Parking: generous sized lot right off the main road with a turning lane for piece of mind Decor: rustic yet modern and stylish with exposed beams, fantastic color combinations with reserved yet stylish art and accents throughout the entire location. Staff: we had Gabe at the bar to start and his drink knowledge and customer experience is on point. When we were seated on the patio...the enclosed patio space is such a nice touch...our server was Abby. She knows everything on the menu and her attention to detail was something I truly wish other places taught their staff...and the best part was she wasn't hovering...she just knew when to replenish our drinks and to do "check-ins"! Food: started with steak egg rolls cut at an angle and do well yummy! The freshly made meatballs were so tender yet so flavorful that I could have ordered more and been done. On to the entree's my ribeye was so well prepared...dare I say PERFECT which I don't say often in my reviews...that I didn't even use the added sauces! My colleague let me try her steak with garlic cheese topped...OMG!!!! The sides...multi colored carrots on a pesto base, shaved Brussels and garlic mash! It was so delish that I actually asked to give thanks to the chef that created all these masterpieces and Chef Matt came to the table and I didn't know where to start with the praise but I am glad I had the chance to truly appreciate the masterpiece menu! Drinks: cocktails with so many types of rums, tequila, bourbon that they can meet anyone's needs...the wine list is spectacular too. We wrapped up dinner with a Stag's Leap Artemis. Overall: I found my go to when I'm in the area, without a second thought!!! Check out the pics below!! read more

See all

Well, we all know how much of a fan I am with Nick's Steakhouse. Just had another PHENOMENAL dinner! I can't stop. Never had anything I didn't like and can't make any of it at home, which is unique. Exceeds expectations every time. So full and had to bring food home. Excellent staff, of course. read more

See all

Can't stop talking about Nick's! The food was amazing, service was precisely synchronized and Abby anticipated our every need. We had the pleasure of meeting the owner and were so impressed by the level of service , quality of food and hospitality we received. As much as we would like to keep this secret, we highly recommend this perfectly appointed spot. We can't wait for our next visit. Thank you all for a perfect dinning experience! Thanks, The Browns' read more

We had an exceptional meal on New Year's Eve at Nicks. Upon walking in we were greeted warmly by the hostess and a waitress. We were seated in the enclosed patio which was so warm and cozy. Our server Katie was very sweet and helpful. The bread service was pretzel bites with a truffle cheese dip. TO DIE FOR. The apps - French Onion soup, wedge salad and tuna tartar - also delicious. Best tuna tartar I've ever had. Tuna was very fresh. Entrees were a ribeye and NY Strip. Both cooked to perfection, seasoned well and all around so tasty. My husband and I each got sauce on the side, but it was not needed. The steaks were just so good on their own. Sides were just as good. Green beans cooked perfectly, twice baked potato was big and delicious, covered in cheese and crunchy bacon bits. Cocktails were on point. One of the best Old Fashions I've had. Dessert was a GIANT piece of chocolate hazelnut cake. OH MY was it good. Moist and chocolatey with crunchy hazelnuts in the frosting layers. I was soo pumped to snag a reservation there last minute on NYE, and my oh my we cannot WAIT to go back. We've tried most restaurants in the Ogunquit/Wells/York area, and this by far is our favorite. Thank you Nick's for a wonderful experience. P.S. my 2 year old loved their truffle fries! read more

Never had less than a perfect experience! Whether we eat at the bar, or in the dining room, the ambience is perfect! The food is amazing, service amazing. Best steak you Could ask for! The dessert??? Well, the picture doesn't do it justice! read more

Nick’s Steakhouse - Death by Chocolate Cake - Steakhouses Near Me - York, Maine

What a phenomenal experience! From the moment we walked in - being greeted by Nick the owner, Gabe the bartender, the owners wife, and our waitress - service was exceptional. We arrived early to our reservations to spend time at the beautiful bar and get a flight of bourbon. Their selection is amazing !! They also carry two single barrel picks from Old Forester and Markers Mark. The flights are very reasonable. Sitting at the bar chopping it up with Gabe is what really made the experience. Such an asset to the restaurant. He even made my wife an off the menu cocktail that she absolutely loved! After spending some time at the bar our table was ready. Our waitress was so nice and kind. Attentive and helpful. The atmosphere is cozy but felt special. Food was great, they accommodated all our requests, and never made us feel like we were being rushed. I wish I lived closer because the overall experience we had here was second to none. I still plan on visiting as soon as possible just to come back here! read more

