Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Johnny’s Diner - Casselberry

    4.5 (64 reviews)
    Open 6:00 am - 3:00 pm

    Johnny’s Diner - Casselberry Photos

    Business Info

    JOHNNY’S DINER - CASSELBERRY ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Dogs allowed
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    More like Johnny’s Diner - Casselberry

    Recommended Reviews - Johnny’s Diner - Casselberry

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Morning grits, sausage and eggs. Coffee and water to keep you hydrated!

    Hearty breakfast every day through the week! Excellent staff, cosy environment and tasty food!

    Alyssa H.

    Went on a Sunday morning after church there was four of us. They did have open seating, which was quite easy for us to eat. Our waitresses was extremely intentive, making sure our coffee was full, and our drinks was good. They made sure our food came out expeditiously. We had a lot of people so we have a few different meals. I personally had the Gyro dinner and it was delicious. The meat was well cooked. It wasn't dry and crusty. It's a decent size diner, so it's walk-in and see yourself Lots of menu options very casual place. Staff is super friendly.

    Chicken Salad
    Cheryl V.

    Orlando~ Cute little mom & pop diner. Filled with moms & pops! Food was good but not outstanding. We both had the same entrée so it is a little bit harder to review properly. We had the chicken salad. The pita bread that came with the salad was hard as a rock, but other than that, the flavor of the salad was good. This place reminds me of good old-fashioned cooking with down home entrées! Service was good. I'm not going to go rushing back, but if I'm in the area and feel like meatloaf or liver and onions, I think I'll give this place a try again.

    Michael M.

    From the outside looking in, this seems like every other stereotypical diner... A line outside the door. Breakfast served all day. Fresh, hot, coffee refills before your cup is even empty, and a specials board outside. Nothing was great, but everything was decent. Eggs were cooked exactly as ordered, special orders were perfectly satisfied, and we all left full. Being from South Florida, where we have a diner on every corner, prices were high for diner food, but I guess it is what it is.

    Corned Beef Hash and two eggs
    Spensyr K.

    Johnny's is a serviceable diner option in Casselberry. No reservations so be prepared to wait during breakfast and brunch hours on weekends. There's also not a great seating option for large families. We squeezed 6 into one of the larger booths but it was cozy tight. The servers were friendly and those drinking coffee were never left with an empty cup or a hot refresher. The food was average diner food fast, tasty, well priced, but not special. Because it was busy it wasn't a great place to just chill and chat because we felt guilty with the line waiting. But we had a filling and well priced meal and went elsewhere to hang out! I had the corned beef hash with two eggs over easy...it was as expected and filling.

    Carrot cake to go. Yum
    David D.

    Been back twice since my initial review. Have now had the waffle which was great and i can't think of a place that had better biscuits and gravy. Service is consistently excellent

    Farmers Omlette, seasoned fries, whole-wheat toast and ham.
    Mike Y.

    This is Johnnys second location from the first initial one on 436 and University. The newer location is on Universityy and Dean. This one is on 436 in Casselberry across from Pet Bazzar. Can't say nothing but higher phrase about this establishment. Plenty of seating during normal hours during the week. You'll definitely have to wait your turn during the weekends. Parking is plentiful. I usually stick with what I like. Farmers Omlette, grits, whole wheat toast and ham slices. Service is pretty quick depending on how many people are inside.

    Anna T.

    Love Johnny's. Go a lot for breakfast on the weekends and it's such a good experience every time I'm there. Staff is wonderful and welcoming, always attentive and the food is great. We never have to wait long and our meals are always excellent. Classic diner vibes, couldn't ask for better.

    Renee T.

    On 6/25 we took my parents to Johnny's Diner for breakfast. We seated ourselves as that is the custom here and were greeted by a friendly server who knew my folks. We placed our orders and within 15 minutes our food was on the table. I really enjoyed my hash browns with cheese and onions added with a side of crispy bacon immensely. We come to Johnny's every time we visit and other than the BLT, have always enjoyed everything we have tried. Give them a try if you haven't already, great food, friendly staff

    Looking for a place to BLEND'uh? I
    Mike T.

