Stopped in for a drink before dinner. Nice, clean venue. Friendly staff. A couple of TV's for sports. It's a good place to have a drink. We didn't try food so can't opine on that. read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

This place is convenient but very average. The staff is super nice and welcoming but the kitchen gets simple orders wrong and the food is below average. Good selection of beers. Edit I wrote this review and then tried my wife's Cesar salad and the chicken was incredibly dry and over cooked. 2 stars. You can't mess up a burger and salad that's the two most simple things to make. read more

Had a great time watching the Knicks game on Friday. Had a reservation for six people at 7:15, but they didn't mind when one person showed up a bit late (and with an extra person). Super large TVs everywhere in the dining area on the second floor, and the pub food (mozzarella sticks, fish and chips, and curry fries) were all good. The chocolate cake was a bit dry though. read more

See all

Great Irish pub with helpful staff, delicious and fresh food. The wings hold up to the hype on Irish wings. I love that the appetizer has Michale's sampler appetizer has soo many different dips and variety! The dumplings were perfectly fried, the mozerella sticks had a great pull, the wings were perfection! I ordered the steak frites, the steak was perfectly medium rare. I asked for a special mezcal cocktail and they followed all my instructions to a t. They made sure we sat in a comfortable both near the bar. Very clean and good lighting. read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Steak frites - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I tried this place for lunch with friends. This place is pretty busy but they sat us within ten minutes. I ordered sliders and wings, the wings were crispy which I love. The ambiance was great at lunch so I can only imagine how it must be for happy hour...I will be back. read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Wings - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We stopped by this Irish bar for a drink and a quick bite, and we were not disappointed! The atmosphere was lively, with plenty of TVs to watch the game--my husband was thrilled with that. We ordered nachos, which were delicious--loaded with cheese, chili and jalepenos. The Reuben was really good as well. The bartender was great, she brought us a side of very spicy mustard to try with the Reuben. It added a kick to the meal! read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Only in NYC can you walk into a bar on Halloween and find it fully decked out for Christmas McHale's Bar & Grill understood the assignment -- spooky season on the sidewalk, holiday season at the bar. Between the cozy lights, the over-the-top decorations, the warm cocktails, and the perfect comfort food (those fries and mozzarella sticks... unreal), it felt like stepping straight into a festive movie scene! Cheers to celebrating Halloween with a side of Christmas magic! The service was just the best as well!! read more

See all

Great spot near the theater! We had low expectations, finding extra time to kill before our show. We love a good Irish pub and this didn't disappoint. Excellent service, strong drinks and the shepherds pie was the best I've ever had. 10/10 read more

The scene if you want to watch all the games (and I mean, all the games at the same time) and get a stiff drink to match. I go basic when I'm at an Irish Pub and this one is an authentic one at that: welcoming bartender, relaxed vibes and heavy pour. My Tanqueray and Tonic ($11!!) was not measured, thank God! while I love my craft cocktails, sometimes when you're wrapping up your night, you just want something stiff before heading back to the hotel. (ahem, TWSS) The bros who frequent this space are all LOUD (hey, I'm over 40!) but they don't bother anyone. I mean, I would yell at the TV too if stupid named X player didn't score. Aren't they paying him millions!?! get it together. Come for the vibes and leave happy coz you didn't burn a hole in your wallet. See?! NYC is afforadble! read more

Great Reuben here. Trinity our server was an absolute delight and took care of us the whole time with a smile. We watched the NBA finals game here. Sat at a table and watched it ahead of us. A little far but oh well on short notice! Reuben kinda falls apart but the meat is great. The fries are insane to me. They were so tasty I ate them so fast. More!!!! Saw a celebrity here so that was cool! read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Reuben - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

Really great food and atmosphere. Servers are really on top of it and we never had an empty glass of beer or water. Fish and chips were really good and I would definitely order them again! read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Donegal Fish and Chips - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

