Went here for Valentine's dinner, service started out a little rocky but they turned it around. They were busy and it was pretty late so I give them some grace. The server was very nice. The food and drinks were amazing. We kinda had no idea what we ordered, but ended up loving both pastas. Lively space and a great spot for a night out with gf or friends. read more

The interior is great, nice decoration and beautiful natural lighting coming in. Our server was attentive and helpful. Food was nice, the seafood risotto had good flavor. The salad was definitely on the small side, underwhelming but other than that the food was good. Solid spot but nothing spectacular, would be okay with coming back. read more

See all

This was my second visit to Macello and it's a great off the beaten path (1200 W Lake) neighborhood restaurant with an awesome outdoor patio. We lucked out with perfect weather to sit outside. Great kids menu along with all your traditional pastas, fish, lamb chops, and brick Owen pizza. My kids got a pizza and spaghetti with meatballs off the kids menu while I got a pasta with pistachio and mushrooms. Staff and service was friendly and attentive. My kids had a great time and I am sure we'll be back again to enjoy their beautiful patio. read more

Macello Cucina di Puglia - Pistachio cream cavatelli with burrata - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Amazing service at the bar + perfect happy hour experience. The pizza was perfectly cooked with flavor to match. THE OLIVES. Heavenly. I will be back. read more

Macello Cucina di Puglia - PIZZA MACELLO + spritz - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Takes credit card. Excellent excellent service Lots of table seating and bar seating. Marcello Pizza ($24)- really good pizza. Thin crust. Risotto Adriatico $30- hearty amount of clams and mussels. Great tomatoes flavor. Risotto could be more soft read more

Macello Cucina di Puglia - Risotto Adriatico (seafood risotto) - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

We came here during Happy Hour, and thoroughly enjoyed the ambiance, service, cocktails, and pizza. The crust was delicious and wasn't soggy, like some other (neapolitan) pizza venues. I would happily go back to try some other food options. FYI, the Happy Hour pricing affects how much we spent per person. Without it, I would expect $30-$40 per person. read more

Definitely a hidden gem in West Loop When there's like 200 different Italian places in west loop, it's easy to just go for the obvious places but this restaurant at the edge of west loop (further west from the center/hub of west loop) was such a great find! Wood fired pizza pugliese (mortadella, burrata on a tomato sauce base) was really delicious and the crust was baked really well with a nice crunch but not burnt edges! Definitely less fluffy than a traditional neapolitan but the flavors were really solid - well balanced and not to heavy on the salt The seafood risotto was also pretty well cooked. Service was alright and the interior decor was definitely on the ... more edgy...?? Side but overall still a great spot for a casual dinner / date night! read more

See all

Bit of a hidden gem in west loop! Street side parking available outside and it's not as crowded because it's a little further out from the other restaurants. Plenty of seating inside. Their pizza is so good, crust is a the perfect texture. I got the lamb chop casserole, the casserole was on the saltier side but the lamp chops were perfectly cooked. Not a huge mocktail selection and the mule I had wasn't very good, so docked points for that. read more

Macello Cucina di Puglia - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I went for my birthday dinner and had a very pleasant experience. The server was attentive but not overbearing and everyone in my party was happy with their food. Everything is quite pricy as can be expected for the area, but splitting a pizza is a great cost efficient option. The place is also cozy and a good mix of slightly upscale but not at all stuffy. Would 100% recommend. read more

Macello Cucina di Puglia - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Unfortunately this place has gone down since we last came here ..Service was attentive but off food portions are very small and the gelato severed on a dinner plate not even a bowl freezer burned and old no flavor and when we told the server he just shrugged it off that's terrible. People go just for the pizza ..We won't be back we did like this place but something is terrible off here. On to the next that area is loaded with places .. I will say the food had a good flavor and dinner wise things were very tasty just small. read more

Restaurant week review: 1. Fried Artichoke & Cauliflower 2. Cavatelli al Forno 3. Lamb Chop 4. Tartufo Di Nocciola - cocoa covered hazelnut truffle with cacoa liqueur The quality of food can be summed up as well-made but not particularly special. Fried artichoke was tasty. I liked the batter although it could be crispier. Cavatelli pasta was homely. Lamb chop was tender and juicy but wasn't seasoned. Tartufo Di Nocciola was basically a chocolate sauce covered chocolate ice cream. Again, not bad, not incredible. Service was not the greatest. Staff were slow to change out our plates and not all of them sometimes. But our interactions with them were nice. read more

