Service and food is always fabulous…read more High tops are perfect for up to 4 Drinks, small plate and that beet salad is great

This was a disappointing and embarrassing dinner. We took out-of-town family here for a graduation…read moredinner and it was bad all around. Service: everything took very long. Our waitress was great but she was working the entire side of the restaurant where we were sitting. This was especially pronounced because one of my guests couldn't leave late. Food: subpar. We were here a few times a few years ago and I remember it being much better. The wings were good, especially the sauce. The sticky ribs were too salty and the ribs, while tender, tasted dry and overcooked. The pastas we ordered were overcooked and soft. The beef bulgolgi wasn't great. It was ok. Overall, a disappointment. Price is high for quality of food. Ambience: I remember this place being more lively and full. This time, on a Friday night, at dinner time, it was half empty. Other: trauma alert- read at your own risk. Once read, it cannot be unread!! When my daughter opened her napkin with the utensils, a spider jumped out at her and she was screaming! It took a while to get another set of napkins and utensils but when we finally did, I had to open the napkin for her because she was afraid to open it....

Excellent and delicious choices of pizza. Staff was friendly & hospitable…read more We shared a few slices. The grandmas was excellent, the chicken and vodka was good, and we shared a Carmela salad which was fresh & simple yet great. We also took home a chicken bacon ranch and a veggie slice to try and, they were good. Crust is nice on all the pizza!

For a mom n pop pizzeria, Carmela's sure is one of the best NY style pizzas that I've had. We…read moreordered a large size cheese pizza, along with some garlic knots/bread. The pizza came out hot n ready from the oven. The cheese was just stretching away and the sauce was robust. The dough itself tasted very good. We sprinkled some red crush peppers and garlic seasoning/powder. Mmmmm more and more garlic. And more garlic. And wait....even more garlic. The garlic knots were delicious. They were heated warm And I asked them to lace it with extra garlic oil. A perfect combination of both items. There's a few tables inside and it's a simple looking pizzeria. They do offer pizza by the slices also.

Been to this pizza place a few times with my girlfriend and the service is amazing and the food is…read moreexcellent... Please try

Amazing! And more Amazing every time I eat there! Another must go to whenever I visit NJ…read more So much on the menu! Service with a smile. The ambience On any given day there are more than 10 different pizzas on display to choose from! One more different and delicious from the next! Try the inside out pizza! Similar to the Bklyn L&B pizza but better (more sauce and sesame crust!) Also I had the Terminator sandwich so good almost forgot to stop and take a picture!!!

Never fail.... Garlic knots, grilled chicken anything, plain, mushroom, pepperoni, SPO, pizza,…read moreShaun's favorite, vodka anything, chicken parm, salads, empanadas, Stromboli, French fries, been eating here for 30 years, love it as much now as I did then. I moved 50 minutes away but anytime I come "home" I never miss my chance to eat here.

This was some really good pizza, like really good pizza. Perfect crisp, with a great amount of…read morecheese to sauce ratio. Nice old school feel to the shop, brought me back to HS. They also have ZEPPOLES which was an awesome surprise. They were light, fluffy and fresh. Pretty decent customer service as well. Will def return next time I'm in the area.

The Doughfather had a smaller spot, but it has since moved to a larger place with a sit-down…read morerestaurant that's truly romantic, classic and special. The inside has the typical takeout pizza counter for quick, casual dining. The sit down experience you need to be or should dress up. Perfect for a family gathering, or a date with your special one. The owner and the staff know are profesional, they're funny and engaging. *The food quality: they only put the best ingredients- and you can rate it *alfredi pasta is incredible.. just amazing *the calzone is ridiculously huge -- My favorite experience was when i ordered a calzone with a ridiculous amount of pineapple and i love pineapple on pizza too

A friend and I grabbed some lunch at The Doughfather and overall, it was good. They offer indoor…read moredining near their pizza counter if you are just there to grab a couple of slices, but also have a separate dining room for the full restaurant service. I had a Stillwell slice and buffalo chicken slice, both of which were fresh and tasty. The buffalo chicken slice however was not spicy at all, so I'd consider getting a side of buffalo to dip/drizzle to add a kick. I also had their in house orange soda which was very good! My friend had a Sicilian slice, grandma slice, and root beer, all of which he enjoyed. We also grabbed 3 plain slices to go and the total was a little over $40, which was a little higher than expected. They have a large variety of slices which is enough to draw me in for another try. See you soon!

We dinedat Brothers a couple of times now so I think I can confidently say it's one of best pizza/…read moreItalian restaurants in the EB area. The bread is consistently great. The pastas are tasty too - we've had the chicken alfredo fettuccine a couple of times now. The broccoli rabe with sausage is also good. The sausage is a tad salty but tastes good and in a home made kind of way. The penne and the broccoli rabe were perfect. Pizzas here are also pretty good though we've only ordered by the slice. I'm sure a cooked to order pie would be even better. Prices are reasonable too and service is friendly.

Really friendly! Great pizza and even better customer service! Brought my daughter in, after we had…read moreour pizza and when we went to pay...she pointed and asked what is that (zeppole) I told her... the worker that was at the counter heard the conversation and gave her one for free... I think it's the little things like that... that make you want to come back and it made her day... so thank you for being kind! We will definitely be coming back... Side note... when you walk in, you get that like old fashion pizza smell and it's just amazing and a nice calm place to just sit in and enjoy your pizza

Not good. Pizza was gross and staff were rude. Go to Brothers or Villa Borghese. Brothers is the…read morebest

Moved to spotswood recently from NY, wanted to try pizza places in the area. First time here and…read morethere was hair in my food. Also staff was rude. Will never go back.

they're very nice but they are all over the place - the place is a mess - not welcoming at all when…read moreyou walk in - they're unorganized and maybe italian isn't their forte, maybe stick to what you know? the food wasn't very good - went to give them business after reading reviews similar to mine but with a but the food is great, but it's not, the pizza is not good either. i hope they find their way bc they're very nice

I went hiking yesterday with the Staten Island Hiking meetup group yesterday. It was a beautiful…read moreday and we certainly had an interesting hike. Lost the trail on the way back and had to bushwack out way through 1.5 miles off trail. After 6.5 miles we were back at the parking lot. Tired and hungry we found Montes. Very good pizza, excellent crust, thin and crispy with a good amount of cheese. The granny squares looked so good and the girls said the were excellent. One of our hikers got a salad with grilled chicken. The chicken was done perfectly! Juicy on top of a huge salad! Looked so fresh and greens were crisp. He shared and took some home. Neighboring table had spaghetti with garlic and oil which smelled devine and a huge portion. Prices were not crazy but low to moderate. Very clean too, wooden tables were spotless. I didn't taste the other food therefore I gave 4 stars. If I'm out that way again I will definitely stop for lunch or dinner.