We were in NYC for the week and noticed there was a USMNT game playing. After searching for a place to watch soccer nearby, we landed at McHales. Drinks were poured well, and the server was perfectly attentive. We ordered mozzarella sticks and french fries which were freshly fried and paired well with the Irish whisky :-D read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Tasty mozzarella sticks. - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped at McHales after visiting the tree! We made a reservation but didn't need it. We were welcomed and sat right away. Started with drinks (my husband's Smokey Palmona was excellent) and my daughter was demanding a hot dog- she ate the whole thing! The French onion soup was excellent and my husband's burger was cooked perfectly. My daughter devoured the cheesecake and the Bailey's coffee was the perfect ending! The bar was decorated beautifully for Christmas and the lighting was perfect. They turned a soccer game on towards the end of our visit and it was a bit too loud, but still a wonderful experience! Our server was friendly and attentive. read more

The outstanding thing was the service. Other than that, meh. The Rueben sounded like something others really enjoyed but bottom half was soggy, sauerkraut was mushy, and the meat was ok. Kinda disappointing. But again the service was super great and it was a warm friendly environment. Def don't bring kids because the regulars can really drop f bombs like it's their job lol read more

Our sever Rachel and the host Jesiah literally made our trip to New York. They each were proactive in their kindness and being thoughtful accommodating. When traveling to a big city I don't expect amazing service or to meet anyone so kind as I'm just another face in hundreds you must meet very day. These two broke the mold and made us feel welcome and were just simply the best humans. We'll be coming back here for future trips to NY and have made customers for life just by their kindness and general amazingness: read more

Not great. The soda was flat and the Philly Cheesesteak egg rolls were flavorless. My wife's Sheppards pie was the size of a child's portion but the Rueben was good. I have to keep in mind that it's the theater district so you get drawn into tourist traps from time to time and this is one of them. The server was nice enough and the place itself was clean and had a classic Irish Pub interior. It's NYC so I expected more. read more

We came here after a show and just had drinks. The interior has that wood the is reminiscent of an Irish Pub. The lighting is a bit bright for my taste as I like it a bit darker. I did like that the tables are not tight together and there is plenty of room to stand and not feel tightly squeezed. We ordered all of our drinks at the bar and it was no problem on a weeknight. The bartender was fast and friendly. There are lots of TVs, but not too many. The restrooms are clean and there is a dart board as well. This is a chill place and our group of 6 people had a great time here. read more

The flavors here have become part of my personal favorites. The workers provide dependable friendly service. Good meals created from quality ingredients. The menu costs less than competitors. This restaurant exceeds high expectations. read more

Whether you call it soccer or football, McHale's is arguably the best place in NYC to watch it. I've been making the occasional journey since last summer when I found out a favorite team of mine had a supporters club based here. There's a wide range of good options to choose from as far as food and drinks are concerned, and the staff are all great people. Definitely a place worth visiting, especially for soccer fans. read more

See all

We stopped in here on our way to the ball game because it's important to pre-game before actually gaming. Comfy vibe in this bar which does have food. Today, just sitting at the bar and drinking. Interesting group of barflies. Friendly bunch. Good service. A nice watering hole. [Review 15660 overall - 256 in New York - 1164 of 2021.] read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Sitting at the bar at McHale's Bar & Grill - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

See all

A fun place and great service. Stopped in here before a concert at the Music Hall. I think it could be worthy of a higher score but I was terribly disappointed with their fish & chips - supposedly a house specialty. Folks that had burgers liked them a lot! read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Fish & Chips - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I've been here several times. Friendly spot with good food. Also always have sports playing if you're looking for that. Nice atmosphere and staff. read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Homemade Bowl of Beef Chili - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