See all

Hidden little gem in Fulton market. Dark and romantic atmosphere. The food was decent overall, but the vodka sauce lacked flavor I was hoping for. While the pasta was cooked well, the sauce could have used a bit more flavoring. On the plus side, the service was attentive and warm, with staff eager to ensure a pleasant dining experience. Overall, while the atmosphere and service stood out, the food didn't quite match the enchanting setting. read more

See all

This restaurant is located in the west loop area, and the atmosphere is wonderful. You enter and walk into an old shopfront with plenty of Italian cheeses to choose from. The seating area has beautiful lanterns adorning the ceiling and murals along the walls. We ordered burrata to share, which was quite yummy. Additionally, we ordered the pizza barese and risotto barese with sausage. I enjoyed both, feeling the pizza was better than the pasta. In terms of pricing, the food here is a bit on the expensive side though pretty comparable to surrounding restaurants. read more

See all

We LOVE a Friday night at Macello's! The best pizza in the city, delicious salad (lightest dressing! So classy!), the artichokes & a few cocktails read more

See all

I rarely feel compelled to write reviews and now I am writing my 2nd on this place so I make sure people know to stay away. What a terrible experience and disappointment. I've been to Macello before a few years ago and it was so good- this time I was at a whole new restaurant. Ambiance was terrible, bad music, no one else in sight on a Thursday but I understood why. The saltimbocca was beyond dry, I couldn't find the filling in the in the braciole, the Barese sausage had nothing Barese about them and tasted like breakfast sausages, and THERE WAS A HAIR IN MY FOOD. The food was not good. Service was also beyond lacking- couldn't believe the hospitality fee when I didn't receive hospitality. Even if I wanted to address the issues at hand the staff did not seem to care at all. I asked staff for a recommendation, and you'd think they'd never eaten there. The menu is huge, there was 4 people and the only rec i got was 1 pasta off the special's menu. I should've realized why he had nothing else to recommend. We kept talking amongst ourselves wondering if they changed owners or what happened- based on the other recent negative comments something must have happened. A terrible representation of southern Italian food and a terrible experience especially for the price. When I reviewed this on Google the owner then commented back arguing about my experience as I see they have done with any other people here and on Google. If they spent more time improving staff and menus and food instead of arguing with people and proving the point about poor hospitality- maybe they wouldn't have to defend themselves as much. read more

Great place. Food and service were great (thanks to Sarah!). She recommended and excellent Puglia red whine. read more

See all

Excellent pizza the macello pizza was my favorite- so fresh from the oven. The pizza is so light yet tasty and delicious. The crust has the perfect amount of thickness The chicken from the main course was so juicy and tender with the grilled broccolini The service is very friendly and prompt The drinks are great too - my personal fav is the matcha doing Def a cool local Italian spot with old Italian family vibes. Great find in west loop - slightly hidden from the bustle of the Randolph street. read more

Valentine's Day dinner with the family... we were escorted to our table right away, the inside is unpretentious and cosy with wood fire - pizza oven and minimal decorations. Our server Joseph brought out our drinks and accidentally dropped beer on me and broke the bottle . My new red dress messed up and I was wet and uncomfortable for rest of the evening. My wine was served in a stemless glass not sure why , didn't enhance my experience of the good Pinot noir. We got the mussels, delicious! Some sausage appetizer and Main course whole chicken, pasta and seafood risotto. Dessert cannoli and tiramisu. Loved the pasta sauce wish they sold in the deli up front. They offered lemon cello @ the end for the valentines. Not sure if I want to come back . read more

See all

This a fun looking place with an old time feel. The service Is excellent! The wines and mixed cocktails were great too. The food was very good. The one item we had that was the winner was their pizza! Right out of a wood burning stove and the ingredients tasted like they were imported from Italy! The crust was crispy right to the center. I would definitely go back again! read more

See all

This place is adorable. The veggie pizza was topped with amazing fresh veggies and wood fired right in front of us. Our server, Valerie, was delightful and attentive. The atmosphere is so wonderful! Loved the Italian music. Had a great birthday celebration here! Can't wait to come back! read more

See all

We have been fans of Macello's for several years. The atmosphere is very warm and inviting. The food is Puglia style with savory pastas and excellent wood fired pizzas. John was our waiter and he was the best. If you want an intimate and relaxing authentic southern Italian experience, you have to try Macello's. read more