See all

My girlfriends and I went to Nick's last month on a Friday night during a weekend trip to Maine. Our server was super friendly and gave us lots of time to select drinks and apps/entrees. One of the girls chose a specialty gin cocktail but was unable to drink it as it was so strong. She ended up ordering a different beverage - although we told the waitress that the drink tasted like pure alcohol and only a sip was taken from it, there was no offer to comp the drink. Our appetizers and bread were the best part of the meal, particularly the cheesesteak egg rolls. Steaks were not cooked right and sides were just okay. The homemade cake was delicious! Unfortunately, we expected more from Nick's based on prices along (as they are more in line with a Boston steakhouse than a Maine steakhouse). read more

I have been going to Nicks since they opened. It is without a doubt one of the best experiences in dining in the area the atmosphere is cozy very stylish and welcoming. The service is amazing. We were a party of four this past Sunday. Started at the bar our friends wanted to see the remainder of the football game. The bartender was very friendly and attentive. We then moved to our table. The waitress was very attentive but not ever invasive. It was three out of the four of us celebrating our January birthdays which we have done for the last four years. She went over and beyond to make our experience a joyous celebration. I wish I remembered her name to give her kudos. She is fairly new and that always is a feather in a servers cap. As for the food I give a 10. The steaks and sauces are perfect. The sides ample to split and all winners. I had a tuna tartare starter that was so fresh, delicious. We always think of Nicks for any special occasion. read more

Finally got to try Nick's and we're so glad we did. Service was lovely and the steaks were superb in our opinion. Will definitely go again. read more

See all

Horses and wait staff were exceptionally friendly and accommodating. We were seated quickly and settled in with drinks while we waited for the last two of our party who were running behind. I tried the Maine Lemonade, honestly not a fan. I like the idea of it but thought it tasted like seawater with blueberries floating in it. I ordered a dirty martini and was much happier with that choice. Classic and well made so kudos to the bartender. Appetizers were stuffed meatballs (delicious), tuna tartare (decent but not my favorite). Three of us had filets. My 8oz filet was great. I ordered it as medium and that's how it came out. Flavorful and tender, every bite was enjoyable. We did garlic mashed potatoes for a side and I was happy with them. Sized that one side dish is shareable between two people. Positive experience and I'm sure I'll be back next time I need a pleasant dinner in the area. read more

Second time at Nick's last night was delish! We started with the cheesesteak eggrolls which were so good - we got them last time too. For our dinner, I got the 5oz filet with au poivre and Jake got the ribeye with bearnaise. We shared the asparagus and the garlic mashed potatoes. Drinks and dessert were great, as was the service and environment. read more

Nick’s Steakhouse - 5 oz filet with au poivre and ribeye with bearnaise - Steakhouses Near Me - York, Maine

Let me start with the good. The staff and service were excellent and accommodating. Now the bad, very bad. The worst meal I had in all of 2025. Waygu Brisket was unrecognizable and inedible. Not sure if this was a one-off, but for $50+/meal I anticipate excellence. I requested the staff to take my meal away as it was not satisfactory. I did not request the charge be removed from the bill. Once through with dessert I received the bill and was surprised to find both my dinner and 1 of 2 desserts were stricken from the bill. The meal was $250+, but the unfortunate circumstance was handled professionally and for that I am grateful. read more

Great service. Steak was perfectly cooked as were the sides. However the sides are tiny so despite them being called family style, its a side for two people. Overall its very pricey for a place in York and while it was good food, I would not go back because I felt the value for what you got was just not there. read more

We went to Nick's last Mother's Day, there were 7 of us, with one 3 year old. We ordered 6 entrees. The fish was not good, and 4 of the menu entrees came with only the meat.. We were brought one small basket of pretzel bites, with no refills given or offered, and 3 of our group were under 15. The sauce with the pretzel bites had curdled or broke, very gritty and bitter, and the same sauce was also served with one other entree. For dessert we ordered 2 carrot cakes and a cheesecake brûlée. The brûlée was excellent, however, the carrot cakes were stale and very very dry. They tasted like they had been frozen and thawed. Our Server was excellent, very attentive. Very expensive for a steakhouse! The meal cost us $481. read more

Second visit for us. Service was great and food quality was solid. The kitchen just can't seem to get cooking the steaks to the right completeness. My filet came out cooked beyond medium and one of my dining companions came out beyond medium rare. If a high end steak house can't cook steaks to to right completeness why bother. read more