Finally got a chance to check out McHale's. First, great atmosphere and outdoor seating. Also excellent service. Staff was more than happy to accommodate my shih tzu Big Ern and even brought water for the little man. We ordered a few Guinesses which were perfectly poured and well temperatured. I ordered the F.O.S. which was meh. 5.7 on my F.O.S. scale. Came out a bit cold and needed more cheese. Be sure to check out @doctor_f.o.s on instagram for other F.O.S. Reviews. My wife ordered the grilled chicken wrap which was fresh and tasty. Side of fries was great, and their chipotle mayo was fire! Overall, great spot, good prices and awesome service. Will be back! read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - F.O.S. Review. Follow @doctor_f.o.s for more FOS reviews in nyc and elsewhere! - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

McHale's rocks. I love a classic Irish bar and grill. I stopped in on a beautiful Saturday morning at 10:00 A.M. for a quick drink and breakfast. Sitting at the bar, I ordered an "Irish" Breakfast Sandwich (scrambled egg, ham, sausage grilled onion on a brioche bun, $15.99 only available in the mornings) that came with fries and the Wicked Appletini (Absolut vodka, sour apple Schnapps, sour mix, garnished with a maraschino cherry, $15.00). Oh God, talk about a good fucking sandwich. There was an abundance of meats and onions mixed in with the egg and the brioche bun was yummy. The fries were salty, crispy and delicious. The Appletini really didn't do much as to giving me slight buzz but it was very good! read more

See all

Best beer, bar food and service I've had in the theatre district of NYC. We had an hour to spare before our Wicked show that was directly across the street, and wanted a quick bite and some drinks. Our waiter was super friendly and made sure we had enough time to make the show on time. If a burger, fries and bar food could be a 10, this is the place to get it. Great Irish pub and highly recommend! read more

Went there very late at night . Excellent food . St Patrick's Day . We ordered Irish Coffee , Fish & Chips and curry fries , Irish soda bread .All were very tasty . Loved the ambience .Friendly waiter. read more

See all

We stopped here on a Sunday afternoon mainly to get out of the cold and we were greeted with a friendly atmosphere and good service. Food was good. Served hot and quick. read more

McHale's is my go to place when I travel to NYC on business. I've always found the staff to be friendly and gracious and the food good, great beverages and a nice variety of options. I was in town with my wife on vacation and suggested McHale's for a date night as we wanted something informal and simple. We had a great time. Our waitress, Sadie, was amazing. She was friendly, attentive and helpful. Also a call out to Alberto for his great sense of humor and warmth. My wife had a quesadilla which was fine. I had the Shepherd's Pie which was really tasty and gave a taste of it to my wife and she loved it so much she nearly ordered another one for herself...but she was full so it will have to wait for our next visit. We'll be back next time in NYC! read more

A fun, festive Irish bar was just what we needed. They have outdoor seating with heat lamps under a tent and a few uncovered tables on the sidewalk. They have hand sanitizer and a QR code menu at every table. We got a baileys coffee which was warm, sweet, and delicious. We also got a spicy crispy chicken sandwich. I highly recommend this dish. It was truly crispy including the bread! There was a generous portion of chicken! And it was actually chicken meat not mystery meat. It wasn't too spicy but still well seasoned with a smoky flavor. And there was a lot of fries to complement the sandwich. read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Bailey's coffee - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We found this to be an awesome place! Food was good, the service was excellent and yet, it was still low-key. Great location, too! Molly, the bartender, was especially great! read more

Beautiful inside and out. I have a great love of original hard wood and stained glass. Just stunning!! This bar is a must do if you are near Times Square. read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Appletini. Birffffffday Drankssssss - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

McHales may be a pub but don't discount it for super delicious food. The Shepard's Pie probably ranks as my new #1 in Shepard's Pies. The sauce had such deep and developed flavors. I would have eaten every bite but the portion was huge. We had dinner here before a Broadway show, being in the heart of the Theater District it's a smart choice for a fun and appetizing meal. The server was super witty and had me try a beer that I would have never ordered and I loved it. read more