    When you need to take the chill off, Ambiance and music have you banging the trough. Taking it from your friendly giraffe ...MT, Etching each inch of this place Linda's decor subtle-fancy. Rich in flavor, the food is a work of art, Inches and pinches, flinches no Grinches, Next door to Pet Bazaar, bring your wrenches, Gonna be digging ditches and making hitches with the protein packed into this haven of pleasantries and honeys, funnies and bunnies. Hurry down and check them out, Open the doors and let out a shout, Luscious and lively, what it's about, E.t.c.h. E.a.c.h. I.n.c.h. and fill the mouth, Make your way here and and tell them about the South, That MT sent you and they'll give you a hint of the hidden a-mount. "We like this place because of Linda. We come here all the time. Best Philly cheese steak in town." S.C.

    Two eggs with 4 slices of crispy bacon and grits
    Debi W.

    Today we visited ready for a great breakfast. We saw a sign on the door "Cash Only" because their CC machines were down on the whole block. We had only $20 cash. The good news is--their prices are so low it wasn't a problem. We were even able to leave a generous tip. Yay!

    Reuben, Fries & Coleslaw
    Julie N.

    What a great find! This place has the best Reuben I've had since childhood. If you know of Wicks Applehouse in MI, it is just like it. Our waitress Sidni was the best, great service all around.

    Rueben

    See all

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Connie B.
    49
    235
    8

    13 days ago

    Johnny's Diner has the most perfect pancakes. We'll, everything I have had there has been delicious. The servers are super efficient.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    17 days ago

    The waffle was burnt. Service was good, though. My sister's order was just average. ...............

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 2
    Love this 3
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 2
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Always fresh food breakfast is a must service is top notch lunch is great the staff are amazing

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Always great. Breakfast, sandwiches and meals. Very friendly staff. Always busy. You can't go wrong.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    A definite throwback to the diners over the last few decades. Basic menu, prepared perfectly at a price that most people can still afford.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Food is good. Service is great. Ambiance is ok. It is always a line out the door for breakfast. So it's super inconvenient in that way.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Nice family diner. First time. Great family team. Excellent breakfast. Seat yourself. Will come back.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Beth B.
    3
    50
    18

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ashley D.
    73
    21
    10

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jody T.
    1
    25
    32

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 1 of 2

    Ask the Community - Johnny’s Diner - Casselberry

    You might also consider

    Sourdough Bread House - American breakfast

    Sourdough Bread House

    4.5(298 reviews)
    0.8 mi
    $$

    I visited Sourdough bread House back in the day when they were in Maitland and was pleasantly…read moresurprised by their new, larger space. The food was just as good as I remembered from a few years ago. It can be difficult to find consistency in restaurants these days, so I really appreciate that the quality hasn't changed. It's nice to have a spot like Sourdough to add variety to the rotation of mostly American breakfast spots. I ordered the Sourdough Bread Plate, which is a large portion. Even though it's listed on the lunch menu, I was still able to order it for breakfast. Their bread is incredible, and everything tasted so fresh! The ezme is a wonderful addition to add to the avocado and labneh toasts. I also tried the Turkish coffee, but as someone who doesn't drink black coffee, it wasn't quite for me. I would recommend it mainly to those who enjoy strong, black coffee, though it was a nice touch that it came with a Turkish delight! My only minor critique is that the staff weren't around very much. Our server checked in on us once, and after waiting a bit for someone to bring the check, we eventually just walked up to the counter to pay. Nonetheless, everyone was very friendly!

    This place was so delicious! The sourdough bread was my favorite part, with the crunch of it and…read morethe fluff. The turkish coffee was also strong for how small the cup was, with a little turkish delight to take the edge off. The bacon was beef, which was nice. Overall, the food was delicious. However, the service wasn't the best, there was about 3 customers in the restaurant when I went, but the server left all of us when we had to pay, leaving all of us to stand in a line waiting to pay. For a weekday, that felt a little odd. I think the food definitely makes up for it.

    Photos
    Sourdough Bread House - Interior

    Interior

    Sourdough Bread House - Avocado Breakfast Panini

    Avocado Breakfast Panini

    Sourdough Bread House - Check out at the front

    See all

    Check out at the front

    First Watch - Veggie Burger

    First Watch

    4.0(28 reviews)
    2.2 mi
    $$

    We came on a Sunday afternoon and it seemed pretty busy, but we were seated pretty quickly. The…read morestaff came by with water and it was a breeze to place our order. The food was delicious. My brother got the seasonal coffee and it was a tad too sweet. I got the hash which is always a good choice, and they had a seasonal one that featured steak which was quite lovely. The bathroom was a little messy, but stocked and in working order. The place was well decorated and we were sat in a comfortable booth. Overall, it was a good experience.

