My 2nd time eating here and it couldn't have been any better Chicken parm is excellent soups are delicious and the waiter gave me the shirt off his back .. true story Can't wait to get there soon read more

Great service from an amazing team. This is a great place to meet and eat, as the food is Delicious!!!! read more

Mr. Nick's Brick Oven Pizza - Cousin get together - Pizza Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

I asked for a replacement pizza because it was excessively salty. Instead of addressing the issue professionally, the employee threw my credit card back at me. I found the interaction disrespectful and unacceptable. I have contacted management and documented the incident. I hope they address how customers are treated. read more

I asked for a replacement pizza because it was excessively salty. Instead of addressing the issue professionally, the employee threw my credit card back at me. I found the interaction disrespectful and unacceptable. I have contacted management and documented the incident. I hope they address how customers are treated. read more

I love this restaurant!! Owner is very friendly & can't do enough for us! We get together with my cousins at least 2x a year & we all enjoy the food & atmosphere. Their brick oven pizza is amazing! Would definitely recommend Mr Nicks. read more

I recently ordered 5 pies for 13 hungry tweens. The pies were embarrassingly small and the girls polished them off very quickly. The size of the pies have shrunk a bit so I can no longer recommend ordering pies here when trying to feed a large group. sadly i did not take any photos. the girls devoured the pizza before I could get any photos. read more

See all

While in Tarrytown, we search for the best pizza by the slice and up comes Mr.Nick's so off we go. On street parking was easy on a Sunday night. The restaurant is bright, clean, and honestly, beautiful. You walk in and there is a small seating area in the front by the windows, the counter where you can select your slices, a full on bar and table seating in the back. Service was fantastic - quick and efficient. We had 5 slices in total for $25. The slices were huge and of great quality. My favorite was the spinach with ricotta, parm and mozzarella and the tomato and basil. My husband enjoyed the 4 cheese and 2 chicken based ones. We were very satisfied! read more

ordered food today from Mr Nick's and and was especially pleased with the portion size and quality. Eggplant parm and lasagna pizza...yum! We all raved - how delicious everything was! Try it! read more

The service here is disgusting and unprofessional. It even gives off a little racist vibe. I will never come here again. The service, food, and workers at this establishment are all disgusting. You wouldn't want people with such negative energy and a disgusting demeanor preparing your food. read more

Exceptional service and delicious food make this one of my top Italian restaurants in the Westchester area. The food is consistently crafted with fresh ingredients. The ambiance is elegant yet cozy. The bar features a stunning white marble-like granite surface, creating a perfect spot to relax and enjoy a drink or two. read more

Mr. Nick's Brick Oven Pizza - Tuscan eggplant panini - Pizza Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

PSA - Only a takeout review. Did not sit down to eat. Staff is always friendly. Love Nick and his son Avi, they're fantastic. Look, is it the best slice of pizza ever? No. It is solid, although a tad pricey. Expert advice -- order the "Mimosa" slice. If you live close by, not a bad place to order from. Overall: 3.5/5 read more

Nice, quick service. Good amount of seating. Excellent selection of different slices with a full Italian menu available as well. Thin crust pizza (which I like in general) was ok; the most flavorful slice I had was the Buffalo chicken-slightly spicy and tangy. Regular slice and grandma slice were ok; I think I should have had something with more sauce-or asked for a side of it. Casual, busy, walk-in atmosphere. read more

See all

Mr Nicks is the best! You wont find better pizza in the area. Amazing chicken parm. The owners are great people.

Had a great experience here. We walked in very late at night but they were happy and eager to serve us, which surprised me in a small town. The service was great. The food was also excellent. I got a pizza which was fresh and hot out of the oven. My wife really liked her seafood dish as well. Very nice back dining area, casual but upscale. Great spot, will be back! read more

Love this place, lasagna is great, very good dining vibe in the back...it's a real italian restaurant, the best in Tarrytown

We have ordered delivery 2 times. Great pizza (Mimosa and Grandma)! Great chicken parm's. Arugula salad is excellent as well - love the balsamic dressing. And delivery is quick and friendly. read more

Mr. Nick's serves Good food, including the Crispy crust pizza. Good entrees, Great salads, dependable prompt delivery.