The best steak I've ever had. 4 of us all left saying the same thing. Awesome. Amazing. Spectacular. The service was solid. 5/5 . The ambiance was very nice. It's an older house converted to a restaurant. The tables are well spaced, the air conditioning excellent, the lighting perfect. I got the sangria to start, calamari - perfect and a little spicy too! We also had a tuna tartar with avocado. Oh my. My wife and I split a tomahawk steak ... 32 ounces. $115. Amazing. Cooked too perfection. And a house salad. The other couple had 2 steaks also. And loved it. A great glass of Malbec with the steak, and then some Hennessey VSOP. The whole meal cost about $150/ person including taxes and tip read more

Nick’s Steakhouse - 32 ounce Tomahawk steak. We split it. Awesome - Steakhouses Near Me - York, Maine

See all

Sat at the bar with the wife. I have no idea why this place is not 5 stars. Bartenders were both very sweet and attentive. Drinks were great. I got the bone in tomahawk. It was fantastic. Wife got the 5 oz filet. We had brussel sprouts, mushrooms for sides. Burrata and french onion soup for apps. Everything we ate was fantastic. The one downside was no espresso machine for after dinner. But i wont downgrade the restaurant on that alone. A+! read more

Nick’s Steakhouse - Bone In Tomahawk 22 oz. Fantastic! - Steakhouses Near Me - York, Maine

Nick's steakhouse is an excellent addition to the York, ME restaurant scene. I highly recommend sitting at the well-appointed bar & ordering from all available food menus. (Those mini beef wellingtons were delightful...along with some solid cocktails) My highest compliments to both the owner & the chef for executing their vision in such an inspiring way, especially for the area...I truly hope this restaurant ups-the-ante for all surrounding establishments. I will 100% be dining here again! read more

See all

FYI: I drove from NH to visit Nicks steakhouse and it did not disappoint one bit! From the moment I walked in I knew we were in the right place. Warm welcomes from the staff even though we didn't have a reservation in a nice & elegant yet rustic venue. We were seated outside only to be joined by none other than the two owners Holly and Nick having dinner together. They shared amazing stories on the history of the restaurant and how they bottled their own Makers Mark right at the distillery. They made us feel like family right from the start. Matter of fact we may be back next year same time and Nick made a deal with me that he will save the last bottle of their special made bourbon for us NY'ers. Food was outstanding and the service provided by Mya was top notch. Bottom line this is the place to go so stop searching on yelp and book your reservation. See you guys next year! read more

Nick’s Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - York, Maine

Absolutely amazing night for Valentine's Day! From being greeting by the owner and the sweet personable family feel of the restaurant. You can tell the employees genuinely love working here. Our waitress was SO sweet and personable and made the dining experience perfect. She was attentive and able to answer any and all questions about the menu. The food was all brought out at great timing and was to die for!! Cheesesteak egg-rolls were made to perfection. Drinks were soo goood. The restaurant had so many cool sections of outdoor, a romantic section, and a unique bar. I will certainly be coming back here again and again as it would be great all times of the year. Thank you for such a great night!! read more

We went last night to celebrate my birthday. The service was impeccable, before we even got there. The manager called to see if she could move us inside based on the weather, and when we got there we were taken right to a perfect table inside. It's so pretty and romantic inside: it's like you're having dinner in someone's elegant home. The bar looked lovely and intimate too. It's quiet and elegant, tastefully decorated. From there, the most attentive service continued. We ordered drinks and wine, and the apps were the calamari dish and the burrata prosciutto app. Calamari was cooked perfectly, very tender, and the burrata dish was delicious. Plenty of food for 5. Next up was our steaks: 3 ribeyes and 2 filets. Two of the ribeyes had the au poivre sauce which was delicious and not overpowering. One ribeye was a bit over cooked but honestly, it was so delicious it didn't matter. We got mashed potatoes, mushrooms, and truffle Mac & cheese for shareable sides and there was again plenty to share and enough to take some home. I can't believe we ordered dessert but they sounded so good we had to: homemade carrot cake and a hazelnut dacquoise, both excellent. We will absolutely be back. read more

