Pros - Hidden gem! Nice variety on an extensive menu (see photos), prices quite reasonable…read more Affordable specials too! Friendly & knowledgeable service, spotless restaurant & clean dining area, especially right after lunch. Food presented on a real plate! A few outdoor seats are available. Unique specialty pizza & toppings. Very clean restroom. . Cons - Free parking, but limited. Needs a wider selection of drinks. Dark interior could use an update, open blinds & lighter paint. Could use soft music and/or turn the TV on, but overall I'm very pleased.

I thought this was very good pizza. We had a combo and it was tasty. I'm usually an IPC guy, but…read moreDiggs can definitely be in the rotation.

Was craving pizza so decided to try out this place. Did some research online and from the photos it…read morelooked good. I got the large pizza, half pepperoni, half cheese. It took about a little over 20 minutes to make but it was worth the wait! The pizza is massive. The cheese is flavorful and they use cupping pepperoni so it has that crunch effect when you bite it. The undercarriage is slightly charred (how it should be), and the crust is crispy but not burned. Overall, the pizza was great! I could have probably finished the whole pizza by myself, that's how much I liked it. The restaurant has a chill ambiance too. The only con is that it was a little on the greasy side but other than that it was ideal.

Best NY style in Boise imo. Service is good and they…read moreconsistently make a great pie. Love the simple throwback pizza shop ambiance of the place. Right next to the skate park makes it even better.

We visited this location after being super happy with our visit to the Nampa location. We were not…read morenearly as impressed-- or actually very impressed whatsoever. Initially, the young man working the register was very personable. We mentioned having gone to Nampa and he made a comment like "oh, we're better!" I actually liked that he seemed to have that opinion and was really hoping it would be true, or that at least it would be comparable. Unfortunately, the only thing that was comparable was the product... Had out of town friends with us who had contemplated a salad bar with their pizza but the items all looked less than fresh, so they decided against it. Both couples ordered the Everything pizza but with some modifications. We removed several toppings (salami, onions and mushrooms) and substituted extra pineapple and pepperoncini. Given that we removed three items and substituted only 2, we didn't expect a price difference; however, we DID end up being charged an extra $2.50 which the receipt did not clearly show-- only figured it out because the price charged was $2.50 more than what was listed on their digital menu. Friends wanted extra pineapple on the entire pie, all of the tomatoes on one side and all of the ham on the other side. That was hard for the kid taking the order to understand, though it seemed like he eventually got it right. When their pizza was done, it was wrong and had to be remade, which was done without complaint by the other young man working, but all in all we spent over an hour in the location. There didn't really seem to be any rhyme or reason to what order the pizzas were made in; a gentleman walked in after we were done ordering and placed an order-- he received his before either of us. Our friends, who ordered after we did, got their first one next, then we finally got ours. The final pizzas were good, although it did seem as though there was more sauce than the other location-- not a big deal for most, we're just not really sauce people. When our friends finally got their remade, correct pie, we just took it to go (they had put all of them into boxes anyway, which seemed like kind of a waste, but I'm assuming the boys were trying to have as few dishes at close as possible; we placed our order at 6:42 and didn't leave until about 7:50) The young men working were dressed quite... unprofessional. I get allowing employees to be comfortable and that it's "just pizza" yet I still feel like there should be some level of accountability in what they wear-- the shorts that one of them was wearing looked almost like swim trunks! Also, I noted that the amount we were charged was higher than what was shown on the menu board, brought it up to the cashier and was just told "I don't know why. I can ask my manager but she's not here right now". So, no real resolution-- and it seemed as though there was nobody actually "in charge" to be able to assist with a customer issue. Of the five or so groups of tables in the restaurant, only one of them seemed clean. I took napkins and wiped down the ones we wanted to sit in. This was bothersome to me due to the fact that when we walked in, they were not busy; one of them was standing there at the register while the other did dishes (or so we were told when I asked if he was the only one working). Customer area cleanliness should have taken priority over dishes, in my opinion. Three stars simply due to the fact that the final product was decent, although I'm not sure that we'll go back to this location. We'll probably stick to making the drive to Nampa when we want this pizza.

Great pizza, love their marinara sauce & their staff is always so nice. Been there a couple times…read moreand it always feels homey.

This place is pretty good. You could get all you could eat pizza buffet for six bucks and for three…read moredollars more get the salad bar that's pretty cheap. I would definitely come here again. The people here were friendly too, and that counts now because a lot of places that I go to there's bad attitude guys and girls that work there.