Excellent,friendly, accommodating service. Food was very, very good, and prices extremely reasonable. We live in Tarrytown and will be sure to dine there again. The ambiance was good, although a little noisy. read more

The pizza was excellent. everyone in our family loved it. the service was very friendly and helpful. I wish it was closer so we could go more often! read more

Wanted to try it out but when you come from nyc your pizza expectations are high, pizza was very dry and lacked flavor. Not only that guy at register with the silly looking mustache was rude. I definitely won't be coming back and wouldn't recommend wasting your money here. read more

We got takeout from here. Food was absolutely delicious. Even better was the service. Nick was superfriendly on the phone. There was a small mixup with the order. He insisted we keep the part of our order that was wrongly delivered to us and hustled the food we ordered over to us. He apologized and the delivery driver refused a tip. You don't get friendly service like this everywhere. We'll be ordering from here the next time we're in Tarrytown. read more

We stopped here for lunch after I came from Rhode Island and my family came from Delaware so we met in the middle. I just randomly selected this from Yelp. I was not impressed I have to say. Being in New York you want really good pizza and this wasn't it. They had a lot of varieties that you could choose from that were pease and would be heated and served so maybe I just chose the wrong one but I got the grandmother and the grandfather and they just weren't great. My cousin ordered the calamari which was terrible. It was big and tasted like paper and was not even hot. The subs looked OK. We went up to the counter to order and they did bring it to our table. When it was time to leave and I paid for lunch they tried to convince me that a 20% tip would be appropriate. I didn't really think so. read more

See all

The new restaurant is so delicious, and the service is very friendly and attentive. The lasagna is tasty, hot, and fresh. The Mediterranean salad is awesome- especially the dressing! I have eaten here a couple of times since the new restaurant opened and have had great experiences. Check it out! read more

Mr.Nick's is the best place for a slice or pie of pizza in Tarrytown. Their different flavors are exceptional with my favorites being chicken, bacon, ranch, and white pizza but some honorable mentions that I know that my friends like are caesar salad, buffalo chicken, mimosa (Margherita without tomato), penne, and plain cheese. I have both sat inside and often order delivery from Mr.Nicks. The restaurant itself has a good amount of seating with quick service and very nice workers. Delivery also is always seamless and the pizza and food travels well. Aside from the pizza Mr.Nick's has the best chicken tenders and fries combo around Tarrytown and their honey mustard dipping sauce is also one of my favorites of all time. I also believe that they have the best mozzarella sticks around Tarrytown being perfectly breaded, crispy and amazing cheese pull. read more

See all

It's not often that an excellent neighborhood slice and pie joint grows into a fabulous Italian restaurant but Mr. Nicks pulled this mighty feat off. The pies are still outstanding but the rest of the menu shines brightly. Don't miss the eggplant rolletini app or my fav, the grandma pie. read more

Sat down for a quiet Tuesday dinner and I have to say it was the best restaurant experience I've had in a long time. Both the service and the food were impeccable. Had the Chicken Marsala and Veal Parm... both fantastic. Our sever and the bartender were beyond nice and helpful. Absolutely made our night! Would highly recommend for any occasion! Cannot wait to come back in the future. read more

Mr. Nick's Brick Oven Pizza - Chicken Marsala - Pizza Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

We stopped by for some pizza on our way to church. It was the perfect snack. Pizza was hot and crispy. The service was excellent. Restaurant was very clean and neat. Nice decor. The staff were very nice. I like how the restaurant has the option for full service restaurant in the back and quick slices of pizza in the front. Nice local small business. I hope you do well. read more

THE food was amazin and the customer service was so pleasant and they made you feel like home, I had the chicken parm and. slice of pepperoni pizza and they were perfect the marinera sauce on the chicken parm was perfect and the chicken was juicy and fluffy and the breading on the chicken cutlet was filled with rich flavor, and the pepperoni pizza was made with love the perfect combination of a light layer of sauce and a crispy but also fluffy layer of cheese and the crust was crunchy but soft in the middle and to top it off i had the tiramisu it had to be TOP 2 pizzarias i have eaten at, overall i give it a 9.5/10 and the place was soo calming with the soft relaxin music. read more

Just got back home after a 5 hour drive from upstate and all I could think about was Nick's Brick Oven Pizza. Right in my backyard and the BEST pizza and prices. I also buy their pizza dough to make my sausage bread for the holidays. The friendliest owner and staff ever. Always a great experience. read more

Little known secret, Mr. Nick's Brick Oven Pizza in Tarrytown has been our favorite down-county pizza spot for years. We never posted about it because it was a place for us to escape during crazy times. Selfishly, we wanted to keep it ours. Nick has since transformed our favorite down-county pizza spot into the most amazing Italian restaurant (still serving awesome pizza). We spent Christmas Eve there tonight with Nick and his beautiful family. I can keep it secret no more -- the ambiance is beyond beautiful, the food is fantastic, the drinks devine, and the service is top notch. When you're there you're treated like family. For all my Westchester and Rockland friends and beyond, this is the place you need to try! read more

See all

After a long time away, we returned to New York and a priority was to renew our acquaintance with the best pizza anywhere. Mr. Nick's did not disappoint. Lovely atmosphere and extremely attentive service. Next time we'll try the menu entrees. Strongly recommend as a place for excellent food and friendly service. read more