If you are in York ME, on vacation, and looking for a premier steak house, this is not the place for you. I suggest you travel another hour south to the Danvers/Peabody line and hit Pellana. The extra gas price will be worth it. We went with friends for dinner after a show at the playhouse. The Blueberry Maple bacon appetizer was disappointing...and I mean how is bacon EVER disappointing? This appetizer lacked flavor and was a mediocre start. The menu stated the bacon portion was 9 ounces I'd say it was closer to 3.5 ounces total. Two in our party ordered steaks and both were overcooked and dry. One guest ordered the Salmon which was flavorless and had the texture of canned tuna. The halibut I ordered was dry. Our cocktails were expensive and lack luster. They tasted watered down and were devoid of the finesse of an advertised signature cocktail. The sides of garlic mashed and truffle fries were average at best. The dessert "death by chocolate" was the most disappointing as it was served "straight from the fridge" . The cake was dry , butter cream was brittle and ganache tasted like store bought chocolate chips. This dessert should RIP. Despite adequate service ,they could not offer or provide fresh brewed coffee which did not improve my opinion of them. They were able to offer bottled cold brew. read more

Gave Nicks a second chance after a really bad first experience... Very nice atmosphere and a server who was overly friendly to the point of being super fake. A food runner dropped off some pretzel bites (4) that were hard as rocks as they were "Microwaved" for way too long....very classy Ordered an appetizer of Bruschetta, came back with the toasted baguettes with a 3" pile of tomato gloop on top...never had anything like it and hopefully never will again. Finally I ordered a $52 dollar fillet, i didn't want to pay $18 for a baked potato so opted for steak fries. The steak fries were way overcooked to the point that it had no interior potato left, just a hard outer inedible flack jacket. My steak might have been ok, but it was hard to tell with the half inch layer of pepper on top of it. I did not order it "Aupoivre" it wrecked it. My wife's Caesar Salad with grilled chicken looked ok, although she could not eat it as it was also loaded with so much pepper that seems like the cook was trying to pull a prank on us.... Total disappointment. Pretty empty in there, now I know why. read more

Best steakhouse on the seacoast!!! Staff are outstanding and food consistently top notch!!!

What a huge disappointment! A 58.00 ribeye that was basically a Hannaford steak ! Brussel sprout side I could not eat ! Sad this is southern Maines option for a steak ! read more

I've read the other reviews and I agree with them. The food is good, but for a restaurant on route 1 without a view, and in the middle of no where the prices are Wayyyyy to high. I would expect these prices in NYC or even a high end steakhouse in Boston. 2 salads, the chicken dish and a small steak with potato, and no drinks whatsoever was $220.00. As locals, we are truly disappointed, we will not be back and will continue to support our other local restaurants. read more

So Nick's in York , Maine wasn't our original plan for a graduation dinner celebration, but we are so very happy we went there! We had been looking for a good steak house that could handle a party of nine on a Sunday evening in the Manchester/Portsmouth area, but everything was either closed or had an hour plus wait! When we called to ask if Nick's could accommodate us, the owner, Holly, happily said they'd be ready for us as soon as arrive! This restaurant is a hidden gem, and definitely one of the best experiences my family has ever had! The restaurant is a renovated Early American house with much of its original features providing wonderful ambience. The steak is the star in our book! And although the prices are higher than some, the quality of meat, preparation, and presentation are worth every cent! When ordering the steaks, the sides are ordered and served family style. Then to top of it all off, the wait staff is professional, friendly and totally happy to answer any questions we had. I would recommend this to anyone wanting to celebrate a special occasion, or just is looking for a wonderful night out! read more

See all

Food amazing best shrimp scampi I have had French onion soup flavor delicious Fillet perfection new twist on bourbon flavor Ice cream sandwich made in house. Service at the bar 10/10 Liquor Wine inventory will not leave you without a choice. Owner Nick spoke with us and cared about our dining experience. Hostess charming. We recommend this restaurant for an adult dining experience, and you will not be disappointed. read more

Absolutely fantastic experience! Loved the options on the menu. The Shrimp Scampi was delicious! The ambiance was cozy yet sophisticated, and the staff was attentive and friendly. The truffle fries are definitely worth a try! I'll be back soon. read more

Charming outside, cozy inside. Clean, modern aesthetic complements but doesn't distract from excellent food. Highly recommend steak (of course), but also chicken parmigiana (devoured by Italian connoisseur in our group). The mocha frosting on Death by Chocolate cake was perfect counterbalance to the deep chocolate sweet. Service was impeccable (even though we arrived a little late and had some special requests). We had such a good time, we closed the joint. Owner Nick went above and beyond to help us get back to our hotel. 11/10 read more