    I have a complicated relationship with First Watch…read more It's kind of like that actor who's been incredible in some movies and absolutely unbearable in others. I've had experiences at certain First Watch franchise locations that left me questioning not only the meal, but several of my life choices leading up to it. So when I walked into this location in the Fern Park/Casselberry (Altamonte Springs) area, I'll admit it... I came in cautiously optimistic at best. Thankfully, this visit reminded me why the chain became popular in the first place. Right away, the staff stood out for being personable and genuinely pleasant. Not the robotic "corporate friendly" where someone smiles while dead behind the eyes. Actual warm, attentive service that made the place feel welcoming. And here's something restaurant owners should probably frame on the wall because it's becoming weirdly rare these days: the food was cooked correctly and served hot. Hot. As in actually warm when it hit the table and not sitting under a heat lamp long enough to qualify for Social Security. I ordered the omelette, and it absolutely hit the spot. Comfort food done properly. Fluffy, flavorful, filling, and exactly what I wanted breakfast to be. My daughter ordered the steak and egg hash, and visually... let's just say this isn't a dish entering any beauty pageants. It kind of arrives looking like breakfast got into a small argument with itself. But one bite in and none of that mattered. It was rich, hearty, luscious, and cooked just right. The kind of dish where every bite feels indulgent enough that you briefly stop caring about cholesterol or responsibility. This location honestly felt dialed in. The kitchen was on point, the service was strong, and the overall experience reminded me that consistency is what separates a good restaurant visit from a forgettable one. Because of my mixed history with First Watch overall, I can't quite bring myself to throw five stars into the air like confetti... but this particular location absolutely earned four stars and deserves credit for getting it right.

    Photos
    First Watch - Inside

    Inside

    First Watch - Pretty good biscuits

    Pretty good biscuits

    First Watch - Pineapple Express

    See all

    Pineapple Express

    Maitland Breakfast Club - Pumpkin pancakes

    Maitland Breakfast Club

    3.8(297 reviews)
    2.1 mi
    $$

    Breakfast @ the Maitland Breakfast Club, and it turned out to be a pleasant surprise! Our waitress,…read moreCindy A., was as sweet as apple pie and made us feel right at home. On my first visit, I ordered the Apple Cinnamon Oatmeal Pancakes with link sausages and a glass of orange juice. The pancakes were delicious, the sausages hit the spot, and the orange juice was... well, you know... orange juice. It did its job! The atmosphere reminded me of a classic country diner--cozy, welcoming, and filled with an older crowd, which I honestly prefer. One thing I really appreciated was being able to seat myself. That's always a plus in my book. Sometimes being escorted to a table means ending up in that one awkward corner nobody wants... but I digress. Overall, I had a great experience and would happily come back. My significant other, however, wasn't nearly as impressed. Oh well--you win some, you lose some! Sometimes breakfast is just a pancake split decision.

    Maitland Breakfast Club reminds me of why the diners are an ultimate American staple. Diners are a…read morecompletely American thing that started in America as a mobile eatery and has transformed into what it is now, which are stationary eateries that feature affordable, filling food that appeals to the blue collar man. Fun fact, diners were started in New England region of America in the 1850s. All this to say, I love a good diner. I mean the American diner has always been there for middle America. The closest one to me and honestly it's definitely hidden away is the Maitland Breakfast Club. It's pretty much situated on the boundary line of where the City of Altamonte Springs starts. They have large space that's casual and what you would expect for a diner. Anyone can walk in wearing their Sunday best to pajamas. The waitresses are very welcoming and exactly the kind of person I would expect to invite me into a diner. We had gone on a Saturday afternoon and they're not a diner that's open late, so more of a breakfast diner really. Now I got the eggs Benedict with bacon and hash browns. For me, there are three breakfast staples I believe all amazing must revisit breakfast places should have. A good cup of warm regular coffee, eggs Benedict, and good crispy hash browns. I mean some places have other things like lattes and hash brown bowls, and I'm not saying those aren't good. However, when you nail the basics, you can do anything else. The hollandaise sauce was great and didn't split and bacon was crispy. The hash browns were super crispy, which I loved, and I could tell it had been made on a flat top grill, which is another very classic American restaurant kitchen appliance. The cup of coffee was good, I mean they had the sugar packets and the creamers right there. Overall, I would rate it a 9/10 and it set us back about $15 for just my portion. I will be back (said menacingly), Maitland Breakfast Club.

    Photos
    Maitland Breakfast Club - Dining room.

    Dining room.

