The restaurant was overcapacity during a pandemic, not at 50%. patrons were standing around tables most We're not ordering food and just drinking. It seems the staff were selective on who had to order food and who didn't (we were there for Food and drink so that didn't matter). Bouncers on power trips assaulting customers physically and verbally... grabbed a member of my party and ripped the chair out from under him and grabbed him (while complaining about being in a pandemic he was in our 6-foot radius) cursed out a woman of our group (assuming because she filmed the bouncer assaulting the member of our party). Moral of the story would not recommend we've been here many times over the years and not sure where this bouncers power trip came From but it sure ruined my outlook of this Business and I will be sure to tell all my friends with homes out East and who frequent here. read more

Very cool place in Westhampton Beach. We stopped after our trip to Montauk Lighthouse and had some calamari, garlic shrimp and shrimp tacos. Fast friendly service, calamari was overdone but good and the garlic shrimp with rice and shrimp tacos were a hit! Fresh and tasty. We will be back! Oh and an added bonus Dune Rd. is amazing. read more

Let me start off by saying I love the atmosphere here. The Hamptons is known for fancy restaurants. This is a dive bar that reminds me of NYC. You have a beautiful outdoor seating area with live music at times, a large bar area and plenty of indoor dining. The drinks are pricey at $14 each, but they are strong. If you come here with 2 or more people, a buyback is usually a possibility. The food is very good, priced right, but won't blow you away. The Lobster roll is good, but for $39 you will be very disappointed. This is a great place to visit after a day at the beach. read more

*** for Ambiance. Come here for a place to sit near the ocean with a view of the reeds and bay water between the mainland and Dune Road. Far better than sitting in some dark restaurant inside somewhere.. So location is why you come here. ** Food was really just touristy stuff. Eat light here and have a drink of whatever you drink. ** Don't get the weird but huge baked clam.. strange to have minced peppers maybe celery and flavors that are not awesome. read more

John Scott's Surf Shack - This is the Surf Shack in Westhampton on Dune Road. - Salad Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

The food is pretty consistent, great view and service. Love the old bay fries and crab specials.

Grabbed lunch at John Scott's Surf Shack on Thursday afternoon. A mixed bag in terms of food, but isn't a bad spot to enjoy a drink when visiting Cupsogue Beach. Quality: We ordered the Blackened Shrimp Tacos and the Lobster Roll to share. The Blackened Shrimp Tacos were just okay. Filled with house slaw, field greens, pico de gallo and smoky garlic lime sauce with corn salsa on the side, they just seemed to be overloaded and leaving a muddled flavor. The Lobster Roll was better, but still had issues. That issue was certainly not the mounds of delicious lobster, which I was a big fan of. It was the pathetic piece of bread it was served on and the less than thrilling fries. Quantity: The Lobster Roll is absolutely massive and stuffed with tons of lobster. The Blackened Shrimp Tacos come with two, which is a substantial lunch. Value: $15 for the Blackened Shrimp Tacos. $32 for the Lobster Roll with Fries. Ambiance: John Scott's Surf Shack is a small bar and seafood spot overlooking the bay in Westhampton Beach. It is one of the few restaurants in the area, and it has an okay view of the water, even though it is actually quite a distance away. They have a ton of outdoor seating with a covered patio, a raised porch, and open area tables with umbrellas. It was unclear to me if they were allowing folks to eat inside yet as most folks requested outside, but it did seem like they were ready. The music was expected soft rock and the vibe was very relaxed. Crowd: Despite arriving before they opened, we weren't even the first ones. The entire outdoor seating area was filled before we finished eating and this was on a rainy weekday afternoon. Service: Sat us and took our order before they technically opened and had the food out insanely fast. They also were quick to offer a different table as it started to drizzle. Parking: Large stone parking lot in front of restaurant. read more

John Scott's Surf Shack - Blackened Shrimp Tacos - Salad Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

See all

Lobster roll sandwich (or order it over mixed greens if you are low-carbing it), Honey BBQ Wings, Steamers. Drinks. View. Done.

