Nice service and very clean establishment. It is no wonder the food is as good as the place. Nice to have a pie just as New York as it can get in Stafford. read more

Well, this was my second time to Manhattan Pizza. And it was just as good as the first time I was there. What I found heartwarming about this trip was the waitress remembered me from the first time I was there. First time there, I tried the Manhattan supreme pizza. This time I wanted to try something different. So, Jaila recommended the Brooklyn Bomber. That pizza was very good. Everyone at the restaurant is very friendly. I just love Jaila. She added to my experience there at Manhattan Pizza. When I am in the Stafford area, I will definitely be back again for a good pizza. Jaila, I'm gonna want another recommendation from you. When you're in the Stafford area, stop by Manhattan pizza for a friendly environment and great pizza! read more

Manhattan Pizza - Stafford - Brooklyn Bomber Pizza (Medium) - Salad Near Me - Stafford, Virginia

A coworker brought this brand of pizza in to share for a fast lunch. It def hit the spot. Fast forward to today and picking up a small on the way home. The pepperoni is a little greasy but to me this is a fantastic pizza They have loads of different menu items like gyros, burgers, shareables, pasta, wings, salads, calzones, sandwiches, and pizza. Can't forget about desserts but it all looked fantastic. Lots of to go orders. They do have coupons in their menu to hold onto for different days of the week. I can't wait to try other items on the menu. They deliver too so you don't have to go through a 3rd party app. Don't forget to sign up for their awards program. read more

See all

The pizza is good and friendly service. Two large slices of pizza and drink for $6. The atmosphere is very nice as well. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Stafford - Pizza slices - Salad Near Me - Stafford, Virginia

Tried giving Manhattan Pizza another chance, and regretted it. The store is filthy. Trash cans overflowing, tables sticky, plus there's a foul and mysterious odor in the air inside. Piles of stuff in the hallway leading to the bathroom. Counters were grungy. I don't think the restaurant would pass a surprise health inspection. My gyro was OK, but nothing notable. Food took about 15 minutes as expected. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Stafford - Menu cover - Salad Near Me - Stafford, Virginia

See all

We called in an order with 3 items: 1. Baked Ziti with 2. Garlic bread 3. Steak and cheese calzone. My husband went to pick it up. As soon as he arrived they handed him the calzone and nothing else. He asked for the baked ziti. They forgot it. They had to make it. He waited. They handed him the baked ziti. He asked for his garlic bread that is supposed to come with it. They forgot it. They had to make it. Again he waited. Finally they gave him the complete order. Now, for the worst part: The calzone was cold after waiting for so long. It was supposed to be STEAK and cheese but there was almost no steak in it. The onions and peppers were raw, not grilled or fried, and it was loaded with them. It was like eating a raw onion and cheese calzone. I seriously could not taste any steak and when I looked for the meat, it almost wasn't there. As for the ziti, my husband say it was not very flavorful and he would not order it again. He said the garlic bread was good. We will not be going back. We do not recommend them. read more

I feel like i was getting good service but things are slipping. The last two times i came here the pizza they gave me tasted old and stale like it had been sitting out alllll day. Then the next time i come i ask for my pizza to be reheated and they said no cause there " was like 100 pizzas being made" even tho i was looking through the window and no pizza were coming out. This place is def going down and i think its time to find a new place to get pizza from smh read more

We are regulars at Manhattan Pizza, have ordered almost everything on the menu at one point or another, and have never been disappointed! Food is always delicious, and service is always friendly and prompt read more

Wow I am surprised at the mediocre reviews. My fist time trying them only because my job orders from here ALOT! Simple burgers and fries and it was very good. Generous amount if meat- can't place the taste but it took me back to my childhood..... maybe like Frischers Big Bot? We are getting pizza today- I will update my review once I try it! read more

Manhattan Pizza - Stafford - a sandwich and french fries - Salad Near Me - Stafford, Virginia

