New York Pizza Photos
Business Info
New York Pizza Popular Dishes
You might also consider
More like New York Pizza
Recommended Reviews - New York Pizza
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Pizza was good, wings were good. Nice people, friendly service, local joint, would come again.
I was craving pizza and decided to try something new and decided upon this pizza place. They have a pretty big and extensive menu with some interesting signature pizzas. Since it was my first time trying it, I got a half gyro, half chicken pesto pizza. The pizza looked really good immediately after opening the box. They did not skimp on any of the toppings and it was hot and fresh. The pizza tasted great but it was greasier than I imagined. Overall I'd come back again because the pizza was good, the service was good, and the price was pretty fair for what you get.
I love grabbing just a slice or two here and it's so convenient. Sometimes you just want "a slice or two" grab and go! Perfect spot to do that and only $2.99 a slice. Amazing deal and big slice.
Eh, not what I'm looking for when it comes to New York style pizza, but not a bad spot if you live in the neighborhood and need to feed a crowd. No skimping on toppings on the pepperoni & mushroom pizza that I ordered (especially the pepperoni...it was loaded!)! Decently tasty red sauce, but flavorless and rubbery cheese. Was hoping for a really thin and slightly crispy crust, but the crust here is more of the pillowy type. Delicious cheesy garlic bread! A garlic cream, alfredo-like sauce, is used. Okay-ish service. Lady at the front counter didn't bother with a greeting, but the gentleman who walked up from the kitchen and handed me my order was all smiles.
update: we decided to try a few other items. Their calzone and gyro and veggies pie. yum. Calzone: this item is huge. it looked like a folded small pizza. we ordered one with red sauce, pepperoni, spinach, and cheese. this was very good. My son only ate half this monster calzone and he was satisfied. Large veggie and gyro pie (half/half): fresh veggies, pie was not soggy, perfect ratio of veggies/cheese/and sauce...this was a tasty veggie pie. We had the creamy garlic sauce instead of the red sauce and it made this pie great. In fact, i would like to order all their pies with this creamy garlic sauce instead of their red sauce! The gyro half was also delicious. the mozzarella cheese, creamy garlic sauce, red onions, and tomatoes had the perfect balance. The only caveat: the gyro meat was sparse and didn't have any flavor. Perhaps substituting their gyro meat with chicken or mushrooms would've been a tastier option. Again, i would still prefer a pie from Romas or Luigi's. but not bad for a local pie place.
Gave them another shot after a few months, and they delivered -- literally and flavor-wise. The garlic cheese bread? Buttery, cheesy, and perfectly pull-apart. The Super Hawaiian? Sweet and savory, -- chef's kiss!
Ordered a California chicken artichoke pizza on Valentine's Day. The pizza was missing half of the toppings which is disappointing, the pizza could have been a lot better, you think you'd prioritize accuracy for a night like valentines. No fresh garlic or tomatoes which made for a lack luster pizza, False advertising too. While I was sitting in the car I noticed them rubbing their faces and one guy even behind his ear during downtime in between customers and also while talking on the phone, pretty gross considering they also work the pizza dough and cash register barehanded. (Watch from your car, you'll see it too.) Most of the people who work there are high school aged with careless attitudes. The interior is very basic and modeled after a basic chain pizza restaurant, There's a few places to sit, nothing to write home about. I've been patronizing this location recently, now I'm reconsidering. Double check your pizzas before leaving to verify that it has everything described because they will skimp on toppings.
The pizza and wings were great! I loved that the pizza crust is thin & I got a great deal when I ordered online (family deal). I will say, I wasn't a fan of having to wait to get my food even after I ordered ahead 2 hours prior & had a set pickup time. It seemed like that was common there as other people were told to wait too. However, the food was fresh and still very yummy! I would definitely give New York Pizza another shot
Been here a few times now and love it! Great place to come for a slice of pizza on your lunch break! A sweet couple runs the place and makes sure your food comes quickly. There is only a small bench inside, so you do need to eat somewhere else.
