Craving pizza so we tried Mateo's. They have Middle Eastern inspired pizzas and regular pizzas among other meal choices. We wanted to try the Lahmacun which is a super thin crust Turkish pizza. Crisp and savory this was really good. We also got a Cappadocia pizza, Turkish Pepperoni, Pepperoncini, Arugula and Oregano. Dang this was good! Fresh and piping hot out of the oven. Young girl (family member) training at the order counter was being coached by grandpa? Super friendly and hard working. Limited indoor seating but they have a few more tables outside too. Check out their menu for other meal options not just pizzas. read more

See all

A major plus for Mateo's Pizza is that it's halal! The location is small but easy to find with convenient parking. They have a great variety of options including different pizza flavors, build-your-own pizzas, wings, salads, and Turkish pies (which we didn't try this visit but will definitely be back for). The shop has a cozy setup with two tables, a bar top with a few stools, and some outdoor seating. The owner was kind, the staff was friendly, and being greeted with "Salaam" was a thoughtful touch that was appreciated. There was a small issue with our order being heard incorrectly, but the team handled it well and fixed it by adding the missing toppings to our pizza. The pizzas are made fresh and come out quickly. The wings were just okay, nothing too unique, but they were cooked perfectly. The pizza had a good crust with a nice bite, and the toppings tasted fresh. It was a solid pizza, although not necessarily something I'd cross the bridge specifically for. They also have an extensive drink selection, and next time I'll definitely be trying the desserts. Overall, a nice local spot that I'd happily return to when I'm in the area! read more

See all

I had begun to exhaust all of Yelp's top pizza spots in the South Bay and as such, had started to explore their options on the Peninsula list and Mateo Pizza was one of them. The description of "pizza with Turkish influence" caught my attention and I decided to try them. I was really tethering on giving this place five stars versus four stars. I will start with the reasons why I was going to give them five stars and then move on to why I ended up giving them four. Although this place advertises as New York style, I would more accurately describe their pizza as a mix of New York and Neapolitan with even a little bit of standard American mixed in it. The pizza was definitely tasty but their Lahmucun was even better and definitely delivered on the "Turkish influence" aspect. Their desserts (which are generally not something you think about ordering at a pizza place but I ended up ordering a few because they were homemade and looked tasty) were also delicious. The reason I knocked off a star is because when it came to the pizzas themselves, I really expected a lot more delivery on the Turkish flavors especially for a place that advertised itself as being Turkish influenced. Besides the desserts and flatbreads, the menu was a pretty standard pizza menu with only a couple options having Turkish ingredients here and there. In fact, even taking out the Turkish aspect, the overall menu looked relatively basic and not super innovative compared to other pizzerias. Additionally, I live in Mountain View and for a place that's reasonably far to get five stars, it needs to worth the drive and unfortunately, I didn't necessarily feel that way about Mateo Pizza. I do have to add that while the staff is super friendly, they don't speak much English. I try to always order over the phone (to avoid third party fees for the restaurant) but you are probably better off ordering online with this place. As other people have mentioned, there is not much room to sit so this pizzeria is definitely more of a takeout spot. Overall, if I lived in the area, I would definitely consider Mateo Pizza as a great neighborhood pizza joint. read more

We tried this place for the first time and ordered the Meat Lover pizza, which features beef pepperoni, beef ham, and Turkish pastrami. While we loved the sound of the toppings, the execution fell a bit short. The pizza was on the greasier side, which seeped through the dough and left the bottom quite soggy. Aside from being rather salty, the overall flavor was lacking. On the bright side, the service was fantastic--the staff was incredibly friendly and even treated us to complimentary Turkish tea. Great hospitality, but the pizza itself could use some improvement. read more

Mateo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

Had the lahmacun and plain cheese pizza. Lahmacun was 5/5 and for $8-9 it is definitely worth getting if you try this place. The cheese pizza wasn't doing it for me. Lacking a good crust and flavor in the sauce. but I'll be trying another type when I have a chance. read more

