Really good slices and pricing. I enjoyed the service and different options to choose from.

If you're craving New York-style pizza, look no further than New York Slices in HP! From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with the smell of fresh pizza and a welcoming, laid-back vibe. The pizzas here are simply great. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy with just the right amount of chew. Beyond the pizza, the customer service is top-notch. The staff is friendly, fast, and eager to make sure your experience is a great one. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or dining in, you'll feel like a valued guest. The portions are generous, and the prices are reasonable, making it the perfect spot for a casual meal with family or friends.Best pizza joint in the area. Highly recommended for anyone who loves authentic, mouth-watering pizza! read more

New York Slices - Cheese Pizza 20" (8 Slices) - Pizza Near Me - Highland Park, Illinois

See all

Such a neighborhood gem! I didn't know I could get a beautiful NYC style slice near my place! Love it! read more

See all

This is pretty good pizza! Also the staff is really cool. Very quick and convenient. I recommend it if you're in the Highland Park area.

Here's what you need to know: I was nervous about the service here given the reviews before by my favorite Yelp reviewers but we received absolutely outstanding service from Chris and Sooki. UHMAZING CALZONE (NYC style with fresh ricotta). Kids loved the sausage NYC style pizza too. Ambiance is fun and shabby, but super clean. Loved our experience here and the food and the service. read more

New York Slices - Sausage Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Highland Park, Illinois

Usually has delicious pizza. Today went to get a slice at 8:30 was fully shut not a person inside. Online and sign on the door says open until 9. Not good service to do so and now I'm hangry and upset. read more

Good quality thin crust pizza Other interesting snack items Relatively fast service Clean and quiet read more

So far, in Highland Park, this is my favorite pizza. Good sauce and a crust. I'm still chasing my beloved chicago style tavern cut from my old local place but I'll find it! read more

Great pizza and excellent customer service. Very knowledgeable staff. Interesting decor.

loved this place, ambience was old timey and they had coke in - glass bottle. Was concerned upon entering that the restaurant was empty of customers but the guy who served us was friendly and the food came out quick. i had the pasta pizza which was quirky but very yummy. i recommend, especially if you want a cheap classic eat. read more

New York Slices - 16" Pasta Pizza (Baked Penne smothered on top) - Pizza Near Me - Highland Park, Illinois

Ordered a pie for pick up and it was pretty good. They were just closing up and it looks like they have slices available as well if you're looking for a quick bite. As far as our pizza, it was solid. We had a half pepperoni half cheese and it was made well. The crust was really solid too. read more

The service is always great and I love all of the guys Bobby and Greg are especially awesome. The food is so good. I always get the veggie slice or the Grandma pizza. It is the best pizza in Highland Park hands-down not even close. And the ambience is cool with the NY mural and just an overall unique feel. read more

There's plenty of pizza around highland Park Illinois. Now and then I have to have New York Slices, one of the best pizzas around. Not the least bit greasy with a half chewy half very crisp crust. The pizza's always ready on time and whoever's at the counter is always courteous and a pleasure. The pricing is great as well. They have days where one pizza gets one free and other specials that make a great piece of doubly good. This place has been around forever and will always have my business. I have a taste for NYS, now! read more