This place just opened. I was at Starbucks awhile back and thought I would inquire about this place. I saw someone spinning pizza dough with two hands with skill and I thought I would give this place a try in the future. There are other locations. Ambiance It is a very small place in a nice strip mall. Looks like ur typical Pizza Guys with soft drinks out front but smaller space. Customer Service It was Friday night so the place was hopping. Got two topping pizza for $14.99 called on the phone and was told ready in 30 minutes. I noticed the total was about $2 more I asked about that. I was informed 40 cent fee for credit card. I don't believe I saw any sign stating a fee like u see at a donut business. I don't mind paying this as long as I know ahead of time. Pizza When I got there pizza was ready. Pizzas were stacked high on top of each other. The pizza was slightly warm so it must have come out fast. This is a high volume pizza factory. Pizza itself was very good, generous portions of pepperoni and mushrooms. The crust could be better. Bang for buck is hard to beat. Better than Pizza Guys. Round Table is my go to for a chain but only go there when they have promotions. So will come here when they don't. Will come a little earlier when I order by phone to get warm pizza.
I wasn't sure about this place when i first saw it opening! My son (8yr) has been patiently waiting to try this and we finally did. It's located between the Starbucks and wingstop in the florin lake crest shopping center. It's an order and take or you can call ahead but my husband ordered and waited outside while the pizza was prepared! It was done in 15mins and since it's not far from my house it came home nice hot and fresh. The crust was the best part for me. Cooked perfect with the right amount of soft and crunch! The crust is everything for me and they passed the test. The pizza wasn't greasy and not overpowered by cheese or sauce. I'll be visiting again really soon
I wanted to check this place out after hearing about their $2.99 pizza slices, which sounded like a great deal. I ordered two slices of pepperoni pizza, and my husband ordered a cheese slice since he's vegetarian. As soon as we got our food, I opened the box and immediately noticed how greasy the pizza was--in the best way. It smelled amazing and reminded me of a classic New York-style pizza. I was tempted to eat it right away while it was fresh, but I ended up waiting until I got home. Even though I didn't eat it until later, it was still delicious, and the leftovers the next day held up surprisingly well. If you're looking for a quick, affordable bite, this is definitely a great spot. Just don't forget to ask for ranch if you like it with your pizza--they charge $0.75 for it. Next time, I'd definitely recommend eating the pizza as soon as you get it while it's hot and fresh for the best experience. Ambiance: small spot you go in and order your food read more
Good neighborhood pizza option that's not a major pizza chain. New York Pizza is located in the Lake Crest shopping center in Greenhaven off Florin and Greenhaven drive just west of the I-5. They offer pizza, wings, calzones, pizza subs, and salads. This is a takeout only pizza joint but they do offer delivery. The pizza prices are very reasonable compared to some regional pizza chains and a lot cheaper than the major competitors. I ordered the large New York combo. The toppings and taste are very comparable to a combo from Round Table, Mountain Mikes, or Pizza Guys. The owner Albert has pizza in his DNA. Albert comes from a long line of pizza makers from Long Island and knows his pizza! Will be back to try some of the other pies and items on the menu! Prices & fees Large New York combo $22.99 Credit card fee 4% read more
I was craving pizza and decided to try something new and decided upon this pizza place. They have a pretty big and extensive menu with some interesting signature pizzas. Since it was my first time trying it, I got a half gyro, half chicken pesto pizza. The pizza looked really good immediately after opening the box. They did not skimp on any of the toppings and it was hot and fresh. The pizza tasted great but it was greasier than I imagined. Overall I'd come back again because the pizza was good, the service was good, and the price was pretty fair for what you get. read more
7 months ago
