New York Pizza & Pints - 4900EldoradoPkwyMckinney At the risk of being cliché, i've had a lot of pizza in my 52 years on this planet, a lot of good and a lot of bad. But what I haven't had is exceptional pizza.,...... until now that is. To say this pizza truly has no equal would be an understatement. You name it?...the crust alone, it seems to be airy and light and dense all at the same time, with an aftertaste that beckons you to continue to masticate and digest as much as you can, because you don't want that savory blessing to go back to heaven. And now the toppings, the fresh unadulterated toppings... that merge with the cheese like two identical twins that were separated at birth, and after 30 years, they find each other, and embrace, and that one embrace seemed to make up for the last 30 years they've been separated. If this pizza could speak, it would lovingly tell you, "I'm here, and it's okay, I understand, I'm here for you and only you". I think this pizza enjoyed me as much as i enjoyed it. read more

I have been searching for authentic pizza in McKinney for years. This place is it! The toppings are fresh and the crust is delicious.

Very good service and hit the spot when it comes to New York Pizza! It was our first time stopping in and we will definitely be back

We uber'ed pizza from here and boy were we shocked by the size AND pleasantly surprised with taste of their pizza! It was definitely good and worth repeats! The way they packaged our entire order was evident that they care about the service they provide. We haven't dined in yet but that's definitely on food bucket list! :) Anyway, we had the pizza (24"), hummus (super yum!), pepperoni sliders & garlic knots. All were yummee-licious!!!! Hope you get a chance to order! :) read more

New York Pizza and Pints - 24" pizza - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

ZERO STARS!!! Whoa!!!! Big issues. New ownership... BIG PROBLEMS!!! Straight up lied to me!!! Bc they screwed up my order, she told me I SCREWED IT UP.... , me the one who ORDERED THE 14"pizza and got a 24"????? She even said she clarified the size...NOPE....She hadn't and she med not try to clarify, I've been here more times than I can count. I am more than familiar with the Piezilla, and the large (the only other size) LAST TIME!!!! Why do you think it's a piezilla... it's in the name...(godZILLA). Get it... huge, not large!!!!! I know what a piezilla is and NOT THE ORDER I PLACED! Just the fact that the chick lied is reason enough. If you're looking for the generous, kind people that use to own it... they're long gone leaving behind dishonest, unruly people. Even the piezilla was wrong. They got nothing right! Crust is horrible. Sauce not close to the same.... Never go back. read more

Great service, and a bargain at twice the price! Definitely a noteworthy establishment! read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Pep, mushroom and black olive - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

We order frequently and typically through Uber Eats and this was the case for tonight. Normally - we love the extra large pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms Tonight the pizza was sub par with no sauce on the pizza. We added extra cheese but got literally no pizza / tomato sauce and limited ingredients quantity overall. Wow - prices are high and obviously impacting end quality. This was just disappointing. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

Christina and the staff were so sweet. The pizza was amazing definitely a 10/10. I recommend the Buffalo pizza!!!!

Several issues: My wife arrived when it was supposed to be ready and they told her they don't have our order and she had the wrong location. She showed our order receipt from online and then a few minutes later they said it's still cooking. Clearly they forgot about the order because it took an extra 20 minutes from that point. One of the 3 pizzas was totally burnt. The pictures don't look as bad as it was in person and it tasted bad. Caesar salad came with some pink 1000 island dressing instead of Caesar. Most unacceptable part is there's no answer after 20 minutes of calling to figure out their mistake. Won't try again read more

See all

I ordered a supreme slice and a pepperoni slice. Just look at this foolishness! It's actually 2 stale pepperoni slices from the day before with supreme toppings thrown on top of one! Ridiculous! Trashed both slices. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Trash pizza - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

I called and placed a order at 2:29 and the lady on the phone told me I will receive my pizza at 3:00 it is now 4:00 and still haven't received my pizza. I called back and asked for my money back and she had a attitude on the phone so I will not be calling this place for some pizza. I waited a long time super hungry and still no pizza. read more