Took my best friend to dinner for his birthday last night and it was terrible. $400 for 3 people and we'll never go back again. Worst espresso martini that I've ever had. Rum punch was so strong. Then the food came. French onion soup is 10x better at the steakhouse in Wells and cheaper. I had the chicken parm and the chicken was thick and tough and the sauce was spicy. The other two had filets. One was overcooked with no seasoning and the other was just ok. Creamed spinach was cold. Truffle Mac and cheese was just ok. Corner room in Portland is way better. Asparagus was tough and not seasoned. Trying to save the day with a pumpkin spice cake with buttercream frosting by a local bakery. Cake was huge. Heavy and stale and the frosting was definitely not buttercream. It was as tough as fondant with no flavor and came off the cake in chunks like it was two to three days old. This place is as expensive as the Fore St in Portland but not even in the same class of food. Don't go there. If I could give it zero stars I would. read more

The renovation of this old building is worth the visit. It is amazing! For a small restaurant the tables seem very private and warm! The new bar is amazing and the bartenders and clientele very cool! The greeting by Reenie andl Holly made us feel very welcomed , that hospitality continued all evening. Jillian was our server and advisor as we asked for her recommendations and they,, were spot on. I had a Old Fashion that was wonderfully prepared and Debbie enjoyed a house special Blueberry side car type drink that she thoroughly enjoyed. We split the lump crab with a house remoulade sauce that was fabulous. Debbie, on her birthday, had her 8 oz Filet Mignon medium rare and I opted for the bone in Ribeye, rare, both were cooked to perfection and out of this world. For sides we got the Bake stuffed potato which was a meal for two in itself And the mushrooms which were a medley of which I've never had before! For desert we shared their locally baked chocolate peanut butter cake which was fantastic, but they don't serve coffee or coffeedrinksafter dinner which was a minor disappointment . Im thrilled to have a first class Steakhouse in York. Not inexpensive but a memorable Birthday evening ! read more

Really amazing food and service. Great people that put on and amazing dinner. I would highly suggest

I had the pleasure of dining at Nick's on a recent Saturday evening. We (party of five) we're greeted warmly and well taken care of by all the waitstaff on the patio. The steaks are excellent, perfectly cooked to our order. All sides were delicious and imaginative. Massive bourbon list - specialty cocktails. Highly recommend - special kudos to the chef!! read more

We went to Nick's on a stormy rainy night in Dec '23. Atmosphere was nice in the dining room area and our waitress was wonderful! I had the sea scallops which were the best ever! Cooked perfectly and with the corn/pancetta sauce it was delicious. Would recommend for a special day. read more

Lovely interior and the staff is trying hard but the food and service don't justify the exorbitant prices. Main courses came before appetizers were finished. Cutlery was not placed prior. Dessert is available but not coffee. The steaks were cooked properly, the side dishes were just okay, but with Boston prices there is an expectation of a better run establishment. Will not be back. read more

Excellent menu---food---service----I was visiting friends in York and they highly recommended the restaurant I thought the restaurant was fanastic read more

Fabulous food, best bourbon selection in the area, and the most friendly owners. While I always enjoy a great steak at Nick's. I also highly recommend the halibut. read more

Have had several meals at Nick's Steakhouse ; never disappoints. Steaks are done to order and sides are varied, especially like the baked potato, with all the fixings. Service is friendly and timely. I feel fortunate to have Nicks in the neighborhood read more

Not as good as I had hoped. First, We had a table in a small back room where we were completely cut off from the main part of the restaurant. But I could live with that if the rest of the experience was up to par. Unfortunately this was not the case. The server we had was very inconsistent. In the beginning she stopped by way too much, but once the main course was served she disappeared entirely. There were 4 of us and we all ordered beef, as one is inclined to do at a steakhouse; 3 filets and a bone in sirloin strip. We also ordered mashed potatoes and asparagus to share. My filet was definitely over cooked, having ordered it med rare and it was medium at best, mostly med well. Our server never checked back to ask how our meal was so I ended up eating what I should have returned. The quality of the meat was also disappointing, having a grainy shredded quality when cut into and not especially tender. The strip steak however was excellent, and the sides were good as well. The wine list was overpriced but had some good variety, and there were also some nice cocktails. The most frustrating part was it took the entire time we were eating and an additional 25 minutes after we were finished before we saw our server again. She asked if we wanted dessert. We decided to think about it for a minute but unfortunately it took her another 15 minutes to come back. At this point we decided to ask for the check rather than spend what was likely to be another hour sitting at the table. If our server had been more attentive during the meal we would have very likely ordered a second bottle of wine as well as dessert. Overall an overpriced disappointing experience. read more