We came to Sleepy Hollow for a little day trip away from the city this Sunday. We wanted to get a quick bite to eat so we could continue to explore the area, and stumbled upon this restaurant. We saw a couple of reviews that said that the service was quick which was what we wanted. As soon as we came in they were eager to sit us down quickly... the last time that the service was quick here. We waited for 20 minutes to get water to our table (as seen in the picture we ended up reaching for our own bottles). But we got it sometimes when its busy things get a little behind schedule, but this should have been our sign to leave. Finally someone came to take our order. While ordering we found that many of the entrees were not available so we settled for vodka pastas, salmon, fettuchini carbonara, a minestrone (only two people ordered this), and a chicken parmigiana. They assured us that the soups would get to the table first and then the mains. Again, understandable -in theory. We waited 35 minutes to recieve the soups and some bread (no butter even though other tables had butter). The soup was the the best dish served, which gave us false hope that the entrees could be as good. After the soup was taken we asked for more bread and waited for the entrees. We waited for an hour. It was not that the kitchen had an issue or anything since we saw plates leave and be delivered to tables, some which arrived after us. At that point I raised my hand and a young waitress came, I asked her politely where our food (and bread) was as we had been waiting for an our and other tables got their food. She interrupted me and said your food is coming but those tables got here before you... which was a lie to all five of us. From that point they said it's coming in five more minutes which turned to 30 minutes. At this point it had been an two hours since we arrived to the restaurant and no food (or bread) in sight. We were planning to pay our soup and leave when the food finally got here. It was the most mediocre italian food I have ever had, for such a long wait I would expect home made pasta and sauce which it all tasted like it came from a packaging. You could taste the vodka in the vodka pasta and not creamy; the fetucchini carbonara was so greasy and goopy it sat like pourrige that with each bite that you took the oil would stick to the roof of your mouth; the salmon was dry and served with boiled spinach; lastly, the chicken parmesan was soggy soily and the sauce still tasted like the can, it was served with boiled veggies which was still served with burnt garlic. Mediocre would be an understatement. Since by then we were mad they gave us "free" dessert, which was also mediocre. All for a whooping $150. By then we had lost about 3 hours of our trip and went straight home since everything was closed. Also the bread from after the minestrone never arrived. Would absolutely NOT recommend! read more

See all

Solid pizzeria in Tarrytown, had never been through the area before. I'm used to Long Island and NYC pizza - the sicilian here was pretty good. Crust could have been a little crispier and the sauce a little more flavorful- but all in all it was a reasonable pie. read more

Mr. Nick's Brick Oven Pizza - Sicilian pie, 1/2 pepperoni/green peppers 1/2 cheese - Pizza Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

I've just started eating pizza again cause lactiaid changes their formula and now it works. We came here and got a Sicilian pie, which I think we just ordered wrong. The pizza-pizza arguably looked legit and I think we'll have to go back and give that Ok. Not bad pizza in any sense, just I didn't send my brother a photo of the pie and thats usually my gauge. The also had a many many different types of slices if thats your thing. read more

Pizza was excellent would recommend this pizza place enjoyed the atmosphere and staff very good Will be back when we revisit area read more

Let me just start with there are not many times (if at all) I am truly impressed by an establishment. I will also add that this is my first ever positive yelp review! This was a result of excellent food, wait staff, ownership and overall atmosphere. The complete overhaul of the restaurant has been nothing short of amazing! Fresh ingredients, fresh food and exquisite service! I do not remember the last time I have cleared a dish, and let me tell you what...it was well worth it. I cannot wait to return and dine here again! Thank you to all at Mr.Nicks Brick Oven Pizza for an amazing dinner service! read more

Stopped in here for a rainy day lunch and the pizza was SO GOOD! We got the Grandmas (square pizza with fresh basil, marinara, and olive oil on top) and another one I can't remember, maybe the Summer pie? It had roasted peppers, fresh tomatoes, basil, and fresh mozzarella on it. They were both so incredible and the worker helping us was so nice! I would definitely come back here if we visited again! 10/10 would recommend to anyone wanting good pizza in the area. read more

We've been going to Mr. Nick's for years. Excellent Brick Oven Pizza! If you live in the area they deliver right to your door and are very friendly. They have an all new look to their restaurant. Super fancy! read more

Outstanding! The Chicken Scarparillo was just like my Momma use to make the Pizza's are delious! The wait staff and ambiance is sheer profection! Been dining here for years, and still love to enjoy a great dinner night out! read more

First time at this restaurant and it was busy on a Saturday night. It was too warm inside which I noticed right away. Little did I know... Order Chicken Scarpariello as I have in at least a dozen other Italian restaurants over many years. As it was served it didn't look right. The chicken appeared to be grilled and was dry and tough to cut with just a butter knife. The taste was awful and that was my last bite of chicken. I ate the penne pasta though I had ordered the spaghetti. Will never return to this restaurant. There are so many far superior Italian restaurants where I will continue to dine. Also ordered the clams appetizer. The waitress said it was very good. It was very bad and very fishy tasting. First impressions are important in all facets of life. Mr Nick's left a bad taste in my mouth. Literally. Don't waste your money here!! read more