Mateo Pizza - Lahmacun - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

Finally tried this Pizza shop after passing by at least 30 times. Was looking forward to it based on all the positive reviews but was disappointed by the quality of the dough and ingredients. Much less tasty compared to rainbow Pizza and amicis. Caesar Salad was unimpressive also. Pizza was ready quickly as promised but leftovers were not up to expectations. sorry! read more

Amazing little halal pizza spot. Staff are super friendly and hospitality is great! Food is always on point, have tried several flatbreads (Lahmacun, Soujuuk, Roast Beef, Spinach) and all have been super flavorful and perfect. Chicken wings are also a good side to pair with the flatbreads. read more

Mateo Pizza - Lahmacun ( 2 pieces ) - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

I ordered a medium half-and-half pizza for $28.99, and it was absolutely delicious. The olives on the veggie side were incredibly flavorful and fresh. The staff here are super welcoming and provided excellent service throughout our visit. The restaurant was pleasantly quiet during lunch hours, making it a perfect time to beat the crowd. Coming at this off-peak hour also made it much easier to find a parking spot nearby. Ending the meal with their heavenly dessert paired with a cup of hot tea was a truly divine, classic culinary treat. Coming at this off-peak afternoon hour is a total lifesaver for finding an stress free parking spot right away! read more

See all

Mateo Pizza was really good! Pizza came out hot and fresh, and the crust was on point. Super chill spot and the service was nice too. Definitely coming back. read more

Excellent service here and made us feel at home. Server suggested the popular pizza of ottoman and bergamo. Waited about 10-15 minutes for a medium pizza. While we were waiting, the server offered us Turkish tea. Came out very hot for the cool night. Pizza was freshly baked and had a very crispy and thin crust. Flavorful pizza. The bergamo was my favorite. The balsamic glaze gave it a nice sweetness to contrast the savory Turkish pastrami. The Stracclatella topped it off with a cheesy gooey texture. Offered us baklava for being first time customers. Perfect treat to end with as it was not too sweet. It had strong nuttiness and layered crisps. This spots opens late and has lots of regulars come in during the hour we stayed. Love the relationship the store maintains. Limited indoor and outdoor seating. Street parking in front of store. read more

See all

Where to find NY-Style Pizza with Turkish Twist in the Bay Area! .. and the best part: it's open late! @mateopizza__ is open until 2am everyday for those late night cravings. They also use halal meats and really put love and joy into the food they make. Here for the pizza, but don't skip the desserts! Service is super friendly and it's a small space but can definitely do a grab and go read more

Mateo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

Mateo's Pizza is in a great location in San Mateo, in a well-lit area and open late--perfect for a night out or a late bite. The pizza is absolutely delicious! I especially loved the pesto chicken pizza with Turkish pastrami, arugula, and pears--the flavors all worked amazingly well together. The pistachio dessert was flavorful but subtle, and the caramel tres leches dessert was very tasty. The owners clearly take pride in this place--the staff is welcoming, and the restaurant is clean. We highly recommend Mateo's Pizza! read more

Amazing Turkish pizzas! The lamacun was just so light and crispy! We also got a Turkish flatbread with pepperoni which was also delicious! I'd highly recommend this place. The people working there are also super nice! read more

Mateo Pizza - Lamacun - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

See all

Finally found the best lahmacun in the area at this cute, cozy spot in Redwood City. It's prepared and served the authentic way: with lemon, parsley, and thinly sliced onions (not piled with lettuce or random salad ingredients). The dough was perfectly crispy, and the topping-to-crust ratio was just right. Their pide and ayran were also absolutely delicious. Friendly service, great atmosphere. We'll definitely be back. read more

Mateo Pizza - Lahmacun - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

Pizza was amazing and so was the service! Best beef pepperoni pizza I've ever had. Highly recommend checking it out. read more

Came to Mateo Pizza and thoroughly enjoyed the experience. It looks like they mostly do to-go, but if you choose to eat in like us, there are a few tables set up so you can. We ordered 2 large pizzas all half and half such that we could maximize trying flavors. I personally liked the truffle mushroom pizza and the Turkish pastrami pizza best! Moreover, the pizza was tender and the cheese pull was strong! The owner was super kind too. As we wound down our meal, he also offered us Turkish tea which helped to cut the greasiness and also gave us a small plate of Turkish delights which allowed us a sweet bite to wrap up our meal. Now that's what I call service! Needless to say, my friends and I have now been recommending Mateo Pizza to our other friends too. I also want to come back to try the more traditional pide! read more

