Visited Meat &Potatoes on 1/17/18 my second time there. I ordered 2 hot dogs and fries, everything on the dogs except sport peppers. I love great Chicago Style dogs and have been looking for some exceptional dogs in the area had not found any that lived up to my picky standards until I had these at Meat & Potatoes. They were the best in McHenry well above any others I had. The only thing missing was the sesame seed buns. They were great. The fries were really good crisp not soggy and not over fried either. Recommend highly my first visit was I had the beef sandwich and frie and loved that also. Looking forward to going back again. read more

Great food, been there several times. Highly recommended. Can't go wrong with the Polish or the fried pickles

I ordered from here while on vacation and was not disappointed. The food was great my favorite was the pot roast over fries yum!! The service was also great and although I don't live out there and probably won't get to enjoy the food again, I'm sure my brother and his family will because they had never tried it before and they liked everything too. read more

This place was very clean very helpful wait staff food was good lots to choose from.I do recommend this place

Well I liked this place until today. I ordered the crazy caprese sandwich and when I received it instead of the balsamic vinaigrette dressing that was supposed to be on it there was a white dressing all over it. I brought it back up to the counter and when I told the snotty girl behind the counter she said " oh we don't put balsamic on anymore, we use a Greek sauce .huh? I said how long have you been doing this she said " oh a-month or so". Funny I was there two weeks ago and it was served with The balsamic. You put a Greek sauce on a Caprese sandwich ? .Any type of caprese is served with balsamic vinaigrette. And on their menu board, menu pamphlet and online it says it's served with the balsamic vinaigrette. I was given a replacement sandwich without any dressing, it sucked . Snotty girl every time I come in, replacement on a main ingredient without any notice .. I'll take a pass . Response from manager: new place .. ah no you've been there a while .. tweak a sandwich when it is clearly stated on the board, and on your menus it's balsamic on a caprese.. never anything else. Btw went to your other location and ordered the caprese and it was served with balsamic. So weak excuse ... read more

Nice place and very friendly staff with a smile which I liked. Some of the menu is "Pricey" so I just went with the gyro. It was delicious and had very little grease. The place wasn't busy but I felt I was sure standing around a long time waiting for a simple gyro to go. That and price will have me questioning if I want to come back. read more

We love this place and have enjoyed everything we've tried. The menu isn't typical choices, so I like the variety available. The meat and potato bowls are good. I also love chicken gyros. Nice addition to McHenry. read more

Went there with a larger group of ladies, they happily accommodated ten of us! We all were very excited to try something different, their menu sounded so yummy! We were not disappointed! I had the fish sandwich, also the fried mac n cheese bites, and to top it off, you have to try the cookie bites! I definitely enjoyed my visit and will be back! read more

We ordered a burger and fish hoagie. They have high tables, low tables, tv, wifi, it's clean, the food is good and the people are great! They also sell beer and have video slot machines if you're into that. We had an enjoyable date night, we will be back! read more

Yesterday was my first time here. Cute and clean place! The order for our party was... a grilled chicken sandwich, lentil soup, BLT sandwich and sweet potato fries (a generous thick-cut portion). Food was tasty and filling. The lady taking our order and the gentleman that delivered our food to the table were both very friendly and courteous. We arrived shortly before lunch...it was very quiet. by the time we got our food (10 minutes), the place was filled; however, it was not loud at all. Bathrooms were very clean and they have a small gaming room off to the left when you walk in (it's separated by cute saloon-type swinging doors). Definitely will be coming back again to try something different read more

Great food and great service, only issue is the daily specials should be post to Facebook. I work near and order often and have yet to have and issue. Thanks and keep it up! read more

We had 3 different meat and potato bowls...the country bowl, chili bowl and m&p bowl! What a great concept! They did have other choices like hot dogs, beefs, gyros. Yum! read more

Our first time here after passing by and being intrigued by what lay inside and on their menu. We'd go back if we wanted some good inexpensive comfort food. Pot roast on mashed potatoes (Country bowl) was tasty. My wife said her baked potato with the works could have been baked a bit longer, but appreciated the real, fresh bacon topping. Nicer on the inside than expected with 2 good size tvs to watch this afternoon's college football games. Very friendly counter service and quick food prep. read more

Really good! Traci had gyros I had the meatloaf. Good portions and very affordable. Definitely come back! Great menu too!