We came here for a weekend dinner and it was packed! The interior has a lot of natural light and there are decorative balls on the ceiling that light up once it gets dark! We ordered a seafood mussel dish and a salad for our appetizer. The mussels were so delciiius and juicy! Next we ordered sea bass, seafood pasta, and a truffle oil mushroom pasta. Let me tell you. The sea bass was 15/10!!!!! So tender and buttery and flaky. I fell Inlove! We also got a flan like caramel flavored dessert. Overall, the service was amazing and the food was incredible! I would definitely come again!! read more

See all

I was prepared to make a glowing recommendation of this low-key Italian restaurant in the Fulton Market area of Chicago. The food was wonderful and our server was personable and helpful. What soured the evening was the GM walked through the restaurant and spoke to every table in the place EXCEPT ours. What's with that? We were there for more than an hour and generously spent money and ordered food so...why not ask us how we were enjoying ourselves? That pretty much sealed it for us- great food but felt dissed. Won't go back. read more

See all

The ambiance was beautiful great for a date night. The waitress was so friendly and helpful she explained each dish to us and the drinks. We went with another couple we all tried the popular dishes the Bass, Chicken the spicy pasta seafood dish and the filet. Everything was delicious I was feeling under the weather the waitress immediately offered her assistance got me some ice chips and bottled water if I could give them more stars I would just for their kindness. I'm returning in a few weeks . read more

Macello Cucina di Puglia - Whiskey drink - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Macello was an excellent experience. The food was delicious and the service was beyond impeccable. Our waiter was Leo and he was friendly, accommodating and professional. The regional food of Puglia was authentic and I highly recommend this restaurant! read more

Located in the West Loop, this Italian spot is great for a nice dinner with friends or family or perhaps even a date. Stopped by around 5:30PM on a Friday night and there were plenty of table open, by the time we left however it was PACKED. They have indoor seating, a bar, and a patio. Definitely go for the patio seating if you can! It's a really cute space. Onto the good stuff, the fooooood. So delicious! They start you out with warm crust bread with olive oil and parmesan cheese. I had the Laganelle Tartufata, a pasta dish with truffle, mushrooms, sausage and the goat cheese which really makes the dish. We also had a cocktail which was very good, don't remember what it was something with Limoncello maybe? I may have been enjoying the food too much. For dessert we ordered the spumoni which was creamy and delicious! The service was great, they didn't pressure us at all even as we neared the 90 minutes they're limiting tables to at the moment. They were quick with taking our orders and clearing plates also. Highly recommend Macello's for good Italian food in the West Loop. And free street parking available nearby yay! read more

Macello Cucina di Puglia - Laganelle Tartufata - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

My partner and I had a really great experience at Macello. Not overly crowded, good service, great food. Parking is free on the street too! They also have valet ($8). What we had? Shrimp over Spinach appetizer special - 9/10 - honestly some of the best flavored shrimp i've had to date Cauliflower Soup of the Day - 8/10 - really good, but more watery than i thought it was gonna be. however had solid chunks of soft cauliflower Chilean Sea Bass - 9/10 - so crispy and flaky at the same time, i'd recommend it Tartufata - 8/10 - pretty good, very mushroom heavy fyi, solid flavor and the cheese really brings it together Tiramisu - 10/10 - GET IT. OUTSTANDING. Overall, WONDERFUL. I recommend this restaurant and I also plan to come back. We also had a wonderful bottle of wine +. 2 limoncello shots @ the end. In total with tip we spent $230. read more

See all

I'm not sure why I haven't written a review for here yet...this is one of my favorite Italian restaurants in Chicago! I come here quite often too, and it never disappoints. Last night we came in with a table of seven to celebrate birthdays and we had a great time! Wine was pouring, service was spectacular, and the food was beyond delicious. Starters - Bread basket with olive oil and parmesean (Free!!) - Barratt cheese with prosciutto, arugula, on slices of bread shaped like pizza (on special) Favoritr Meals of the night - Pizza Pugliese - Cavatelli al Forno (my all time favorite) - Farro ai Fungu Porcini And then finished the night with limoncello (on thr house). This place is a must go to if you've never been! read more

See all

This place is amazing!! Great food, drinks, service, vibe & decor!! The menu has great variety! Lots of pizza, pasta & salad options! We made reservations to celebrate my friends birthday! We were allowed to bring balloons in and a cake. (they charge a plating fee which is pretty standard) Everyone's food was amazing. My girlfriend and I shared a pasta dish and the Bianca Pizza. Both were delicious! read more