My smuppers and myself really enjoy the availability of outside seating. The waitstaff is always super accommodating!! The prices are great. Amazing lunch specials from open to 3 P.M. every day of the week. Jailia and Rex are always accommodating every single visit!! read more

don't even get me started on this place.. pizza is a ten out of ten must have!!!! the deals are unstoppable and all the options choices are fantastic. The workers are very helpful and super sweet. they are always there to serve u and be there for whatever you need. the wait time is also very short and great. food is always made fresh. must try manhattan pizza. read more

This place has the worst service and not a bargain for the money. Pizza is below average. Don't get delivery! They always screw up the order or forget something. read more

Been in Stafford for 5 years now and have never considered strip mall pizza ... but here goes. Turns out it's great place for a quick lunch! Slices are yuge, plus youz can get a salad and a soda for only $9!! Service was friendly and prompt. Menu packed with items, pastas, sandwiches, etc. Modern industrial seating, very clean and inviting. Will be back again fer sure read more

I would absolutely have Manhattan Pizza food again. A CLASS ACT, with outstandingly delicious and fresh food!!! My daughter and grand kids came to visit and we ordered 2 steak sandwich's and I had the Gyro. When I opened up the order, my Gyro was not there, so I quickly called the restaurant and the manager immediately came on, apologized and said she would make it for me and have it delivered. About 20 mins later I had a knock on my door (I live less than 3 miles away) and "it was the manager I spoked on the phone with....and she was holding my order. She personally delivered my order, apologized for the mistake and threw in a dessert. Now I have had mistakes made before, but no manager has ever personally delivered what was missed to me. Manhattan Pizza....I loved your food before but now, you have gained a cult following from me with my forever loyalty to your team. Ma'am, thank you again!! read more

Currently having their soft opening. They'll be closing at 5 every day until their official open date of 22 June and then that's when they'll initiate their normal hours. The interior is nicely decorated although there seemed to be an issue with the AC. It was very stuffy inside. The menu is pretty big and they offer multiple options of pizza, burgers, calzones, subs and gelatos. They also have a kids menu. Their gelato fresh and in house made and is presented beautifully. Teir cannolis are filled with creme to order. Absolutely loved my raspberry cheesecake gelato. My hubby loved his biscoff gelato. The cannoli was just okay and tasted like it was lacking something. The pizza smelled amazing and we'll be back for dinner this week. The service is a little slow right now as to be expected but they should get the kinks sorted soon. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Stafford - Salad Near Me - Stafford, Virginia

Honey was in the mood for a Stromboli so we decided to give this place a shot. This place is reasonably priced and food is very good! I got the gyro salad, which came with both beef and lamb meat. The salad size was huge and they were not stingy with the amount of meat and cheese! The Stromboli is a little smaller than what we've had at other restaurants, but my husband said it was still pretty good. We will definitely be back since we have family live in the area and it's easier to get to than something off of 610. read more

See all

I've visited this establishment a few times and I personally have never had a bad experience. The pizza is top tier and the customer service is just as good. I've been in this area going on four years now and they have the best pizza in the area so I would definitely recommend this place. read more

We tried Manhattan Pizza on a whim. It was pretty good. We ordered a gyro platter that was delicious. We added an extra pita and it was perfect for my husband and I. We also ordered what they call pepperoni rolls. My husband is from West Virginia where a pepperoni roll can be an entire meal. These, while good, should be called pepperoni bites. Overall, not a bad option. Looking forward to trying some pizza soon. read more

See all

So yourself a favor and don't pay extra for onion rings when you buy a sandwich. They literally give you 3 medium acne 2 small onion rings. I thought it was a mistake but this is the second time I've ordered from them and the same thing happened. The fries aren't any better. You get 10 fries with your order. read more

See all

Easy online ordering. Third time ordering from here. One dine-in and twice carryout. Last order was Manhattan supreme.. pizza was damn near cold after a 5 minute ride back to the house. Appeared to be a warmed over pizza. Service was good and friendly. read more

The price is accommodating as well as a family friendly dine-in experience. Service is typically managed in a timely manner. Great lunch specials. Kid-friendly. read more

Okay so I read thru some of these reviews and got kinda turned off to go to this place. I just wanna say this place is fantastic, the food was really good, service was friendly and I LOVED the nyc deli feel to the place, it truly felt like I stepped into a deli for a chopped cheese. I got a pepperoni pizza and the buffalo chicken rolls, both Super good and cook to perfection. Def give this place a chance . (Best pizza in stafford va, imo) read more

