Let me preface this review by saying that my review is based on being a foodie from NYC with access to every type of cuisine, so my expectations are high when I see an establishment with a nearly 5 star average. To ME, this is not a 4 or 5 star establishment at all. I appreciated the eastethic of the place...it was relaxed but a lot of the diners were dressed nicely. However, why did the hostess have on a hoodie?! This is very strange considering (for the area) this is what they consider a higher end restaraunt. I absolutely hated sitting outside! People will talk about NYC being ghetto....Our table was literally right next to the waiting area. This guy almost hit me because he was that close to our table. smh but we are in times where establishments want to make money on every inch of available space. Take that into consideration if there is only seating outside, which may not be a biggie for others. The food: the bang bang shrimp was VERY heavy on the mayo and the shrimp weren't as crispy. We didn't finish it. I ordered the scallops and they were good but I wasn't a fan of the risotto and didn't taste truffle oil on top. My aunt ordered one of the fish dishes and her fish was overcooked. lol At that point I was feeling gaslit by the reviews because my expectations were wayyyy too high for this place! Service: Our waiter was very nice but he literally came over THREE times to get the bill. There is a tactful way to do this (look from a distance and wait for the customer to clearly be ready and book closed). It was the one turn-off regarding his service that night. Maybe we needed to order other dishes, maybe our expectations are too high for an area like this but we weren't blown away by this dining experience. read more

I utilized yelp to come across this place for a girls dinner and it delivered in droves. I shared the special "crispy skin red snapper" and it was absolutely delicious. Not huge portions, but that's ok. My friend had a wedge and their blue cheese is quite possibly some of the best blue cheese ever. I know it's dramatic to say that but it was that good. To drink I had a vodka martini with the blue cheese stuffed olives and it was crispy and delicious. The server was great and plenty of gluten free options for me to eat. It's a random shopping center but adorable inside. Definitely recommend. read more

This might be my new spot in Rehoboth Beach. Staff were nice, friendly and accommodating. The food was excellent. Pricing was reasonable. Very nice eclectic ambiance. Can't wait to go back! Highly recommend! read more

Not so great the service is as rude and the food was average. We had will no longer dine there. Use to be good idk what happened.

Very good, flavorful food. Crowded, but with good service. Nice dinner spot. Parking is available and free.

Appetizers you can have as a meal on their own. The firecracker shrimp, calamari and salad are great. Food that is prepared with as much love as how it is presented. The day boat scallops, chicken malonaus and salmon entrees are delicious. The banana cheesecake is yummy. You are always guaranteed an excellent meal and the wait and bar staff are absolutely wonderful. This is a finely tuned dining experience and a must when you come to the beach. read more

The owner is very nasty she did not treat us with respect she will pick the sitting table and we had ask her nicely we wanted a different table because was a leak in the ceiling and she gave us a hard time, read more

Make reservations. This is a popular place and well deserved. Service was wonderful and so was the food. The atmosphere is cozy and they have real candles on the table! read more

What a cute cozy place- The service is very friendly!! The short ribs are delicious and the attention to details on their drinks -I loved the Sangria. We will be back!!!!? read more

I have to say been coming here for years...and it's consistent. Tonight's was my Birthday Dinner and it delivered. I had my Makers Mark Manhattan to start, olives and bread, Caesar salad, Tuna Poke....all delivered....Great wine with the Papillion, an Orin Swift selection. Entree, filet special with fingerlings and mushrooms, horse crusted salmon, chicken Milanese and seared scallops..All Delicious...Thank You Michy's and Mark our server...All Excellent...Dessert we chose a peach and blueberry cobbler with vanilla ice cream....we wanted 2 of them but we could online get one, sold out early...bummer....Great establishment and top notch. read more

See all

We had never heard of this place and showed up without a reservation but they found a spot for us 2. I had the bolognese and wife had the salmon. The bolognese was well seasoned and the noodles al dente which was just perfect. The salmon was done to perfection and my wife loved the sauce it was basted in. The bar drinks were perfect too. We will definitely will be back when we get back to Rehoboth! read more

One of the best restaurants we've tried on the East Coast! We sat at the bar and really enjoyed the delicious food recommendations and hospitality. We are definitely coming back on our next trip to Rehoboth. read more

Michy's Relaxed Dining - American Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

See all

My husband and I had the best dinner we've had in Rehobeth! We rolled up without a reservation around 6pm and the first table available was on the patio. So book a reservation if you can. If we had a table inside, we would have given the 5 stars. It was a little chilly this evening. My wedge salad was so fresh! The beef tenderloin was tasty and broccoli is well seasoned. The French baguette was crusty on the outside and soft and warm. The chicken Milanese was crispy topped with a fresh arugula and mozzarella salad. Dessert was a winner too! My husband didn't leave a morsel of cheese cake. And Jess is just the best server! read more

