Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Katheryn's On the Square

    3.6 (5 reviews)

    Katheryn's On the Square Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Katheryn's On the Square

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 days ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    This is a hidden gem! Great good, nice atmosphere, wonderful service, BYOB and great prices! Will definitely be going back.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 4,499 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Watershed Pub

    The Watershed Pub

    4.4
    (341 reviews)
    4.8 mi
    $$
    Outdoor seating
    Full bar

    I've passed Watershed Pub a million times and never stopped, so when I met a friend for lunch, it…read morefinally felt like the right time to check it out. Naturally, I had already done my due diligence (read: stalked the menu for a full week) and had a game plan. At the top of my list? The deviled eggs and the Kale Caesar salad with salmon. The only problem...I absolutely did not need $40 worth of food for lunch. So I quietly spent the week putting "deviled egg energy" out into the Universe, hoping my lunch partner would suggest splitting them. Manifestation is real, people. I arrived around 12pm and found plenty of parking out back in Watershed's designated lot, which is clearly labeled--a good thing, because parking in that area looks like it could get competitive if you're not paying attention. We had made a 12:15pm reservation (Monday lunch felt safe, but why risk it?), and our table on the enclosed patio was ready when we arrived. It was the perfect setup--sunny and bright, but still warm enough to be comfortable on a chilly day. The vibe was great, and our server was even better--friendly, attentive, and consistently checking in without being overbearing. Then it was time to order. I let my lunch partner go first and waited... "Do you want to try the deviled eggs as an appetizer?" Are you kidding me?!. YES. Yes, I did! We ordered the deviled eggs ($11) to share, and I followed through with my Kale Caesar salad ($15) topped with seared salmon (+$13), officially completing my week-long menu-stalking mission. The deviled eggs came out FAST, and in my excitement, I completely forgot to take a picture--which tells you everything you need to know. Each egg was topped with a cube of candied bacon that absolutely stole the show. Sweet, savory, and just the right texture to complement the creamy filling. We made quick work of all four--excellent start to the meal! Not long after, our lunches arrived, and my salad? Gorgeous. Like, actually exciting to look at. I dug in immediately and it delivered. The mix of shaved brussels sprouts, kale, and romaine gave it great texture, the dressing was well-balanced, and the red onion didn't overpower the rest of the flavors. But my favorite part? The garlic parmesan crouton crumble. No chasing rogue croutons around the plate--just perfectly distributed crunch in every bite. Genius! The portion size was generous, too--I made it through about half before calling it and boxing the rest for dinner later. By the time we were wrapping up, the enclosed patio had filled up significantly, which tells me this is a popular lunch spot--and for good reason. The food is solid, the atmosphere is great, and the service was spot on. That said...$40 for deviled eggs, a salad and water is a bit steep for an everyday lunch. For me, this feels more like a "treat yourself," client meeting, or special occasion kind of place rather than a regular rotation spot. Would I come back? Absolutely. Would I be casually popping in every week? Probably not. But those deviled eggs? Totally worth manifesting!

    Atmosphere and seating around the exterior is on point. Really nailed the interior and fixing. They…read moredid a great job with heaters outside and retracting canopy blinds to make the outdoor space work in large swaths of the year. The main challenge: the food on two orders was a real miss. The review for the Greek salad was that it was one of the worst tasting Greek salads my brother has ever had, despite the attempt at some flare with phyllo on top. My second salad was equally uninspired. We didn't bother with anything else admittedly so perhaps their salad game is just very very weak, or a bad day in the kitchen. Hard to say; but wouldn't be bothering with their food again compared to hunting around.

    Photos
    The Watershed Pub
    The Watershed Pub
    The Watershed Pub

    See all

    The Millworks

    The Millworks

    4.4
    (1.5k reviews)
    7.6 mi
    $$
    Locally owned & operated
    Free parking

    Scott was amazing and really helpful. He has a great personality! The restaurant looks very nice…read moreand the food was delicious! 10/10 would recommend!