    Maitland Breakfast Club - Pumpkin pancakes

    Pumpkin pancakes

    Maitland Breakfast Club - Country fried steak, hashbrowns, and 2 eggs (sunny side up)

    See all

    Country fried steak, hashbrowns, and 2 eggs (sunny side up)

    The Hungry Stork - Apple cinnamon pancakes

    The Hungry Stork

    3.5(15 reviews)
    3.6 mi

    This used to be Max and Meme's restaurant. They opened a few months ago, temporarily shutdown to…read morefix an AC issue, and now they're open and ready to serve with a smile. Our server was so kind as well was another employee that stopped by to chat with us. They offered suggestions and their fave menu items. My food was good. I really enjoyed the grits. My country fried steak was ok. I ordered rye toast but received multigrain. It was still delicious. I really wish they offered fountain sodas rather than cans at $2.99. Next time I would order coffee so I can get my caffeine fix. Also, I would prefer that they offered really butter instead of a butter/margarine blend. My last suggestion would be offering actual hot sauce mini bottles rather than a plastic cup of nondescript hot sauce. I have faith that this place will be great. They've already hired the best employees and service was great. There's just a few personal preferences I think the could add. Pay them a visit.

    The Hungry Stork has been open for about two months. It has been remodeled and painted since the…read moreprevious restaurant in its location. The wait staff are so friendly and accommodating. The restaurant is clean and the a/c is working. The bacon was perfectly cooked, the wheat toast and grape jelly were delicious, the eggs were very good. I did not care for the hash browns. They were not bad just not crispy enough for my taste. The coffee was hot but not a strong blend which I prefer. Our main server Savannah was so kind and efficient and the head server/ manager checked on us often during our breakfast. They both were amazing and kind. I think it was a good breakfast with a good price. I am sure to come back again to try some other items from the menu.

    Photos
    The Hungry Stork - Smoked turkey veggie omelet with grits

    Smoked turkey veggie omelet with grits

    The Hungry Stork - Outside

    Outside

    The Hungry Stork

    See all

    Maya Café lounge & gallery - Hair in my food

    Maya Café lounge & gallery

    4.5(121 reviews)
    2.0 mi
    $$

    We went today to celebrate my 50th birthday with my husband's family. Our server (male, very…read morehandsome) was incredibly attentive and very nice. He explained everything on the menu to everyone at the table! We sat in the table in the middle because there were 5 of us, and it was perfect. The artwork and just "mood" of the place was amazing! Even though my husband's mother got a bit confused at times during the visit, that is normal behavior for her these days, as she gets older. Thank you for being so gracious and understanding of her situation. We will absolutely be back for the dessert and another piece of the burrata toast!

    The aesthetics were really nice--very artsy, cute, and inviting and the staff was super friendly…read moreand welcoming, especially Marcos! I also loved the heart shaped plates;they were such a cute little touch and added to the overall charm of the café. I ordered the Banana Caramel Coffee, the Slimmer pressed juice, and the steak sandwich. Unfortunately, the Banana Caramel Coffee was a bit disappointing. It was bland, lacked flavor, and wasn't nearly sweet enough for my taste. The Slimmer juice, made with pineapple, cucumber, and lemon, was pretty good and refreshing. But that steak sandwich stole the show! It was REALLY, really good! The flavor was on point, and I would definitely order it again. Overall, I think this is a cute little café with a fun, artsy atmosphere and friendly service. If I'm in the area again, I'd stop by to grab the steak sandwich to go!

    Photos
    Maya Café lounge & gallery
    Maya Café lounge & gallery
    Maya Café lounge & gallery

    See all

    The Hen & Hog - Birria Tacos

    The Hen & Hog

    4.4(179 reviews)
    4.4 mi
    $$

    My friend and I stopped in over a weekend for lunch. We were greeted by the friendliest guy who…read morecame up to the front who explained everything on the menus we saw upfront on the screens, about specials, and how to order at the counter. We took our time scanning through all the options and I settled upon the cuban sandwich and my friend had a burger. You order at the counter and they bring the food to you. The inside of the restaurant was cute. I really enjoyed the live stream of the cows grazing in the fields. The rustic vibe fit the brand great. It only took a short while to get our food. My cuban was great. The bread was nicely toasted. The meat was extremely juicy on the sandwich. My friend enjoyed the taste of her burger. We both thought the fries had nice crispiness. There were several families enjoying lunch inside while we were in here. I saw they had a brunch menu and think in my next visit I want to experience the chicken and waffles I keep hearing about.