It had a wide and varied menu. Lots of food the money. You coould easily share an order of fries. Clean and inviting atmosphere. The food tasted really good, I can't wait to go back and try something else. read more

Clean, neat place. Had a beef with sweet peppers and cheese and it was excellent. My husband had the corned beef. Also very good. Ice cream sundaes to top it off! Definitely would go back. Could do without the type of music playing. Not very relaxing. Perhaps some 60s music would be fun. I would recommend this place though. read more

Great burgers, so juicy! Meatloaf sandwich was awesome with grilled onions on a pretzel roll. Yum!

Just found out about this place today and went for lunch. Had the Pot Roast dinner. It's the best pot roast I ever had with 2 scoops of mashed potatoes and some mixed veges. EXCELLENT tasting dish. My wife (who is very picky about her food) loved her fresh seasonal salad. I can't wait to return. The only disappointment is they serve everything on plastic....it just seems so cheap and it's so bad for the Earth. It also limits who I would bring to this establishment since it makes the whole place. If you're going to serve amazing food, put it on a nice ceramic plate and give me some decent silverware. read more

Went there twice 1st time burger and was not impressed. Secomd timevgreek chivken and mestloaf not worth the price.

We have been here 4 times, the first two times we got bowls that were good and an appetizer that was way over cooked both times. Third time we did without an appetizer and the bowls were ok. Wanted to give it one more shot and had bowls again, I got the loaded bowl and the burger was so over cooked it was charred and crispy. We will not be going back again. read more

The food is good; it arrived at the table hot and fresh. But, I was shell shocked when she told me the price was $25.96 for 2 small drinks, two potato wedges (there were not that many wedges in the basket) and two 6" Italian beef sandwiches (not as full as other places). This is not a higher end restaurant that meets that type of pricing. Portillo's, Fratello's, Tommy's, Hickory Pit, Panino's in Richmond, are only a little over $18.00 for the same thing. I will not go back - due to the prices; when I can get the same things for cheaper in the same area. (I am not affiliated with any of the restaurants that I mentioned) read more

Ordered my food over the phone during my lunch time which I only get a half hour for. I drove over got my food and ate it. All in a half hours time. When I got there, they had my food ready to go. It was really . No waste of time. And the food was good. I had the fish hoagie which was very big, very delicious and worth the price. read more

Your going to love this place. Come by yourself, or bring a large group. Their Italian Beef and chicken gyro are fantastic. Great service!

Amazing idea and place. If you walked in you would think there was 30 of these joints because of how well designed and clean the look is. So I had this daily special chicken club, can safely say it's in top 2 chicken sandwiches I've ever eaten. Definitely should be a menu item and not just a special! You must stop in here and give them a try! read more

Customer service here stinks! Make sure you ask them if they have made any changes to there menu before you order and where there deliver ranges end at. You would be think with a name like "Meat & Potato Eatery" that all there dishes would be served with Potatoes like the menu says...... not the case!!! I stated I wanted to he roasted chicken and potatoe wedges dinner and got chicken & rice instead. No one told there menu had changed until I noticed I had rice. Then the young lady acted like I should have none that when I asked her where my wedges were.....Sorry can't read minds young lady!!! Food was good but because of the poor customer service I will not be returning to eat there!! read more

I had ordered a gyro and fries for lunch I had it delivered and when it got here (10 minutes away) the fries were cold. The gyro was very small and it was also cold. I thought i would give it a try because it is so close. But I was very disappointed. For the price I would have expected a much better product. read more