This is definitely a unique spot in Caldwell, but unfortunately the overall experience was…read moredisappointing. The dining area has some seating, although the layout feels a little awkward. The cleanliness also left a lot to be desired--the dining room and bathroom were not very clean, and the bathroom was low on toilet paper and completely out of soap. The biggest issue was the wait time. We waited over an hour for just two pizzas, while several tables that arrived after us received their food first. We eventually had to go to the counter ourselves to check on the order. It seemed like a high volume of takeout orders was causing major delays for dine-in customers. There were also problems with the soda fountain, leaving only Country Time lemonade and water available. Unfortunately, even the water had a strange flavor, so we avoided drinking it. The pizza itself was decent and had a nice crunchy crust, but the service and cleanliness issues outweighed the positives for us.

Flying Pie has been around Boise and have always had the best in town. Was so excited when they…read morebrought one close to me. Its the only pizza we eat.

Flying Pie is a hometown Boise pizza company who has been one of the best and most creative…read morepizzerias around. The pizza is excellent. The "contest combo" has so many fresh and authentic toppings and is loaded. The Stromboli with the sourdough crust is so balanced and delicious. It will absolutely surprise you. The Hawaiian with smoked Gouda....the list goes on. What was disappointing about this location this week is that my family went in at about 8:30 with a group after a night of kids baseball and softball games. They were told they had to call ahead and make reservations. They offered to split up and sit down. They were told that the two people up front were going home in 30 minutes. It was 2 1/2 hours before closing. There is no signage about the dining room closing early. The employee up front was extremely rude. The manager was not able to make the situation better and the employee continued to yell even when other customers were at the counter. One customer came up and said they couldn't believe what had happened. My family left. We are huge fans of flying pie, but it's more than just the great pizza, it needs to be a place where families can walk in and be treated with kindness and respect. So tonight we gathered at a different pizzeria and the contrast was big. They were accommodating and patient and we enjoyed being together and having the space and time we wanted. Flying Pie may be the best pizza in town. I'm hopeful they rectify the issues my family faced and are more welcoming and communicate better.

This place just gets better and better everytime I come and the owner remembered me I felt special…read moregenuinely. You need to come here on a Friday night when they do cinnamon pizza it's too good to pass up; Dave portnoy should review this place. Good vibe too tvs music and like a ski surf kinda decoration inside.

My son absolutely loves this place! We come here often because the pizza is always fresh,…read moredelicious, and such a great value. It's hard to beat the quality for the price. The restaurant is always clean, the staff is friendly, and the service is great. We always have a good experience and will definitely keep coming back!

The food was amazing. You could taste the freshness of everything on the menu! Our waiter was an…read moreangel. So kind and accommodating. However, we overheard an unsettling conversation between the manager and a waiter. She was yelling at him in an unprofessional manner in front of the customers. If that's how she acts in front of customers, I don't even wanna know how she acts behind closed doors. It was so unprofessional and made us all uncomfortable

We love pizza and will always seek out good pizza places when we're traveling - holy COW am I glad…read morewe found this place. (honestly, you should just stop and go there now) If you're still reading and want more information - fine, here you go... As soon as I saw sour dough crust, I knew that this was the place we'd go for our first meal in town. We went for a late lunch but the place was still busy. Tip, don't let a line at the door stress you out, it really didn't take long to get seated and the waiting area is tiny so it probably looks worse than it is. It's welcoming and a bit upscale for what I expected. They have a good looking cocktail menu (I did not partake that day), and their pizza menu included something fun-sounding called Honey Badger Pizza. (Why did I just share that with you? I don't know, we didn't order it - I just love the name) Our waitress was McKenna, she was nice and super helpful. We were a simple table that day, a Pepperoni pizza with parmesian, the hubs got a soda and I stuck with water. When I waved off a drink and said something like "I probably shouldn't order what I really want because I haven't eaten yet today", McKenna replied "I'm not here to judge, I'm here for the tips." What a HOOT! I fell in love with her that very moment and promised myself if we go back again we'd ask for her (we didn't make it back during this visit). The pizza was absolutely everything I was hoping for. SOOOOO good. From the first bite at the pointy-end all the way to the crust. If this is what they serve in heaven, I think I'll be fine. We took a couple of pieces back to the room with us and it reheated in the microwave just fine. Clean restroom, well lit restaurant. Everything was fantastic. We prefer to walk when we're in the city. The Wylder is in an adorable area of Boise, which is plenty walkable and I felt completely comfortable doing so. Are you still reading? I'm not sure what else to tell you - if you like pizza, just put down the phone and go! Thank you for reading my review.

They had incredible customer service and delicious pizza! Their prices werent too bad as well.read more

Price is good. Owner is a hard worker and trying to make it…read more Pizza a bit better than some. Cheese bread very good. The pizza could use more topping. Including cheese. I'll be back. Inside like the lobbies of all the chains.