Great spot I. Westhampton Beach with a backyard vibe and a view of the marsh. Lobster roll was the biggest and tastiest I've ever had. Fish and chips was fresh and plentiful. Happy bar staff too. read more

John Scott's Surf Shack - Lobster roll and fries. - Salad Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

See all

Yesterday, my group was denied entry to John Scott's for their Monday wing special because "Your group doesn't spend enough money". When we arrived at 4:30 with a group of 10 people, most of whom had not attended this restaurant previously were denied entry, we were shocked and appalled. Management didn't rectify this situation and we left and spent our money elsewhere. Needless to say, being denied entry to this establishment was embarrassing for all of us. We will not conduct business here again. read more

On Saturday, June 12th I went to John Scott's with a few friends to grab a few drinks and enjoy a nice summer night. I walked up to the bouncer to present my ID and the first words out of the bouncer's mouth were "put that necklace away, you're not getting in with that necklace." Confused, I asked the very large and intimidating man why that is, as I've never heard of a rule like this. For reference, I was wearing a Mezuzah (a Jewish parchment inscribed with religious text) necklace. When I asked the bouncer why this is a rule and that I've never heard of anything like this, he said, "well now you have." Very informative. A second bouncer came to back him up and intimidate me. They claim and pretend that this is just some rule of the establishment, but there were MANY girls and guys visibly wearing necklaces and chains inside. So if that is the rule, why did it not apply to them? Also, I have been here many times over many years and NOT ONCE has anyone ever said anything like this to me. Absolutely disgusted and infuriated my friends and I left. The clear and utter disrespect toward me and my religion as well as the blatant anti-semitism, nonetheless in a community full of Jewish people, seems like it borderlines a hate crime. John Scott's management and staff members: I highly recommend re-evaluating your morals and "rules". They are disgusting. Pathetic and shameful. read more

Really fun place live music friendly staff sunset views neighborhood place I go all the time

I think the food was very good. I had a lobster roll and french fries. Delicious my husband had fish tacos. Delicious. The only reason I didn't give it Five stars was it was the worst Margarita I ever had in my life. I don't know why bartenders can't make a decent margarita. read more

Great seafood shack. We had fish tacos, baked clams and fish(made in coconut oil yum!!!). Kid friendly.

Overall, I really enjoyed this low-key restaurant. The service was quick and friendly and very "So-Cal" surfer-dude. The coconut shrimp was PHENOMENAL. The fish and chips had a giant portion but wasn't worth the $18, in my opinion. I would definitely come back for the shrimp. read more

John Scott's Surf Shack - Fish and chips - Salad Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

The food was okay, the service was absolute shit. The only thing asked was about my outfit, not the drinks, not the food, not the 4% credit card fee. Had to ask for utensils, and a cup of water, never got a single refill. When we were finished we were asked how is everything, and shortly after given the check, no offers of dessert or the check. Truly was just so inconvenient I would rather go to drive thru than pay for service not given. read more

John Scott's Surf Shack - Lobster @MKt price $40 - Salad Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

See all

What a scam and a disappointment. Been coming here my whole life for dinner, and more recently for the nightlife over the past few years. This year it seems John Scott's has completely sold out. Arrived at 9:45pm and waited in a cold, dark line in the parking lot for TWO HOURS and never saw one person from the line getting let in at the entrance. Yet mysteriously, people who were in line behind us magically appeared inside the bar, along with anyone who pulled up in a Porsche or Mercedes. I'm convinced the line is a scam to create the illusion of demand, meanwhile the staff will let in anyone who rolls up to the side entrance who might have a little extra to give in addition to the TWENTY DOLLAR cover. Ended up leaving at 12am after wasting 2 hours of my time on line to NOT get into a place I used to love. This is not a high end bar with ample amenities. This is not an exclusive club. This is a dive in the middle of nowhere. The only reason it gets this crowded is because it's one of about two bars in the area for a younger crowd. Save your money. Save your time. RIP John Scott's. The locals will miss the old you. read more

Ok...let me hit my joint so I can mellow out before I write this review...Pulling up, the place looked cute. Obviously wasn't expecting a Michelin star dinner. Local scene, cigarette machine, horrible live band which is actually the best part of the experience, place seemed cool. Everything's great! I'm in the Hampton's, I can get into the vibe. Beautiful day, so I'm good. We're in West Hamptons so I'm not expecting Pierre's, let's get that clear. I know what this is. And that's my point. Local cheap bar food. But wait, my bill is $140 for two lobster rolls two glasses of wine and two clams, literally two stuffed subpar clams. I took one bite of the lobster roll and ate half the clam, because I was hungry...I'm done smoking my joint and I don't even care about the money or the food anymore. Whatever, go check it out if you're ever in town. Anyway, about to throw something on the grill. read more