Manhattan Pizza - Stafford - Salad Near Me - Stafford, Virginia

Pizza was wonderful! Crust cooked nice and crisp like I love it. The NYC interior layout is a perfect layout for a pizza shop. Customer service was awesome. Even brought us out fresh cookies on the house. 10/10 I will be back again. read more

After hearing about this place and reading all the mediocre and negative reviews, we decided to give it a try on a weekday for lunch. They were about half full with customer when we went, so we were hopeful food would be fresh and good. First thing we noticed was that they have a huge menu loaded with not only pizzas, but sandwiches, subs and salads too. They also sell pizzas by the slice and they're on display in their front cabinet at the cashier and we were impressed with how beautiful all the pizzas looked! We opted for a large pizza, fresh and custom made... We ordered pepperoni with extra sauce and jalapeño on half. The young man taking our order really wasn't cut out (or perhaps not properly trained) for this job... he was playing with the front of his T-shirt collar and sticking it in his mouth while talking to us... Very off behavior for a cashier and food handler at a restaurant. We asked for two cups for drinks from their soda fountain and then paid. He gave us our order number for our table, but never gave us cups, we assumed they were at the fountain, but they weren't so we went back to get cups. Of course, they were out of Barqs Root Beer and Coke, so we had to ask for them to replace the syrups for those. The tables weren't very clean, but we found one moderately clean that we sat at. Looking around the dining room and outside, it's a beautifully decorated restaurant with interesting outdoor seating under square sun shades. The place looks really nice on the inside, they clearly spent a lot to build this place out. It's just HORRIBLY sad that the owners aren't running the place properly at all! They have no social media presence, because if they did, they'd pay attention to the helpful/negative comments and make corrections. There was also no clearly marked manager or supervisor in the front of house while we were there... Lots of employees, but with our cashier doing odd things, with the soda fountain area being so disorganized and dirty and with the general lobby not well-kept, they're clearly lacking management up front. Out food was quick to be made and brought to the table and I have to say, the pizza looked great! It's a thinner crust, which was great for lunch. The jalapeño on it looked really fresh, not even pickled from a jar, which was impressive and nice. The extra sauce seemed non-existent, the cheese was very thinly laid, not impressive at all. Flavor was the pizza was nice though. We enjoyed what we had and ate it all. It most definitely wasn't the best pizza we've ever had, about mid-range or so. Price is rather high for just a large pizza, I think it was like $22. Considering the cost, poor training/service of the employees and the lack of keeping the front end stocked, clean and orderly, I don't see us returning... which is sad, as we really do need some restaurants around here, but we need them to have a good product and be properly and well-managed! read more

See all

After visiting this restaurant several times this past month Using pick-up, delivery, and dine-in services, I must reduce my star rating. Service has been consistently slow and I received the incorrect order several times. The food is still good but the service is just so slow. I think with more training and better customer service this place will be good. The food gave it a 3 star but if it weren't for the food it would get a 2 star. read more

I absolutely love this place! The staff is extremely nice, the food is delicious, and considering it's all homemade the price is awesome! Stop in if you are in the area. read more

I visited this restaurant for dinner this evening, it's was ok. The food was OK. Nothing to brag about. I will definitely try the restaurant again maybe they'll be something else on the menu that will tantalize my taste buds. My wife and I had a Hawaiian pizza, chicken, Caesar salad, and the food was average. If you're living in the Stafford area it's worth giving it a try. read more

See all

Amazing pizza! I love the entire menu and can always get something different and delicious. The subs are top notch NY style. I'm a big fan of the sauce and typically get my pizzas "well done" for that golden brown crust and gives the cheese extra pull on every bite! 10/10 drool factor! read more

Manhattan Pizza - Stafford - Pepperoni, sausage and mushroom custom build pizza! - Salad Near Me - Stafford, Virginia