See all

I got the mixed greens salad with shrimp. Paid an extra $7 for 4 shrimp. Kind of insane. Not saying much about the rest of the salad because it was really simple, which is what I wanted and I'm fine with that, but, if you're going to charge $7 for shrimp... at least more than 4 pieces? If you want extra sauces, that's also a charge of 50 cents per each. I don't recall that being disclosed on the menu but my friends who ordered honey mustard and ranch were surprised. But guess that's what you get out of a Times Square pub. Our server was really nice and it appeared she was pulling double duty as the hostess for the second floor, so she would sometimes be away for some time. The restaurant wasn't busy (which is why we chose this place because we were hungry after a Broadway fitness walk and didn't want to wait) read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Mixed greens salad with shrimp - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped in on a Sunday evening with a friend after a show! The bar is decorated very nicely for the holidays. They have two floors with a bar on each floor and lots of TVs with sports on. We opted to sit upstairs which was about half full. Our waiter was very friendly and able to give us many recommendations on what we should order. I opted to try the beef stew since it is an Irish pub. For $18 the dish was small and underwhelming. I was expecting there to be some vegetables in the stew however there was only potatoes and beef. The beef was very tasty and tender however the entire dish was a tad salty. Overall, average pub in Midtown. You'll be paying Midtown prices here! read more

Delicious, and a little spooky McHale's did a nice job decorating for Halloween, and an excellent job with my McHale's Shepherd's Pie. We stopped in for dinner a couple of nights ago, attracted by the outdoor appearance. We were shown to a table upstairs, and settled in. Someone soon appeared to take drink orders. It had been quite a while since I have had a Shepherd's Pie, a dish of mostly ground beef gravy with peas and carrots, topped with mashed potatoes. My server recommended I top it with cheese, a recommendation I pass on to you. The food arrived in a reasonable amount of time. Nice presentation with the yellow cheese on top of my Shepherd's Pie. It was plenty of food. I don't think there was very much ground beef but lots of gravy, and I enjoyed it to the last bite. Service wasn't as sharp as it could have been, we were left alone well past when I emptied my soft drink. Getting our bill to pay dragged on as well. My food was fine, but if this review was written by my 7 yr old granddaughter, she would rate her food much lower. Her kid's chicken was so dry it was almost inedible, and at 16 bucks, I'm not happy about that. read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - McHale's Shepherd's Pie - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

I came here on St Patricks Day and it wasn't super crowded which was good but I liked that it was also festive. They even hired Irish dancers to do a performance which I thought was super cool and fun. I didn't like that the floor was sticky but that's to be expected at bars so can't complain too much about that. They had darts in the back though no one was playing. Bathrooms could also be cleaner. read more

Ruben was fantastic and was unable to finish everything. The service was excellent, and the environment was fantastic- classic pup vibe.

I live in New York City, and this the best bar ever! If you actually want to go to an authentic Irish pub, this is where you need to go! The bartenders are fantastic! Nothing fancy here, just good cold beer, and good cocktails, and good music! read more

Football season is in full swing and as are the Minnesota Gopher watch parties at McHale's. We moved downstairs to the back tv near the dart boards and the rest rooms. It's a nice cozy area for our modest Gopher group. Drink specials and food specials with Gopher themed menu items are also a nice touch, newly offered this year. I'm on a sour kick so get whatever sour beer is available and to eat either a personal pizza or the buffalo chicken dip. I've been known to finish that dip on my own on several occasions. It's delicious! Also cool bartender's name is Sarah. How could I have forgotten that? Thanks to McHale's for accommodating us! read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

Perfect drink spot and they are open on Sundays. Music is not to loud to enjoy your conversation and drinks are awesome. I had the most delicious coconut mojito! Birthday drinks with my guy!!! If you get the bartender name Chris, you're really going to enjoy your night!!! read more

McHale's Bar & Grill - Bar Booth. Bad lighting for photos but perfect for romantic night! - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York