Excellent meal here last night. We didn't have reservations, but were lucky enough to secure the very last unreserved table on the porch. The service was excellent and the food was delicious. We both chose items from the regular menu... the short ribs, and the horseradish crusted salmon. Both were fantastic!!! Skip the downtown crowds and expensive parking and have a great meal here. read more

Michy's Relaxed Dining - From the regular menu: horseradish crusted salmon - American Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

See all

Our table of 4 sat on the heated patio. Our server was fantastic and helpful with her knowledge of the menu. Don't be deceived by the outside appearance. Loved the scallops, short rib, tuna and pear salad. Great drinks and overall terrific spot. read more

Wonderful delicious food! The servers were fabulous. The ambiance not so good. When considering this restaurant eat outside unless you don't care about screaming at anyone to hear you. We were there last night and this group of people were so obnoxious and loud it was over bearing. Again food delicious served in a timely manner and servers wonderful... ambiance terrible. read more

The food was fresh. The baguette was hot homemade, delicious, and hot. My husband thought the tenderloin was tender and flavorful. read more

Michy's Relaxed Dining - Tenderloin sitting on mash potatoes - American Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

Michy's is a wonderful dining experience. The food is creative and the vibe is welcoming. The servers are fun and knowledgable.

At the edge of a strip mall on Route 1, you will find one of the top dining destinations in the Rehoboth area. Michy's sports an artsy funky vibe and is packed with locals enjoying a fun night out. I like to start with one of the fabulous craft cocktails and the flavorful dish of warm olives. The firecracker shrimp is also outstanding. I typically enjoy one of the seafood options, with my top go to choice award, the scallops. On a recent visit, the other half enjoyed the spectacular beef bolognese. Do call for reservations! read more

Michy's Relaxed Dining - Day boat scallops, risotto with mushrooms, truffle, parm, parsley - American Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

Logistics - Parking is ample, easy ingress /egress from the main drag The Food - I've been coming to DE for several years now and this is, hands down, the BEST food I've had. The short ribs dissolve under the fork's touch, the horseradish crusted salmon, fuggetaboutit. The Atmosphere - heavy on relaxing and the chill vibe. The Service - attentive and welcoming. The downside - their limited hours. Reservations are a must. read more

Service was helpful and professional. Food was special and superbly prepared. All in all, one of the best meals and experiences in Rehoboth. We will be regulars. read more

The food was fabulous and our server was the best! I would definitely recommend Michys. Try one of their amazing cocktails - you won't regret it!! read more

Excellent service once past the person that tried to greet us. Great selection, drinks were great appetizers and entrees were delicious and our waitress was excellent. A fun place to have great drinks and some creative delicious meals. The service was professional and excellent. read more

food was OK but expected better. biggest issue was learning at check out that several other customers bills had been mistakenly charged to my credit card. waiter gave me a copy of mistaken receipts and suggested I moniter my credit account. WHAT!!!!!! Fortunately, 24 hours later only one erroneous bill had been applied to our account. So far. Meanwhile, we weren't offered as much as a free cup of copy! Great experience? Hell no!!!!! read more

Excellent dinner at Michys. Wedge salad was amazing. Dayboat scallops were cooked perfectly, but the accompanying mushroom pea risotto, while cooked perfectly, was a shade on the salty side. Also, the inside tables were pretty close together -- I could hear the conversations at adjoining tables perfectly throughout my meal. Next time (and there will be a next time), I'd choose patio seating. read more

Michy's Relaxed Dining - Wedge salad - American Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

See all

Without a doubt, one of the best restaurants I have ever been to! I have been dozens of times so this review is very overdue. I live in Washington DC and Michy's is above and beyond my favorite restaurant, better than any restaurant in DC (and we have some excellent ones!). If you are looking for delicious, unpretentious food and drinks, look no further. My go-to entree is the Horseradish Crusted Salmon--I'm not even a big horseradish person but WOW it is amazing every time. My family loves entrees such as the short ribs, bolognese, and chicken milanese. Even the poke, which I don't usually eat unless I'm actually in Hawaii, is fantastic. "Simple" dishes like Caesar salad and beet salad are also DELICIOUS! I always take guests who are visiting from out of town and everyone is blown away by how amazing everything is. I am also very picky about cocktails and hate paying $15 for a cocktail that is meh--but that is never the case at Michy's! Their speciality cocktails are consistently amazing and whenever I have ordered other cocktails from the bar (gimlet, for example), they've been excellent. The ambiance is very nice and they did a great job updating the patio during Covid to allow for more seating/outdoor dining. It looks like some people have complained that they felt rushed here--in my experience I have never felt rushed. But if you are the type to really linger for hours at the table, book a later reservation so there is no one coming behind you (they seem to generally do an early seating and a later seating, like 5/5:30 and 7/7:30). I eat here every time I'm in a Rehoboth and whenever I try somewhere different, I always just wish I came to Michy's! Don't miss this place when you're in Rehoboth! read more

Love the Hawaiian Poke great Staff excellent atmosphere and Food Surprisingly flavorful for your Taste buds read more

See all

I like the food and service. Now I'm just writing more to hit the 85 word minimum. I need to type a bit more...and end.