New York style pizza here in Chicago -- yes, it's almost blasphemy! -- would never survive here if it wasn't better than New York Pizza in New York just to stick it to them! To show you how good this place is, New York Slices has been around at least 10 years. The decor here is fun, with a New York City mural painted on one wall, a floor which almost feels like (but not dirty like) a New York street or subway platform, and the counter and drink coolers which really feel like you're at a New York carry-out pizzeria. There is a small dining area with stainless metal chairs and tables, and always good music playing inside New York slices. Customer service staff is young but friendly and polite and attentive. Street parking out front and the street is plentiful. Currently, during covid 19, there is no dine-in service, the same as most everywhere. The boys inside made pick up very easy because they were all ready to go with my order and receipt when I walked in. Before covid 19, the joint was the same, just with people at the tables -- healthy New York volume of chatter and music, and quick customer service. Tonight I ordered only a 10-inch, personal-sized, brick-oven, New York thin pizza with ham, bacon and pineapple. The toppings were plentiful and tasty, although I would have enjoyed bigger pieces of bacon. The crust was slightly crunchy on the outside, and airy and a tiny bit chewy inside, exactly as I hoped for, and there was not the slightest hint of saltiness or preservatives commonly found in national chain, mass-produced pizzerias. A New York pizzeria -- especially one with the chutzpah to use the Big Apple name in our City of Big Shoulders -- would not survive in Chicago's thick pizza environment if it wasn't damn good. These guys are damn good. What's more, you're getting the New York pizzeria environment at New York Slices WITHOUT THE NEW YORK PRICES! When you look at the menu, you'll realize that all prices are very reasonable for the high quality you are getting in comparison to everything else in our market. On my next visit, I'll probably grab one of their meatball sandwiches or a calzone, and take home some of their Homer's Ice Cream! read more

New York Slices - a pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Highland Park, Illinois

Was nearby at lunch so grabbed a slice (I didn't go in). I got the veggie and wow! It was covered! They were fresh and cooked right, not mushy or hard. Will be back for dinner and a full pizza! read more

New York Slices - Veggie Slice - Pizza Near Me - Highland Park, Illinois

Do not sleep on the Grandma slice! I know you may be here for a New York style pepperoni or prefer tavern style, but for a great understated, garlicky, not overly cheesy piece of nostalgia, get a simple Grandma slice. It's not as thick as the Sicilian so the crust is crispy not crunchy. There's a nice layer of cheese topped with their tomato sauce that has a gentle sweetness. There are garlic cloves in there too despite no additional toppings. I would come back for this alone but they also have great deals and their regular New York slices are solid. Parking is a little tough with the construction in the area right now but it's worth the trip! read more

Excellent pizza ! Ordered for the first time yesterday via Uber eats . Will plan to come there in person.

10+ years as loyal customers...every single week! 40 minutes to closing we called to order our usual Thursday pizza. One of the guys working there literally got on the phone and I heard him say to my husband that they decided they "don't feel like making anymore pizzas tonight." Guess what? We'll be one less pizza you have to make on Thursday nights. I really hope the owner reads this review. Your employees are going to run your business right into the ground. End of an era...never again. Byeeeee read more

I'm so happy I moved to highland park and found this place! I'm a Philly girl and was so pleasantly surprised with how good the pizza was. My only complaint was there was a ton more mushroom than sausage but that could be because I ordered right before closing? Either way this will definitely be my new go to pizza place! read more

Closest pizza to actually being back in nyc. I wish I was closer to this place to have it more often!!! read more

On the plus side, the sausage pizza is pretty good. It's something I wish I had gotten two of instead of just one slice and the other items I ordered. On the negative side, their cheese fritters, which is sort of like part of a cheese filled breadstick, are very bland. Definitely not worth the money or stomach space. Also, I wasn't a fan of the chunks of onion in the sausage stromboli-like thing when all I was told is it contained sausage. If it contains onion as well, that's fine, but tell your customers that when they ask what's in it. I ended up tearing the thing open and picking out as much of the onion as I could, but of course the onion flavor had already seeped it's way into everything else. read more

We just ordered from them for the first time (using DoorDash, who jack the prices up), and everything was really good. We've got picky eaters in our house and everyone is in agreement that New York Slices makes a very tasty NY style pizza. We ordered a plain cheese, which was delicious, and a white pizza, which will be my personal go-to from now on, and also buffalo wings, which were awesome, but maybe not quite as buffalo-y as I prefer. The sauce is sweet and tangy, almost like a bar-b-q sauce, but not too spicy. Still, the wings are huge and fantastic. Somebody in the chain from restaurant to delivery forgot our dressing to dip the wings in so that sucked, but people make mistakes. All in all, we'll be ordering from them all the time. read more