    What a gem! The night before leaving Harrisburg I was looking for somewhere special to eat and I…read morestumbled upon this restaurant that is a multi purpose space: it's a restaurant, brewery, event space and a studio for artist. The Millworks support local talent from growers to local artist. The restaurant provide fresh seasonal items. A menu that has something for everyone that includes homemade pizzas, sandwiches and full meals. With a solid drink menu that includes cocktails with shrubs, their beer, wine and more. I sat down at the bar and was warmly greeted by fellow patrons and the bar staff during a busy Thursday night! Pro tip: make reservations if you want a table. The bar overlooks the courtyard that offers limited seating. The main dining area offers a very size able seating area. Note when the sun goes down you can be blinded at the bar. The menu looked all soooo good . As it was so good that I was having trouble deciding on some food but I paired down to a couple items and with help of the patrons and bartender we decided on a pizza with mushrooms. The pizza was very large and filled with mushrooms. A great pizza for mushroom lovers. I complimented my pizza with an adult beverage. I had a champagne with a local shrub. It was the perfect balance. During mg time at the bar, I learned this is one of three restaurants in town. The owner has a "dive bar" that looks to be a tiki bar and a date night place. Great to see these places pop in Harrisburg as the downtown area needs a facelift. Come and enjoy! Also check out their happy hour..:

    Photos
    Food
    Food
    The Millworks
    The Millworks

    See all

    Marzoni's Brick Oven and Brewing

    Marzoni's Brick Oven and Brewing

    3.4
    (213 reviews)
    1.7 mi
    $$

    Sometimes the best food adventures start with a friend saying something so ridiculous that you…read moreimmediately assume they're making it up. In this case... "Have you ever had crab rangoon pizza?" Excuse me?! Surely that's not a real thing! Rather than doing any research whatsoever, I decided to blindly trust the adventure. If crab rangoon pizza actually existed, I needed it in my life immediately. That quest led me to Marzoni's. We arrived around 3:30 on a Saturday afternoon in July and almost had the place to ourselves. We grabbed a booth near the bar, settled in and were greeted by a super friendly, attentive server who made sure we had everything we needed throughout our visit. Marzoni's has been serving wood-fired pizzas, sandwiches, burgers, pasta and an impressive selection of craft beers for years, but on this particular day there was only one thing on my mind...the Crab Rangoon Pizza. Of course we ordered a large. A short while later, our server rounded the corner carrying our pizza...and I'm pretty sure audibly squealed. At the very least, my mouth fell open and I was speechless, which is an absolute miracle! It was real! And it was BEAUTIFUL! The crust was perfectly baked with those wonderful blistered bubbles that tell you it's going to be good before you even take a bite. It was topped with creamy cheese, generous chunks of crab and crispy wonton strips that made it unmistakably crab rangoon...just in pizza form. We gave it a minute to cool...and then I took my first bite. Holy. Cow. It actually tasted exactly like crab rangoon! The creamy filling, the sweet crab, the crispy wonton strips...somehow it all worked together perfectly. It was one of those foods where your brain spends the first few bites trying to figure out how something this weird can taste this right. I happily devoured my entire slice and immediately started negotiating with myself about whether I should have another. Or another. Or maybe slices three through ten. My Responsible Adult Self (who is a complete buzzkill sometimes) eventually won that argument, but only because I still had more adventures planned for the day. PRO TIP: Come hungry or bring friends. The large pizza makes plenty, and you'll almost certainly be happy to have leftovers once you realize how good it is. Parking was plentiful in the lot outside, the restaurant was clean, the atmosphere was relaxed and the staff couldn't have been more welcoming. Will I be back? Absolutely! Because now I know two things. First, crab rangoon pizza is, in fact, a real thing. Second...it's apparently a craving I didn't know I was capable of having until now.

    A group of us caught up for lunch and one suggested we try this place because it was fast and good…read more They were right on both accounts. Six of us sat down for a quick lunch about 12:30 in the afternoon ordering a variety of sandwiches, including burgers, Rubens, and salads. The fancy nancy salad caught my eye as did the add-on of salmon. This was a very full meal for lunch, but on the super healthy side. Beside the salmon that they put on top which was very large and not at all fishy tasting, the salad included mesclun greens, almonds, cranberries, feta cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers, and their house Italian dressing. What an enjoyable salad this was. I think the best part of it was that it didn't include things I don't like such as onions and croutons!,

    Photos
    Reuben with sweet potato fries
    Reuben with sweet potato fries
    Stuffed shells
    Stuffed shells
    Marzoni's Brick Oven and Brewing

    See all

    Men In The Kitchen

    Men In The Kitchen

    4.1
    (21 reviews)
    7.2 mi

    This place was one of the unexpected highlights of our trip! My mom randomly picked a place that…read morewas close to our Airbnb and we arrived to great music and welcoming staff. We had a party of 7 and one disabled person, they were super accommodating. The first thing that came out was complimentary cornbread and it was delicious! What followed was amazing dish after amazing dish! Homemade croutons, house made chips for buffalo dip! Delicious sweet potatoes. A group fav was the fried Brussel sprouts. We couldn't stop complimenting the food to our server Teron. By the end he brought the Chef out so we could tell her in person just how wonderful the food and experience had been. And we sang along to music all evening. Even the drinks were good! I got 2 lemon drop martinis - so good! I truly hope my travels bring me back to MIK!