See all

Was excited to try this place since it's new to the Stafford area. The pizza is just ok, unfortunately. I would not call this "Manhattan" worthy pizza at all. The pizza was very doughy on the bottom. I would have given this place 3 stars based on the pizza alone, but the customer service is completely nonexistent here. Therefore, 2 stars is what I would give it. Probably won't be back :/. read more

We got the zucchini sticks and pizza. The zucchini sticks were average. They came with an average ranch dip. And the pizza was good but for my liking it had too much cheese and not enough sauce. I would however get the pizza again. The gelato was good but did not taste like regular gelato. I could not put my finger on it but it wasn't as smooth as gelato, but it was still good. The service was really good and we didn't wait too long to get our food. I would try it again. read more

See all

I would give less than 1 star review it wasn't for the gyros,which were good. We ordered calzones. I ordered the Mediterranean and while the crust looked done the insides were cold. They reheated and the insides were like warm. We also ordered the cheesesteak. The crust was done and the vegetables inside were raw. Go to Basilicos!!!! read more

Maybe because I'm a native New Yorker, my review may be a bit harsh, but this is not Manhattan Pizza or Meatball Parmigiana. Very bland. They always said it may be the tap water in NY that makes the pizza taste good. Maybe Virginia is missing that. read more

I enjoy the pizza here. Being from NY it's closer to home than any of the other chains around here. I gave it 4 stars because they have to step up their knots game. Pizza is pretty good though. read more

Clean establishment. But slow service order pizza over the phone and was told 15-20 mins but been waiting over 35 mins , cashier went to back and started touching the pizza with his bare hands .. no gloves .. read more

Great food consistently with a very friendly staff and great atmosphere to relax and enjoy a great meal.

First time coming here and loved the Gyro salad!! Service is fantastic and the staff are extremely kind. Pleasantly surprised at this spot. Would definitely come back - clean and family friendly! read more

Service sucked but pizza was decent. Hard to complete a full review because it really wasn't a memorable experience. Just like fast food pizza but 5x the wait time read more

Delicious fast New York style pizza! Convenient location! Solid Customer Service! 5 stars!

Someone who has lived in Manhattan and moved into the boon docks of Virginia no one knows how to make pizza. Sad . I gave the establishment one star because the pizza is terrible you put to shame the name "Manhattan Pizza" you might as well call it "Virginia Pizza" because that's what it is. In addition a large cheese pie was $18 crazy. The pizza was soggy not even crispy- and you call that pizza crust. Looked like a frozen pizza just jammed into the oven. Sure they have a huge menu selection but I'm afraid to try. The wait time could have been better because they looked unorganized crowded because of their opening. They need to close their doors and rethink their pizza crust because it's no where near Manhattan Pizza lol . I get better pizza from Paisano's in Stanford shopping enter next to shoppers. Yeah I don't think I'll be coming back. Definitely the first and last time. Extra Large pizza at Piasono's is $12 read more

Manhattan Pizza - Stafford - Manhattan Pizza slice - Salad Near Me - Stafford, Virginia

I've waited over a month for Manhattan Pizza to open as there aren't any really good pizza places in Stafford. Tried ordering my food online but their website hadn't been updated with the current operating hours so I could not place my order online. I tried calling in my order multiple times but the phone was either busy or no one would answer so I decided to drive there and order in person. The line was quite long but it moved fairly quickly. I ordered my food and asked how long it would take. I was told about 30-40 minutes. After waiting 45 minutes and no food, I asked how long they think it would take and I was told that my salad was ready, but my garlic knots and pizza were not. I waited another 30 minutes and got one of my pizzas and garlic knots, but was still missing a second pizza. I asked multiple employees about my missing pizza and they couldn't locate it so they had to make me another one. An hour and a half after placing my order, I finally got all my items. However, by this time the first pizza was cold. My family ate the food and it was decent, but not the best, and certainly not worth an hour and a half wait. I was hoping to be able to give this place a great review, but I was very disappointed. I decided to give this place two stars because the employees were very polite and I could see they were frustrated at how things were going. They were trying their best to take care of the customers. Had it not been for them, I would give Manhattan Pizza zero stars. To be fair, the place just opened a week ago. Hopefully it will be better once they work the kinks out, but I will be waiting a while for this to happen before I go back. read more