Little over a week since dining here and we're still craving the seafood pasta and salad. Obtained said meals after a long hike and couldn't have been more pleased. Honestly we couldn't believe it took us until the last night to try this restaurant, otherwise we would have been here every night. The seafood pasta had a beautifully light sauce with scallops and large shrimp. Salad was incredibly refreshing, light, and dressed very well. read more

The early bird dinner here is such a great deal! The restaurant is very cute, and the service and entire experience were great. So many delicious drinks too (the frozen limoncello and frosé were both great). My entire family got the early dinner three course meal, and we thought it was a steal at $28 for the variety, quantity, and quality. We tried every appetizer and all were fabulous. The mains were also great. A perfect portion size! We got and would recommend the salmon, crab cakes, beef tips, and NY strip. All of the desserts were delicious as well! I would gladly eat anything from this restaurant again. read more

LURE - calamari, caesar salad, frosé, and limoncello - Seafood Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

The food was very good, I think. We were so rushed by our waiter, George, that we didn't have much time to enjoy our cocktail, appetizer or dinner. For that reason alone I will not be going back. I've already shared my experience with a long time Door County resident and he was surprised. Lure and Chop are owned by the same group and I've been to Chop 3x in the last year and the service is exceptional and courses were not rushed. Go to Chop and skip Lure, unless you're in a hurry. read more

Delicious dinner in a beautiful atmosphere...and great service. Can't ask for more! Walleye, whitefish and ribs were all yummy.

Exceptional food, service, location and atmosphere! We had a table of 6 with teenage kids and was perfect for all of us. Great table outside. read more

Went here for Saturday night dinner. Got the crab cakes, and my wife ordered Walleye fish fry. It wasn't good; we left disappointed. Crab cakes were underwhelming and walleye fillet had bones in it. Will not be going here again. Service was ok. Ambiance was nice. read more

One of the best meals my husband and I have had in a while. I ordered surf and turf and substituted the filet for an upcharge, 100% worth it. My filet was cooked and seasoned perfectly, fell apart in my mouth. My husband ordered the fried perch, the breading was thin and crispy unlike other fried fish he's had in the past. We highly recommend this place for dinner, and will hopefully be back up that way in the spring for round 2. read more

LURE - Grasshopper - Seafood Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Good food. Nice decor. The bar is quite pleasant. Pricey but a solid choice in Door County.

This is one of our favorites for our annual trip to Door County. Full disclosure, we go up in the winter so I can't speak to how crowded Lure is during peak season! One of my favorite things is the location. The building used to be a church and I enjoy looking at the little details that give you a hint at the buildings history! You can still see the choir loft and I'm fairly certain that the booths are repurposed pews. At least in the winter time, the menu doesn't change much but can always be relied on for a solid steak and fun surf & turf options. Their cocktails are really tasty and are a good start to a cozy romantic dinner. If you're in Door County and are willing to spend a little bit of money, check out Lure you'll enjoy it! read more

My husband and I had the 3 course early bird special. My husband's 1st course was a tasty chefs salad, blue cheese and bacon. I chose the pot stickers that came hot and crunchy with a soy dipping sauce. My main course was a New York Strip steak that was tender & flavorful and he had the Beef Burgundy which included a hardy sauce of onions and mushrooms, both meals were delicious. The desserts were also great, the layered carrot cake was moist with a decadent cream cheese frosting and caramel swirl and I had the creamy but tart Key lime pie which I would expect from any good Florida restaurant. Beautiful night out on the top deck and service was quick and efficient. I would definitely make this a stop while in Door county along with their sister restaurant Lure, both in Sister bay. read more

Hubby and I had a great dinner here last night. He had the halibut and I had the tuna with well-prepared red potatoes and vegetables. The place was hopping and there were plenty of servers so the service was great. We will definitely be back! read more

The dining experience was excellent. Very attentive and friendly staff. The crab nachos were very well prepared. The walleye and whitefish meals were superb and the servings very large. We ate outside and was pleasant surroundings. Will definitely be back. read more

LURE - Walleye - Seafood Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Lure's "early dining menu" was excellent! The portions were small but filling. Between the two of us, we had salad, bisque, salmon, strip steak, and cherry pie. The price was fantastic. Even with drinks and wine, we were able to enjoy a reasonably leisurely dinner and make it to the AFT show with time to spare. A great bargain! read more

Fish is not fresh when you can smell it as it comes to the table. Just ok. I wouldn't eat here again for the price. But the cherry pie was delicious. read more

Great service, great food - a Sister Bay must for my family! Request seating on their outdoor patio or the porch (glassed in). Their grilled salmon is delicious, and I've also enjoyed Caesar salads and steaks - never had a disappointing meal. Highly recommended! read more

Service is great , accommodations outside are very nice. We had dinner and tried some dishes. Sushi, shrimp tempura, mussels were very good. Main dishes like fish pasta and crab cakes ( 26$ and change each) very bland. Pasta was a soupy plate of noodles with way to much cream and crab cakes had not texture/ flavor: both not worthy. Overall a good dinner but need some improvement read more

Simply unbelievable. The entire menu. Wide range of dishes, even the deserts are homemade. TU side, outside and patio dining with great atmosphere, incredible bar, the friendliest foreign J1 workers. Known for their extensive seas food menu. Only drawback is parking in sister bay on busy days. read more

Terrible chicken and bad servers. They're getting 20% automatically so they don't care.