Eh, not what I'm looking for when it comes to New York style pizza, but not a bad spot if you live in the neighborhood and need to feed a crowd. No skimping on toppings on the pepperoni & mushroom pizza that I ordered (especially the pepperoni...it was loaded!)! Decently tasty red sauce, but flavorless and rubbery cheese. Was hoping for a really thin and slightly crispy crust, but the crust here is more of the pillowy type. Delicious cheesy garlic bread! A garlic cream, alfredo-like sauce, is used. Okay-ish service. Lady at the front counter didn't bother with a greeting, but the gentleman who walked up from the kitchen and handed me my order was all smiles. read more
3 days ago
7 months ago
update: we decided to try a few other items. Their calzone and gyro and veggies pie. yum. Calzone: this item is huge. it looked like a folded small pizza. we ordered one with red sauce, pepperoni, spinach, and cheese. this was very good. My son only ate half this monster calzone and he was satisfied. Large veggie and gyro pie (half/half): fresh veggies, pie was not soggy, perfect ratio of veggies/cheese/and sauce...this was a tasty veggie pie. We had the creamy garlic sauce instead of the red sauce and it made this pie great. In fact, i would like to order all their pies with this creamy garlic sauce instead of their red sauce! The gyro half was also delicious. the mozzarella cheese, creamy garlic sauce, red onions, and tomatoes had the perfect balance. The only caveat: the gyro meat was sparse and didn't have any flavor. Perhaps substituting their gyro meat with chicken or mushrooms would've been a tastier option. Again, i would still prefer a pie from Romas or Luigi's. but not bad for a local pie place. read more
2 months ago
5 months ago
2 months ago
1 year ago
Gave them another shot after a few months, and they delivered -- literally and flavor-wise. The garlic cheese bread? Buttery, cheesy, and perfectly pull-apart. The Super Hawaiian? Sweet and savory, -- chef's kiss! read more
7 months ago
Ordered a California chicken artichoke pizza on Valentine's Day. The pizza was missing half of the toppings which is disappointing, the pizza could have been a lot better, you think you'd prioritize accuracy for a night like valentines. No fresh garlic or tomatoes which made for a lack luster pizza, False advertising too. While I was sitting in the car I noticed them rubbing their faces and one guy even behind his ear during downtime in between customers and also while talking on the phone, pretty gross considering they also work the pizza dough and cash register barehanded. (Watch from your car, you'll see it too.) Most of the people who work there are high school aged with careless attitudes. The interior is very basic and modeled after a basic chain pizza restaurant, There's a few places to sit, nothing to write home about. I've been patronizing this location recently, now I'm reconsidering. Double check your pizzas before leaving to verify that it has everything described because they will skimp on toppings. read more
The pizza and wings were great! I loved that the pizza crust is thin & I got a great deal when I ordered online (family deal). I will say, I wasn't a fan of having to wait to get my food even after I ordered ahead 2 hours prior & had a set pickup time. It seemed like that was common there as other people were told to wait too. However, the food was fresh and still very yummy! I would definitely give New York Pizza another shot read more
1 year ago
Been here a few times now and love it! Great place to come for a slice of pizza on your lunch break! A sweet couple runs the place and makes sure your food comes quickly. There is only a small bench inside, so you do need to eat somewhere else. read more
2 years ago
This place just opened. I was at Starbucks awhile back and thought I would inquire about this place. I saw someone spinning pizza dough with two hands with skill and I thought I would give this place a try in the future. There are other locations. Ambiance It is a very small place in a nice strip mall. Looks like ur typical Pizza Guys with soft drinks out front but smaller space. Customer Service It was Friday night so the place was hopping. Got two topping pizza for $14.99 called on the phone and was told ready in 30 minutes. I noticed the total was about $2 more I asked about that. I was informed 40 cent fee for credit card. I don't believe I saw any sign stating a fee like u see at a donut business. I don't mind paying this as long as I know ahead of time. Pizza When I got there pizza was ready. Pizzas were stacked high on top of each other. The pizza was slightly warm so it must have come out fast. This is a high volume pizza factory. Pizza itself was very good, generous portions of pepperoni and mushrooms. The crust could be better. Bang for buck is hard to beat. Better than Pizza Guys. Round Table is my go to for a chain but only go there when they have promotions. So will come here when they don't. Will come a little earlier when I order by phone to get warm pizza. read more