See all

The small pepperoni pizza was perfect just before a Costco run. Not bad for two people at least. Small space that was friendly, even offered us some Turkish tea as we left. Definitely want to come back when in the area. read more

I was looking for a quick bite late night and ordered a Lahmacun. Elias greeted me very warmly and explained the menu. The Lahmacun (which the menu describes as a kind of flatbread)was well seasoned and a little spicy - they suggested eating it rolled up. I regret not bringing home a pizza and look forward to trying more menu items. The hospitality was quite memorable, I'll definitely be back. read more

We Turks are very fond of Turkish flat bread (lahmacun). I've tried it at many places, but this is the first time I've had one in America that tastes this authentic. The dough was incredibly thin and crispy, and the filling was full of flavor. I can honestly say it was outstanding. At the same time, the service and hospitality were truly top-notch. I definitely recommend it. read more

Mateo Pizza - Turkish Flat bread - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

Came to Mateo Pizza after a long flight and pre-ordered a very tasty Beef Flatbread. I have tried Mateo Pizza at gatherings with friends and really enjoyed it so thought I would give it a try myself and order one of their specialty items. The flat bread was hot, ready, and very tasty. The beef was seasoned very nicely & the cheese was the perfect amount. I'm impressed by the overall quality & flavor. It's nice to have a really solid local pizza option with delicious Turkish flavors. Service was also really nice and kind! read more

Mateo Pizza absolutely blew us away. We ordered the Ottoman pizza and the pastrami flatbread, and both were unbelievably good. The meat was packed with flavor and cooked perfectly, and the dough incredibly delicious. Every bite was better than the last. Easily one of the best pizza spots in the Bay Area. I'm definitely coming back! read more

only been here twice but plan on coming by more often, place has a nice intimate vibe. staff offered their turkish tea and treated us like family which felt very heartwarming. also a perfect place to go to if you are craving pizza late night. read more

Mateo Pizza - Grand Mateo Pizza (M) - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

I'm writing this 0-star review as a loyal customer who used to order here often and even left a 5-star review just a few weeks ago. Unfortunately, the management showed the worst customer service I have ever experienced. I placed my order through DoorDash like always. Later, I received a call from the restaurant claiming I had already picked up my order, even though I clearly hadn't. When I denied it, the person on the phone (Elias) called me a liar, said they had it on camera, and then hung up on me. I was shocked, so I drove there myself to clear things up. When I confronted Elias in person and told him it was me who placed the order, he finally admitted he would make it. But at that point I was so angry, insulted, and disappointed that I refused to take the food and walked out. I have never seen such unprofessional, disrespectful behavior from a restaurant. After this experience, I will never order from here again. read more

See all

I walked away feeling quite negative about my experience. First of all, the prices of these pizzas are wild. But, I like to support local and the reviews were quite encouraging. I place my order for the Cappadocia pizza. They bring the pizza out to me, we open the box, and it's just a pepperoni pizza. I ask "where's the rest of it?" They take it back inside, throw a couple arugula leaves on it and *whole* pepperoncinis...not even sliced. They handed it to me and I looked at it stunned, but decided "this isn't worth fighting about at this point." See photo attached. The crust was very average, nothing special. For those prices and these reviews, I would expect much better. Won't be going back. read more

Mateo Pizza - Cappadocia Pizza (S) - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

The pizza was absolutely delicious, some of the best crust I've ever had - very fluffy! Nice indoor and outdoor seating. We sat outside, it was beautiful out. Service was excellent, the owner is very nice. Definitely recommend coming by! read more

Mateo Pizza - BBQ Chicken Delight (L) - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

This is the go-to pizza spot for our family, been coming here since we discovered it a year ago. We were introduced to lahmacun (Turkish pizza) here and we can't get enough. The food is amazing, our usual is the lahmacun and roast beef flatbread for our 3 year old. Food is absolutely delicious and super reasonably priced. Muhammad and his uncle are delightful hosts, my daughter loves watching Muhammad cook! We will definitely continue to frequent Mateo Pizza, highly recommended! read more