The food was scrumptious and the server was accommodating. We had the Asian salad, lobster bisque, calamari, and shrimp tempura, which were all delicious. The outdoor seating was enjoyable on a absolutely beautiful evening. Please consider putting cushions on the outdoor chairs for added comfort. read more

Great service at the bar and restaurant. The food was excellent every time we have eaten there. I highly recommend this place

We ate at Lure on July 4th. Really excellent food and service . The salmon was the best I have ever had . However, this restaurant has a 3.99% service charge added to the bill . This is just greed. We will not go back to this restaurant again until the service charge is removed . read more

Highly recommend local fish - walleye and the sushi. It's great place. If weather is good try to sit outdoors we lived the food and the drinks. read more

Waited a long time to be seated for our reservation. Took a long time to get our food, it was not cooked correctly and was cold. Have dined here every summer since they opened, will not be returning. read more

While driving through the area we found this place to stop for dinner. Parking is ridiculous, very little parking and a lot of it on weird inclines. Lots of parking on the street but during peak summer and a holiday weekend you couldn't find any. Stepping into Lure it has a nice upbeat trendy feel. Staff was friendly. We were seated right away. Their cheddar biscuits were great. We ordered the Ny Strip steak and their Crab Sushi stack. Our server was OK.. She was slow.. took forever to get things. The ceasar salad is medicore at best. Not even sure there was dressing on it and alot of the lettuce was brownish. They brought out my steak, but then had to wait about 10 mins before my nieces Sushi came out and a steak knife. Restaurants should NEVER bring one entry out and make customers wait for the other meals especially when its SUSHI! The steak was cooked to perfection, very flavorful and juicy but not worth almost $30. My niece loved the sushi. All in all the food was ok but this place is extremely overpriced and slow. Maybe it was just a bad night, who knows. read more

LURE - Seafood Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

We were really excited to try this place, given the reputation of sister restaurant Chop. The menu has a variety of different fish dishes and a few interesting Asian touches, so we were looking forward to mixing some classic and more fun dishes. We started with the Old Fashioned and Spicy Cucumber Gimlet; the Old Fashioned is not traditional in any way and has so many competing flavors that you end up not really tasting much of anything (disappointing given the price) and the Gimlet was tasty but so spicy that you couldn't taste anything for a few minutes after. We order the crab "nachos" as an appetizer, which means we paid $16 for 100 wonton chips, 2 tablespoons of crab, and some queso. Somewhat tasty, not at all worth the price. My fried shrimp were very tasty, as was my partner's fried perch. The fries were acceptable but nothing special. Overall, we were not happy with the price we paid for what we received. While our server was perfectly pleasant, she was rather absent for most of the meal. One of the things that bothered us MOST was the fact that Lure is advertising on their website that they were no longer offering indoor seating for health and safety reasons due to COVID-19 (good on them!) but when my partner went to the bathroom, the indoor space was PACKED WITH DINERS. This made us feel so uncomfortable and that they were not taking the health of their customers seriously. read more

Expensive and mediocre meal. Made a last minute decision to dine there. Were able to be seated without a reservation. Didn't like the location of the slopes table on the edge of the main parking lot but hey that one was on is for not making a reservation. The meals do not include bread or a salad so we ordered a bowl of clam chowder as an appetizer. The soup was flavorless and had an odd texture. Very small size for what was called a bowl. As someone mentioned it was $6 just to order bread and butter as a appetizer. The sushi roll ordered for dinner was ok. The Cajun salmon dinner was overcooked and dry. Served with sweet potatoes and regular coleslaw. Just a weird combination and the dressing from the coleslaw made the fried soggy. Blah. Will give them another try but this current impression was not good. read more

One of the few places I have rated 5 stars here in DC. Service was great and not overbearing. Everything we ate was awesome -- the cheddar biscuits were underwhelming...but still good...expectations ruined everything. My side blt salad came out promptly after and was large. I initially didnt like the presentation because I had to rip the bacon to distribute it....as I ate it I amcame to appreciate the flavor The balance of flavor was nice . The crabcakes came out shortly after and the flavor was good but the texture was interesting. Entrees arrived shortly after and we both loved our food. I got the salmon...green beans were the veg of the day... they were phenom. She let me try some of her pasta ... the flavors were awesome. I'd recommend this place 10/10. read more

See all

1st time experience.... Not in a good way. The "manager...." Fake manager told us we were " disturbing children." Very unwelcoming. 1st time in our life that we have been ridiculed by 5+ staff members. Manager has no back bone. Im sorry to post this and I hope the staff does better. Been looking forward to going to the Lure for 3+ seasons. read more

HORRIBLE SERVICE!!!! We came in for drinks and thought we would come back for dinner! Never again!!!!!