Over 3 years since I last reviewed, and they still have the same issue of forgetting your sauces for delivery orders. Unfortunately the food itself has gone down in quality too. Garlic knots were burnt and hard. Pizza was cold/old tasting. Jalapeño poppers were barely fried and soggy. What a shame. read more

I had to update my review after taking a group of students here on a field trip. I saw online that New York Slices has a special on making your own pizza for $4.99. Adam helped us out and he was awesome with our students. He demonstrated and assisted them in kneading the dough. He made separate containers or each ingredient so the students couldn't complain that anyone got more. When the kids were done making the pizza they brought them into the kitchen to bake. Each pan is numbered to ensure students get the correct pizza. This also helped prevent any arguments. The pizza was delicious. The service was fantastic and Adam was generous enough to offer all the kids ice cream. They are super kid friendly. Service this great makes me want to go out of my way to be a repeat customer. read more

New York Slices - Make your own pizza ingredients! - Pizza Near Me - Highland Park, Illinois

See all

I was walking around the area and walked by here. Grabbed a slice of cheese and was really happy with it. Definitely give it a try!

This was a fun experience!! I had JUST gotten back from New York the day before, having experienced only Lombardi's pizza. So I wanted a more authentic NY pizza experience. The boyfriend said that NY Slices is definitely more authentic. They didn't have a lot of choices when we went in, but there was a cheese pizza, a deluxe pizza, and some fritters! I can't fault a place for being out of pizza when there's a rush on slices because it's tasty. We ordered 2 slices of deluxe, I snagged the last piece of cheese, and 2 cheese fritters. Worth it!! Really liked the crust, and I really liked the sauce. The thing about this pizza is that it's not your Chicago pizza- it's not pie, it's slices. Which I learned is kind of a thing in New York, that it's about beautiful simplicity and ease of eating. I can appreciate that! One guy was workin' the oven in the back, and they could probably use more staff, but honestly for a smaller shop they were doing fine. More pizza came out before we left, so we got a pepperoni slice and a sausage slice, which wound up being just devoured when we got home. One of the beautiful things about New York Slices is that it doesn't give you bloated sadness like Chicago pie does, because it's just not as heavy of a pizza. And I am DEFINITELY okay about that! I never thought I'd say this, especially as a Chicago area native, but, I think I very well may prefer New York style to Chicago, and this is definitely a good go to for that change! As long as you don't have crazy expectations about the place, I would totally recommend. It definitely does cater more to a younger crowd, so if Karen and Becky want to have brunch and yell at managers, maybe sit this one out. If you wanna suggest a decent place for the kids and teenagers or anyone chill in general, definitely check out New York Slices, at least once. read more

Best NY pizza place I have found in North Burbs !! Great slices and mean Sicilian too...

Don't order here via GrubHub, they got my order wrong and refused to refund or replace it. The girl who answered sounded bored during the call - she honestly sounded halfway asleep. I'm sad because this was my fave pizza joint for a long time read more

As a guy from the Northeast US that's used to good NY style pizza, I have to admit that' my pickup pizza measured up very well & authentically NY. My only criticism is that while I had a scheduled time for pickup, when I got it, it was just "warm". I had to reheat when I got it home just two mins after pickup. read more

If I could give it 0 stars I would. I'm 59 and it's the worst pizza I've ever eaten and my wife agrees. I don't know how they stay in business or why anyone would chose to go there more than once. The pizza doesn't even taste like pizza. It tastes like cardboard. It's dry, no herbs or spices, you would need a magnifying glass to find any sauce and the cheese tastes like it came out if a can. I've only written a handful of bad restaurant reviews and this is one that needed to be written. read more

Good food and good service the pizza slices are good even the unfortunate slice I had that was a little older

Not the greatest pizza. Obviously didn't taste fresh. Had a decent flavor but most likely won't return. It took about 5 minutes to get a slice of pizza. Unacceptable. The guy was on the phone taking phone orders and had to wait for two different orders to be placed before mine. Even though my slice still had to be put in the oven to get reheated. read more