Macello Cucina di Puglia - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Food was pretty solid. We didn't expect to have olive as an intense ingredient in most dishes, and sadly we are not huge fan of olives. However it does not impact too much on the flavor and we still liked the food. The lamb chop casserole was a bit burnt but I love the risotto. Tiramisu was amazing. Ambiance wise, the restaurant is a bit too dark and hard to read the menu. Still recommend! read more

See all

This is the same region my father is from in Italy. So I may be a bit biased. But the food is amazing. It tastes like "home". The service has never been a problem. My family comes here a lot. We do a yearly cousins dinner. Ambiance is great! read more

The restaurant is as I remember it before Covid - a pleasant dinning experience with delicious food and wine. Meeting friends here for a midweek dinner on a beautiful spring evening was a perfect. Wednesday is half off on selected bottles of wine, my chef friend selected a wonderful red one. It helped us ignore the occasional passing train above. We enjoyed the patio - maybe a freshen-up this spring is needed . We shared our dinner selections: fried calamari, pizza Macello & faro ai frutti du mare . Dessert was cava and cake. There is a deli in the front entrance, a large dinning room with colorful murals & lanterns and patio in back. The location is out of the restaurant bubble but worth the trip. read more

Vibe was nice, dark and intimate yet fun. Service was good, our waitress was sweet. The calamari was a standout for me, light and crisp and cooked perfectly. I may go back just for that and a glass of wine at the bar. My pasta was good but spicy next time I'd ask for that to be toned down a bit. They upsell you on the wine and it was expensive. read more

Excellent cuisine, stylishly presented, interesting decor and friendly service. You might not go here on a budget, but you could come for an occasion when you want to impress people and not break the bank. As the name implies, this is not only an Italian restaurant; it focuses mostly on the region where Puglia is located. Therefore you'll see many of the items on the menu are beyond the style most American Italian restaurants have as their main stays. Enjoy the slightly different fare, and learn there's more to Italy's food that can be great and different. read more

Warm ambience and fabulous food made for a perfect evening. The decor is fun and inviting. (I want one of those colorful light fixtures!) The Italian cuisine is authentic and prepared perfectly. My friend and I decided to share everything. We started with a bottle of Prosecco, the Macello salad and the grilled octopus... followed by the pizza Pugliese with burrata cheese. There are two wood burning fireplaces, and the thin crust pizzas are a specialty. Loved every bite. Left room for dessert... a yummy tiramisu. Our attentive server brought us several coffee refills and complimentary Limoncello's. Lots of free street parking. Can't wait to go back. Who could ask for anything more? read more

Macello Cucina di Puglia - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

All the food we had was amazing! The waiter was more than happy to answer all our questions and give recommendations about menu. Drinks were delicious and unique! Owner was delightful! Will be returning soon! read more

In "hidden gem" territory for West Loop based on the menu but needs a lot of work. Waiter seemed relatively untrained and skirting the fence between very socially awkward and having smoked before coming to work. Table for two served two slices of a loaf of bread that were not fresh at all. Pasta in ceramic bowl was served scalding hot and was still barely edible after sitting for 10 minutes. This process needs to be refined. Received the wrong pizza. Wine decanter had not been cleaned properly and had visible smudges all over the top part. Ordered an expensive bottle and nobody made an effort to refill our glasses. read more

The food was excellent, especially the Chilean Sea Bass. The server said it was her first night, and it showed. She knew very little about the menu, which led me to order a side of spinach when my entree also came with spinach. She also forgot our appetizer order, but that turned out ok because we had plenty with our entrees. The restaurant is also a bit loud and has distracting televisions. I ordered black tea and they brought Stash, which is not the worst option but far from the best. They also had no honey for the tea. read more

Macello Cucina di Puglia - Chilean SeaBass with Shrimp Rice and Spinach (not well described on the menu, but delicious) - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

We had a really nice meal here for Valentine's Day. Ambiance is great indoors and we've been on the back patio in the past which was nice too. Love that there was complimentary bread and oil like traditional places. Pizza we got was really good (can't remember which one). The pastas were also good. The one with mussels was great. It was a bit pricey but well priced compared to other west loop spots. definitely recommend! read more

We love Macello! We recently were introduced to Macello in November by a friend and since, we've been back 4 times. The food, drinks and service have been phenomenal each time. We will continue to recommend to others. read more