Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Michael's Pizza

    3.2 (42 reviews)
    ModeratePizza
    Closed 10:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Michael's Pizza Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Michael's Pizza

    Recommended Reviews - Michael's Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    cars parked in front of a restaurant
    Tyler C.

    Thin crust pizza a step above 7-11. Nice size slices, but at 4 pm it had been out for a while and was dry. They have to go, but no menu they could share. When they did get one I was told to ignore the prices as the menu was old. Lunch specials looked good.

    Thought this was really cool. Lots of places ban students. This place has deals for them. Good show.
    Jude T.

    This is a pretty normal hole in the wall pizza place. However, their slices are huge! Their cheese steaks are extra cheesy, and the service is far above par! I had a chicken cheese steak and some cheese fries (very crispy!). The sub was filling and the fries were definitely cheesy. The guy at the counter was super nice to my whole party. I'd come back here if the occasion presented itself. As an aside: They also have specials/deals for local high school students after school. Lots of places ban students these days, but Michael's invites them right in with discounts. As someone who works with teens as part of my job, this is greatly appreciated...a lot of them feel like they can't go anywhere anymore.

    a menu and a pinball game

    See all

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Michael's Pizza

    Review Highlights - Michael's Pizza

    They are such a support to Hereford, Parkton, and White Hall and the surrounding areas.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 3,315 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Woodfire Kitchen - Margarita pizza...and a create your own! Yum

    Woodfire Kitchen

    4.4(205 reviews)
    0.4 mi
    $$

    We found this place last fall. We live in Cockeysville and bike along the NCR. I love this cozy…read morefriendly restaurant with great food and service and frequent it at least once a week. We have NEVER had a bad meal. The pizza is wonderful. They have a gluten free option. The portions are generous. I particularly like their apple and fig salad. They have great wings with a generous portion. My friend likes their fresh tuna salad and bowl. Again generous serving size. Very diverse menu options to satisfy everyone. This is a local gem It should be supported by the community. The owner is very philanthropic. He supports local charities churches NCR etc by donating 20 percent of collections for that day for people who come in and mention the name of the charity. Who does that every week on Tuesday and Wednesday throughout the year? Please support this restaurant!

    Stumbled across this charming restaurant when I was looking for a lunch spot for me and my child!…read moreWhat an adorable little restaurant. The staff were incredibly friendly and accommodating. Needed some guidance on what to order and my server suggested the grilled chicken Caesar wrap. It was delicious and fresh! My child ordered the pizza. It was so cool watching them put it in their brick oven! I had to sneak a bite of his pizza since they are known for pizza. Did not disappoint! The crust and sauce were extremely fresh and light! Had more cheese than I like. But my child was loving it!!! When we come back, I'll probably order the margarita pizza since that is more my speed of cheese, sauce and crust ratio! If you want to sit indoors there are plenty of table and if you'd like to sit outdoors there is an adorable patio with umbrellas! You can tell this is a beautiful family owned restaurant with plenty of stories and character. The interior looks like a barn which my server later told me it was and got renovated to the restaurant we see today. They've been open for about nine years. The best word to describe this restaurant is charming. I loved it. It is located off a main road so I would advise being careful with parking. I was unaware that there is a parking lot in the back of the house next to the restaurant! Google maps didn't show me that so I was slightly concerned when I pulled up but found the big lot quickly.

    Photos
    Woodfire Kitchen
    Woodfire Kitchen - Hot wings, traditional, with ranch. Very well sauced and cooked properly.

    Hot wings, traditional, with ranch. Very well sauced and cooked properly.

    Woodfire Kitchen

    See all

    Bruno’s Pizza

    Bruno’s Pizza

    4.4(52 reviews)
    7.7 mi

    This is hand down the best Pizza around!! Everything about the pizza is perfect down to the last…read morebite!

    Did we even eat at the same Bruno's everyone else is raving about? I should've taken a photo of our…read morefood before writing this, because I honestly don't know how anyone could defend what we were served. We ordered two 16" pizzas--the Parmigiana Chicken and the Napoli--plus 14 wings. The wings were laughably small and wildly overpriced, but that doesn't even scratch the surface of how bad this experience was. I was excited to try this place. The reviews were glowing, the photos looked incredible, and we chose Bruno's specifically to celebrate New Year's Eve with my partner. What a mistake. Both pizzas were completely ruined. Burnt, tough, dry, and utterly flavorless. They looked nothing like the pictures in the reviews--almost no sauce, overcooked to the point of being inedible, and closer to stale cheesy cardboard than pizza. If this is "authentic," then authenticity has a serious problem. For a moment, we genuinely wondered if we had been given someone else's order or sent food from the wrong restaurant. But no--this was Bruno's. The same Bruno's people are apparently losing their minds over. What's most insulting is that someone saw these pizzas, knew they were overcooked, and sent them out anyway. Charging full price for food this bad feels deceptive at best. When you compare what we received to the photos other reviewers have posted, it honestly feels like a bait-and-switch. Never again. I'll happily drive to Pasta Mista in Towson from now on--the only place around here that seems to understand what pizza is actually supposed to be.