New York Slices - Sausage slice - Pizza Near Me - Highland Park, Illinois

I keep coming back because the slices and prices are ok. It's also the only place around where you can get a single slice of pizza. Honestly, if you're not a teenage boy, you don't always get treated very well here. The last two times I've come I've been pregnant. This time, the girl with the pink hair (not tied back) and half of a shirt ( not sanitary) hair decided to take a teenage boys order who was in line behind me before mine. This matters if he's going to order the last slice of a pizza I want. When I worked at a pizza shop we were required to keep our hair tied back and be fully clothed. The time before this, I got here about 15 minutes before they opened. I was standing in front of the store checking the hours on my phone when the owner rudely asked if I needed help (not in a friendly tone). I explained I was just checking the hours on Google since they're not posted on the door and the door was locked. She snapped, no we're closed now. That time I left and went somewhere else. I'd still probably come back because it's the right sized lunch for me, and pizza is alright, but I hope to see customer service and clothing/sanitary requirements for food handlers improve. Side note- I've ordered take out and somehow it's not as good as just slices. Maybe it has to do with the reheat? Tldr; decent food, mediocre environment, good prices, and could use better customer service. Could be a 5 star if they improve on customer kindness and respect. read more

NY Slice makes delicious thin crust pie! I ordered online for pick up and the food was ready right when I arrived. The pizza is just what you imagine when craving NY style 'za - thin, foldable slices fit for even the hungriest of Ninja Turtles! I also liked their home made balsamic dressing on the side salads. The french fries were crisp too! I made sure to order extra pizza so we had left overs - still great on day 2! I'd definitely recommend this Highland Park staple! read more

We order pizzas for shipping, the company processed our order online (accepting payment) - and the confirmation we received said shipping would be completed within 3 days. After 3 days we had to call the company 2x to inquire about our order. Instead of receiving a call back, we received an email back from Mark saying they made a mistake, shipping is no longer available, and they are refunding our money. Super un-cool, our son who was looking forward to celebrating his birthday with "New York style" pizza will not be. Will not order from these guys again, perhaps a call back to apologize instead of an email would have helped. read more

Great pizza! Friendly staff! Very urban ambiance. *mental transporta to NY* during the first bite! read more

Love this HP staple for great NY style pizza. It is consistent and if you like NY style this is the place. They also have some really great daily specials which aren't available via the 3rd party providers like grubhub, doordash, etc. But I know Thursdays they have a deal for $10 for a large which we do often. 2 large definitely feed a family of 5, but we get a 3rd for leftovers. Definitely worth a try. read more

My kids love this place, we make a visit at least once a week. Great NY-inspired slices to fold and eat. Also some thicker Sicilian options, garlic knots, and a few other things you might find in the Big Apple. Great place to pick up a pie on the way home. The prices are really good in my opinion. My two little guys can almost polish off a large cheese by themselves, so it's good to save a few bucks when there is a chance I may not get to have any. Staff is always friendly and helpful and they have a loyalty rewards program that links your payment methods to your e-mail so you don't have to worry about always using the same method of payment. read more

So I apparently have a problem lately and that has been that I have ordered this pizza 3 nights in 1 week for my family. I forgot how much I loved the thin, simple, cheesy goodness of a huge piece of pizza! No fancy business. It's just the perfect piece of foldable pizza. They make it quick for pick up or delivery. The only problem now is that it is the only thing my family wants for dinner every night. So it has a slight addictive quality! Anyhow, I am glad that it is available to order when the pizza mood hits. I had totally forgotten they were in HP. Take this advice from an actual Italian family. We know our pizza. read more

Man... The calzones are terrible. If you don't want to sell me a calzone then don't, but don't go out of your way to make a physical embodiement of displeasure just to make me pay for it. The staff is very friendly though... They just secretly hate me and my calzone enjoying ways... You just can't please some folk. read more