HORRIBLE. Angel was terrible. Asked what drinks we ordered 4 times (Corona with Salt and Michelob), gave us the wrong drink still, couldn't figure out how to pour the beer (tried to give us a beer that was more than half foam), couldn't figure out how to get salt on the rim, went against their policy of allowing tasters for beer, was SUPER rude and unapologetic, overcharged for our pizza (rang it up wrong to charge extra), was going to charge extra for ranch (which we've NEVER been charged for), and NEVER apologized. Unless the awesome Hispanic guys are there, DO NOT GO. read more

Genuinely one of the worst pizza's I've ever eaten, crust is bland & extremely thin with no taste, the sauce is just tomato no seasoning to give it flavor either, cheese and pepporoni are just that(can't mess that up at least), to call this "New York pizza" is a disgrace as a New Yorker the owner of this business clearly thinks any larger than average slice is a "New York pizza" but this is the farthest thing, I'd honestly rather a frozen pizza from Walmart before ever eating this again, to make matters worse I got garlic knots.... Save the money. They are just rolled up bread. No garlic no flavor, the marinara side is again just pure tomato sauce this is honestly the worst pizza I've had out here read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

Ordered a large pie it was made to order and fresh. The staff is always nice and the food is always hot. They take their time. The restaurant is always clean. read more

Needed pizzas - checked the website and said it was open. Ordered pizzas. CREDIT CARD CHARGED. Showed up and they were closed. Will take my business elsewhere and have the credit card company figure it out. read more

It is with great sadness that I have to do this review... New York Pizza & Pints has struck out!! Since my 1st review, we have visited this establishment 3 more times. And each time we anticipated the same quality and consistency from the 1st visit... And we were sadly disappointed and now, after the 3rd strike... New York Pizza & Pints is Out of the Lineup!! The service was good but it inconsistency and lack of flavor and quality of the ingredients on the pizza was disappointing, and lacking. I'm only giving 1 star because I had to. I give this a 0 star rating and 4 thumbs down read more

Love this location for our pick up pizza orders. I always grab a pint of Velvet Hammer to enjoy while waiting on my order. The pizza is made fresh and the slices are large. We also love the cheese bread. Service is friendly and ambiance is casual and a place where you can hang, watch tv or grab a to go order that won't disappoint. read more

See all

Took order online. Charged card. Drive up place is closed will open next week. Why accept online order and charge? No pizza. no money. Lots of aggravation read more

Now, I am no pizza expert! But I enjoyed this no red sauce pizza. I find pizza hard to enjoy w/o the red sauce. Not the case here. I absolutely loathe the usual pellet sausage so I was happy to see a pie with prosciutto and proper sliced sausage. They are tossing these crusts in the air, I enjoyed the chewy texture. The side of marinara was generous and delicious. On a side note, their croutons were sturdy crunchy & flavorful, I usually just push them to the side but these were very good. Salad was basic but fresh. Great for beer drinkers. Small eat in area, big carry out business. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Manhattan Pizza added Italian Sausage, 1/2 House Salad - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

Came here while I was in McKinney from out of town, and wanted some pizza by the slice! The reviews were a little lower than I usually go for, but the pizza looked like what I wanted! Lol. I got the "Chefy's Special" which is a 1/2 salad, a cheese or pepperoni slice, and drink for $8.99. The salad was definitely WAYYYY bigger than any "half" salad I've ever seen. It was a full plate! The pizza was great, perfect amount of toppings, and cooked perfectly! read more

New York Pizza and Pints - 1/2 House Salad - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

I ordered pizza for delivery tonight from the McKinney location. Pizza arrived dry and shriveled like it had sat around for hours. Amount of cheese was ridiculous even though I ordered and PAID FOR extra cheese. Incredibly disappointing. read more