    Coming back from New Orleans is tough, especially when this foodie ate his fill of fried chicken…read moreand gumbo. But I had an urge to find some fried chicken that is lightly battered and this place hit the spot. Located just off of Park Avenue and Fairbanks is The Hen & Hog. Got a 6 piece fried chicken anf a few sides which consisted of mac and cheese, fries and a pickled slaw. Juicy freshly fried and ever so gently battered chicken that was crisp with every bite. Definitely some tasty chicken. I really liked the slaw that had garlic onions celery and some other items but it cut through the savoriness of the chicken. Yes, i ate all of it to the bone. Wife also got chicken and waffles which she thoroughly enjoyed. Also had fried banana peppers with a pimento spread. Pretty nice combination. Staff was super helpful. They also have wings with a lot of great sauces to try. That will be my order for next time. Cant wait to come back.

    Photos
    The Hen & Hog - Interior

    Interior

    The Hen & Hog - Andouille Po' Boy

    Andouille Po' Boy

    The Hen & Hog - Pork Schnitzel

    See all

    Pork Schnitzel

    Briarpatch Restaurant - Blueberry lemon cream pancakes

    Briarpatch Restaurant

    4.2(2k reviews)
    4.0 mi
    $$

    The ambiance and service continue to be outstanding. However, the chunky chicken salad was a big…read moredisappointment. I have been eating at the Briarpatch Restaurant for over 40 years and have totally enjoyed the chunky chicken salad. But this time, the salad was not chunky it was a typical shredded chicken salad with too much pepper - not the traditional chicken salad I have had over the past 40 years. Ownership needs to do something about this.

    We finally got to visit Briarpatch with my partner, and this time we decided to try something a…read morelittle different. We both started with a cup of coffee and a large glass of fresh orange juice. Everything was so fresh and delicious! I ordered the French toast with fresh fruit and mascarpone cheese. OMG, it was SO good! I didn't even need extra syrup because the mascarpone and fresh fruit blended together into the perfect naturally sweet breakfast. Every bite was delicious! My partner had the best breakfast, too. He ordered the short rib, and it was incredibly tender and flavorful. The potatoes were perfectly crispy, just the way we like them! We were both so happy and left feeling like we had just enjoyed an amazing breakfast. Our waiter was super cool and provided wonderful hospitality. He made our experience even better. The restaurant is always beautiful, clean, and welcoming. I highly recommend this spot! If you're looking for a delicious breakfast with great service and a beautiful atmosphere, Briarpatch is definitely worth a visit!

    Photos
    Briarpatch Restaurant - Dining room

    Dining room

    Briarpatch Restaurant - Crimini Mushroom Omelette

    Crimini Mushroom Omelette

    Briarpatch Restaurant - Nutella Waffle @tiffhuangry

    See all

    Nutella Waffle @tiffhuangry

    Buttermilk Bakery - Bacon Cheddar

    Buttermilk Bakery

    4.6(545 reviews)
    4.9 miNorth Orange
    $

    If you want the most delicious pastries you've ever had in your life, Buttermilk is your girl…read more My go to is the Bacon Cheddar Pull Apart Bread. However, they always have fun creations popping up in their case. Some fan favorites are the Mango Sticky Rice Tart and literally any of their pop tarts. The staff is kind and efficient. There's usually a line out the door. However, we never wait longer than 15 minutes to get the goods. The space is definitely small on the customer end inside. However, they have plenty of outdoor seating that's perfect for hanging out with friends on a Sunday morning. Literally one of my favorite spots. Thank you Buttermilk for being THAT girl.