Considering we had such high hopes and were excited for this dinner, we were VERY disappointed. There are so many great places to eat in Door County, and this is not one that I would recommend to anyone. We both were sadly very disappointed with our whole dining experience. We made a reservation, and didn't get seating until 15 mins after our reservation time. Not a big deal, sat at the bar, and waited. But once we got seated we were only 5 feet away from the table at the bar we could have just sat at in the first place. So we had the cold draft from the open doors the whole dinner. After being seated, it took 15 mins of countless servers walking past us before I asked who was serving us because at this point we have been there for 30 mins and I still wasn't served any water. We ordered the spicy tuna roll for an appetizer and it was not good. Not sure why, but the fresh raw tuna, was warm. The whole roll had a warm mushy texture, and I wouldn't recommend it. For our meal, we ordered the whitefish almondine and the walleye pecandine. While waiting for our food our server was no where to be seen, no checking on us. The whitefish almondine was good. However the walleye almondine was not good. The fish was very slimy, like it was boiled? And had no flavor. The boiled potatoes and broccoli were cold. read more

LURE - Whitefish Almondine - Seafood Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Food was great. We had whitefish which was nicely prepared and cooked just right. Problem was the entree's came out two minutes after we were served our appetizers. Bad timing. read more

Had a fabulous time at Lure. Our group ordered the crab nachos to start and they were amazing. I could have easily had just that. I went with the scallops and they were awesome. Cooked perfectly and just right. The old fashions and Moscow mules were great too. I would definitely stop back. read more

LURE - Happy hour specials even on Saturday! - Seafood Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

First place to go for dinner after 4 hours drive to Door county. Great dinner and food are great. Just wish we can sit outside but they are full outside. Good price for the dinner and server are great. Definitely will come again. This place is located at the downtown area so parking can be a little hard to find. But still can find one within 5 minutes driving around. read more

See all

Had dinner here on a Monday night (6/27), not sure if this factored into the quality of the meal. The good: Our server Faith was excellent - prompt, friendly and professional. Drinks were very good and priced appropriately. The ambience and setting is modern and beautiful. A bit fancier in décor and clientele than a lot of other DC restaurants. Overall the food was good with a few exceptions. The biggest disappointment were the mussels and fries. I was not a fan of the sauce (I prefer the more classic saffron wine butter sauce), but the bigger issue was the quality of the mussels. Several of them had that cow poop taste (which if you've had some questionable oysters, then you're familiar with it.....not pleasant, hard to shake off of your taste buds). I stopped eating them after 4 duds in a row. The fries that came with were not the shoestring frites I'd expect with mussels...they had that starchy coating on them (Sysco lower grade?) which I can't stand and comes across cheap, especially in a restaurant like Lure. The crab crusted halibut was good, but needs a bigger impact sauce. Lobster bisque was very rich, heavy on the cream and sherry style. Cornbread was very good and ample. Grilled vegetable side was essentially raw veggies with some char marks on them. My wife loved her lobster tails, but agreed that the fries were nasty. Overall, would come back but be more selective on the choices. read more

Happy hour is wonderful. We had a blast sitting at the bar enjoying cocktails and small plates. Bartenders are welcoming.

Fish was wonderful. Service was outstanding. Very busy on a Saturday night. Decor was modern

Party of six or more they add 20% tip. No problem there, but when I pointed out the tax should not be included in that figure, she pointed it out to manager, but didn't change anything. Cost me $5 bucks, but cost them their reputation! read more

My husband and I visited this restaurant on a Saturday night. We were fortunate that they were able to fit us in at the last minute in the bar area. We ordered a cornbread as an appetizer which was really for 4 people but was amazing! Both our dinners, fried walleye and grilled Salomon were also great. Service was a little spotty, but that may have been because we were seated in the bar area. Overall very happy with our dinner. Subtracting one star for an ambiguous service charge for 4% tacked on to our check that wasn't apparently associated with a credit card or anything else. If they need 4% more, just increase menu prices. read more

We really enjoyed the $2 Oysters. They were fantastic even though it is August. We also had the Crab Nachos . Very nice and light because the chips were fried wonton! Lump crab, mango, micro greens, and white queso , avocado, and green onions. Such a nice balance. Forgot to take a picture before we dug in!! We will be back! Great atmosphere and service. One last thing...think about the name...their name is NOT OUTSIDE! Yes, we were lured in with the oysters....! read more

See all

The Lure has become an annual dining location for us while in Sister Bay. Lure is pet friendly and very accommodating for our dog in its outside dinning area. We ordered the walleye and also the lobster special. Our sides included potatoes and slaw. Our food was excellent in all areas. All servers were great always checking to see if anything was needed. We really appreciated our table location and the attention given to our pet dog! Hope to see you again in the future. read more