We are having pizza here for the first time. The pizza is hand made and delicious. If your visiting San Francisco give it a try. read more

Mateo Pizza - Hawaiian Pizza- pineapple and ham. - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

See all

Absolutely blown away with the quality of the Mediterranean flat bread (5/5 stars), it was thin, crispy, flavorful! We also got the ottoman pizza (2/5 stars) which was of a similar quality to a chain pizza (like Dominos and Papa John's). It had a thick, doughy, and bland crust, tons of cheese, and not much sauce. We'll be back again to try other flatbreads, but we'll be passing on the pizza, I think. Servers were kind and attentive, the space is tiny but new and clean. read more

Mateo Pizza - Ottoman Pizza (M) - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

See all

I ordered two Xlgs and one small pizza. It came to $110! There was hardly any sauce or toppings at all! What it cost for them to make this order to what they charged is unbelievable! Hey we all get ripped off from time to time but I will say as a food purchase that was the worst ever! I will NEVER go there again! PATHETIC! read more

Nice people, but mediocre pizza that is far too expensive for the quality - Taste was not impressive and the dough needs work. Sorry, but this would be a pass in the future. read more

Food, dessert, atmosphere is perfect, owner is nice and friendly. I highly recommend. If you try their pizza, you never try other pizza

Great New York style pizza with a Turkish twist from a charming family owned spot in San Mateo. We got a large pizza, half Ottoman and half Meat n' Veggie Combo. Very nice folks running this place. They gave us complimentary tea with our meal which was nice. Not a lot of seats in case you plan on coming with a group. Overall, I enjoyed the meal and would come back again. read more

Mateo Pizza - Large pizza with half Ottoman (left) and half Meat n' Veggie Conbo (right) - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

Place has gone downhill real bad. You're better off going to seniores that's halal meat and better quality. Absolutely disgusting place now read more

See all

I love the food here. Authentic Turkish food made with passion and love. Would recommend. Very nice people. read more

Mateo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

I tried the Bergamo pizza. This came with pomodoro sauce, mozzarella cheese, Turkish Pastrami, stracciatella cheese, balsamic glaze, and arugula. This is made with fresh cheese and the combination of flavors was really good. The dough could use a bit more flavor. I would have loved a pop of flavor in the crust but overall, the pizza seemed very unique. It had some arugula too and a little bit of balsamic glaze. It seems they have a good variety of sauces. It is made to order and they have a variety of pizzas that offer delicious Turkish flavors. The service was nice. I would definitely want to try their other flatbreads and the Ottoman pizza as that one seems quite popular. Great addition to the area! read more

Loved the lahmacun at Mateo Pizza. It came out fresh, thin, crispy around the edges, and full of flavor. I'll definitely come back for it again. read more

The service was great, very friendly and fast. We felt really welcome. The lahmacun was delicious, crispy and full of flavor. Definitely one of the best I've had. They also added desserts to the menu. We were too full to eat them there since we ate way too much, so we got one to go. They looked amazing and I can't wait to try it later. Great place overall with tasty food, nice people and a cozy vibe. read more

Mateo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

I called up. I got the owner on the phone.. He was very nice.. He was kind enough to actually deliver it to me!! Hands down. This is one of the best Pizza I have had in years!! Fresh crust and dough, delicious flavor... I will definitely continue to order their pizzas..Thanks Adam HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! read more

After hearing a lot about Mateo Pizza, I finally had a chance to try it myself. The staff were very friendly. They have a large pizza selections to choose from. We ordered a pizza half a kind and other half is a different kind and it was delicious. We tried their famous Turkish pizza called lahmacun. It was a big piece and delicious. Definitely a must try item. Oh don't forget to try their house special dessert! It is to die for! read more

See all

My first meal for 2025! No regrets! I have been wanting to try this Pizza place for months now and finally decided to make it my first meal this year. I ordered the Four Cheese Symphony. Every bite is just amazing. read more

Mateo Pizza - Four Cheese Symphony (S) - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California