    Photos
    Bruno’s Pizza - Waiting for the best!

    Waiting for the best!

    Bruno’s Pizza - Eggplant Parmigiana pizza

    Eggplant Parmigiana pizza

    Bruno’s Pizza - Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

    See all

    Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

    Casa Mia's Restaurant and Pioneer Pub

    Casa Mia's Restaurant and Pioneer Pub

    3.3(198 reviews)
    1.0 mi
    $$

    Yesterday, we had a fantastic experience at Casa Mia's Restaurant, thanks to the exceptional…read morehospitality by Leah and Alisa (I am not sure how she spells it, hoping I got close to getting it right). We were a huge group and we made our reservation for outside before we realized how sweltering hot it was- and the team pivoted with exceptional grace and thoughtfulness. We are tremendously grateful and will be sure to come back again soon!

    Went to Casa Mia's Restaurant to celebrate my daughter's and my birthdays in September. On a Friday…read morenight and my wife forgot to make reservations. Oops! When we arrived there were cars parked on the side of York Road, maybe 20-25 of them. Ouch! We were lucky to grab a parking spot as someone left. My daughter went in to check on how long the wait was - and they found a table for the four of us. Needless to say it was busy... and loud with live music almost deafening. We were brought menus and waters. My wife, a friend, and youngest daughter had joined the birthday team. Three of the four girls had not tasted "real" Maryland crab cakes before, so we ordered one as an appetizer. After a bit it came and was divided for each to try. They loved it! So the four girls each ordered the Crab Cake meal and I had my eye on the Prime Rib, on weekend menu. After a wait, the meals came. The Crab Cakes came with side salads or fries. My Prime Rib came with Loaded Baked Potato and Asparagus, with horseradish on the side. The Crab Cakes were great! All the girls loved them. My Prime Rib was a different story. It was tough, many tendon(?) strings through it all that were very difficult to cut through. Now a little fat is great for flavor, but this Prime Rib was half see pic) gristle & fat. And there was no flavor to meat that was there. What I could eat, I had to salt & pepper to get any taste. Absolutely the worst Prime Rib I have ever been served. And of course we had to have dessert to celebrate the birthdays. We ordered an chocolate peanut butter pie and It was an excellent. The music was too loud to have conversations and tables having conversations talked loudly over the music, which made it even noisier! So if you love Maryland Crab Cakes, no place does it better. But stick with what they are famous for, otherwise take your chances. And if you want conversations, don't come on weekend evenings.

    Photos
    Casa Mia's Restaurant and Pioneer Pub - Inside

    Inside

    Casa Mia's Restaurant and Pioneer Pub - Mixed grill.

    Mixed grill.

    Casa Mia's Restaurant and Pioneer Pub - Inside

    See all

    Inside

    Underground Pizza - The Vegan Chicken Parm with pesto

    Underground Pizza

    4.4(586 reviews)
    21.0 miDowntown
    $$

    Yumm this was such a good find for Detroit style pizza. I ordered online and picked it up, a…read moreseamless process. No hate to the location but the parking situation was a little rough. I was hoping to park on the street to run in but ended up driving around for 10+ minutes before ending up in the lot. Turns out my parking was free so it worked out just fine. For the food, I got the cheese pizza with prosciutto and the mango habanero wings. The pizza was fantastic, and I really liked that you can order a half portion which was great for 2 people. The crust was crispy, and the cheese and sauce were great, and it was packed with prosciutto. The wings were also great, I loved the sauce and the sesame seeds on some of them which was a fun twist.

    First time dining in but not the first time eating here! I enjoy their pizza. The UPC Classic is…read moreyour classic cheese pizza and it was so good! You can tell a good "pie" restaurant, in my opinion, by how good or bad their standard cheese pizza is lol. I also ordered the mango habanero wings which were decent, I feel like it was missing some more habanero or something. I'm sorry but Wing Stop has the best Mango Habanero wings to me! We sat at the bar and our bartender was good. He was friendly and helpful. The place gives me a dive type vibe but I like the atmosphere.

    Photos
    Underground Pizza - Even Woody knows, Wu Tang Is Forever!

    Even Woody knows, Wu Tang Is Forever!

    Underground Pizza - Chicken Wings buffalo

    Chicken Wings buffalo

    Underground Pizza - Cranberry holiday drink

    See all

    Cranberry holiday drink

    Michael's Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...