2 months ago
2 years ago
I wasn't sure about this place when i first saw it opening! My son (8yr) has been patiently waiting to try this and we finally did. It's located between the Starbucks and wingstop in the florin lake crest shopping center. It's an order and take or you can call ahead but my husband ordered and waited outside while the pizza was prepared! It was done in 15mins and since it's not far from my house it came home nice hot and fresh. The crust was the best part for me. Cooked perfect with the right amount of soft and crunch! The crust is everything for me and they passed the test. The pizza wasn't greasy and not overpowered by cheese or sauce. I'll be visiting again really soon read more
3 months ago
Didn't want to cook so I decided to give this place a chance. Placed my order online and took advantage of their 1st order discount (10% off with minimum purchase must be 25 dollars). This place has a few chairs for people who are waiting for their order but it is pretty much a pick up spot. The inside is what you normally expect for most pizza places. I got the 12 inch cheese and 10 inch Hawaiian. The Hawaiian had the normal Canadian bacon and pineapple but it also came with bits of real bacon. Nice and welcome surprise that made it even more delicious. The cheese pizza was good but a little bit of a drop off compared to the Hawaiian. read more
9 months ago
7 months ago
3 months ago
5 months ago
Very good pizza very friendy people i get pizza here twice a week their wings are good also very good prices!! read more
3 months ago
I was browsing Yelp for places to eat for lunch and came across this place. I called to place an order for a New York Combo Pizza. Guy on the phone said 20 minutes, I arrived exactly 20 minutes and the guy was boxing up the pizza. I usually order a combo pizza when trying a new place and theirs didn't disappoint. It had a ton of toppings and sauce was good. I also didn't find that the pizza was too greasy. They have a large menu of other pizzas. I was actually interested in their Greek pizzas because I like Greek food. Maybe I'll try one of those next time. I've never ordered pizza from the Pocket area and order from someplace either Downtown or Elk Grove but I think I found my new place that is close by for pizza. read more
3 months ago
9 months ago
$26 for an extra large specialty pizza. You will not find this anywhere else! The pizza was delicious. Definitely coming back if we are in the area again read more
1 year ago
What a solid spot. More of a 3.7/5. No dine in only carry out. My order took 20 mins which is quick. Great service. Great pricing. Will be back for more. read more
3 months ago
Tried this place after driving by a few times and wondering if it was good. Did the online order and pleasantly surprised to get a 10% first-time discount. Got two large pizzas, the antipasto salad, and app sampler. I walked in 5 min before it was ready. It's a strict takeout only place. Very friendly greeting from the gent at the counter. Order was ready minutes later... same gent apologized for the wait and handed me the hot pizza. Got home... everything looked great. The salad could've used some pepperoncinis, which I like. The sampler needed some marinara sauce for dipping, but it was decent. Pizza and salads were otherwise very good, especially for the value. I'll be back when I'm in town. read more
2 months ago
7 months ago
4 months ago
We had a fantastic experience here! Would definitely return. Love the ease of ordering, the friendly customer service, and, most importantly, the delicious pizzas. They executed our order perfectly. The interior is simple: just a counter to order and some chairs--just what is needed for to go orders. We also love that they offer slices. I love me a white pie so I highly recommend the creamy garlic sauce! read more
9 months ago
This is my 2nd review. Called in an order. Of the SUPER CHICKEN PIZZA, AS We call it. Wife picked it up. Only 20 minutes, in traffic from natomas. OH MY ITS AS GOOD AS THE 1ST TIME. The Farlic sauce is so deliciously buttery, and garlic. It's Phenominal. Keep doing what your doing. We will continue to Patronize. read more
Page 1 of 3
