again read more

This sandwich shop was excellent. I ordered my sandwich on white bread, and it was soft, fresh, and really delicious. The meat and cheese were thick and generous, making it very filling. Service was quick, and the place was well-lit, clean, and had plenty of comfortable seating to sit back and enjoy a great sandwich. read more

See all

Overpriced and double charged! Will not return. It's easy to see why ratings are "meh" for this new restaurant. I ate there in February 2026, and the food was good, but a small sandwich cost $10.88. The owner said my credit card didn't go through because of their card system, so I gave him a second card. Months later, I found out the charge went through on both cards, and the assistant manager would not give me my money back or a credit since the charges were months earlier. She said I would have to return to speak with the owner that day, but it was not convenient for me to do so. I therefore spent $21.76 on that good but not great sandwich. If you eat here, check your credit card receipt carefully. read more

bro was smackin down like there was no tomorrow this food was fireee!! the big easy was a solid choice!!! read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Bread was delicious. Light potions of meat and cheese. Was busy at the new location. I will go back, but Jersey Mikes still my go to. read more

Walked into shop, verbally ordered three sandwiches at the counter. After a bunch of confusion from the cashier that I just wanted a meat, bread and mayo on the sandwich...When I got home, it was still incorrect. They added lettuce which my 13-year-old does not like on her sandwich. Called and asked for credit for another sandwich and was told they don't do refunds or credits. You made the mistake and you won't rectify it? I did a little math and figured my family's order is approximately $45. We would probably grab sandwiches there twice a week. That's $360 worth of business that they apparently don't care to keep. I was really hoping that there was another choice of places to eat here at the four corners. Now, for our family, Mr. pickles is not one of them. read more

I just saw Mr. Pickles the for the first time the other day and had to try them out. I am half way thru my Goomba and it is really good. I hadn't heard of the Dutch Crunch bread before but it is amazing. The sandwich was good sized for the price and the ingredients were fresh. Will definitely be going back to try their other sandwiches. read more

Customer service and or order of operations need to change. Understandably this is a new place and training needs to change. You can't have someone at the register ring up the order wrong and not fix the sandwich for the customer when they didn't get what they ordered. Telling them there is no refunds when it's the establishments mistake is not acceptable. read more

Not sure what is special about this place. Bread was dry and hard, meat looked like ends and pieces. Wondering why the name Mr Pickle? We got a cookie that was hard and didn't seem fresh. Maybe I was expecting something unique. I will be staying with Jersey Mikes, but had to give Pickle a try. read more

There's a reason that all the Mr. Pickles in the valley are rated around 3 stars. It's not amazing, the menu sounds great. But the actual meal you get is lack luster. I got one with "the works" and it was so bland. Absolutely no flavor. My husband got a "hot=spicy" wrap and it was sized for a toddler and not spicy. We were the only ordering customers and it took them forever to make the meal. Sticking with Jersey Mike or Jimmy John or even 'grab and go' at QT. read more

I thought expensive. outdoor seating taken, inside-music way too loud and cold in there , we ended up eating in our car! I ordered BLT on sourdough. bread was very hard. could not finish. hubbys food was good. bad experience. read more

We came in with a big group and Mr. Pickle's was super accommodating. We grabbed outdoor seating, everyone loved their sandwiches, and the customer service was friendly and on point. read more

My son and I tried it and meat was high quality, nice presentation, soft bread, high quality cheese and the mayo was amazing. A must try! It was absolutely amazing! read more

Great sandwiches. Nice service. Very busy at times. Will go back. Lots to choose from.

Not impressed with the new location. We went there yesterday and were disappointed. Crunch bread was at least a day or two old. I asked for avocado on my sandwich and my wife asked for avocado on the side. Neither one of us got avocado. I asked for it and it took them almost 5 minutes to get it. Avocado had to be a day old cause it was brown. Not good. read more

Excited to know of something that originated from SF Bay Area! The pastrami sandwich was great . If you want a simple and not an over bearing sandwich of different flavors, this is the place! Warm, fresh with the works, makes it tasty with a good pile of meat. Love the combination of garlic spread and the Dutch crunch bread which is rare in most sandwich places. Tim the owner was very nice and helpful . This place is close to our house and convenient when shopping in the area. Will surely be back and plan to use them to cater a small gathering. Thank you for coming to 4 corners! read more

Mr Pickle's is absolutely phenomenal! The service was excellent and the ambiance was a vibe! Everyone is so kind and the food is delicious. Will absolutely be coming back as it has become a top 5 lunch spot for me! read more

I have tried this place several times and have been disappointed each experience. Twice I have been there during times when it was not busy. Food took 20 to 30 min to be prepared. Each time there were 3 employees. On one occasion 2 were singing and dancing to music instead of working. On that order we waiting at home 20 min after placing an online order and an additional 15 min in the shop as it wasn't ready. For a family of 4 to pay 80 for sandwiches, drinks and a tip for subpar service and food that isn't great no thank you. read more

Excellent customer service. Lexi knew the menu by heart and even asked if we wanted water while waiting. Very clean. Quick and order was correct. Nice job! read more

I ordered the Reuben - marble rye bread was hard and stale; sandwich was tasteless. My wife ordered a turkey sandwich with extra garlic sauce, didn't get any sauce. Will not go back. read more

We liked the meat and the toppings however I would stay away from the Dutch crunch roll. Probably the worst bread we have ever had, hard as a rock. Definitely not a good first impression. read more

It took way too long to build a sandwich plus 2 little sandwiches it was $31 I'm not going back

Excellent!!! Very busy but the staff was doing a great job. I had the pastrami and it was loaded with meat and very tasty! Bread was soft - environment clean - we will go back. read more

One of the best Rubens I've had in a while, they aren't shy with the meat or the sauerkraut. Over all really impressive sandwich.

I visited Mr. Pickles Sandwich shop last week and ordered a BLT sandwich on Rye Bread - when I got home the bread was dried out and hard - very disappointing - as I love their products - I live too far to bring it back - just thought the management should know - read more