What a cute little place! We went on a Friday afternoon after the beach and the wait wasn't too long. Drinks were good and the food was DELICIOUS. This place really does hit the spot after a long day at the beach. read more

John Scott's Surf Shack - Margarita, blackened shrimp tacos, corn salsa - Salad Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

Fun atmosphere, beautiful views and excellent mussels fra diavolo. Recommend lunch or dinner at sunset

Unfortunately, they live up to the "shack" in their name in terms of the filthiness of their bathroom, and not in their pricing. But if you're dining on Dune Road, it's probably going to cost you a pretty penny no matter where you go (well drinks down the road go for about $20 apiece). That said, they've got fairly large portions of decent grub. Anything with the fried popcorn shrimp will be tasty enough (the buffalo shrimp wrap, the firecracker shrimp app), and the fries themselves are reminiscent of McDonald's (in a good way). You're paying a bit more than it feels like you should, but if you don't like eating fried seafood in the sunshine with a beer in your hand, you've got bigger problems. read more

This restaurant has been absolutely inconsiderate to myself and my two friends. John Scott's sells cigarettes in a vending machine at this location. My two friends and I were ID'd THREE times at this location. I was treated by the staff members with negative attitude and ignorance. Apparently customers were complaining about me smoking a single cigarette and talking about my senior formal (from college), mind you my friends and I were above the legal age of 21+ and this location sold various different forms of cigarette brands. Therefore I believe this overly ostentatious restaurant should shut down if they believe their location is built upon pleasing their customers and consumers. read more

We just went to lunch or attempted to..we sat down for 20 minutes and not a single person attempted to take our order or even acknowledge our presence. After 10 min I said something to hostess who was right next to us and she said "no one took your order" I said no we still have our menus..she then came back and apologized saying it was her fault but another 10 min no one was in sight. One blonde waitress kept walking by and didn't stop or anything. I said to the hostess who was busy taking selfies we were leaving and she just stared at me and said nothing. We walked out..they lost $60-$70 read more

This is mostly a review for their wing night which I've been to several times. Their wing night promo is the best around, but keep in mind that if you do have their wings, your bill has to be paid in CASH. You can get them with sauce on the side or tossed. I usually prefer on-the-side so they don't get soggy in case it takes our group a while to eat them. The fish tacos we also had were somewhat bland. The fish was beer-battered but had little texture inside of the taco. It was just all a bit mushy and without flavor. You also might have trouble parking on wing nights so make sure you get there early! read more

Nothing Special at all. Food is meh and staff is rude. Drinks are not good either. For a place near the beach the view is nothing to look at. It is all marshy and you will get eaten alive sitting there. Seems like this is the only place in WHB on Dune Road. I really suggest going elsewhere. read more

We love John Scott's! It's a perfect place to bring your kids and casually have lunch or dinner. We go here often!

This is a negative star review. I asked at the door if I could order take out. The girl said yes just go to the bar. I waited at the bar for about 10 min and was told I couldn't order take out. If you can't order take out, do not advertise it. read more

Rustic place that is open in the summer. A surfer bar. You must try the muscles! My favorite! I will go there for a bowl of these delicious muscles. Fun place to stop at after the beach. read more

Cute place yummy food overpriced but not for the hamptons. Def a place I would really come to drink rather than eat however I high recommend their clam chowder read more

Awesome food. I'll go just for the corn salsa/salad. My only complaint, you get beers in a plastic cup. You're on a deck, glass pints wouldn't be problematic. None the less, everything here from service to food to drink selection to ambience is top notch. read more