This was a no good, horrible experience. Waited well over the quoted wait time for a 14" pizza and "salad". The pizza given wasnt mine so I brought it back in and was quoted a 10 minute wait time for a replacement. After an additional 15 minutes, pizza wasn't even in the oven. I just asked for my money back and left. Instead of a full refund, I only got money back for the pizza and came home to this "salad" that is only vegetables in a bowl. I looked at the romaine in further detail and saw this poor quality lettuce. Did not feel safe feeding it to my family so I tossed it out. The servers were working hard but unhelpful. Again, they were trying but it looked like there was no management or experienced team member to lead service in a timely manner as other customers were frustrated as well. Will stay far away from this place next time. They also kept the tip I gave them, which I feel is a smidge tacky. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

I just ordered from here. Now I'm from Jersey, worked May years in New York. This is not! Ny pizza! I could have gone to Walmart and picked up a frozen Barons and that's what this tastes like. Called Angel, he's the manager. Told him this was not good pizza, garlic knots, and cheese bread. They literally meant cheese bread. I've never gotten anything like this in all my life in NY. You are giving the east coast a bad name with this. Angel didn't care. I don't want a refund. I want you to take my feed back and get better. Cavalli makes way better pizza. Actually, I should have ordered paper John's. This is not NY pizza. Angel said you have 5 locations. This is the first I've heard of this place so I gave it a shot. I will throw this $35 worth of Uber eats garbage in the trash and order something else. Please folks understand, this is not east coast pizza. This is garbage! Thanks. read more

See all

The flavor is always good, but this pizza is way too expensive for me to bring it home and find this. The broken off crust shows me they knew it was burnt. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

This pizza is amazing however service is slow. Waited 1 hour for 3 slices of pizza. I would call ahead/order online before coming. Seems like they prioritize to go orders over coming in to order. read more

Compared to all other times we've ordered from here, pizza was just fair tonight. It wasn't warm when it arrived, but some of that could be chalked up to the chilly temps. Giant pizzas are usually cut into eight slices, but tonight they were only six, making the slices even harder to manage than usual. Even folded, because that's how you have to do it, they were huge. Biggest issue tonight was the crust consistency. Usually it's got a bit of a crisp to it, which is the closest we've found to real NY pizza. Tonight, it was very doughy, almost spongey and undercooked. Not particularly easy to eat with a gummy consistency and not particularly impressive. The flavor of the one we got with lamb, onion, and mushroom was rather bland. The lamb was so thinly sliced, it barely had any flavor. Next time, we'll just stick with the cheese and hope the crust is better than it was tonight. read more

See all

Not NY authentic style pizza. Service was okay. Very disappointed. It might be okay for those that have never had NY Pizza. Don't let the name deceive you! Slices are way too big and we're not good at all. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

Hubby and I stumbled upon this place based on distance and Yelp reviews. We originally ordered the 24" pepperoni, and were amazed! The quality of this pizza is unbelievable - crust edges are crispy, slices perfectly foldable (if you're a folder) and the toppings were generous. We ate the entire thing in the span of a weekend. Fast forward to today - doctor's appointment in the area, stopped at Kroger for curbside groceries and BAM! Wait - this is that place - it's RIGHT HERE! So, I called when my groceries were being loaded and went with the 24" cheese pizza, with extra cheese and extra sauce. Bout 10 minutes (literally) later, BOOM this pizza is in my car and on the way home! On our first visit, we tried the meatball mozzarella sandwich and didn't like it - meatballs were dry and I'm not sure what the bread was - maybe pizza dough? We also got the NYC Panini which was tasty but likely not worth VTS (valuable tummy space) in favor of stuffing in more pizza! Today the place was empty (I'd love to go here, drink a few beers (of their many choices) and have some 'za with friends....I'm still in the 'pickup/drive thru only' camp because hubby and I are moving to Europe as soon as they open the borders up, so we're not taking ANY chances. The place seemed spotless, the staff was cleaning while I was there and the food handling looked to be regulation-worthy. If you have a chance, check this place out - I think they have multiple locations, but we've only gotten from here, but if this is any indication, they're all amazing! read more