    The Review: Men in the Kitchen…read more My reviews are different. I do not announce myself or tell anyone. I am here to do a review!! It was a rainy Sunday, and I was working up a hunger while driving Uber for content. I went to three different spots before I finally found the place I should've gone to first. The food and atmosphere at this restaurant are so good that I want to find another establishment just like it, but so far--at least on this day--nothing in the area can beat it. I don't know why I treat this restaurant like a good wife that a man might constantly cheat on but always returns to. I'm not saying that I actually cheat; I'm just using that for context! So, I found myself once again at Two Men in the Kitchen. Since it was Easter Sunday, they offered a buffet or a special limited menu. There was fish and chicken wings available, and I chose the wings. Since I don't eat meat often, I asked for their "House Sauce," and it is by far amazing. I paired the wings with the 3-cheese baked mac & cheese and sweet potatoes. I went for the sides first because I wanted to save the best for last--I already knew that house sauce was going to be incredible, especially on the chicken and greens eggrolls they have. The mac & cheese was great; it had a crunchy outside yet remained soft in the middle, and the cheese pull was amazing. The sweet potatoes were definitely homemade; I could tell because every slice was a different cut, which I appreciate because it proves they didn't come out of a can. Now for the best part: the chicken wings. They were cooked perfectly--neither overdone nor underdone, with no pink on the inside. Everything was pure. I did happen to taste a little bit of Old Bay on the wings, so I asked the chef if that was part of the secret seasoning. He said no, so maybe someone slipped some in by accident, but it didn't stop me from indulging. I also ordered one of their house special drinks--a Hennessy and rum cocktail. It was a very pretty drink, but unfortunately, I am not a fan of Hennessy. Personally, I think it tastes like house keys or licking a brass knob when you're a kid. On my scale, the drink was a 2 out of 5; I just don't think rum and cognac should mix, but that's just my opinion. The atmosphere was amazing and the bathrooms were clean. I will definitely visit this place again and again, although sometimes it is hard to tell if they are open because of the heavily tinted windows. For those who know the area, this is the old firehouse in Harrisburg. I was told that on the weekends, they clear some tables to create a dance floor, which is a nice touch. There is plenty of bar seating and booths, making it a kid-friendly environment. The only thing I don't like--which applies to every restaurant on 2nd Street--is that it's very hard to find parking. The Scale * Location & Parking: (3/5) * Staff & Engagement: (4/5) * Food Consistency: (4.7/5)

    Photos
    Men In The Kitchen
    Chicken and collard green eggrolls
    Chicken and collard green eggrolls
    Men In The Kitchen

    See all

    Thea

    Thea

    4.3
    (179 reviews)
    2.0 mi
    $$

    It's been about a year since we were at Thea's so we decided to dine there again for our 10th…read moreanniversary. And again, the experience was absolute heaven. AnneMarie actually remembered us from last year and came out to check on us several times. This time I had the veal saltimbocca, the Mrs. had the crab cakes, and the son had the shrimp and pasta. All of these were the best we've ever had. In my humble opinion AnneMarie is the best chef in the world and one of the kindest people on this planet. She had even written a happy anniversary card for us. Our server, Fotini, was excellent as well. Friendly, professional, and took very good care of us. And dessert, gadzooks! AnneMarie put the raspberry cheesecake on a large platter and spelled out Happy Anniversary in the raspberry sauce (see photo). The son and I had the peanut butter oreo pie. All are fantastic. I'd give her ten stars if I could. I cannot recommend Thea enough. If you visit Mechanicsburg you've GOT to dine at Thea. The best food and the best service. Thank you, AnneMarie for making our anniversary special.

    While visiting our daughter in Hersey Pa. we treated ourselves to a really classy and genuine GF…read moreCertified restaurant. Our daughter's favorite in Pa since she suffers from Celiac Disease . The food is fresh and amazing. The staff is incredible as well and since our daughter's favorite restaurant, the staff know her and her husband very well.

    Photos
    Lobby area
    Lobby area
    Pork Chop
    Pork Chop
    Strawberry Burrata

    See all

    Strawberry Burrata

    Katheryn's On the Square - newamerican - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...