Service was great. Food was delish. The scallops were the best I've ever tasted!!! Party of 6 & all of us left very happy!

Very pleasant experience. Food was delicious, atmosphere was relaxed , service was attentive . Kicking myself for not coming sooner! Now I know . I will notify my peeps to this hidden gem. We will keep it hopping for another 10 years read more

Food is great atmosphere a bit noisy because it's small Drinks are extremely expensive 2 drinks could be more expensive than the meal Service was timely and pleasant read more

Wonderful, attentive service, well prepared, fresh food and a good wine list. The warm olives started off the evening. The fish special was generous and beautifully seasoned. We wrapped up with gelato and decaf. Definitely worth the price. The only short fall was the beer list. Nothing interesting, reminiscent of the eighties (think blue moon and Michelob). read more

This restaurant came so highly recommended, hence, my decision to take my family there for a special occasion, albeit with great disappointment. First, this place is not cheap. Bring plenty of cash. That being said, I can not express my disappointment in the staff. Especially the manager who decided it was ok to approach one my guest when she didn't like my comments regarding being overcharged for a drink that was undrinkable. Had I heard the comment, I would have made a scene. Lucky for them. The worst of which was when prior to being seated, I personally informed the waitress that we were celebrating two birthdays. The waitress did nothing to acknowledge this celebration. Not a candle, a happy birthday wish. Nothing!! After receiving a $402 bill, I thought to myself how sad, that we had to end the evening without the recognition of the two birthdays. I can not tell you how upset this made me. So, these people get two black eyes. One for not caring, the other for approaching my guest with their off color comments. To end this, I will never patronize this place ever again. Good luck to you all. read more

Food is really good... However, the place is very small and it gets extremely crowded so I wouldn't exactly say it's relaxed... It seems to me they should take reservations only read more

Always get your reservation in order if you are interested in eating at Michy's. The food is always fresh and tasty. The staff is professional. The ambiance is relaxing. Highly recommend! read more

Very disappointing... I've been to Michelin star restaurants that offer more. Paying for water and no bread; odd. Ordered the short ribs which was a portion of.beef which was tender but flavor.level of Sunday pot roast at a diner. Vegetables were raw; could not peirce with a fork. Rigatoni bolanaise was missing tomatoes in the sauce and very salty. Yuck. Thought to try to violet margarita...had zero taste, definitely not violet and then the rim was old bay. Completely ruined it; violet and old.bay, what were they thinking. Tables had vases with plastic flowers from the dollar store as well as.the planters on the new patio. Will not.go back. read more

Great restaurant, wonderful people and great food. One of my favorites. Richard is an amazing chef wonderful flavors and everything is so fresh. read more

The food is fabulous and the atmosphere is relaxed. The staff are fantastic. Love it there!

Another wonderful night at Michy's. We didn't have reservations but went in a whim and we're able to snag bar seats, score ! The service with our 2 bartenders was amazing- typical at this creative local spot. We started with an appetizer of firecracker shrimp, always delicious, then moved into a few specials for dinner. My date had the pan roasted beef tenderloin with fingerling potatoes, sun dried tomatoes, fresh basil, local asparagus and blue cheese butter. It was amazing- he almost licked the plate. I had the swordfish special, with fresh corn, smoked bacon, red pepper, potato hash, basil and lime. Every time I try a new seafood dish at Michy's it is the best thing I've ever eaten. Beyond amazing. We had a few cocktails to go with our dinner and enjoyed great conversation with our bar mates. We ended our evening with a homemade ice cream sandwich- dark chocolate chip mint. Another hit. We don't go to Michy's frequently- but it is one of the absolutely best restaurants in Sussex County Delaware. The creative menu and absolutely fresh local ingredients combined with personable and professional service never disappoints. You really must have reservations if you want to be sure you can get in- you will be very happy you went. read more

See all

We tried Michy's tonight for the first time and it was not good. Was it just a bad night? We have heard such great things. We live locally and have somehow just not gone here. The shrimp appetizer was soaked in mayonnaise. My halibut special was almost inedible - so much salt and pepper that I could barely choke it down. I didn't send it back only because I had flown in today and was STARVING. My husband had the chicken Milanese and it was very dry and tasteless. But the worst of it was we had a 7:30 reservation and they told us to come early because they thought they could get us in at 6:30. We waited until 7:50 for our table. When we asked why they told us to come early they seemed surprised and asked who said that because our reservation was for 7:45. It wasn't. I don't think we will ever come back. Is it always this weird or was it just an off night? read more