New York Pizza and Pints - One slice of 24" pizza with xtra cheese and xtra sauce - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

This neighborhood pizza place is outstanding. We just started ordering from them, and they are our favorite. We particularly like the chicken Alfredo pizza. Give it a try! read more

We placed an order for delivery on grub hub and to our surprise the pizza was huge!! We ordered the large 24" pepperoni pizza and a regular chicken parmesan pizza Both were great and wow the size of that 24" was huge with big slices. Taste was good sauce was good not heavy like some other pizza places. crust was very good thin with nice edge crust. My only problem was the pizza arrived cold . But honestly I can't b mad we live far from this place but was definitely worth a try and glad I didn't have to drive in the rain with the kids. So delivery was very convenient. So I'd definitely try this place in person and would get this pizza again. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - 24" and regular size there's a big difference - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

The piezilla is the way to go. Wondering why if everything is bigger in Texas why there aren't any other options in sizes of pizza? Delicious in every bite. Enough for the whole family. read more

Great neighborhood gem. We love the pizza and this is our go-to for large and small orders. We love to drive there to order our take out, so we can sit and enjoy a beer on draft while waiting on the order. It's the closest thing to NY style pizza in the area. read more

Yum! The perfect NY fold...Better than I expected. Super-friendly staff. Dough is perfect. Sauce is awesome! Perfect balance with the cheese and pepperoni. Nice late night snack. Great find! Happy stomach! The Cuban Sandwich was really good too! read more

Great place for hand tossed pizza. This is the closest to the pizza we ate in New York City! It's soooo good. Great tasting pies, beers on tap, friendly, helpful staff. I'm a vegetarian and I love the Queens pizza. My husband and kids usually get a gigantic Pizzazilla! Try these folks soon, you will have a new favorite pizza place. read more

Wasn't amazing but wasn't horrible. I loved the quickness and cheapness of the place. I feel like the sauce isn't zesty enough for pizza in my opinion...it just taste like sauce. Kind of bland, & the pepperonis were kinda of thin and literally tasted like a pepperoni brand that I use from the grocery store. Wasn't super impressed. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

They do a very good vegetarian pizza, healthy servings of vegetables, very good, always consistent quality.

Small and quaint but super yummy and i felt at home. we got the chicken and park pizza it was bussin. read more

Pizza is decent but the staff has gotten my order wrong more than once then will argue with you instead of trying to fix your order. Walked out of their the past two times I've ordered without food. Pretty bummed cause the service used to not be this bad. Don't order a large because they'll give you a 24" despite the menu calling that a giant. you'll leave with no food or spend $30 on their mess up after they argue with you. read more

Okay here it is. This Italian girl is eating crow. Actually this girl just had a few bites of her husband's as usual Slicezilla. Good, I mean REALLY good! This is one of those *face palm* oh man look what I've been missing out on. I did what I usually don't do is not go back a 2nd time to make sure I just hit them on an off pizza pie. I am 99.7% sure that's the case. I'd go % but I'm anything if not honest when it comes to my opinion which is just that. Regardless of those few bites which btw didn't sit well with my husband I am sorry I didn't get a true NY slice of cheese pizza. But in not getting that I would have missed out on the Gyro. I'm not sure what Doner means but I was pleasantly surprised by what was in front of me. I am convinced these guys only do big. I opened up the container which is one of those round foil containers, the big one and there in front of me is this Gyro on steroids. Come on guy's I don't have room in my fridge for my lunch for the next two days. I told my husband I'd only be able to eat a 1/4 of it but I lied. I ate half of one of the halves. I couldn't stop eating it. The only thing I wish they had was a tzatziki sauce or something saucy. I used some ranch & it actually tasted pretty good. So there it is. I've never been more happy to admit I was wrong. read more

So I went here and they had no pizza which sucked. I did get a calzone which was good. I guess I would go back if they actually had pizza lol but other than that I guess we shall see read more