Where do I begin with describing our horrible experience at this dump of a bar. The main reason I am giving them 1 star, and I rarely ever come on Yelp to bash a place, is because they were very very rude to my wife and I at the door. They claimed her ID was fake, but they had no way of actually verifying anyone's ID at the door, so instead they decided to just discriminate and take the subjective BS approach. We are all 30+ year olds. Bless their hearts for thinking we looked 20 years old or younger LMFAO. It seemed to me, as well as many other folks who reviewed this place on Yelp, that if you're simply from out of state, they just won't let you in no matter what condition your ID is in or how old you CLEARLY look over the age of 21. I guess they hate outsiders and MONEY. We spoke calmly and we tried convincing the bouncer every possible way, including driving back to our house 40 min away to get my wife's passport instead, only to be told that wasn't apparently still good enough to get her in. In the end, the bouncer started repeatedly and rudely telling us we were trespassing and had to leave, after essentially ignoring all of our pleas and sound logic to let my wife in. Talk about a freaking power trip. Eventually, after having to CALL the place ourselves because the bouncer wouldn't talk to us, managed to get a hold of the manager working that night to come out and listen to our story. A much much nicer guy, but still under this crazy idea that looking at an ID was good enough to know if you're 21, but other subjective approaches like how you physically look, dress, or act, were not. In the end he offered to let us all in, but my wife couldn't drink. We regrettably went in because we were more hungry than even thirsty for alcohol at this point of the night. Food was very mediocre and poorly put together. Cheap though. Not worth taking photos and posting on Yelp that's for sure. TIP for MANAGEMENT/OWNERS: If you're reading my review and the others from disgruntled customers, and thinking about how much you hate me and the rest of us, then you clearly know NOTHING about customer service and how to run a successful bar. We are not the enemy, we are just being honest about our experience and you should actually get it through your stubborn heads and LISTEN versus get defensive about it. Also....BUY A F*$@ing ID scanner. If you really TRULY care about not letting under age kids into this bar, then take my advice and stop pretending you know how to tell a fake from a real ID for all 50 states in this country. Your ignorance and arrogance will ABSOLUTELY get this place shut down one day. Just looking around the place, I could already tell there were some people clearly not 21+ of age. read more

A staple of casual dining in Westhampton Beach. They've really upped their food and atmosphere game while managing to retain that relaxed low-key atmosphere that many have come to rely on over the years. Plus they have the best Chicken nuggets with BBQ sauce that I've ever eaten. read more

My favorite casual "come as you are" place to rage after a day at the beach. Legit food & great service- esp at the bar. Keep the nice pours of sauvy b flowing! read more

Took my girlfriend and brother here after the beach around 4oclock. It was not busy and now I understand why. Service was terrible. I ordered the BBQ burger , muscles , cajun chicken wrap. Everything was cold . They forgot to serve us drinks. The waitress never checked up on us. Just a terrible experience. I will never come here again. The view is not worth it either. read more

Great stop on the way back from the beach ! Had blackened shrimp tacos and the buffalo chicken tacos as well and both were fresh an delicious ! They serve it with a delicious corn salad and we also ordered a side of the old bay fries which were a perfect addition . Friendly service and fun atmosphere . Would definitely recommend! read more

John Scott's Surf Shack - Salad Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

Great drinks, fish tacos are amazing! Always a good time when here. Service is either hit or miss but they are always busy so makes sense.

First off, the "teeny boppers" the owner employs to hostess out front need better training so first impression was not so good. After speaking with the owner about being seated AFTER people who came in after our group, left me feeling more frustrated but finally got seated properly. Owner asked if there was anything he could do to make the situation better. I replied that he should get us a round of drinks ( in their plastic cups ) to make up for it. His reply was he could not. Stupid response. After seating was straightened out, ordered our food & that was satisfying enough for an appetizer dinner. The Quahogs, mussels, wings, all were tasty. New England clam chowder was so so, as well as the iceberg lettuce salad. Fair to mediocre bar & dining experience at best. If you like a partial marsh view, go for the outside picnic tables. read more

What an enjoyable night. Great people. Great view. Great drinks. Owner very personable. They valet park your car and the wait is short. I will come back over and over. PS: thanks for letting me wear my sleeveless shirt!! read more

Ashleigh is 5 Star Cold drinks great food fantastic service. The best Beach Shack you will ever find

What a great atmosphere--casual and fun inside and out. The fish and chips and the lobster roll were fantastic. Calamari also great and large portion. My new favorite place read more

Thank you, thank you, thank you. Finally a place that represents Long Island seafood.Service was great too!! I Loved the wasabi shrimp salad. Laid back and casual attire (not sloppy). read more

See all