    I have been a Buttermilk Bakery fan for well over a decade. Until this last weekend…read more I got online at 8:15 in the morning to place my order. Each item that I selected came up with a message that read, "Our store is not currently accepting orders." I tried again a few minutes later. Then again. And again. And again. I tried to call and received a voicemail that stated a different number. At 8:50am, the option to order seemed to be back up and running. I ordered five items, including the Roasted Tomatoes & Goat Cheese Quiche. For context: I live 45 minutes away from Buttermilk Bakery. It used to be on my way to work but, as of a few years ago, that is not the case anymore. So, it is now a special occasion destination. Reserved only for weekends when I can make the trip. More context: I have been raving to one of my closet friends for years about how much I love this place. My most emphatic musings have been about the quiche. Today, since she and I were planning an afternoon poolside, I thought that I would surprise her with an assortment of Viennoiserie and other items. At 10:36am, I received a call from Buttermilk. The woman on the phone informed me that they had run out of the quiche. How?!? Once the website was working, I was able to place my order quickly and the item didn't even read, "Low stock." I know that this is a small problem in a world full of large problems, but the thing that really set me off is that when I arrived at the store, the person in line in front of me asked for the Strawberry Buttermilk Pie. He was told that they were out of stock. He was pleasant in stating that there appeared to be slices in the refrigerator case. The girl behind the register told him that they were being held for online orders. When it was my turn, I stated that no one had held my slice of quiche. She blandly said, "I am sorry," and proceeded. I then stated that I was unhappy and had driven some distance. She asked if I would like something else. I responded that the person on the phone had simply told me that I would receive a refund. I then asked for the girl to check on my refund. She said it was not processed yet. So, I said that I would wait. She needed to ask for help to process the refund. She wasn't nasty to me, but she did not care one iota. My effort and subsequent inconvenience meant nothing. I wonder if my refund would even have been processed had I not asked. My friend and I thought the pastries that we received were fine, but she is fitness-minded and was hesitant to indulge in so many carbs without the rich protein that the quiche would have provided. And, yet, more context: This happened once before. With the quiche. Maybe a year ago. Though, that time, I believe it was a butternut squash quiche. My husband needed to be in the area, so he suggested that he pick-up at Buttermilk. When he arrived, he was told that there would be no quiche. No call. No nothing. He didn't think to ask for a refund and we never received one. That time, I simply thought, "Well, accidents happen." This time, I think that I received very shoddy service. I felt very disrespected. I felt unseen. I have loved this place, but I am so disappointed.

    Photos
    Buttermilk Bakery
    Buttermilk Bakery - Almond croissant

    Almond croissant

    Buttermilk Bakery - Croissant with egg inside.  It was different and yummy.

    See all

    Croissant with egg inside. It was different and yummy.

    Einstein Bros. Bagels

    Einstein Bros. Bagels

    3.0(78 reviews)
    0.7 mi
    $

    My favorite bagels are Einstein. Unfortunately, this is the closest one to where we live and it's…read morenot very close. Then again, maybe it's a good thing because I'd probably be eating bagels every day and that's A LOT of carbs! LOL This was our first time here. I placed a mobile order and went inside to pick it up. Nice, large restaurant. Area with plug-ins for laptops for anyone wanting to work remotely. Ordered a chocolate bagel, a blueberry bagel, a blueberry muffin, a chocolate chip cookie, and a doggie bagel for my service pupster. First, I have to say my pup LOVED the doggie bagel. Another reason I probably shouldn't live so close b/c I spoil the heck outta my dog and I'd be here getting him bagels every day too. LOL The bagels were excellent, as I always expect from any Einstein Bros. The blueberry muffin was ok, but honestly I've had better. It has been probably 5 years since I've ordered a muffin from this chain, so it's possible they changed them, but it was not as good as what I remembered. I didn't try the chocolate chip cookie, but hubby claimed he loved it. The reason for the 4 stars is because the cleanliness could have been better. We got there around 10am, which was just after the breakfast rush. There was only one other customer in the restaurant when we got there and the employees were all behind the counter. I feel like perhaps someone should have been wiping the crumbs, etc. from all the tables. The restaurant was clean, as were the restrooms, but when they are not busy, it shouldn't be a problem to find a clean table. The employees were friendly and smiling. No complaints there at all. Make sure to check your bag when you leave. They had forgotten to put the chocolate chip cookie in. As this was our only visit here, I can't say if this is something that regularly happens or not. But again, they were not busy - it shouldn't have been missed. It's all good though; mistakes do happen.

    I had been wanting to try the maple house egg sandwich for a while and let me say it did not…read moredisappoint . Unfortunately I had to drive 30 minutes to get it but was it worth it absolutely . So it comes on a maple bagel with syrup which I opted to do light on the syrup . I decided to take out the meat and add egg, cheese and the honey almond smear. It was both savory and sweet. I only ate half at the restaurant and ate the rest the next day. I will put more maple syrup the next time I order the sandwich . The servers were nice . I also got a passion fruit drink but it wasn't my favorite because I don't like orange juice . But that's my fault . The ambiance was clean, nice and inviting . I would come back . I see they are opening an Oviedo location which I am excited about .

    Photos
    Einstein Bros. Bagels
    Einstein Bros. Bagels
    Einstein Bros. Bagels

    See all

    Johnny’s Diner - Casselberry - diners - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...